How to Write a Defensible Thesis for a Rhetorical Analysis Essay | AP Lang Q2 | Coach Hall Writes

Summary

In this educational video, the host guides viewers on crafting a defensible thesis for AP Language's rhetorical analysis essay. The introductory paragraph is dissected into three parts: the hook, context, and thesis, with the latter being crucial for setting direction. The thesis should identify the author's strategies or choices and their purpose, potentially considering the audience's response. The video offers a checklist for creating a strong thesis, emphasizing specificity, avoiding prompt restatement, and ensuring prompt response, ultimately aiming to strengthen the essay's argument.

Takeaways

• 📝 The video discusses crafting a defensible thesis for an AP Lang rhetorical analysis essay, focusing on the second question.
• 🔍 An introductory paragraph should be structured like an inverted triangle, with a hook, context, and thesis statement.
• 📌 The thesis can be placed anywhere in the essay according to the College Board's rubric, but placing it at the beginning helps provide direction.
• 👉 The context should identify the specific passage, including title, author, genre, tone, speaker, occasion, audience, and exigence.
• 📖 A defensible thesis should include the author's strategies or choices and their purpose for using them in the argument.
• 💡 Adding the effect of the strategies on the audience can strengthen the thesis, considering why the author made specific choices.
• 📑 The example provided shows how to integrate context and thesis in a single sentence, using the author's full name and article title.
• 📝 The thesis should be specific, avoiding restating the prompt and instead offering the student's interpretation of the passage.
• 🔑 To make the thesis stronger, consider using verb forms that convey action, such as 'defines' instead of 'definition'.
• ✍️ The video emphasizes the importance of answering the prompt directly and ensuring the thesis is not just a restatement of the prompt.
• 👍 The video concludes with a checklist for creating a defensible thesis, including identifying strategies, adding specifics, and answering the prompt.

Q & A

What are the three parts of an introductory paragraph for a rhetorical analysis essay?

The three parts are the hook, the context, and the thesis.

Can the context and thesis be combined into one sentence in the introductory paragraph?

Yes, technically, the context and thesis can be combined into the same sentence.

What should be included in the context portion of the introductory paragraph for an essay or article?

The context portion should include the title, author, genre, and tone of the essay or article.

What elements should be considered for the context of a speech or letter?

For a speech or letter, the context should include the speaker, occasion or exigence, audience, and tone if possible.

Where can the thesis be placed according to the College Board's rubric?

The thesis can be placed anywhere in the essay, not necessarily in the introduction or conclusion.

Why is it recommended to restate the thesis in the conclusion of the essay?

Restatement of the thesis in the conclusion, even if worded differently, helps to reinforce the argument and increases the likelihood of earning the thesis point.

What should a defensible thesis for a rhetorical analysis essay include?

A defensible thesis should include the author's strategies or choices, the author's purpose, and potentially the effect on the audience.

Why is it important to specify the argument or message in the thesis?

Specifying the argument or message in the thesis provides clarity and ensures that the reader understands the focus of the analysis.

What is a way to make the thesis more complex and potentially stronger?

Adding another layer to the thesis by considering the effect on the audience can make it more complex and strengthen the argument.

What is the purpose of changing the verb in the thesis statement?

Changing the verb in the thesis statement, such as from 'develops' to 'furthers', adds specificity and shows the writer's interpretation rather than just restating the prompt.

Why is it crucial to answer the prompt in the thesis statement?

Answering the prompt in the thesis ensures that the essay is focused on the specific question being asked and demonstrates that the writer understands the task at hand.

Outlines

00:00

📚 Mastering the AP Lang Rhetorical Analysis Essay

This paragraph introduces the topic of the video, which is crafting a defensible thesis for an AP Language and Composition (AP Lang) rhetorical analysis essay. The speaker explains the structure of an effective introductory paragraph, using the metaphor of an inverted triangle to describe the progression from a broad hook to a specific thesis. The paragraph emphasizes the importance of including the context of the passage and the thesis statement, which should be a clear and defensible claim about the author's strategies and purpose. It also touches on the flexibility of thesis placement according to the College Board's rubric and suggests restating the thesis at the end of the essay for clarity and emphasis.

05:01

🔔 Stay Updated with AP Lang Tips and Tricks

The second paragraph serves as a call to action for viewers to subscribe to the channel and turn on notifications to receive regular updates on content related to AP Lang, including tips and strategies for excelling in the AP Lang exam. The speaker encourages viewers to engage with the channel to benefit from the ongoing series of educational videos aimed at improving their writing skills and exam performance.

