Algorithm Design | Approximation Algorithm | Vertex Cover Problem #algorithm #approximation
Summary
TLDRThis video delves into the Vex Cover problem, a well-known NP-complete problem, and its solution using approximation algorithms. The presenter explains the concept of Vex Cover and its reduction to the Independent Set problem, highlighting the challenges faced when dealing with NP-complete problems. The focus is on finding the minimum number of vertices required to cover all edges in a graph. The script introduces an approximation algorithm called 'approx Vex Cover G', which iteratively selects edges and removes incident vertices until all edges are covered, aiming for a polynomial time solution that approximates the optimal answer. The video also discusses the time complexity and provides examples to illustrate the algorithm's process and its 2-approximation property, ensuring users understand how the algorithm performs in polynomial time but may yield solutions that are twice the size of the optimal.
Takeaways
- 📚 The video discusses the Vertex Cover problem using approximation algorithms, a methodology for NP-complete problems.
- 🔍 It suggests that for NP-complete problems, there are difficulties in finding polynomial-time solutions, and approximation algorithms offer a way to achieve near-optimal results.
- 🎯 The goal of the Vertex Cover problem is to find the minimum number of vertices that cover all the edges in a graph, which is a part of NP-complete.
- 🤔 The script explains that taking all vertices as a cover is possible but not the minimum solution, which is the focus of the problem.
- 📘 The presenter refers to the Cormen book for the algorithm, indicating that the content is based on established literature.
- 🔧 The 'approxVortexCover G' algorithm is introduced, which iteratively selects an arbitrary edge and adds both vertices to the cover set, then removes all edges connected to these vertices.
- ⏱️ The time complexity of the approximation algorithm is discussed as being proportional to the number of edges, which is polynomial time.
- 📉 The script provides examples to illustrate the algorithm's process and how it arrives at an approximate solution, which may not always be optimal.
- 📝 The concept of an 'approximation ratio' is introduced, with the example given having an approximation ratio of 2, meaning the solution is at most twice the size of the optimal solution.
- 📚 A theorem is presented to prove that the approximation algorithm runs in polynomial time and achieves a 2-approximation of the optimal Vertex Cover.
- 💬 The presenter encourages viewers to comment if they have doubts, indicating an interactive approach to education.
Q & A
What is the main topic of the video?
-The main topic of the video is discussing the Vertex Cover problem using approximation algorithms.
Why are approximation algorithms used for NP-complete problems?
-Approximation algorithms are used for NP-complete problems because they can provide near-optimal solutions in polynomial time, which is not always achievable with exact solutions.
What is the Vertex Cover problem?
-The Vertex Cover problem is a NP-complete problem where the goal is to find a minimum set of vertices such that each edge in the graph is incident to at least one vertex in the set.
What does the term 'approximation' mean in the context of the Vertex Cover problem?
-In the context of the Vertex Cover problem, 'approximation' refers to the process of finding a solution that is nearly optimal, but not necessarily the absolute minimum, in polynomial time.
What is the significance of the term 'epsilon' in the approximation algorithm?
-The term 'epsilon' in the approximation algorithm represents the degree to which the solution can deviate from the optimal solution. For example, a 2-approximation algorithm provides a solution that is at most twice the size of the optimal solution.
What is the time complexity of the approximation algorithm discussed in the video?
-The time complexity of the approximation algorithm discussed in the video is O(e), where 'e' represents the number of edges in the graph.
How does the approximation algorithm select vertices for the Vertex Cover?
-The approximation algorithm selects vertices for the Vertex Cover by arbitrarily choosing an edge and including both its endpoints in the cover set, then removing all edges incident to these vertices from the graph, and repeating the process until all edges are covered.
What is the difference between the optimal Vertex Cover and the approximate Vertex Cover?
-The optimal Vertex Cover is the smallest possible set of vertices that covers all edges in the graph, while the approximate Vertex Cover is a solution that may be larger but can be found in polynomial time.
