Samsung S24 Ultra vs iPhone 15 Pro Max camera- After The Updates!

GadgetRevNow
30 Aug 202410:57

Summary

TLDRIn this ultimate camera comparison, the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and iPhone 15 Pro Max face off in various photography and videography tests. Both flagships showcase their updated features, with the S24 Ultra offering a natural color profile, high dynamic range, and superior optical zoom capabilities. The iPhone 15 Pro Max delivers vibrant colors, excellent contrast, and a warmer white balance. Each device excels in different aspects, such as low-light performance, macro shots, and stabilization, making it a close call for the title of the better camera smartphone.

Takeaways

  • 📱 The video compares the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and iPhone 15 Pro Max, focusing on camera performance after updates.
  • 🌈 Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra retains a natural color profile with less saturation and a cooler white balance, while iPhone 15 Pro Max offers more vibrant and saturated colors.
  • 📸 Samsung's camera smoothens colors and has a high dynamic range look, exposing shadows and subjects better, but sometimes appears less refined.
  • 🔭 Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra offers an additional three times optical zoom not found on the iPhone 15 Pro Max, enhancing its versatility.
  • 🌆 In low-light conditions, iPhone 15 Pro Max manages highlights better and has a tendency to be warmer, which some users may prefer for a more inviting look.
  • 🤳 Both phones perform well in portrait mode, with Samsung offering a smoother skin effect and Apple providing more detail and a stronger contrast.
  • 🌌 Night shots on Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra are darker and more controlled, while iPhone 15 Pro Max is brighter and more saturated.
  • 🎥 Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra supports 8K video recording and has better stabilization across all sensors, including in 4K slow motion.
  • 📹 iPhone 15 Pro Max excels in video recording with better noise reduction and exposure, especially in macro and close focus shots.
  • 📲 The choice between the two phones may come down to personal preference for color saturation, camera features, and overall performance in various shooting conditions.

Q & A

  • What are the main differences in color profile between the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and the iPhone 15 Pro Max?

    -The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra has a more natural color profile with less saturation and a cooler white balance, while the iPhone 15 Pro Max produces more saturated colors and stronger contrast, especially in reds, greens, and shadows.

  • How do the two phones compare in terms of dynamic range performance?

    -The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra handles high dynamic range better by exposing shadows and highlights more effectively. However, in certain situations, this can make some images look artificial. The iPhone 15 Pro Max has a more balanced contrast but can sometimes crush blacks, losing details in dark areas.

  • Which phone has better zoom capabilities?

    -The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra has superior zoom capabilities, featuring a 3x optical zoom and a 100x 'space zoom,' which the iPhone 15 Pro Max does not offer. Both phones have 5x optical zoom, but the Galaxy S24 Ultra has the advantage in extreme zooming scenarios.

  • What are the main differences in portrait mode between the two phones?

    -Both phones perform well in portrait mode, with good subject separation. The iPhone 15 Pro Max has better cut-out performance in busy backgrounds, while the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra offers a smoother skin effect by default. The Galaxy S24 Ultra also has a 3x optical zoom option for portraits, which the iPhone lacks.

  • How do the phones compare in low-light or night photography?

    -In low-light conditions, the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra manages highlights better and exposes shadows effectively, but the overall image may appear darker. The iPhone 15 Pro Max produces brighter images with more saturated colors, handling noise and exposure better, especially in pitch-black conditions.

  • Does the iPhone 15 Pro Max have any unique features that stand out in comparison to the Galaxy S24 Ultra?

    -The iPhone 15 Pro Max stands out with features like macro photography, which the Galaxy S24 Ultra lacks. Additionally, iOS and iMessage, exclusive to the iPhone, contribute to a smoother user experience for some users.

  • Which phone has better video recording capabilities?

    -The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra offers more advanced video features, including 8K video recording and 4K slow-motion at 120fps. However, the iPhone 15 Pro Max has better audio quality for video recording, making it a better choice for vlogging.

  • How do the phones compare in terms of stabilization during video recording?

