Jessica Roth on Trump Trial Closing Statements
Summary
TLDRこのスクリプトは、元大統領ドナルド・トランプが関与した34項目の不正行為に関する裁判に関するものです。裁判所は、検察官が7時または8時まで裁判を続けることを陪審団に尋ね、早急に判決を出すための努力がされています。裁判は、トランプが記録の改ざんに関与したとされる証拠に基づいていますが、彼の署名がすべての文書にないことについても議論されています。陪審団は、証拠を評価し、有罪か無罪かの結論に達する必要があります。裁判の結果によっては、トランプが懲役刑を受ける可能性もありますが、裁判官は他の選択肢も持っています。シークレットサービスは、裁判の結果に備えてニューヨークの刑事当局と協議しています。
Takeaways
- 🕵️♂️ 検事は被告が証拠を改ざんする計画に関与していたと主張していますが、全ての記録に彼の署名がなかったり、他の証拠が直接的に関連性がない場合もあります。
- 📖 裁判所は陪審団に裁判の指示を与える予定で、彼らが議論を開始する前に裁判を続けることを望んでいます。
- 🕒 裁判所は陪審団のサービスを夜遅くまで延長する可能性があり、結論を出すために証拠を要約する必要があります。
- 🤔 裁判所は陪審団が早く結論に達する可能性があると予想していますが、1人または数人の陪審員が決定するのに時間がかかるかもしれません。
- 🏛️ 裁判所は、被告がこれらの犯罪に有罪判決を受けた場合でも、刑罰を科さないことができます。
- 🏢 裁判所は被告に対して罰金、保護観察、条件付き免訴など、他の選択肢があると示唆しています。
- 🔍 シークレットサービスはニューヨークの刑事当局と会談しており、前大統領が刑務所に収容される可能性があることを準備しています。
- 👥 陪審団は34の訴因を個別に検討する必要があり、それぞれの訴因について有罪か無罪かの結論に達する必要があります。
- 📚 裁判所は証拠が強力である場合とそうでない場合があると示しており、これは陪審団の判断に影響を与える可能性があります。
- 🎯 裁判所は被告が他の人を記録を改ざんするように仕向けたと主張しており、これは訴因の核となるとされています。
- 🗳️ 裁判所は陪審団の判断が一致するかどうかにかかわらず、結論を出すために迅速に行動する可能性があると示唆しています。
Q & A
裁判所はなぜ陪審団に7時または8時まで留まるかどうか尋ねたのですか?
-裁判所は、検察官が今日中に結論を述べ、捜査を終え、陪審団が議論を開始できるようにするためです。
裁判所はなぜ結論を早く述べることを望んでいるのですか?
-裁判所は、陪審団が帰って裁判所に戻った際に、裁判官が陪審団に指示を与え、彼らが議論を開始できるようにするためです。
検察官が7時に結論を述べなかった場合、裁判はどのように進むのですか?
-もし検察官が7時に結論を述べなかった場合、または陪審団がその時間まで留まることに反対する場合、裁判は明日に続けられる可能性があります。
裁判所が今夜陪審団のサービスを延長する理由は何ですか?
-裁判所は今夜結論を述べ終えるために陪審団のサービスを延長し、議論を開始できるようにするためです。
ロバート・マクホーターは裁判の質についてどのように述べていますか?
-マクホーターは、州が非常に良いケースを組み立て、また彼らがクライアントの要求を満たそうとしており、それが最良の法的戦略と完全に重なっていないかもしれないと述べています。
陪審団の議論はどのくらい時間がかかると思いますか?
-議論は長くないと考えられますが、1人または複数の陪審員が決定に時間を要する可能性もあります。
陪審団はどのように裁判を結論付けるのですか?
-陪審団は、証拠が強力であるか、またはないかに基づいて、裁判を有罪または無罪のいずれかで結論付けることができます。
裁判で34の訴因があるとのことですが、それらをどのように扱うのですか?
-陪審団はそれぞれの訴因を個別に検討する必要があり、トランプ氏の署名がすべての記録にない場合でも、彼は記録を改ざんするスキームに関与していたと結論付けることができます。
裁判が陪審団に渡された場合、今週中に判決が出る可能性はありますか?
-もし裁判が明日に渡され、陪審団が比較的迅速に働く場合、今週中に判決が出る可能性があります。
トランプ元大統領が刑務所に収監される可能性はありますか?