Why is the minimum number of vertices important in the Vertex Cover problem?
-The minimum number of vertices is important because it represents the most efficient solution to the problem, using the least amount of resources to cover all edges.
How does the video script explain the proof that the approximation algorithm is a 2-approximation?
-The script explains the proof by showing that for any edge 'a' in the graph, the optimal cover must include at least one of its endpoints, and the approximation algorithm includes both endpoints, thus ensuring that the approximation is at most twice the size of the optimal cover.
Outlines
📚 Introduction to Approximation Algorithms for Vertex Cover Problem
This paragraph introduces the topic of the video, which is the Vertex Cover problem and its solution using approximation algorithms. The speaker explains that for NP-complete problems like Vertex Cover, where finding an exact solution can be difficult, approximation algorithms can be used to find a near-optimal solution. The video is aimed at those who have already seen previous videos on the topic, and it emphasizes the importance of understanding the basics, such as what a Vertex Cover is and how it relates to the Independent Set problem. The speaker also discusses the challenges of NP-complete problems and the three general approaches to tackling them: reducing problem size, focusing on special cases, or using approximation algorithms to achieve polynomial time complexity.
🔍 Understanding the Vertex Cover Problem and Its Approximation
The speaker delves deeper into the Vertex Cover problem, explaining that the goal is to find the minimum number of vertices that, when selected, cover all the edges in the graph. The paragraph clarifies that while it's possible to select all vertices as a cover, the challenge lies in finding the most efficient, minimal cover. The speaker introduces the approximation algorithm 'approxVortexCover G' and explains its basic steps: starting with an empty set of vertices, selecting an arbitrary edge, adding its endpoints to the cover set, and then removing all edges connected to these endpoints from the graph. The process repeats until all edges are covered. The time complexity of this algorithm is discussed, highlighting that it's proportional to the number of edges (O(e)).
📘 Example Walkthrough of the Approximation Algorithm
In this paragraph, the speaker provides a detailed example to illustrate how the approximation algorithm works. Using a graph with seven vertices and eight edges, the algorithm is applied step by step. The speaker explains the process of selecting arbitrary edges, adding their endpoints to the cover set, and then removing the relevant edges from the graph. The example demonstrates the algorithm's progress and how it builds up the vertex cover set, ultimately arriving at an approximate solution. The speaker emphasizes that while this example results in an approximation, the algorithm does not always yield the optimal solution.
🔑 Comparing Approximate and Optimal Vertex Covers
The speaker compares the concept of an approximate vertex cover with the optimal vertex cover. The paragraph explains that the optimal vertex cover is the minimal set of vertices that cover all edges, while the approximate cover, generated by the algorithm, may include more vertices. An example is used to show that the approximate cover may not be minimal but still covers all edges. The speaker discusses the importance of understanding the difference between the two and the trade-off between solution quality and computational efficiency. The explanation includes a step-by-step analysis of how the optimal cover might be determined and contrasts it with the approximate cover provided by the algorithm.
📚 Theoretical Analysis of the Approximation Algorithm
This paragraph focuses on the theoretical analysis of the approximation algorithm for the Vertex Cover problem. The speaker presents a theorem that the approximation algorithm runs in polynomial time and is a 2-approximation algorithm, meaning that the solution it provides is at most twice the size of the optimal solution. The proof involves showing that for any edge, the optimal cover must include at least one of its endpoints, and therefore, the approximation algorithm, which includes both endpoints, will be no more than twice the size of the optimal cover. The speaker emphasizes the importance of understanding the theoretical guarantees provided by approximation algorithms and how they can be used to solve complex problems efficiently.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Vex Cover Problem
💡Approximation Algorithm
💡NP-Complete
💡Independent Set
💡Polynomial Time
💡Graph Theory
💡Optimal Solution
💡Time Complexity
💡Arbitrary Edge
💡Vertex Cover Approximation
💡Theorem
Highlights
Introduction to the vertex cover problem and its approximation using an algorithmic approach.
