Why The Toyota Hilux is NOT The Most Reliable Car!

Summary

This video provides an in-depth look at the most reliable used cars of 2024, based on data from Warrantywise, the UK's leading provider of aftermarket warranties. The video ranks cars using a reliability index derived from thousands of breakdown records, focusing on models under 10 years old. Top-ranked cars include the Suzuki Alto, Kia Venga, and Toyota Yaris, with the Suzuki Alto claiming the top spot due to its minimal issues and low repair costs. The video also highlights common problems and repair costs for each model, offering valuable insights for buyers.

Takeaways

• 😀 The Suzuki Alto is the most reliable used car of 2024, with an impressive reliability score of 95.1 out of 100 and average repair costs of £687.
• 😀 The Kia Venga ranks second with a reliability score of 93.6/100, with the most common issue being electrical problems and an average repair cost of £684.
• 😀 Toyota models dominate the top spots, with the Yaris scoring 91.5/100 and the Hilux providing excellent reliability despite higher repair costs.
• 😀 The most common issue for the Toyota Yaris (3rd Gen) is the electrical system, with an average repair cost of £587.
• 😀 The Toyota Hilux and Suzuki Swift share fourth place, with the Hilux being a reliable but more expensive pickup, and the Swift having air conditioning problems.
• 😀 The Mitsubishi ASX and Honda CR-V (4th/5th Gen) share 10th place, both offering good reliability but with suspension and electrical issues.
• 😀 The Seat Mii has the lowest average repair cost in the top 10 at £489, with cooling system issues being the most common problem.
• 😀 The Mazda 2 (3rd Gen) and Toyota iGo (2nd Gen) both scored 88.4/100, with the iGo suffering from clutch issues and the Mazda from suspension problems.
• 😀 Small city cars like the Volkswagen Up and Seat Mii are more reliable when they’re newer and have fewer miles, but still require attention to common issues like air conditioning and cooling systems.
• 😀 The Suzuki SX4 (2nd Gen) is the most reliable small SUV, scoring 89.3/100, with cooling system issues being the primary concern and an average repair cost of £1,358.

Q & A

What is the reliability index used to rank the cars in the video?

The reliability index is calculated by Warrantywise using data from thousands of breakdowns and car-related problems. The index factors in the age and mileage of cars, average repair costs, and repair times. Each car is given a score out of 100, with higher scores indicating greater reliability.

How does Warrantywise ensure the data is fair and reliable for their analysis?

Warrantywise excludes cars with fewer than 100 warranty plans to ensure a fair sample size. They also disregard vans and only consider models less than 10 years old with no manufacturer warranty left, as aftermarket warranties are considered after the original warranty expires.

Why are the Mitsubishi ASX and Honda CR-V tied for 10th place despite having different repair costs?

Both the Mitsubishi ASX and Honda CR-V scored the same in the reliability index (85.3 out of 100). The repair costs differ due to factors like the average age and mileage of the cars when issues arise, with the ASX typically being newer and having fewer miles than the CR-V.

What was the most expensive repair cost for the Volkswagen Up?

The highest repair bill for a Volkswagen Up was £1,048, which was for a faulty fuel system. Despite this, the Up remains relatively reliable compared to other small cars in the list.

What are the common problems with the Toyota Avensis and how much do repairs cost on average?

The Toyota Avensis, specifically the third generation (2015-2018), often experiences fuel system issues. The average repair bill is £889, but there have been cases where repairs cost as much as £1,950, particularly for fixing the turbocharger.

Why did the second-generation Toyota iGo and third-generation Mazda 2 receive the same reliability score?

Both cars scored 88.4 out of 100 despite having different types of issues. The iGo had relatively smaller repair costs due to clutch and electrical system issues, while the Mazda 2 had higher repair costs, mostly related to suspension and fuel system problems. The Mazda 2's quicker repair times balanced out the higher costs.

What is the most reliable small SUV in the list and why?

The most reliable small SUV in the list is the Suzuki SX4, which scored 89.3 out of 100. Its average repair bill is £1,358, with cooling system issues being the most common. Despite a few high repair costs, such as £6,483 for an engine problem, the SX4's reliability score is bolstered by its generally older age before repairs are needed.

What makes the Toyota Hilux stand out in this list despite its higher repair costs?

The Toyota Hilux, despite having a higher average repair cost of £1,512, is one of the most reliable vehicles due to its low frequency of issues. Suspension problems are the most common, but statistically, the Hilux is less prone to breakdowns compared to other vehicles like the Suzuki Swift.

What makes the Kia Venga stand out in the top 3 most reliable cars?

The Kia Venga ranks second in reliability with a score of 93.6 out of 100. The average repair cost is £684, with electrical system problems being the most common. It stands out for having few issues overall, contributing to its high ranking.

Why did the Suzuki Alto achieve the highest reliability score in the list?

The Suzuki Alto achieved an impressive 95.1 out of 100 in the reliability index. It has an exceptionally low frequency of problems, with an average repair bill of just £687. Warrantywise found so few issues with the Alto that it did not have a most common problem, instead being categorized as 'miscellaneous'.