Casio Continues to Release Flawed Products: PX-S3100 & PX-S1100

Summary

In this video, James Pavel Shakras critiques Casio's newly released digital pianos, the PX-S 3100 and PX-S 1100, arguing they are rebranded versions of the flawed PX-S 3000 and PX-S 1000. He highlights significant design issues, particularly the inconsistent weight of keys, which could hinder beginners' learning. Drawing parallels with a controversy involving Gigabyte's power supplies, he discusses how both companies respond defensively to criticism without addressing core product flaws. Ultimately, James expresses skepticism about the new models, emphasizing the need for quality in musical instruments, especially for novice players.

Takeaways

• 😀 Casio is rebranding the PXS 3000 as the PXS 3100 without significant improvements, raising concerns about their commitment to product quality.
• 😀 The original PXS 3000 was criticized for having a fundamentally flawed key action, which Casio has not addressed in the new model.
• 😀 The key action issue involves the black keys being lighter than the white keys, which is atypical for quality pianos.
• 😀 Casio's marketing approach appears to target Apple users, but it overlooks the importance of high performance alongside appealing design.
• 😀 A company's response to a flawed product can indicate its overall integrity; Casio's actions suggest a disregard for customer feedback.
• 😀 The comparison between Casio and Gigabyte highlights how companies can mishandle product flaws and respond defensively to criticism.
• 😀 The speaker emphasizes the potential negative impact of the flawed key action on beginner piano students, affecting their learning experience.
• 😀 Casio has not provided clear purchasing options for the new models on their global website, leading to uncertainty about availability.
• 😀 The speaker intends to explore more innovative instruments rather than purchasing the rebranded models that lack substantial improvements.
• 😀 Overall, the analysis critiques both Casio and Gigabyte for their lack of accountability in addressing known product flaws.

Q & A

What are the main criticisms of the Casio PXS 3100 and PXS 1100?

The main criticisms involve the limited upgrades over the PXS 3000 and the uneven key action, which affects playability, especially for beginners.

How does the reviewer perceive Casio's marketing strategy for the PXS series?

The reviewer believes Casio is attempting to rebrand the PXS 3000 as the PXS 3100 with minimal changes, which could mislead consumers.

What parallels does the speaker draw between Casio and Gigabyte?

The speaker notes similarities in how both companies respond to product flaws, with vague and defensive statements that avoid direct acknowledgment of the criticisms.

What specific issue is mentioned regarding the key action on the Casio keyboards?

The review highlights that the black keys are significantly lighter than the white keys, leading to inconsistent playability.

How does the speaker feel about the potential release of the PXS 3100?

The speaker is skeptical about purchasing the PXS 3100 unless there is significant demand, as it appears to be too similar to its predecessor.

What does the speaker suggest about the availability of the PXS series?

The speaker points out that there are no purchase options for the PXS models on Casio's international website, raising questions about their availability.

What is the speaker's overall opinion on the Casio PXS 3100?

The speaker finds the lack of substantial improvements and the unresolved key action issues disappointing, leading to a lack of interest in the new model.

How does the speaker view the communication style of both Casio and Gigabyte regarding product testing?

The speaker feels that both companies misrepresent the validity of external testing, attempting to discredit reviewers rather than addressing the product flaws.

Why does the speaker mention Gamer's Nexus in the video?

Gamer's Nexus is mentioned as a parallel example of a reviewer facing similar corporate responses to criticism, emphasizing a broader trend in the industry.

What kind of content does the speaker typically create on their channel?

The speaker usually creates reviews of digital and acoustic pianos, along with occasional discussions on related topics, as seen in this video.