Argument of Proposal Lecture

Summary

In this lecture, the instructor introduces students to the concept of an argument of proposal, which suggests a change or action on a civic issue. The students' third essay will be based on this format, which requires them to propose solutions, backed by solid reasoning and research. Key aspects include defining a clear problem, creating a strong thesis, presenting feasible solutions, and integrating diverse types of research. The lecture also stresses the importance of audience awareness and feasibility in proposals, as well as proper MLA formatting for citations. Students are encouraged to stay engaged and prepare for the upcoming quiz and essay.

Takeaways

• 😀 Argument of proposal essays suggest a change or action, either advocating for or against something.
• 😀 The format of an argument of proposal thesis generally follows: 'A should do B because of C'—with A being the action, B the proposal, and C the reasoning.
• 😀 Proposal arguments should be future-focused, aiming to change behavior or prevent actions moving forward.
• 😀 The audience is central in argument of proposal essays, as the goal is to persuade them to take action or change their behavior.
• 😀 Clear definition of the problem is the first step when writing an argument of proposal essay.
• 😀 The thesis statement must clearly identify the problem, propose a change or action, and provide reasons for this change.
• 😀 Feasibility is a crucial element in proposal arguments—proposed changes must be realistic and practical given current technology and resources.
• 😀 Visuals such as graphs, pie charts, and tables can be useful in argument of proposal essays, but they do not count toward the page total.
• 😀 Research support in proposal essays should be diverse, including statistics, quotes, facts, and logical reasoning to strengthen the argument.
• 😀 It's important to integrate research seamlessly into the argument, ensuring that it is relevant, sourced from reputable materials, and logically connected to the main points.
• 😀 MLA formatting is essential, with proper in-text citations and a works cited page, ensuring that all referenced materials are correctly documented.

Q & A

What is the focus of this week's lesson?

This week's lesson focuses on argument proposals, specifically the third essay, which will be about proposing a change or action related to a civic issue. The lecture will cover Chapter 12 in the textbook, and the students are also expected to read Chapter 11, though it will not be directly lectured on.

What is an argument of proposal?

An argument of proposal suggests a change or action. It can argue for or against something, proposing that a specific action be taken or stopped, with supporting reasons explaining why.

What does the basic structure of a proposal thesis look like?

The basic structure of a proposal thesis is: 'A should do B because C,' where A is the entity or group being addressed, B is the proposed action or change, and C provides the supporting reasons for why the action should take place.

Can you provide an example of a proposal thesis?

Yes, an example could be: 'Every student who takes out a federal student loan should have to perform some sort of national service because it will ensure the country gets something in return for the loan, teach personal responsibility, and enhance national pride and patriotism.'

What are some key characteristics of arguments of proposal?

Arguments of proposal are future-focused, centered around the audience to persuade them to take action, and suggest a change or action. They also require clear definitions of the problem and feasible solutions.

What are the steps for writing an argument of proposal?

The steps for writing an argument of proposal include: 1) Clearly defining the problem, 2) Creating a clear thesis statement that identifies the problem and proposes a change or action with reasons, 3) Conducting research, 4) Developing main points, and 5) Writing the proposal.

What considerations should be kept in mind when developing an argument of proposal?

When developing an argument of proposal, ensure that your change or action directly addresses the problem at hand, that it is feasible, and that it is focused on the future. Additionally, proposals can benefit from using visuals like graphs or charts.

Why is it important for a proposal to be feasible?

A proposal must be feasible because if the solution is unrealistic or impossible to implement, it loses its effectiveness. For example, proposing an outer space filter to block UV radiation is not feasible with current technology.

What types of research should be integrated into an argument of proposal?

Various types of research can be integrated, including statistics, numerical data, quotes, facts, and logic. It is important to use a variety of research sources to strengthen your argument and make it more credible.

What are some tips for effectively integrating research into a proposal?

Some tips for integrating research include: ensuring the support is relevant and from reputable sources, making sure the research flows logically into your argument, avoiding repetition, and using a mix of different types of support (such as quotes, statistics, and logic).