Microsoft Recall is MANDATORY

Summary

The video addresses concerns about Microsoft's Recall service, which was initially said to only affect AI and ARM-based systems but is now being integrated into all systems with the 24H2 update. The speaker explains how Recall is becoming a dependency in File Explorer, potentially affecting user experience and raising privacy concerns. The video also offers guidance on disabling Recall to prevent issues with File Explorer tabs. The speaker emphasizes the need for awareness about these changes and shares updates on a project called 'microwin,' aimed at optimizing the Windows experience.

Takeaways

• ⚠️ Microsoft Recall is being installed on all systems, not just AI or Arm-based ones, starting in 24H2.
• 🖥️ Recall is now a dependency in File Explorer, which could alarm many users due to its implications.
• 🔧 The speaker suggests disabling the Recall service in Windows 24H2 and future versions to avoid potential issues.
• ❗ Co-Pilot removal in 24H2 is breaking the new File Explorer tabs, as reported in changelogs by multiple sources.
• 🛠️ A new method is introduced to manage Windows deployments, including automatically downloading ISOs from Microsoft.
• 🚫 Certain Windows components like NFS, search engine, and remote desktop are now mandatory in 24H2 to ensure File Explorer functions properly.
• 🔄 Coding wonders have been working on a streamlined and updated version of this deployment system, especially for bug fixes.
• 🗂️ The Recall component is crucial to maintain File Explorer’s tab functionality in 24H2, which was not required in previous versions like 23H2.
• 🎉 The speaker celebrates the one-year anniversary of the MicroWin project, highlighting ongoing development and improvements.
• ❓ Concerns are raised about the lack of transparency regarding what the Recall service is doing in the background, which remains unclear and worrying.

Q & A

What is the main concern addressed in the video?

The main concern is the integration of the 'recall' service into the File Explorer in Windows 24H2, despite Microsoft initially assuring users that it would only be for AI-based systems.

How is the recall service affecting File Explorer in Windows 24H2?

The recall service is now a dependency in File Explorer, which is breaking certain functionalities, such as Explorer tabs when the co-pilot feature is removed.

Why does the speaker believe this issue is significant?

The speaker finds it significant because the recall service is being installed on every system, contrary to previous assurances from Microsoft. It also raises concerns about privacy and control for users who may not know about this change.

What steps does the speaker recommend users take?

The speaker advises users to disable the recall service if they are using Windows 24H2 and beyond to avoid its potential impacts on File Explorer and system performance.

What is the impact of removing the co-pilot feature on File Explorer?

Removing the co-pilot feature causes issues with new Explorer tabs, which can break or behave unexpectedly in the updated version of Windows.

What role does the inight change log play in this issue?

The inight change log first reported the issue of the co-pilot removal breaking Explorer tabs, which the speaker later confirmed in their own testing.

What is 'microwin,' as mentioned in the video?

Microwin is a streamlined version of Windows deployment services that strips out unnecessary apps and features, providing a more efficient starting point for users.

What updates or fixes have been made to microwin in response to this issue?

Recent updates to microwin include bug fixes for remote desktop, ensuring it no longer interferes with File Explorer, and improved automation for downloading ISOs directly from Microsoft.

Why is the recall service now mandatory for File Explorer in Windows 24H2?

The recall service has become a mandatory necessity for File Explorer with tabs in Windows 24H2, even though it wasn't required in the previous version (23H2). The reasons for this backend change are unclear and raise concerns.

What is the speaker's primary concern regarding users unaware of this issue?

The speaker is worried about users who may not know about the recall service being enabled by default. These users might unknowingly experience performance issues or privacy concerns without realizing the cause.