CIRCUMCISED or UNCIRCUMCISED | Diverse Group
Summary
TLDRこのビデオでは、UCバークレーの学生たちに割礼についての知識を尋ねています。インタビューを通じて、学生たちは割礼の定義、理由、そして個人的な意見について話します。割礼が宗教的、文化的、または衛生的な理由で行われることを知っている人もいれば、詳しく知らない人もいます。さらに、自分の息子に割礼を行うかどうかについての考えも聞かれています。このビデオは、視聴者に割礼に対する様々な視点と意見を提供します。
Takeaways
- 😀 UCバークレーの学生に割礼に関する質問を行った。
- 😀 学生の年齢は18歳から22歳までで、様々な学年や民族の学生がインタビューに答えた。
- 😀 割礼の定義については、ほとんどの学生が包皮の除去と答えた。
- 😀 割礼の理由については、宗教的理由や衛生面を挙げる学生が多かった。
- 😀 アメリカで割礼が行われる理由については、宗教的および衛生的な理由が主なものとされていた。
- 😀 多くの学生は割礼の宗教的理由について詳しくは知らなかった。
- 😀 一部の学生は、個人的または家庭の伝統に基づいて割礼を行うことがあると述べた。
- 😀 割礼を自身の子供に行うかどうかについては、意見が分かれた。多くの学生が慎重な姿勢を示した。
- 😀 割礼に対する道徳的な論争について、一部の学生は子供が自ら決断できない点に疑問を抱いていた。
- 😀 美的な好みに関しては、ほとんどの学生が割礼の有無にこだわらないと答えた。
Q & A
このインタビューはどこで行われましたか?
-このインタビューはUCバークレーで行われました。
インタビューを受けた学生の学年は何ですか?
-インタビューを受けた学生は主に1年生から4年生まででした。
インタビューを受けた学生の年齢は?
-インタビューを受けた学生の年齢は18歳から22歳まででした。
インタビュー対象者の民族的背景はどのようなものでしたか?
-インタビュー対象者はインド人、白人、中国人、メキシコ人、ユダヤ人など多様な民族的背景を持っていました。
割礼に関する知識はどの程度ありましたか?
-ほとんどの学生は割礼に関する基本的な知識を持っていましたが、詳細な用語や手術の目的についてはあまり知られていませんでした。
アメリカで割礼が行われる理由は何ですか?
-宗教的理由や文化的理由、衛生的理由で行われることが多いです。
割礼の衛生的な理由について知っていましたか?
-はい、いくつかの学生は衛生的な理由について聞いたことがあると答えました。
割礼の宗教的理由について知っていましたか?
-学生の中には宗教的理由について知っている人もいましたが、具体的な宗教的背景や根拠については詳しくありませんでした。
割礼を家族で行ったことがある学生はいましたか?
-はい、いくつかの学生は家族内で割礼を行ったことがあると答えました。
将来的に自分の息子に割礼を行うかどうかについての意見は?
-多くの学生は自分の息子に割礼を行うかどうかについてまだ決めていない、または行わないと答えました。
Outlines
😀 UC Berkeleyでの男性の割礼に関するインタビュー
ビデオスクリプトの第1段落では、ディビッドがUC Berkeleyの学生に男性割礼について知っていることを尋ねています。学生たちは自分の学年や年齢、民族、宗教などを紹介し、割礼を定義し、その目的や理由について語ります。割礼は宗教的慣行として知られており、一部の人々は清潔さを理由にしていると語っています。また、アメリカにおける割礼の普及についても触れられています。
😐 割礼の個人的な見解と倫理的な議論
第2段落では、ディビッドが割礼に関する個人的な見解や倫理的な議論を探求しています。受訪者は自分の子供に対する割礼の考え方、宗教的な理由、清潔さ、個人の選択について話します。また、割礼の倫理的な側面についても議論されており、幼児期に行われる割礼は倫理的に問題があると一部の人々は考えています。受訪者からは、自己の子供に対する割礼の見解や、将来の選択についても言及されています。
Mindmap
Keywords
💡circumcision
💡UC Berkeley
💡ethnicity
💡hygiene
💡religious reasons
💡Jewish
💡Filipino
💡personal choice
💡controversy
💡aesthetics
Highlights
Students from UC Berkeley share their knowledge about circumcision.
Participants include freshmen, sophomores, juniors, and fourth-year students aged 18-22.
Ethnic backgrounds of the participants include Indian, white, Chinese, Filipino, Mexican, and Jewish.
Participants provide their definitions of circumcision, ranging from 'taking off the foreskin' to 'manipulation of the skin'.
Some participants only know circumcision as a religious practice.
Several students mention hygiene as a reason for circumcision.
Religious reasons for circumcision are discussed, particularly in Jewish and some Filipino cultures.
One participant notes that their family is not traditionally Filipino, and they are not sure about the reasons for circumcision in their culture.
A Jewish participant mentions familiarity with circumcision due to their religion.
Many participants do not have a strong personal opinion about circumcision, citing lack of information or not being directly affected.
Some participants express reluctance to circumcise their future sons without more research.
A few students mention potential moral controversies regarding circumcision, particularly when performed on infants.
Opinions on aesthetic preferences vary, with some participants indifferent and others preferring circumcised.
There is mention of potential stigmas but no strong consensus among participants.
One participant shares their personal preference for circumcised partners.