-多くの法的分析家は、トランプが刑務所に行くとは考えられていませんが、裁判所は彼に刑務所の刑を科すことができます。
秘密警護がニューヨークの刑事当局と会談したことは何を意味していますか?
-これは彼らが様々なシナリオに対応するために準備をしており、裁判所の命令に違反する場合の仮に裁判所の命令に反する場合の仮に裁判所に収監される可能性があることを意味しています。
Outlines
🕵️♂️ 裁判の締めくくりと陪審団の判断
裁判は陪審団が7時または8時まで残ることを尋ねる中で締めくくりが行われています。裁判所は被告のサマーマチネーションを完了させるため、陪審団が帰還した際に裁判所からの指示を受け取り、審判を開始できるようにすることを望んでいます。検察側が7時に終了しない場合、陪審団がその時間まで注意を保てるかどうかによって、裁判は翌日に続行される可能性があります。この裁判は非常に注目されており、被告側は強力な証拠と対峙して苦労していました。裁判所での弁護は、客の要望と最善の法的戦略が完全に一致しない可能性があるという課題がありました。陪審団の判断は、証拠とナレッジを評価し、有罪か無罪かを決定するという点で迅速に行われると予想されていますが、34の訴因を個別に検討する必要があるため、完全に一致する結論に達するまでに時間がかかる可能性もあります。
🏛️ 裁判での不敬行為とシークレットサービスの準備
トランプ氏が裁判で不敬行為に問われ、仮に裁判所の封口命令に違反した場合、30日間の刑罰が科せられる可能性があるというシナリオも存在しました。シークレットサービスはニューヨークの刑務官と連絡を取り、そのような事態に備えて準備を進めています。裁判所からの指示に従い、状況に応じて適切な対応をとるために、シークレットサービスは常に準備を整えておく必要があります。
Mindmap
Keywords
💡裁判
💡陪審団
💡裁判所の指示
💡裁判の結論
💡証拠
💡有罪
💡無罪
💡裁判所の手続き
💡裁判の日程
💡刑事訴訟
💡裁判の結果
Highlights
The jury is asked if they are open to staying until 7:00 or 8:00 PM to conclude summations.
The judge hopes to finish the summation tonight for the jury to receive instructions and start deliberations.
If the prosecutor is not finished by 7:00 PM, the proceedings will continue the next day.
There is a discussion on the quality of the defense in a high-profile case involving the former President of the United States.
The defense wrapped up quickly, attempting to connect the dots on the testimony.
Challenges faced by the defense due to a strong case presented by the state.
The defense was also trying to meet the demands of their client, which might not align with the best legal strategy.
Deliberations are expected not to be too long, but the possibility of one or more jurors needing time remains.
Jurors can conclude quickly whether they believe the narrative presented, corroborated by substantial evidence.
There are 34 counts in the case, which the jury would need to go through individually.
Evidence directly tying Mr. Trump to the records is stronger for some counts than others.
Mr. Trump's signature on some checks is a point of discussion, but legally it is not significant as the charge is about causing others to falsify records.
Some jurors might be held up on the fact that his signature does not appear on all records.
A verdict could potentially be reached this week if the jury works quickly.
CBS News reports that New York corrections officials have met with the Secret Service about the possibility of incarceration.
Most legal analysts do not see Donald Trump going to jail, despite the possibility of a prison sentence.
The statutory maximum for the crimes is four years imprisonment, but it is not mandatory.
The judge has discretion in sentencing and most defendants with no criminal record would not be sentenced to prison.
The Secret Service's meetings with New York officials show thorough preparation for any scenario.
There was a gag order violation by Trump, which could have led to discussions about temporary imprisonment for contempt of court.
Transcripts
WE SPEAK TO READ TAKING A BRIEF RAKE TO GET SOME FOOD.
WHAT COULD HAVE AN EXTENDED NIGHT.
THEY ASKED THE JURY IF THEY ARE OPEN TO STAY UNTIL 7:00 OR 8:00
READ I WONDER IF THAT MEANS HE'S GOING TO FINISH HIS WORK
TO THE EXTENT IT WOULD BEHOOVE HIM TO GET THIS DONE TODAY IN
THE EFFORT TO GET TO A VERDICT.
>> THAT IS CERTAINLY THE HOPE THE JUDGE HAS.
