The Dual Challenge: Energy and Environment | Scott Tinker | TEDxUTAustin
Summary
TLDRDas Video thematisiert die duale Herausforderung von Energiezugang und Umweltschutz. Der Sprecher betont, dass Energie für alle Lebensbereiche essentiell ist und dass viele Menschen, insbesondere in ärmeren Regionen, keinen Zugang zu sauberer und zuverlässiger Energie haben. Er beschreibt die Umweltbelastungen durch Nahrungsmittelproduktion und Energienutzung und diskutiert die Notwendigkeit eines ausgewogenen Energiemixes. Der Übergang zu erneuerbaren Energien ist nicht einfach, da diese ebenfalls Ressourcen benötigen. Er schließt mit einem Appell zu einer gemeinsamen Lösung der globalen Energie- und Umweltprobleme durch zivilen Dialog.
Takeaways
- 🌍 Der Duale Herausforderung: Energiezugang für alle und Umweltschutz ist kompliziert, aber notwendig.
- 🥗 Der Sprecher diskutiert den Vergleich zwischen kalorienarmen und nährstoffreichen Lebensmitteln wie Grünkohl und kalorienreichen Optionen wie Rindfleisch.
- 👨🌾 Lokale Lösungen wie Solarpaneele für Bauern in Entwicklungsländern helfen, die Nahrungsmittelproduktion und den Zugang zu Energie zu verbessern.
- 🚜 Landwirtschaft hat große Auswirkungen auf die Umwelt, von Düngemitteln über Pestizide bis hin zu Boden- und Wasserqualität.
- 🏡 Rund die Hälfte der Weltbevölkerung hat keinen Zugang zu verlässlicher Energie, was ihre Lebensqualität stark beeinträchtigt.
- 🔌 Energiearmut und wirtschaftliche Armut sind eng miteinander verbunden – man kann die Armut ohne Energiezugang nicht beenden.
- 🏭 Kohle, Öl und andere fossile Brennstoffe sind immer noch die Hauptenergiequellen, weil sie zuverlässig und erschwinglich sind.
- 💡 Erneuerbare Energien wie Solar- und Windenergie wachsen, aber sie können den globalen Energiebedarf bisher nicht decken.
- ♻️ Auch saubere Energien haben Umweltauswirkungen, da sie Ressourcen wie Metalle und Land für die Herstellung benötigen.
- 🌱 Um das Duale Problem von Energie und Umwelt zu lösen, müssen wir gemeinsam und mit ausgewogenen Lösungen handeln.
Q & A
Was sind die beiden großen Herausforderungen, die im Skript angesprochen werden?
-Die beiden großen Herausforderungen sind der Zugang zu Energie für alle und der Umweltschutz.
Warum verwendet der Sprecher das Beispiel von 'Kale' (Grünkohl) und 'Cow' (Kuh)?
-Er verwendet diese Beispiele, um die Unterschiede in der Energiedichte von Lebensmitteln zu verdeutlichen und auf die Notwendigkeit einer ausgewogenen Ernährung hinzuweisen, ähnlich wie bei einer ausgewogenen Energieversorgung.
Welche Umweltauswirkungen werden durch landwirtschaftliche Aktivitäten hervorgehoben?
-Landwirtschaftliche Aktivitäten führen zu Bodenerschöpfung, Wasserverschmutzung, Luftverschmutzung und großen Mengen an CO2-Emissionen aufgrund von Düngemitteln, Pestiziden und Herbiziden.
Wie beschreibt der Sprecher die Situation der Energiearmut in armen Regionen der Welt?
-Er beschreibt, dass viele Menschen in armen Regionen keinen zuverlässigen Zugang zu Energie haben, was ihre Lebensqualität erheblich beeinträchtigt. Beispielsweise wird in Äthiopien immer noch mit Holz und Dung gekocht, was gesundheitliche Folgen hat.
Welche Rolle spielt Energie beim Kampf gegen Armut laut dem Sprecher?
-Energie allein kann Armut nicht beenden, aber ohne Energie ist es unmöglich, Armut zu bekämpfen. Sie ist ein entscheidender Faktor für wirtschaftliche Entwicklung und Wohlstand.
Warum betont der Sprecher die Notwendigkeit eines ausgewogenen Energiemixes?
-Er betont, dass ein ausgewogener Energiemix sowohl Energieversorgungssicherheit bietet als auch die Umweltauswirkungen minimiert. Verschiedene Energiequellen haben unterschiedliche Vor- und Nachteile, die zusammen eine stabile Versorgung sicherstellen können.
