Нові податки на посилки?

Summary

The video discusses a proposed Ukrainian bill to tax international packages valued under 150 euros, including those from platforms like AliExpress. Currently, packages over this limit are taxed, but the new law would apply VAT (20%) and customs duty (10%) to all imported goods. Advocates argue it will protect domestic producers, while critics warn of logistical challenges, increased costs for consumers, and potential delays. The video highlights concerns over Ukraine's market limitations and the negative impact this law could have on small businesses, volunteers, and citizens relying on affordable international goods.

Takeaways

• 📦 The new tax bill will impose VAT and customs duties on international parcels, even if their value is below 150 euros.
• 💰 Currently, parcels valued under 150 euros are exempt from a 20% VAT and a 10% duty, but this will change under the new proposal.
• 🛡️ The government argues that this tax will protect domestic producers by creating fairer competition between Ukrainian and foreign manufacturers.
• 🇨🇳 Goods from foreign manufacturers, like those from China, don't currently pay VAT, which the government sees as unfair to Ukrainian producers.
• 📊 Ukrainian citizens ordered over 52 million parcels in 2023, with 51.5 million being valued under the 150 euro limit.
• ⏱️ Implementing the tax could cause significant delays in parcel processing due to the large volume of shipments and lack of infrastructure for administration.
• 🚚 The co-owner of Nova Poshta warns that expanding tax regulations to all parcels will cause logistical issues and delivery delays.
• 🤖 Automating the process is essential, but developing the necessary infrastructure is complex and costly.
• 🛠️ The tax could also negatively affect small businesses and volunteers who order important components for things like drones, increasing costs and delivery times.
• 🌐 There are concerns that imposing such taxes will limit the purchasing power of Ukrainians, particularly in a time of economic instability.

Q & A

What is the main subject of the discussed law proposal?

The law proposal aims to impose taxes on parcels from abroad that are valued up to 150 euros. Currently, parcels below this value are not subject to VAT (20%) and customs duties (10%), but the proposal suggests taxing them.

Why does the Ukrainian government want to introduce this tax on parcels?

The government argues that the tax is necessary to create a level playing field for domestic producers who already pay VAT. This measure is seen as a way to protect local manufacturers from unfair competition with foreign goods.

How are parcels currently taxed under the existing law?

Currently, parcels valued over 150 euros are taxed only on the amount that exceeds the threshold. For example, if a parcel is worth 200 euros, taxes are applied to the 50 euros that exceed the limit.

What challenges could arise with the administration of this new tax?

The main challenge would be the administrative burden of processing a significantly higher number of parcels. In 2023, 52 million parcels were shipped to Ukraine, most of which were below the 150-euro threshold. Handling these additional parcels could overwhelm the system, causing delays.

What concerns have been raised about how this tax could affect Ukrainian consumers?

The tax could result in higher costs for Ukrainian consumers, particularly those who rely on cheaper goods from platforms like AliExpress. This could be problematic during a period of economic instability when many consumers are seeking the best deals.

How could the new tax affect the logistics industry in Ukraine?

Logistics companies, such as Nova Poshta, warn that this could lead to a logistical collapse. They already experience delays with the current volume of parcels, and handling the increased number of taxed shipments could cause significant disruptions and longer wait times for deliveries.

How might this new tax impact Ukraine's defense industry?

Many parcels contain components for the defense industry, such as parts for drones. The new tax could increase the cost and delivery time of these essential components, potentially hindering the production of defense equipment.

What argument is made against the idea that this tax will significantly benefit domestic producers?

Critics argue that Ukraine doesn't produce all the goods that people are importing, so consumers are forced to buy from abroad. Imposing a tax on these items doesn't necessarily help domestic producers, as the country lacks the capacity to manufacture many of the items being imported.

How could the tax affect international trade and Ukraine's economic specialization?

Restricting imports through taxes could hurt Ukraine’s ability to specialize in industries where it has a competitive advantage. A more open trade policy would allow Ukraine to focus on areas where it can excel and benefit from global markets.

What are some alternative solutions proposed to address the problem of 'gray imports'?

One suggestion is to encourage international marketplaces to include VAT in the price of goods sold to Ukrainian consumers. This would address tax evasion while minimizing the administrative burden on customs officials and avoiding the need to tax small parcels.