Transcripts
hi I'm David today we're at UC Berkeley
we're going to be asking people how much
they know about
circumcision so what year are you I'm a
freshman I'm a freshman uh so I'm a
sophomore I'm a sophomore I'm a junior
I'm a junior I'm fourth year how old are
you so you're about 18 18 I'm 19 19 and
I'm 19 20 20 I'm 22 I'm 22 22 uh What
ethnicity do you go by uh Indian Indian
okay white white okay um I'm I'm talane
Chinese okay I'm F I'm Chinese Chinese
uh Chinese I'm a Mayan Mexican Jewish a
big mix yeah I'm I'm I'm a mut yeah a
mut yeah um do you have any other are
you Jewish by any chance by marriage Mar
but not by Blood my stepmom is Jewish so
I've practiced some of it hi I'm here
with Grace today be asking her some
questions about circumcision uh in your
own words how would you define
me Define it um it's like taking off the
for right right um I just know it as a
religious practice that takes uh takes
away the for skin of the penis it's when
the
hi it's when when boys are born they get
the thing cut off the thing cut off okay
can you uh go into a little bit more
details do you know any terminology no I
don't we can move on isn't it when they
they cut the for skin right yeah
anything yes that's Works um it's
cutting the for skin offer manipulation
of the skin the four skin manipulation
nothing yeah don't know all right um the
surgical of the forest skin yeah yeah
that's good um America wise why is it
done in this country for what
reasons uh it's for some people do it
for religious reasons I think and then
um some people just think it's more
clean I think okay like just for
religious reasons and cultural Reasons
I'm not yeah I'm not aware of anything
you aware of the hygienic reason
reasoning yeah yeah I've heard about
that okay okay yeah it kind of prevents
like bacteria
um I'm not sure other than for the
religious reason so okay I only know
from my
done um and the Jewish people in America
they do
it I believe so some use it as an excuse
but yeah um hygiene reasons hygiene I
think yep y yeah is it I I would think
it's for the same like reason it's just
safer
like are you familiar with any of the
religious reasons for doing the surgery
no I mean I know there are religious
reasons but I'm not like no I'm not very
familiar like what the bases are do
Filipinos circumcise because of hygiene
or any religious reasons I thought it
was hygiene but I don't really know
we're not really traditional Filipinos
either okay yeah how familiar are you
with the practice of circumcision yes
I'm Jewish oh that that makes sense that
makes sense not that much I'm a girl
okay okay
um I mean I haven't done my own personal
person research but like my belief is
that
it's I mean it I don't know it's
tradition but also cuz it's like I think
it's it's
cleaner okay I mean I know it happens
but as a female I've never okay we're
talking about male circumcision yeah
male okay um do you have a history of
circumcision happening in your family no
no okay for Mo yeah most of the time
well for my experience like with my
family that's what they do with the
babies okay
um I would say traditionally yes further
back but I do know that my mom chose not
to circumcise my brother okay no I don't
talk about it with people okay yeah um I
mean I think most people do
it yeah familiar uh even with Chinese
Americans yeah yeah I think people do it
too okay so you've had it happen in your
own family yeah Two Brothers Two
Brothers how about you personally would
you circumcise your
son
um I don't I don't think so yeah
okay um I will ask the doctors for
advice I guess like it's it it really
depends on the circumstances like if
it's not necessary then probably not I'm
personally a Premed so I'll see like how
it goes so you would be probably not
circumcising your own son in the future
no n i don't I would definitely research
it more as of this moment right now no
no okay I have a little bit of
reservations not for anything specific
just because I rather not cause my kid
pain or not know exactly I'd like them
to make their choice um I guess I don't
really understand the purpose yeah and I
know that there's like a religious
purpose for it um but other than that
like because my family is not religious
would you think that you're going to
carry out certain decision on your own
son when the time comes absolutely no
question no question so I would assume
that you wouldn't do it to your own son
yeah okay and do you feel like there's
any like moral controversy about the
surgery um I think I think when some
people perform it at Birth like there's
a controversy since you're not like the
son or the child isn't really the one
making the decision but I guess like
when you get older if it's your own
choice I don't think because there
should be that much controversy about it
I'm not aware of any do you have any
preference of Aesthetics of an
uncircumcized versus circumcised
place I don't think it matters does
matter okay it doesn't really matter no
no it doesn't matter doesn't matter okay
have you heard of any stigmas regarding
either
kind um like it's something that I would
expect but I haven't really heard of
like people talking about it we just
talked to somebody earlier about like
how they felt that Cal was pretty Pro
circumcision do you feel that I have no
idea like I just came here so I okay
where is this going to be posted cuz I
was okay I'm just say it I mean as like
a like a woman like I prefer
like circumcised you know so yeah I have
not been with someone with an
uncircumcised once so I don't know yet
but I'd like to think not think not okay
yeah I would hope I don't okay yeah I
don't really have an opinion on
that hey guys David here thank you guys
for watching uh be sure to like comment
subscribe and check out more videos from
our Channel thank
[Music]
you
Voir Plus de Vidéos Connexes
Circumcision YES or NO / the FORESKIN dilemma
Circumcised vs uncircumcised! Do girls like circumcised or not?
Is it better to be circumcised or uncircumcised? Facts and myths about foreskin
Some Men Say Adult Circumcision Led to Better Sex
CIRCUMCISION: The Truth!! (I ♥ Foreskin)
Is circumcised better? - Foreskin Curious
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)