Keywords

💡Thesis

A thesis in the context of the video refers to a central argument or claim that the writer makes in an essay, specifically for AP Lang question 2 which is a rhetorical analysis essay. The thesis is crucial as it sets the direction for the entire essay and must be defensible, meaning it can be supported with evidence. In the script, the importance of placing the thesis early in the essay is discussed, as it provides a clear direction for the paper, though the College Board's rubric allows for flexibility in its placement.

💡Rhetorical Analysis

Rhetorical Analysis is the process of examining a text, identifying the strategies the author uses to persuade or influence the audience, and evaluating the effectiveness of these strategies. The video script emphasizes the importance of this analysis in crafting a strong thesis for an AP Lang essay. It involves looking at the author's choices and strategies, such as appeals to emotion or the use of flattery, and understanding their purpose in the context of the argument being made.

💡Introductory Paragraph

The introductory paragraph is the opening section of an essay, which traditionally includes a hook, context, and the thesis statement. In the video, it's described as an inverted triangle, starting broad and narrowing down to the specific thesis. It sets the stage for the essay by providing necessary background information and ends with the thesis, which in a rhetorical analysis essay, should clearly state the author's argument regarding the text's rhetorical strategies.

💡Hook

A hook in writing is a strategy used to engage the reader's interest from the very beginning of the essay. It's the first part of the introductory paragraph and aims to 'hook' the reader's attention. Although the script does not provide a specific example of a hook, it is implied as the initial element of the inverted triangle structure, suggesting that it should be broad and interesting to draw the reader in.

💡Context

Context in the video script refers to the background information that provides a framework for understanding the text being analyzed. For an essay or article, this includes the title, author, genre, and tone. For a speech or letter, it includes the speaker, occasion, audience, and tone. The context is essential for setting the stage for the thesis and is often combined with the thesis in the introductory paragraph.

💡Strategies

Strategies in the context of the video are the rhetorical devices or techniques used by the author to construct their argument. These could include juxtaposition, appeals to emotion, flattery, or criticism. The video emphasizes that a defensible thesis must identify these strategies and explain how they contribute to the development of the author's argument.

💡Purpose

The purpose in a rhetorical analysis refers to the reason why the author employs certain strategies or makes specific choices in their writing. It's the 'why' behind the 'what'—the strategies. The video script explains that a defensible thesis should not only mention the strategies but also the author's purpose for using them, which is central to understanding the argument being made.

💡Defensible

A defensible thesis is one that can be supported with evidence and logical reasoning. In the video, it's stressed that a good thesis for a rhetorical analysis essay should be defensible, meaning it should clearly state the author's argument regarding the text's strategies and purpose, and it should be capable of being substantiated with analysis from the text.

💡Audience

The audience refers to the readers or listeners for whom the text is intended. In the video, it's mentioned that sometimes the author's choices are tailored to the audience, and understanding this can strengthen the thesis. The script suggests considering the effect of the strategies on the audience, such as whether they are intended to provoke thought or action.

💡Argument

In the context of the video, an argument is the main point or claim that the author of the text is trying to persuade the audience to accept. The video script discusses how the thesis should specify not just the existence of an argument, but what that argument or message is, providing clarity on the author's intent.

💡College Board's Rubric

The College Board's rubric is a set of guidelines or criteria used to evaluate the quality of student work, in this case, for the AP Language and Composition exam. The video mentions that according to the rubric, the thesis can be placed anywhere in the essay, although the speaker recommends placing it at the beginning for clarity and direction.

Highlights

Today's video focuses on earning the thesis point for AP Lang question 2.

Learn how to write a defensible thesis for a rhetorical analysis essay.

The introductory paragraph should be structured like an inverted triangle with three parts: hook, context, and thesis.

The context includes identifying the specific passage's title, author, genre, and tone.

For speeches or letters, look for the speaker, occasion, audience, and tone.

The thesis should be placed at the beginning of the essay for a stronger direction.

Restate the thesis differently in the conclusion for a more defensible claim.

When reading and annotating the passage, look for the author's strategies or choices and their purpose.

A defensible thesis should address strategies, purpose, and the effect on the audience.

The thesis should be specific and not just a restatement of the prompt.

Use verbs like 'defines' or 'contrasts' instead of generic terms to strengthen the thesis.

Example given of combining context and thesis in the same sentence.

The author's full name should be used the first time and last name thereafter.

The article's title should be in quotation marks with punctuation inside.

The thesis should specify the author's argument or message for clarity.

Adding a dependent clause can enhance the thesis by analyzing the effect on the reader.

A quick checklist is provided to ensure a defensible thesis includes strategies, purpose, and answer to the prompt.

