Is Makkari A Well Written Speedster?

Summary

In this video, the creator explores the character of McCari from *Eternals*, arguing that she is a well-written and consistent speedster. The creator highlights three key reasons: McCari doesn't have a 'Time in a Bottle' moment, showcasing her as a grounded character; she possesses both durability and strength, which add to her believability; and she consistently fights at super speed, making her combat scenes more impactful. The video also notes that McCari is actively involved in team dynamics, unlike many sidelined speedsters. The creator hints at discussing McCari's flaws in a future video, teasing deeper insights into writing speedsters effectively.

Takeaways

• 😀 Makkari from *Eternals* is a well-written and consistent speedster, praised for her grounded abilities.
• 😀 She does not have a 'time in a bottle' moment, meaning she isn't shown moving in slow motion, which keeps her powers grounded and realistic.
• 😀 The lack of 'time in a bottle' helps avoid the overpowered trope that often makes speedsters seem invincible in other media.
• 😀 Makkari is not depicted as a speedster with enhanced perception that lets her see time slow down, maintaining the consistency of her abilities.
• 😀 Unlike many other speedsters, Makkari shows physical durability and strength that match her speed, helping her withstand attacks without being taken out of the fight.
• 😀 Makkari is shown to have super strength, enabling her to fight and hold her own against powerful opponents while maintaining her speed.
• 😀 She does not suffer from the common trope where speedsters can be hurt by regular strikes, despite their super speed.
• 😀 Makkari fights at super speed, not slowing down to punch or move but using her full speed in combat, making her more effective and dynamic.
• 😀 The fact that Makkari’s strikes aren’t slowed down makes each punch or move feel impactful and grounded, which adds depth to her fighting style.
• 😀 Makkari is actively engaged in her team's battles, unlike other speedsters who are sometimes sidelined or absent during team fights.
• 😀 The video creator plans to explore the flaws of Makkari and how to properly write speedsters in a future video, acknowledging that no character is perfect.

Q & A

What is the main focus of the video in relation to Makkari from *Eternals*?

The main focus of the video is to analyze Makkari as a well-written and consistent speedster, based on three key reasons: her lack of a 'time in a bottle' moment, her durability and strength, and her consistent use of super speed in combat.

Why does the creator mention 'time in a bottle' moments in the video?

The creator mentions 'time in a bottle' moments to highlight how many speedster characters are often shown to possess time manipulation abilities or slow down time. Makkari, however, doesn’t exhibit such abilities, making her a more consistent and believable speedster.

What is meant by a 'time in a bottle' moment for speedsters?

'Time in a bottle' moments refer to scenes where speedsters are portrayed as moving so fast that time appears to slow down for them. These moments can make speedsters seem almost invincible or too powerful, which the creator believes can hurt the consistency of their character.

How does Makkari’s durability and strength stand out compared to other speedsters?

Makkari is shown to have both enhanced strength and durability, which allow her to hold her own against other powerful characters. Unlike some speedsters who get hurt by normal attacks, Makkari can withstand a laser blast and continue fighting, showing a balance between her speed and physical resilience.

What issue does the creator have with other speedsters, like the Flash in CW shows?

The creator criticizes the portrayal of speedsters, like the Flash in the CW series, for not consistently fighting at super speed. They argue that speedsters should always fight using their speed, rather than slowing down for dramatic effects or plot convenience.

What does the creator mean when they say that Makkari ‘fights at super speed’?

The creator means that Makkari is consistently shown to move and fight at super speed, without slowing down for punches or actions. Her strikes are powerful, and you can see the force behind each one, as opposed to some speedsters who are portrayed in slow motion for dramatic effect.

What is the significance of Makkari being actively involved in fights, according to the creator?

The creator appreciates that Makkari is actively engaged in every fight, contributing to the team rather than being sidelined, as is often the case with speedster characters in team settings. This makes her a more compelling and useful character within the team dynamics.

How does the creator differentiate Makkari from other speedsters in terms of consistency?

The creator differentiates Makkari by stating that, unlike many other speedsters, she doesn’t suffer from inconsistencies like being caught off guard or losing because of time manipulation. Her abilities and actions are shown in a more grounded and believable manner.

What did the creator clarify about the Flash’s ability to slow down time?

The creator clarified that the Flash does not have the ability to slow down time. Instead, he moves so fast that his perception of time is altered, making it appear as though time is slowed down for him, which is a common misconception.

What is the creator’s perspective on how to write speedster characters effectively?

The creator believes that speedster characters should be written with consistent rules and limitations. They should not be overly reliant on dramatic 'time manipulation' moments and should be shown to utilize their speed in logical, consistent ways, as demonstrated by Makkari.