Explanation of the vertex cover problem as part of NP-complete problems and the challenges associated with it.
Discussion on the three expected solutions for NP-complete problems, focusing on approximation algorithms.
Definition of polynomial time and its relevance to the approximation algorithm.
Introduction of the approximation algorithm as a method to achieve polynomial time solutions.
Explanation of the vertex cover problem in terms of minimizing the number of vertices selected.
Clarification that the vertex cover problem aims to find the minimum number of vertices, not all vertices.
Description of the algorithm 'approxVortexCover G' and its parameters.
Discussion on the time complexity of the approximation algorithm, which is proportional to the number of edges.
Explanation of the algorithm's process of selecting an arbitrary edge and updating the vertex set.
Illustration of the algorithm's execution with a simple graph example.
Introduction of the concept of optimal solutions and approximation values in the context of the vertex cover problem.
Explanation of the approximation factor and its significance in the approximation algorithm.
Presentation of a book example with seven vertices and eight edges to demonstrate the algorithm.
Discussion on the optimal vertex cover and how it compares to the approximation algorithm's results.
Proof that the approximation algorithm is a polynomial time 2-approximation algorithm.
Conclusion summarizing the understanding of the approximation algorithm for the vertex cover problem and its practical implications.
Transcripts
hello everyone welcome to educ in this
video we are going to discuss about Vex
cover problem using approximation
algorithm methodology okay so those who
are new kindly watch the previous videos
where we discussed about the deductions
that time where we have already
completed some of about the vortex cover
problem to reducible to Independent set
that time we discussed like what is
Vortex cover in depth we have uh read
that one as well as independent set also
we have completed so let us start with
that one like Vortex C problem so here
uh the vertex C problem we are working
with that uh so basically we are going
to use the approximation algorithm the
approximation algorithm especially is we
using like we know when we are working
for the NP complete problems uh we found
like there are three uh difficulties
there are many difficulties we are
getting so there are three solutions we
can expect as we have already completed
in the introductory video that time we
found either the space could be small or
might be we can take the small example
or the small uh categorical problems
through which we can at least expect the
polinomial time because this happens
because of polinomial time though we are
not getting the polinomial time that's
why we reading this one okay like we are
trying to reduce if it is not possible
to reduce is there any other way to
reduce towards the polinomial because
polinomial is a typ time like you can
say B go of n to the per K okay K
represents the constant this is what the
polinomial time so nothing I must not
say that one like nothing in the world
is poal but I must say something there
is a way through which at least we can
achieve the polinomial though we are
getting it that's why we have different
ways one of the ways are one of the ways
you can say uh is your approximation
algorithm so the approximation algorithm
is a way that we have used here
basically Vex cover is a part of NP
complete so as I told you the first we
have a solution like we can take a small
one second as we have already discussed
is you can say uh if similar or a
special case of things we can focus like
three sh some problems we can say
through which at least we can expect the
polom if both two cases which we have
already studed if both two cases are not
there like there is another way through
which at least we can get nearly optimal
result the near optimal result is
approximation which we have already
discussed in the previous videos okay so
here in the vortex cover problem this
this problem basically we are focusing
Vortex cover in the sense like uh
minimization of picking the notes like
we will pick the minimum noes through
which we must say like all the edges
connected to the vortex which you have
have selected is the vortex cover here
Vortex cover that doesn't mean that only
minimum you can take all the vertex as
the vortex cover not an issue but the
problem is if I take all the vertex in
the graph that is also part of Vortex
cover the minimum one is a part of the
Vex cover here exactly what we are doing
we are working for the minimum one that
is where the problem we are occurring
otherwise I must say like the E is the
ages V is a vertices of a graph okay if
I would like to say like it's it's
definitely I must say big of fun to say
vertex cover in what sense if I say all
the vertices which you have is