    -The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra has better stabilization overall, particularly noticeable in 4K 30fps video. The iPhone 15 Pro Max, while good, is slightly less stable and can feel jerky during certain movements.

  • What is the difference in the selfie camera performance between the two phones?

    -The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra offers a wider field of view for selfies, better stabilization, and more vibrant colors. The iPhone 15 Pro Max has slightly washed-out colors but handles low-light selfie situations better.

  • Which phone is better for extreme zoom and high-detail shots?

    -The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra performs better in extreme zoom scenarios with its 100x space zoom. It also has a 200-megapixel sensor for capturing more detailed images compared to the 12-megapixel shots of the iPhone 15 Pro Max.

Outlines

00:00

📱 Camera Showdown: Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs iPhone 15 Pro Max

This paragraph introduces a camera comparison between the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and the iPhone 15 Pro Max, highlighting the need to reassess these flagship phones in light of new releases like the Pixel 9 series and the upcoming iPhone 16. The comparison includes various shooting conditions, both indoor and outdoor, focusing on color profiles, saturation, and dynamic range. It mentions the use of the quad-camera setup of the Galaxy S24 Ultra and the tri-camera system of the iPhone 15 Pro Max. The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra is noted for its natural-looking colors and cooler white balance, while the iPhone 15 Pro Max is recognized for its more saturated and colorful images with stronger contrast.

05:00

🌆 Night Photography and Video Capabilities

The second paragraph delves into the night photography and video recording capabilities of both smartphones. It discusses the performance of the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and iPhone 15 Pro Max in low-light conditions, with Samsung managing highlights better and exposing shadows more effectively, although its images are slightly darker. In contrast, the iPhone 15 Pro Max is noted for its brighter and more saturated night shots with better overall exposure. The paragraph also touches on the selfie cameras, with the Galaxy S24 Ultra offering a wider field of view and better color reproduction, while the iPhone 15 Pro Max is praised for its video recording quality and iOS ecosystem benefits.

10:01

🏞️ Zoom, Stabilization, and Additional Features

The final paragraph compares the zoom capabilities, stabilization, and additional features of the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and iPhone 15 Pro Max. It highlights the Galaxy S24 Ultra's superior stabilization and the unique feature of 8K video recording, which is not available on the iPhone 15 Pro Max. The paragraph also discusses the slow-motion capabilities, with the Galaxy S24 Ultra able to shoot up to 4K at 120 FPS. The iPhone 15 Pro Max is commended for its overall performance, including audio quality, which is considered better for vlogging. The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra is noted for its feature-rich offerings and performance, making it a strong contender in the high-end smartphone market.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Camera Comparison

A camera comparison refers to the process of evaluating and contrasting different cameras or camera systems based on their performance, features, and image quality. In the context of the video, the comparison is between the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and the iPhone 15 Pro Max, focusing on their photographic capabilities after software updates.

💡Color Profile and Saturation

Color profile and saturation are key aspects of image quality that determine how colors appear in a photograph. A color profile defines the way colors are rendered, while saturation refers to the intensity of these colors. The video discusses how the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra retains natural-looking colors with a cooler white balance, in contrast to the iPhone 15 Pro Max, which is described as having a more saturated and colorful appearance.

💡Dynamic Range

Dynamic range in photography is the ratio between the brightest and darkest elements that can be captured in an image. A high dynamic range allows for better detail in both shadows and highlights. The video mentions that the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra has a high dynamic range look, exposing shadows and subjects better, which is an important feature for capturing a wide range of light conditions.

💡Optical Zoom

Optical zoom is a feature in cameras that allows for magnification of the subject without loss of image quality, achieved by physically moving the lens elements. The video highlights the difference in optical zoom capabilities between the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and the iPhone 15 Pro Max, with the former offering an extra three times optical zoom, providing better reach for subjects at a distance.

💡Portrait Mode

Portrait mode is a photography feature that creates a depth-of-field effect, blurring the background to make the subject stand out. The video discusses the portrait capabilities of both phones, noting the subject separation and skin effect, with the iPhone 15 Pro Max having a better cut out and the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra offering a smoother skin effect.