The video offers tips for passing the AP Lang exam and encourages subscribing for more content.

Transcripts

yeah as welcome back to coach all rights

in today's video we're going to be

talking about how to earn the thesis

point for AP Lang question 2 so

basically how do we write a defensible

thesis for a rhetorical analysis essay

for an introductory paragraph think

about it like an inverted triangle there

are three parts the hook the context and

the thesis now technically speaking you

can actually combine the context and the

thesis into the same sentence but the

idea here is to start from the most

broad and then narrow down to the most

specific the context portion of the

introductory paragraph you can actually

combine that with the thesis itself and

so the context portion is just when you

identify the specific passage that

you're talking about so if it is an

essay or an article you're gonna be

looking at the title author genre and

tone and then if it's a speech or letter

you're gonna be looking for the speaker

occasion or exigence

and the audience you would include tone

here as well if possible the final

portion of an introductory paragraph is

the thesis now I should mention that

according to the College Board's rubric

the thesis can happen anywhere in the

essay it does not have to be in the

intro or even in the conclusion however

I find that students who put the thesis

in the beginning of their essay tend to

write a stronger paper because they have

more of a direction I do however

recommend restating your thesis in your

conclusion just worded a little bit

differently that way you have it in the

beginning and the end so you can be more

likely to earn the thesis point because

you are more likely to have set a

defensible claim as you read and

annotate the passage you're going to be

looking for either strategies or choices

these are things that the author does in

order to develop his or her argument it

could be anything from juxtaposition to

an appeal to emotion perhaps the use of

flattery or even criticism so as you

decide what you want to talk about in

your essay these choices or strategies

need to be present in your thesis a

defensible thesis also needs to mention

author's purpose so if the choices and

strategies are what the author does then

the purpose is why the author does it

why does he or she use these strategies

or make these choices and why did he or

she write this piece to begin with in

order to be defensible a rhetorical

analysis thesis should address

strategies and purpose however if you

want to make it a little bit more

complex you can add another layer which

is to consider the

on the audience now this is not

mandatory nor is it always appropriate

to do so however sometimes students want

to strengthen their thesis and this is

one way to do that so think about why

the author made the choices that he or

she did that's purpose but also

sometimes we have to realize that

speakers tailor their choices to their

audience so what is the effect of these

strategies is it trying to get the

audience to think a certain way to act a

certain way there should be an effect of

these strategies because if they chose

these strategies for a reason they're

trying to elicit a particular response

let's take a look at an example where we

have the context and the thesis in the

same sentence so we're gonna lead in

with the context so here we have the

author's full name because the first

time that you reference the author you

want to use his or her full name and

then after that you refer to them by

their last name and then we've got

passionate article so passionate is

describing article here so we have that

as our tone and then lastly we have the

name of the article

America needs it's nerds and notice that

because it's an article we put it in

quotation marks and the punctuation goes

inside the quotation marks this is the

actual thesis portion so this is the

part that is defensible so we need to

have strategies and purpose notice that

we're using the verb form of strategies

here so instead of definition we have

defines and instead of juxtaposition we

have contrast works just fine also the

prompt asked about how the author used

certain strategies to develop his

argument so we have that phrase in here

to make sure that we're answering the

prompt however we don't just stop with

the word argument or message we want to

actually specify what the argument or

message is for clarification purposes to

make your thesis even stronger you can

add on another layer and that is

basically the effect on the reader or

the audience so this can be done by

adding a dependent clause to the end of

your sentence or by simply starting a

new sentence and just analyzing the

effect that way now that we understand

the different parts of a defensible

thesis statement for a rhetorical

analysis essay let's just go over a very

quick checklist here so first of all you

need to identify the strategies or

choices and the purpose you also need to

make sure that you're not just restating

the prompt you need to add specifics and

if possible change the verb for instance

instead of saying develop his argument

you could say furthers his argument you

want to make sure that you're not just

restating the prompt word

forward because that's not defensible

that's the information that's already

provided they want your interpretation

of the passage and then lastly you want

to make sure that you're answering the

prompt now that might seem really

obvious but sometimes students actually

forget what they're supposed to be

looking for because they're so wrapped

up in just finding strategies and

purpose and they don't realize they're

looking at perhaps an introduction of

something or a conclusion of something

and so you need to really think about

what you're being asked and there you

have it guys those are my best tips for

coming up with a defensible thesis for

AP lank you to the rhetorical analysis

question if you are interested in

finding out more tips on how to pass the

AP leg exam please don't forget to click

Subscribe and also turn your

notifications on because I'm going to be

posting more content every week on this

channel until next time guys happy

writing