equivalent to the vertex cover that time
I must say because all the vertices are
covering means are connecting with the
edges in general you can say I'm taking
this example of a
graph clear this is just a graph or you
can say a tree I must still for a graph
all vertices should be connected me
there is a cycle must be present for a
graph okay so if I would like to say the
vortex cover I must say if I'm selecting
all the vertices it's also part of
Vortex cover but this is not exactly our
Target is to find the Vex cover is
minimum one whenever we are focusing on
the minimum like the minimum means the
number of vertices which you are
selecting should be less
clear if I'm selecting
a this will be covered this will be
covered clear if I'm
selecting B this will be covered and
this will be covered so what we have to
do like out of this like there is a
three vertices are there so if I'm
picking this one so I must cover this
one also so two vertices at least needed
to complete or to say a minimum vertex
cover clear this is what exactly we are
targeting to find out so the Tex cover
you can say the total is could be
considered whenever you are considering
total is this is a maximum Vex cover
this is not our Target is the minimum
size the minimum one whenever we are
discussing that is a part of you that is
our Target how to define the minimum
number of edges to be considered as a
part of vertex cover this is our Target
okay minimum vertex cover I must write
that one here
minimum minimum number
of AG uh
vertices
for vex
cover this is our Target or a and
objective you can say to find minimum
number of vertices required or need
needed for the vertex
cover next uh I must tell you like I'm
following the book for this problem I'm
following uh Corman book you can follow
that one the same to same I'm keeping
the lines and wordings there so this is
an algorithm you can say the algorithm
name as approx Vortex cover G here C is
a set you can say C stands for the
set for keeping
the
vertices keeping the
vertices next e Dash is a age which is
equivalent to g dot represents while the
number of edges clear until it is empty
mean suppose as I have already given you
the example so here this is one
graph here the edges are three until the
are three like we will run that one
clear so from this we found uh it will
run for big of e because V Loop we have
included within that while loop we set
until it is e means big of Fe the number
of edges we are actually having that one
we can say definitely it's a part of our
complexity which we have already
completed in our the the first the might
be the complexity video that time we
have completed uh to find out the term
complexity so you can say until so we
will return it Okay so until means we
are just focusing on the number of edges
so here as for the time complexity I
must tell you the time complexity could
be big of e why because the number of
Ages we are focusing at here clear next
once we started this one let
U be on arbitrary edge of e Dash we just
whenever we said e Dash e is skipping
all the number of edges from the graph
clear so then what we'll
do c was previously is a set C was empty
set this represents empty set okay of
five like we include suppose UV suppose
here is a I'm just writing this one a so
a comma B both we will be keeping
because from an age if the if I'm
picking one age a will have two end
points here is for that one A and B
whenever I'm keeping this age so here it
is written UV clear that UV is Union
means we added to that the five which
was previously
there then
remove from E Dash every Edge incident
to either U or V means once I'm picking
this one once I'm picking this one the
two end points I have one and a and b so
what I have to do I have to remove this
one I have to remove this one what it is
written I have to remove that one I'm
just picking this one so written c c is
a so we are expecting our Optimal
Solutions first of all this C is
approximation value the number of
vertices are two if I'd like to say for
this example the optimal optimal means
what what should be the uh the answer
what should be our expected answer clear
means what should be the correct answer
for us so we have already checked that
one for optimal value either a AC CB
anything we can take but at least two so
for uh if this is C if I'm writing C
star so C star could be the optimal uh
solution or optimal uh number of or
optimal set you can say if I'm picking
also it keeps either a b or B comma C or
a comma
C so the optimal means whenever you
focus on the vertex cover the number of
vertices which you are going to pick is
either AB BC anything you are taking so
that should be two also here the
approximation for this example as we
have already covered in the previous
video as an introduction for this graph
for this graph we are saying one
approximation one approximation means
which is equivalent to the optimal
answer optimal
algorithm or optimal value for this