TO FINISH HIS SUMMATION TONIGHT SO THAT WHEN THE JURY RETURNS
TO COURT, THE JUDGE CAN GIVE THE JURY THEIR INSTRUCTIONS ON
THE WALK AND THEY CAN START THEIR DELIBERATIONS.
IF THE PROSECUTOR IS NOT FINISHED BY 7:00 OR WHEN THE
JURY SAYS THEY CAN STAY UNTIL AND KEEP THEIR ATTENTION, IT
WILL CONTINUE TOMORROW. THE REASON TO EXTEND THE JURY
SERVICE TONIGHT IS TO CONCLUDE THE SUMMATIONS. JOE:
WHAT IS YOUR THOUGHT ABOUT WHAT ROBERT MCWHORTER SAID, THE
QUALITY OF THE DEFENSE? IT IS A JURY THAT WILL GET ONE
OF THE MOST HIGH-PROFILE CASES EVER TRIED IN THE UNITED STATES.
DEFENSE WRAPPED QUICKLY. AS THEY TRY AND CONNECT THE
DOTS ON THE TESTIMONY THAT WE HAVE HEARD, I WONDER YOUR
THOUGHTS ON HOW WELL THE FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES
WAS REPRESENTED?
>> I THINK THEY HAD A CHALLENGE IN THE SENSE THE STATE PUT
TOGETHER A VERY GOOD CASE. AND ALSO, I THINK THEY WERE
TRYING TO SATISFY THE DEMANDS OF THEIR CLIENT, WHICH MAY NOT
HAVE ENTIRELY OVERLAPPED WITH WOULD HAVE BEEN THE BEST LEGAL
STRATEGY AND DEFENDING HIM IN THE COURTROOM.
I ALSO AGREE WITH THE COMMENT THE DELIBERATIONS ARE LIKELY
NOT TO BE THAT LONG. ONE NEVER KNOWS, IT IS POSSIBLE
THERE WILL BE ONE OR MORE JURORS WHO NEED TIME TO GET TO
A DECISION.
THERE IS A SENSE IN WHICH WHEN EITHER BELIEVES THE NARRATIVE
MICHAEL COHEN TOLD AS CORROBORATED BY THE SUBSTANTIAL
EVIDENCE IN THIS CASE, OR WHAT IT DOES NOT.
IN A SENSE, THE JURORS CAN CONCLUDE FAIRLY QUICKLY WHETHER
THEY ARE ABLE TO REACH A VERDICT OF GUILTY OR NOT GUILTY
UNANIMOUSLY. THERE ARE 34 COUNTS.
IN A SENSE, THEY WOULD NEED TO GO INDIVIDUALLY THROUGH EACH OF
THOSE ACCOUNTS. WITH RESPECT TO SOME OF THE
COUNTS, THE EVIDENCE DIRECTLY TYING MR. TRUMP TO THE RECORDS
AT THE HEART OF THIS CASE IS STRONGER THAN OTHERS.
FOR EXAMPLE, MR. TRUMP'S SIGNATURE APPEARS ON SOME OF
THE CHECKS THAT ARE THE BASIS FOR THE FALSIFICATION OF
RECORDS CHARGES HERE AND NOT OTHERS. THAT IS LEGALLY NOT THAT
SIGNIFICANT BECAUSE THE CHARGE IS TRUMP WAS PART OF A SCHEME
WHERE HE CAUSED OTHERS TO FALSIFY RECORDS, EVEN IF HE DID
NOT FALSIFY ALL OF THEM THROUGH HIS OWN HAND.
IT IS POSSIBLE SOME JURORS MIGHT BE HELD UP ON THE FACT
HIS SIGNATURE DOES NOT APPEAR ON ALL RECORDS, AND IT COULD
CAUSE THEM TO SPEND MORE TIME GOING THROUGH THE CHARGES
INDIVIDUALLY. BUT THIS IS A CASE WHERE IT IS
KIND OF ALL OR NOTHING. JOE: 34 CHARGES IN THIS CASE.
IF YOU COULD WALK WITH US THROUGH THE END OF THE WEEK
BASED ON WHAT YOU ARE SAYING, IF IT GOES TO THE JURY
TOMORROW, THE JURY WORKS RELATIVELY QUICKLY, WE COULD BE
TALKING ABOUT A VERDICT THIS WEEK.
CBS NEWS IS REPORTING NEW YORK CORRECTIONS OFFICIALS HAVE IN
FACT MET WITH THE SECRET SERVICE ABOUT THE POSSIBILITY
OF INCARCERATION. I DON'T BELIEVE THAT YOU SEE
THAT HAPPENING TO THE FORMER PRESIDENT.