💡Night Mode

Night mode is a camera setting designed to capture better images in low-light conditions by increasing exposure time and sensitivity. The video compares the night mode performance of both phones, with the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra managing highlights better and the iPhone 15 Pro Max offering brighter and more saturated images.

💡Macro Shot

A macro shot is a close-up photograph of a small subject, typically requiring a camera with macro capabilities. The video points out that only the iPhone 15 Pro Max offers a macro shot, allowing for detailed close-ups that the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra cannot match with its standard lens.

💡Stabilization

Stabilization in video recording refers to the process of reducing camera shake to produce smoother footage. The video compares the stabilization capabilities of both phones, with the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra showing better stabilization across various sensors and shooting conditions, which is crucial for producing professional-looking videos.

💡Slow Motion

Slow motion is a video recording feature that captures footage at a higher frame rate than normal, allowing it to be played back at a slower speed. The video notes that the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra can shoot slow motion at up to 4K at 120 FPS, a feature that the iPhone 15 Pro Max does not match, offering more creative possibilities for video content.

💡8K Video Recording

8K video recording refers to the ability of a camera to capture video at a resolution of 7680 x 4320 pixels, which is significantly higher than the standard 4K resolution. The video mentions that the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra supports 8K video recording, a feature not available on the iPhone 15 Pro Max, providing higher resolution and detail for video content.

Highlights

Comparing the camera capabilities of the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and iPhone 15 Pro Max in various lighting conditions and modes.

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra retains natural-looking colors with a cooler white balance compared to the iPhone 15 Pro Max.

iPhone 15 Pro Max has a more saturated and colorful appearance, with stronger contrast.

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra offers a three times optical zoom not available on the iPhone 15 Pro Max.

Both devices have a five times optical zoom and similar color profiles in outdoor shots.

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra's high dynamic range look smoothens surfaces and exposes shadows better.

iPhone 15 Pro Max maintains details and individual colors on subjects, avoiding over-smoothening.

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra's 8K video recording capability is a standout feature not found on iPhone 15 Pro Max.

Dual video recording is a unique feature of Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra, absent in iPhones.

Both phones excel in portrait mode, with the iPhone 15 Pro Max having better subject separation.

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra's default skin effect is smoother, with a more natural-looking skin tone.

iPhone 15 Pro Max's night portrait mode is exceptional, with warmer tones and better exposure.

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra manages highlights better in low light, with more readable text and controlled light sources.

iPhone 15 Pro Max's night shots are brighter and more saturated, with better overall exposure.

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra offers 4K at 120 FPS slow motion, a significant advantage over iPhone 15 Pro Max.

In terms of stabilization, Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra outperforms iPhone 15 Pro Max across various sensors and recording modes.

iPhone 15 Pro Max's selfie camera provides a wider field of view, which may be preferred for vlogging.

Both devices are top-tier in terms of image and video quality, with the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra offering more features and performance.

