Pelopor khusus PBB Ke Papua Menemukan Bukti dan Fakta - Indonesia has deceived the UN

Summary

In an exclusive interview, the indigenous Papuan people express their strong rejection of the Indonesian government's claims to the UN regarding human rights violations and land seizures in Papua. Despite the UN Special Rapporteur's visit and discussions about indigenous rights, the Papuans argue that the government's actions contradict international law and violate their land rights. They demand the revocation of location permits for national projects and a real commitment to protecting their rights, calling out systemic violence, fraud, and lack of accountability in both state and international responses to their plight.

Takeaways

• 😀 Indigenous Papuan people reject the Indonesian government's claims to the UN, stating they are inconsistent with the on-ground reality.
• 😀 The Papuan people express frustration with the lack of genuine political recognition and action from international bodies like the UN regarding their rights.
• 😀 The interview with Dr. Albert Koko Barume, UN special rapporteur on indigenous peoples, highlights the need for real action, not just symbolic gestures, to protect Papuan rights.
• 😀 Despite legal frameworks protecting indigenous rights, the Papuan people demand concrete protection and action from both the Indonesian government and international community.
• 😀 Indigenous Papuans argue that previous visits from international officials have not resulted in meaningful change, as systemic violence, discrimination, and marginalization continue.
• 😀 The Papuan community urges the UN to press the Indonesian government to revoke permits for National Strategic Projects (PSNs) and cancel exploitative land-use agreements.
• 😀 The community accuses the Indonesian government of fraud and manipulation, citing discrepancies in reports and the lack of meaningful consultation with indigenous landowners.
• 😀 During their meeting with the UN special rapporteur, the indigenous Papuans presented evidence of land appropriation and human rights violations by Indonesian authorities and companies.
• 😀 The indigenous people of Papua argue that Indonesia's actions violate the special autonomy law, which was intended to protect their rights and self-determination.
• 😀 Dr. Albert Barume emphasized the importance of international legal frameworks for indigenous rights, though he noted that the effectiveness of these mechanisms depends on the willingness of states to respect them.

Q & A

What was the main message conveyed by the indigenous Papuan people regarding the Indonesian government's response to the UN?

The indigenous Papuan people strongly rejected the Indonesian government's claims made in their letter to the UN. They argued that the government’s response was based on falsehoods and did not reflect the reality on the ground regarding human rights violations and land seizures in Papua.

What are the key grievances of the indigenous Papuan people in relation to the government’s actions?

The key grievances include the seizure of their customary lands without proper consultation, violations of their rights, manipulation of attendance lists to legitimize land use permits, and a general lack of respect for their ancestral territories.

How did the indigenous Papuan people respond to the government’s justification for granting land use permits?

The indigenous Papuan people rejected the government’s justification, calling it a fraud. They emphasized that no legal procedures were followed in granting permits to companies, which were imposed on their lands without their consent or consultation.

What was Dr. Albert Koko Barume’s role in the meeting with the indigenous Papuan people?

Dr. Albert Koko Barume, the UN Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, was present to listen to the grievances of the indigenous Papuan people. He explained international frameworks for protecting indigenous rights and acknowledged their need for real action, not just legal recognition.

What international legal protections did Dr. Barume mention in relation to indigenous peoples?

Dr. Barume explained that indigenous peoples have special protections under international law, including the right to land, culture, and self-determination. However, he also pointed out that legal knowledge alone is insufficient without tangible action and political recognition.

What did the indigenous Papuan people hope to achieve from international bodies like the UN?

The indigenous Papuan people hope to achieve real political action and accountability from international bodies like the UN. They seek not only symbolic recognition but also concrete steps to halt the violations of their rights and to revoke land use permits granted to companies.

How do the indigenous Papuan people view previous visits by international officials?

The indigenous Papuan people expressed frustration with previous visits by international officials, believing that these visits have not led to meaningful change. They are skeptical of diplomatic agendas that appear good on paper but fail to address the ongoing issues they face.

What specific demands did the indigenous Papuan people make during the meeting with Dr. Barume?

The indigenous Papuan people demanded the revocation of all location permits issued by the Indonesian government, especially those granted to companies operating in Papua. They also insisted on proper legal procedures being followed before any land use permits are granted.

What was the reaction to the government's claim that it had followed proper procedures in granting land permits?

The indigenous Papuan people rejected the government's claim, stating that no proper consultation had been made with the landowners or local elders. They accused the government of fraud and manipulation, as the companies involved never engaged in legitimate discussions with the community.

How does Dr. Barume perceive the situation in Papua, based on his comments in the interview?

Dr. Barume acknowledged the beautiful history and landscape of Papua, but he also recognized the ongoing struggles faced by its people. He emphasized the importance of understanding international human rights mechanisms and how they can be used by indigenous communities to protect their rights.