MOST LEGAL ANALYSTS WE HAVE SPOKEN WITH DON'T SEE DONALD
TRUMP GOING TO JAIL. BUT WHAT DOES IT TELL YOU ABOUT
THE SECRET SERVICE IN THIS CASE, KNOWING THE PRESIDENT,
THE FORMER PRESIDENT, COULD BE LOCKED UP FOR A DAY?
I DON'T KNOW IF IT IS OVERNIGHT HOW THIS WILL WORK, HOW DOES IT
PLAY OUT WHAT SHOULD PEOPLE BE PREPARED FOR?
>> IT PROVIDES FOR A PRISON SENTENCE IF MR. TRUMP IS
CONVICTED OF THESE CRIMES. EVEN IF HE'S CONVICTED OF ONE,
THE STATUTORY MAXIMUM IS FOUR YEARS IMPRISONMENT.
THE JUDGE IS NOT REQUIRED TO IMPOSE A SENTENCE OF
IMPRISONMENT, THERE IS NO MANDATORY MINIMUM PRISON
SENTENCE. IN PRISON IS NOT A REQUIRED
SENTENCE AT ALL. THE JUDGE HAS A LOT OF OTHER
ALTERNATIVES. INCLUDING A FINE, PROBATION,
CONDITIONAL DISCHARGE WHERE HE WOULD BE SUBJECT TO CONDITIONS
TO ABIDE BY. IN MOST DEFENDANTS WHO ARE
CONVICTED OF THIS CRIME WHO HAVE NOT HAD ANY OTHER CRIMINAL
RECORD WOULD NOT BE SENTENCED TO PRISON.
THE JUDGE HAS ENORMOUS DISCRETION IN THE APPROPRIATE
SENTENCE. THE FACT THE SECRET SERVICE HAS
BEEN MEETING WITH NEW YORK AS IN OFFICIALS SHOWS THEY ARE
BEING THOROUGH AND DOING THEIR WORK SO THAT WHATEVER SCENARIO
UNFOLDS, THEY ARE PREPARED FOR IT.
IT MAY BE THAT THEY WERE HAVING SOME OF THESE DISCUSSIONS
DURING THE TRIAL THAT MR. TRUMP WOULD BE JAIL FOR CONTEMPT OF
COURT.
THERE WAS A GAG ORDER THAT WAS FOUND TO BE VIOLATED BY TRUMP,
AND THE STATUTE GOVERNING THAT AUTHORIZED PRISON FOR UP TO 30
DAYS. FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE COURTS
GAG ORDER. SO THAT WAS A SCENARIO IN WHICH
THE SECRET SERVICE WOULD HAVE ALSO BEEN APPROPRIATELY TALKING
TO NEW YORK PRISON OFFICIALS TO BE PREPARED FOR THE EVENTUALITY
THAT THE JUDGE, FOR VIOLATIONS OF CONDEMNED OF COURT --
CONTEMPT OF COURT MIGHT BE PUT INTO PRISON TEMPORARILY.
Parcourir plus de vidéos associées
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/eZ2cX8kqOgg/hq720.jpg?sqp=-oaymwEmCIAKENAF8quKqQMa8AEB-AH-CYAC0AWKAgwIABABGE4gMyh_MA8=&rs=AOn4CLDOzbfxxn4nTilgNXuDGHkRfMFo6Q)
Can't Read Too Much Into Note: Zeldin on Trump Jury
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/hMetdS5gjko/hq720.jpg)
Trump called his guilty verdict 'rigged.' Hear Biden's reaction
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/949-G6dGvic/hq720.jpg)
'I did my job': Manhattan D.A. Alvin Bragg on Trump verdict
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/t83bC7btE8U/hq720.jpg?sqp=-oaymwEmCIAKENAF8quKqQMa8AEB-AH-CYAC0AWKAgwIABABGBMgLih_MA8=&rs=AOn4CLD4RW8fWzRpvinI0AvLwcZrYOX04w)
Day One of Trump Jury Deliberations Ends | Balance of Power
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/w7hfhlSJ76w/hq720.jpg)
What you need to know about Hunter Biden's trial | REUTERS
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/8H01qQ1IODE/hq720.jpg)
Trump Found Guilty: Key Trial Moments That Led to Hush-Money Conviction | WSJ
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)