Transcripts

play00:00

this is the ultimate camera comparison

play00:02

video of Samsung Galaxy s24 Ultra versus

play00:04

iPhone 15 Pro Max after all the updates

play00:08

which is the better go let the battle

play00:14

begin today we're comparing the flagship

play00:17

iPhone 15 Pro Max and Samsung Galaxy s24

play00:20

since we now have the new pixel 9 and

play00:22

pixel 9 Pro and the upcoming iPhone 16

play00:24

Series in a few weeks I think it's high

play00:26

time for us to revisit the flagship

play00:28

competition of Samsung and iPhone to see

play00:30

how they stack up today with all the

play00:32

updates in we are shooting both phones

play00:35

in auto mode out of the box we're

play00:36

shooting both indoors and Outdoors we're

play00:38

shooting Sky flowers and random colorful

play00:41

things we're also utilizing the quad

play00:43

camera setup of Galaxy s24 and the

play00:45

triole camera system of iPhone 15 Pro

play00:47

Max we are starting this comparison with

play00:50

color profile and saturation and Samsung

play00:52

Galaxy s24 Ultra after all the updates I

play00:55

feel still retains the natural looking

play00:57

colors comparing with iPhone 15 Pro Max

play00:59

it is less saturated than the

play01:01

competition it has a cooler white

play01:03

balance compared to the competition and

play01:04

you would see that it smoothens the

play01:05

surface or I should say that the colors

play01:07

are blending in depending on what colors

play01:09

dominate the subject you will see this

play01:11

on the flowers and the floors and like

play01:14

any other Samsung phone it has a high

play01:15

dynamic range look you would see that it

play01:17

Expos the shadows and the subject better

play01:19

obviously if some of the errors are

play01:21

against the light Galaxy s24 Ultra will

play01:23

try to expose them a lot of time it

play01:25

works but some of them looks really

play01:26

cheap that feels like coming from a

play01:28

smartphone it manages just the

play01:30

Highlights better you can still see some

play01:31

information on the bright light source

play01:33

and it also has a Bluer Sky compared to

play01:35

iPhone 15 Pro Max Samsung is cranking

play01:37

the colors of the sky a little bit what

play01:40

I love about Galaxy s24 Ultra is the

play01:42

extra three times optical zoom that you

play01:44

will not find on iPhone 15 Pro Max but

play01:47

they both have the same five times

play01:48

optical zoom and you also have the space

play01:50

zoom on the latest Samsung Flagship

play01:52

while iPhone 15 Pro Max after a year of

play01:54

update still retains the tendency of a

play01:56

more colorful and more saturated look

play01:58

than Samsung you can see this on the

play02:00

pink the greens and the Reds it crushes

play02:03

the shadows and the blacks giving a

play02:05

stronger contrast look than the

play02:06

competition personally I like this

play02:08

better just because it gives a little

play02:09

bit of depth to the

play02:11

image sometimes it backfires on a

play02:13

situation wherein you wanted to see A

play02:14

Brighter Image but the photos coming

play02:16

from iPhone 15 Pro Max doesn't look

play02:18

cheap it also feels like it's coming

play02:19

from a proper camera it doesn't blend

play02:22

the colors on the surface you can see

play02:23

individual colors on the subject and the

play02:25

surface unlike s24 Ultra which I feel

play02:27

makes more sense and definitely you

play02:30

would see more details on the surface

play02:31

like the teddy bears and the flowers it

play02:33

doesn't look as beautiful as Samsung

play02:34

competition but for non-ported shots the

play02:37

images looks better and like Samsung

play02:39

Galaxy s24 Ultra there's no

play02:41

oversharpening on iPhone 15 Pro Max

play02:43

again both phones looks really natural

play02:45

and looking at all sensors you got Ultra

play02:47

wide main sensor and three times optical

play02:49

zoom on Galaxy s24 Ultra and they both

play02:51

have five times optical zoom and zooming

play02:53

into the forest you will have better

play02:54

reach on Galaxy s24 Ultra

play03:00

you been dream this is Samsung Galaxy

play03:03

s24 Ultra using the selfie camera in 4k

play03:06

60 FPS outside this camera comparison

play03:08

