She-Hulk Is Absolutely Trash From Marvel (SORRY)

Summary

In this video, the creator discusses their disappointment with the She-Hulk TV series, expressing concerns about its writing, character development, and portrayal of important themes. They argue that the show fails to effectively showcase Jennifer Walters' struggles, rushes key plot points, isolates audiences, and features contradictory character traits. The creator also criticizes the lack of courtroom scenes despite the show's premise and the poor depiction of villains. Ultimately, the video stresses the importance of writing strong, well-developed characters, regardless of gender, and calls for better storytelling in future Marvel projects.

Takeaways

• 😀 The reviewer expresses disappointment in She-Hulk's storytelling, particularly how the show handles Jennifer Walters' past struggles through dialogue rather than visual representation.
• 😀 The rushed writing of the series, especially during key emotional moments like Jennifer's apology to Bruce, diminishes their impact and emotional weight.
• 😀 The reviewer criticizes the show for isolating certain audience groups by catering too much to a specific demographic, rather than appealing to a broader audience.
• 😀 There is a concern that Jennifer Walters' character comes across as contradictory, with inconsistent traits that undermine her development as a complex protagonist.
• 😀 The critique points out that She-Hulk fails to effectively build tension with its villains, leading to underwhelming antagonists that lack depth.
• 😀 The review suggests that the portrayal of Jennifer’s anger and struggles with her Hulk persona is shallow, lacking the necessary exploration of her character's backstory and challenges.
• 😀 The writing is considered lazy in its portrayal of male characters, particularly in how it creates a one-dimensional misogynist figure who adds little to the plot.
• 😀 The review argues that the show fails to balance humor with serious storytelling, missing the opportunity for more impactful moments.
• 😀 There's criticism of how the She-Hulk series treats its protagonist’s conflicting feelings about being a Hulk, calling it inconsistent and confusing for the audience.
• 😀 The reviewer emphasizes that good storytelling in superhero shows, especially in relation to strong female characters, should focus on compelling arcs rather than relying on forced feminist themes.

Q & A

Why does the reviewer believe the portrayal of Jennifer Walters' past is ineffective?

The reviewer argues that Jennifer Walters' past struggles, such as being catcalled and facing discrimination, are only told through dialogue rather than shown visually. This method is seen as ineffective because it doesn't allow the audience to truly understand her suffering. The reviewer suggests a more visual approach, similar to how Bruce Banner's struggles have been shown in previous Marvel films.

What is the issue with the rushed writing in She-Hulk?

The reviewer criticizes the rushed nature of the writing, particularly in emotional scenes. For example, Jennifer's apology to Bruce feels shallow and insincere because it happens too quickly, undermining its emotional weight. The reviewer compares this to other films, like Deadpool 2, which balanced comedy and consequences more effectively.

How does the reviewer feel about the show's appeal to its audience?

The reviewer believes that She-Hulk isolates certain parts of its audience by catering primarily to female viewers, while neglecting male viewers. The reviewer suggests that to create a universally appealing show, the writers should aim to make characters that can be loved by all audiences, regardless of gender.

What is the concern about Jennifer Walters' character development?

The reviewer feels that Jennifer Walters' character is inconsistent and contradictory. She claims to dislike her Hulk persona but at the same time, reacts defensively to being called 'She-Hulk.' This lack of clarity in her character arc makes it difficult for the audience to connect with her and understand her true motivations.

Why does the reviewer criticize the villains in She-Hulk?

The reviewer finds the villains in She-Hulk to be underwhelming, comparing them to stronger villains in the Marvel universe like Thanos and He Who Remains. The villains in She-Hulk are seen as weak and not compelling, which diminishes the stakes and emotional impact of the show.

What is the issue with the courtroom scenes in She-Hulk?

Despite the show being titled 'Attorney at Law,' the writers admitted they weren't good at writing courtroom scenes, which the reviewer finds troubling. The lack of realistic and compelling legal drama undermines the show's premise, and the reviewer believes more effort should have been put into making these scenes authentic.

What comparison does the reviewer make between She-Hulk and Iron Man?

The reviewer contrasts She-Hulk with Iron Man by pointing out how Iron Man, despite being primarily targeted at a male audience, was crafted to appeal to a broad demographic. Iron Man's character development and story were not limited by gender, whereas She-Hulk is criticized for appealing mostly to a specific group of female viewers, which alienates other fans.

What does the reviewer mean by 'don't just write strong female characters, write strong characters that are female'?

The reviewer emphasizes that characters should not be strong solely because of their gender. Instead, they should be well-developed, complex individuals who happen to be female. This approach would make the character more relatable and appealing to a wider audience, rather than focusing on a narrow demographic.

What does the reviewer think Marvel could do to improve She-Hulk and future shows?

The reviewer believes that Marvel should listen to constructive feedback from audiences and make efforts to improve their storytelling. By addressing issues like rushed writing, inconsistent character development, and underwhelming villains, Marvel can create better content in the future that appeals to a wider audience.

Why does the reviewer mention Thanos and He Who Remains in the context of She-Hulk?

The reviewer references Thanos and He Who Remains to highlight the difference between complex, compelling villains and those in She-Hulk. These two villains, despite being powerful, have depth and clear motivations, which make them memorable. In contrast, She-Hulk's villains lack these qualities, leading to weaker storytelling.