example for this example we are
expecting the one approximation where
Epsilon is equivalent to zero means the
extra which we are adding in 2 three
whatever we are taking suppose for two 2
approximation we must say epsilon is 1
why because 1 + Epsilon we have already
said in the approximation one that time
we must say for approximation value if
it is two means more than one suppose we
have so that one more than one whatever
is there so we can say it is Epsilon for
us okay so uh we will be discussing with
the example so for this example which we
just have taken for our uh you know
approach for this one we found one
approximation for this one but this is
not always correct okay next for the
example you can say uh suppose this is
example this is a book example I have
kept here so a b c uh d e f g there are
almost seven vertices we have with us
and the ages is 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 okay
there
are 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 and 8 eight edes are
there so what we are doing first we'll
start
arbitrarily eight means we will start
with the while loop while loop will run
for eight number of times because we
need to remove all the elements all the
edges the number of edges are eight so
we will take all the eight up to in of
five means zero up to up to eight we
will run this is what it represents
arbitrary written arbitrary Edge we are
not always saying only this one will be
picked or this one will be picked number
wise no arbit you can take EF also but
as for the book they have taken B to C
okay so this age once this AG is
selected line five which it says the C
was previously five here C is previously
five for this one C is B comma C the two
elements we have included clear next As
for six remove e- every incident means B
to C which are connected we have to
remove this one just dotted L says we
are removing that one clear this is what
the C value is I'm just writing C value
here B and C node here arbitary again we
have two options we have uh 1 2 3 3 4
five there are four options we have
because every others are we have already
removed so here I as for the book they
have taken E and F so once E and F is
picked now C value will be previously it
was B comma C why because here it is
Union okay B comma c e comma F we are
picking so now C value is
updated only one we have to pick there
is
not no other ver edges are free then
what we'll
do we have to pick that one b c e f d
then G this is our final uh you can say
the vertex cover okay which is using the
approximation algorithm or approximate
vertex cover you can say this is our C
value so uh this one is approximate Vex
cover I can say us approximate so that
that's why I'm just writing
uh
approximate vertex cover or ABC this one
is AVC so which choose we have selected
b c d e f g this is our uh number of
nodes or number of vertices we have
selected but for the optimal which is
said as C star
like if you say the optimal means the
number of vertices which we are
selecting wisely that should be minimum
clear minimum means you can check
suppose I'm picking B indirectly I'm
removing this one clear if I'm keeping e
I'm ring this one means I'm covering
basically here no removing Concepts we
should use we will cover when we are
covering so I'm putting tick mark okay
next if I'll pick D also uh Tex to be
covered so here a part of cover we are
supposed saying so for optimal
indirectly what we are doing so you can
check we can cover all the edges if I'm
saying covering all the edges I'm just
putting this Mark so you can take all
the ages should be covered that's why we
can say it's a Vortex cover so here
optimally what exactly we are doing b e
d this is not always a true but
definitely I must say as we have already
studied in the independent set that time
you can compare one okay so if I would
like to say a then a could at least keep
this one if I'm keeping C so c will
cover this one if I'm giving d d will
cover this one but this age will be
covered by at least one of the uh vertex
that's why the problem will arise for
the optimal one means what should be the
best answer this is our best best one
best or optimal you can
say optimal
value of vertex cover okay so is b d
only clear those
so the the problem is not that much hard
to understand the way how we are doing
the approximate value or approximation
how we doing that one that is playing a
vital Ro
okay so I hope you understood here we
are keeping 3 36 here our C value if I'm
saying mode so it is six here if I'm
doing the mode means the number of
vertices here it is three so if you can
say like which we have studied earlier
is a row value so here is c c
star which we must say two approximate
value or two approximation
to approximation okay this is what we
have
covered like the row value is two here
and we must say it's approximation 2
approximation so I hope you understood
this one theorem I kept for you so here