video what I like about this phone is

play03:09

the screen I like the boxy shape of it

play03:11

and also the S Spen That's Unique for

play03:14

the s24 O this is the 8K video

play03:18

recording on Samsung Galaxy s24

play03:21

Ultra there's no 8K video recording on

play03:24

iPhone 15 Pro Max and this is the Dual

play03:27

video recording on s24 Ultra for Samsung

play03:30

phones there's no feature like this on

play03:33

iPhone

play03:34

to let's talk about Port mode and both

play03:37

phones are really good in terms of Port

play03:38

shots I mean you can't go wrong with any

play03:40

of these two phones if you're paying

play03:42

this much for a flagship phone I bet you

play03:44

will get the best results out of these

play03:46

smartphones let's start with the

play03:48

similarities on both phones I think both

play03:50

of them is great subject separation or

play03:51

cut out on one of the shots where have a

play03:53

busy background with the grass you would

play03:55

see that iPhone 15 Pro Max has better

play03:57

cut out compared to Galaxy s24 Ultra but

play04:00

the Samsung competition is not so bad

play04:03

Galaxy s24 Ultra smooth skin effect by

play04:05

default you would see that even though

play04:06

there's information on the face it's

play04:08

much smoter than the competition you

play04:10

would also noce natural looking skin

play04:11

tone but a little bit pinkish kind of

play04:13

look for both me and my wife the

play04:15

exposure is a little bit darker on

play04:17

Galaxy S14 Ultra and the colors overall

play04:19

are natural looking and it's a neutral

play04:21

tone what I like about this phone is a

play04:23

three times optical zoom also a sported

play04:25

shot so this is more like 60 to 75 mm

play04:27

shot and the iPhone 15 Pro Max doesn't

play04:30

have it while the Apple's Top ofth Line

play04:32

has a warmer white balance than Samsung

play04:34

I would say it's more inviting than s24

play04:36

Ultra also the exposure is a little bit

play04:38

brighter on this phone there's certainly

play04:41

more details on our faces and you would

play04:43

see more freckles on my wife's face than

play04:44

Galaxy s24 Ultra and you would also see

play04:47

that the cont is a little bit stronger

play04:48

than the competition it crushes the

play04:50

darker airs like my eyes and the hair so

play04:52

the subject pops out a little bit both

play04:54

phones are also capable of night

play04:56

portrait mode and both phones are doing

play04:58

exceptional job on this I if you leave

play05:00

more details on Galaxy s24 Ultra it is

play05:02

brighter and iPhone 15 Pro Max retain

play05:04

the Tendencies to be warmer going for

play05:07

the selfie camera I think you have wider

play05:09

fov on Galaxy s24 Ultra and you would

play05:11

notice that the colors on Samsung is a

play05:13

little bit better than the iPhone 15 Pro

play05:14

Max it's a little bit washed out looking

play05:16

at the shirt looking at the night shots

play05:19

both phones are still impeccable in

play05:21

terms of performance I mean these two

play05:22

phones are two of the best smartphones

play05:24

in terms of night shots right off the

play05:27

bat you will notice that Samsung manages

play05:28

the Highlights better you can still read

play05:30

some of the text and it controls the

play05:32

strong light source really well it also

play05:33

exposes the Shadows better looking the

play05:35

trees and the plants you would still see

play05:37

leaves on it unlike the iPhone 15 Pro

play05:39

Max the overall look on Samsung Galaxy

play05:42

s24 Ultra is toned down it's a little

play05:44

bit darker than the competition and even

play05:46

the sky moving to the iPhone 15 Pro Max

play05:49

you would notice it's brighter than the

play05:50

competition it is more saturated you can

play05:52

see this on the greens and the Reds and

play05:54

overall you notice that iPhone 15 Pro

play05:56

Max has better exposure than the Samsung

play05:58

flagship I guess the biggest difference

play06:01

here is the pitch black condition where

play06:02

you would notice a solid performance on

play06:04

iPhone 15 Pro Max it would still admit a

play06:06

little bit of information on the sensors

play06:08

while it's totally gone on Galaxy s24

play06:12

[Music]