in the theorem basically how to prove it
that matters a lot always so approximate
cover is a polinomial time two is two
approximation algorithm it it just shows
whatever the appro oximation that you
have done polinomial time exactly you're
getting but that is two approximation
means it is two times more than the
optimal answers what should be the
optimal answer is this one should be the
optimal answer but it is two time more
the approximation value which you got is
two time more that's why it is two
approximation clear so uh proof that
whenever we are starting with a proof
always you should remember what exactly
we are representing like C represented
as the set of vertices that you are
getting through approximate vertex cover
as we have already discussed that one
clear and here they have introduced a a
is just an age you can say here the
cover and age is a has two end points
okay like it has two end points so
whenever we start with c c is optimal
cover optimal Vortex cover you can say
or optimal cover set of optimal Vortex
cover which we have studied earlier
clear so here this is the optimal vertex
cover or best vertex cover you can say
so it is three so like that but how to
basically verify that one so whenever we
say Vex is a minimum one means there is
an end point of A and B suppose this is
our a clear this is our a I am just
changing that suppose C with d the
naming convention I'm changing just try
to understand suppose this is a we're
having this one so there are two
different end points we have for
whenever we say say optimal we have to
pick at least one if I'm saying
approximate for approximate two end
points have to be selected that is what
the problem is clear whenever I must say
keeping the optimal one optimal will
keep at least C or or D any one of this
but at least one this is what it is
written clear optimal include at least
one end point it is clearly mentioned so
definitely a has two end points and here
it will skip one that's why
clip this C and this one first we'll
cover up so this C whenever we discussed
with C star
and with a what exactly we should have
to do like for the line
four line four means here let youu be an
arbitrary age we just picked arbitrary
age which we discuss this one
clear so next Once the arbitrary AE is
being fixed so optimal cover we should
have the optimal cover optimal cover at
least we will pick one of them so
whenever we should say the one of them
we are picking up so this condition will
satisfy once it is satisfied next C
which is the approximate value c will
keep the both the end points clear both
the end point it should have to keep
that's why it cover up with Cal to 2 a
means there are two different end points
we have So based on that we will pick
this one if you equate if you equate
this to like
3.2 35.2 35.3 if you're going for
equation so what you'll get it like c
equal to 2 a
this is what exactly you got in 3.5
earlier 35.3 so you just equate with the
previous equation definitely you'll get
uh this C is less than equal to 2 C star
means earlier you were just keeping this
was our like for C I must
tell U
First for this example means there is
two edges uh sorry one edge with two
vertices
so c will keep definitely we studied
earlier like two end points C and D okay
so C star will be picking at least one
of them either C or D anything
or D clear so if I'm saying this one so
it represents two because the number of
uh vertices are this one and for C
star it is one it's a basic simple
example that through which we can
understand so definitely it is two times
uh more you know C uh that's why you can
say C is less than equal to 2 into 1 why
you are saying uh less than might be it
is somehow the problem could be the what
exactly you getting suppose 1.5 instead
of 1.5 you you might expect that one so
it is some somehow nearly equivalent to
two-way approximation that's why we are
saying in this order clear I hope it is
clearly understood by you where we are
getting the approximation through which
uh we we have completed the
approximation on Vex cover and we are
getting in polinomial time but the
polinomial time is two two approximation
algorithm two times the optimal answer
we are expect uh we are getting but our
expectation should be exactly one
approxim
but we are getting two approximation
this is what we have completed of the I
hope it is clearly understood by you if
any doubt please comment below thank you
Parcourir plus de vidéos associées
Algorithm Design | Approximation Algorithm | Traveling Salesman Problem with Triangle Inequality
Algorithm Design | Network Flow | Ford-Fulkerson Algorithm | MAXIMAL FLOW PROBLEM | MAX FLOW PROBLEM
Integration and the fundamental theorem of calculus | Chapter 8, Essence of calculus
Discrete Log Problem - Applied Cryptography
Lamport's Mutual Exclusion Distributed Systems Synchronization
Basics of Asymptotic Analysis (Part 3)
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)