play06:16

Ultra this is iPhone 15 Pro Max in 4k 30

play06:19

FPS using the selfie camera what I like

play06:22

about this phone is the iOS and the

play06:23

iMessage obviously iPhone is the only

play06:25

phone that has iOS and also I like the

play06:27

video recording of this phone I think

play06:29

it's a little bit better than Samsung

play06:31

phone if we check who manages the

play06:33

Highlights better if you zoom in on a

play06:35

couple of shots you would not that

play06:36

Galaxy S14 Ultra showed more information

play06:39

and it's not blown

play06:41

out talking about close Focus or macro

play06:43

only Iphone 15 Pro Max offers macro shot

play06:46

you can also use the ultra WID lens of

play06:48

S14 Ultra but it's not as close as the

play06:50

iPhone also if you use the five times

play06:52

optical zoom you will notice that iPhone

play06:54

15 Pro Max still has the closer

play06:57

Focus checking who manages the noise

play06:59

better without the HDR or night shot you

play07:01

will notice that iPhone 15 Pro Max has

play07:03

better exposure and noise reduction than

play07:05

Galaxy s24

play07:07

Ultra in terms of sharpness using the

play07:10

ultra wide lens it's almost the same

play07:12

Samsung only cleans up the image going

play07:14

to the main sensor if you zoom in both

play07:16

phones has the same level of sharpness

play07:18

but only Galaxy s24 Ultra has three

play07:20

times optical zoom that is better

play07:21

compared to the digital crop and going

play07:23

to the farthest Zoom both of them has

play07:24

five times optical zoom but only S14

play07:27

Ultra has 100 times space Zoom

play07:30

and lastly details if you compare the 12

play07:32

megapixel jpeg both of them has the same

play07:34

level of details on the main sensor but

play07:36

you can also use the 200 megapix readout

play07:38

of s24 ultra it's so much Vivid than the

play07:41

competition but it's also soft and blown

play07:46

[Music]

play07:48

out this is the zoom test of Galaxy s24

play07:51

Ultra and iPhone 15 Pro

play07:57

Max and this is the main s

play08:02

I think almost the same

play08:04

quality just a little bit warmer on s24

play08:08

Ultra but maybe it's just the

play08:11

screen this is the three times optical

play08:13

zoom on s24

play08:15

Ultra and you have the two times on

play08:19

iPhone 15 Pro

play08:24

Max then both

play08:26

have the 5X

play08:31

but only s24 Ultra

play08:39

10x this is the stabilization test

play08:41

starting with the ultra wide sensor in

play08:43

4k 30 FPS and Galaxy s24 Ultra has

play08:46

better stabilization you can even feel

play08:48

my every steps on iPhone 15 Pro

play08:52

[Music]

play08:53

Max and this is the main sensor again in

play08:56

4k 30 FPS and still s24 Ultra is better

play08:59

stabilization iPhone 15 Pro Max weighs a

play09:02

little bit

play09:04

[Music]

play09:06

[Applause]

play09:07

bigger and this is the five times

play09:09

Optical zo on both phones and again s24

play09:11

Ultra has better stabilization and focus

play09:14

iPhone 15 Pro Max is a little bit

play09:19

jerky going for the selfie video

play09:21

recording in 4k 30 FPS I think in terms

play09:24

of stabilization they're both the same

play09:26

iPhone 15 Pro Max only has the wider

play09:28

field of view

play09:29

[Music]

play09:31

be the

play09:32

day and this is the slow motion test and

play09:35

obviously the biggest difference between

play09:36

the two Galaxy s24 Ultra can shoot up to

play09:39

4K at 120

play09:46

FPS and this is the low light video

play09:48

recording and we're shooting on all

play09:49

sensors you would notice that Galaxy s24

play09:52

is sking some of the frames while we're

play09:54

changing from One sensor to

play09:56

another it's also a little bit darker on

play09:58

the five times optical

play10:01

[Music]

play10:09

zoom but going back to the main sensor I

play10:11

think it's almost the same look on both

play10:18

phones I think overall iPhone 15 Pro Max

play10:21

is a really good smartphone overall from

play10:22

the image to video I can see any flow on

play10:25

this phone and I also feel that the

play10:26

audio on this phone is a little bit

play10:28

better than Galaxy s24 Ultra so it's

play10:30

really good for vlogging well I can say

play10:33

the same thing on Samsung Galaxy s24

play10:35

Ultra the image quality is really good

play10:37

as the iPhone 15 Pro Max and going to

play10:39

the video recording you got better

play10:41

stabilization you got 8K video recording

play10:43

and 4K slow motion and I feel like in

play10:45

terms of features and performance you'll

play10:47

get more out of s24 ultra

play10:53

[Music]

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

関連タグ
Camera ComparisonSamsung GalaxyiPhone 15Smartphone ReviewImage QualityVideo RecordingTech ReviewCamera TestMobile TechGadgets
英語で要約が必要ですか?