Welche Herausforderungen sieht der Sprecher bei der Skalierung von erneuerbaren Energien wie Solar- und Windkraft?
-Obwohl Solar- und Windkraft schnell wachsen, reichen sie noch nicht aus, um den wachsenden globalen Energiebedarf zu decken. Sie machen nur einen kleinen Teil des gesamten Energieverbrauchs aus.
Wie beeinflussen wirtschaftliche und soziale Bedingungen die Energie- und Umweltprobleme weltweit?
-Die ärmsten Regionen der Welt haben oft die schlechteste Umweltqualität, da sie sich keine Maßnahmen zur Verbesserung der Luft- und Wasserqualität leisten können. Gleichzeitig benötigen diese Regionen dringend mehr Energie, um wirtschaftlich zu wachsen.
Was sagt der Sprecher über den Zusammenhang zwischen fossilen Brennstoffen und erneuerbaren Energien?
-Er erklärt, dass fossile Brennstoffe wie Kohle und Öl nach wie vor einen Großteil der globalen Energie liefern, da sie günstig und zuverlässig sind. Erneuerbare Energien sind umweltfreundlicher, aber derzeit noch nicht in der Lage, die fossilen Brennstoffe vollständig zu ersetzen.
Welche Botschaft möchte der Sprecher zum Abschluss vermitteln?
-Er betont, dass die Herausforderungen der Energieversorgung und des Umweltschutzes komplex, aber lösbar sind, wenn wir als ein Team zusammenarbeiten und sachliche, respektvolle Diskussionen führen.
Outlines
🌍 Die Duale Herausforderung: Energie und Umwelt
Der Sprecher stellt die duale Herausforderung der Energieversorgung für alle und des Umweltschutzes vor. Er vergleicht es mit seiner Ernährung: Ein ausgewogener Mix aus verschiedenen Lebensmitteln, genauso wie bei der Energie, ist entscheidend. Dabei hebt er die Wichtigkeit dichter Energiequellen wie Viehzucht hervor und betont, dass der Einfluss der Landwirtschaft auf die Umwelt erheblich ist. Dennoch ist der Verzicht auf Nahrung keine Lösung, sondern das Ziel, die Auswirkungen zu verringern.
🌞 Lokale Lösungen für globale Probleme
Es wird ein Beispiel aus Afrika beschrieben, wo Solaranlagen Wasser fördern und lokale Landwirtschaft ermöglichen. Der Sprecher betont, dass wir nicht nur dichte Energiequellen, sondern auch Lösungen für den Umweltschutz brauchen. Er verweist auf seine Erfahrungen in Ecuador, Äthiopien, Vietnam und anderen Ländern, wo Armut und Umweltzerstörung Hand in Hand gehen. Besonders die gesundheitlichen Folgen des Kochens mit Holz in armen Ländern werden hervorgehoben, was jährlich Millionen Menschenleben fordert.
💡 Energie als Schlüssel zur Armutsbekämpfung
Der Sprecher erläutert die globale Energieverteilung und hebt hervor, dass Energiearmut die wirtschaftliche Entwicklung hemmt. Er beschreibt, wie saubere Energie in armen Regionen, wie Kolumbien und Afrika, eingeführt wird. Die wachsende Bevölkerung und die damit verbundene Nachfrage nach Energie in Asien und Afrika sind zentrale Herausforderungen. Obwohl erneuerbare Energien wachsen, betont er, dass dichte Energiequellen wie Kohle und Gas weiterhin einen Großteil des weltweiten Energiebedarfs decken.
🏭 Widersprüche in der Energiewelt
Hier wird der Widerspruch zwischen reichen Ländern, die mehr Energie konsumieren als sie produzieren, und ärmeren Ländern, die mehr produzieren als sie verbrauchen, aufgezeigt. Es wird auf die Abhängigkeit von Billigproduktion und CO2-Emissionen in ärmeren Ländern eingegangen. Der Sprecher kritisiert, dass dies keine echte Lösung für den Klimawandel darstellt, und betont die Notwendigkeit einer globalen Strategie für Klimaschutz, ohne die wirtschaftliche Entwicklung zu behindern.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Energiezugang
💡Umweltschutz
💡Erneuerbare Energien
💡Energiedichte
💡CO2-Emissionen
💡Energiearmut
💡Wirtschaftliche Entwicklung
💡Armut
💡Nachhaltigkeit
💡Energie-Mix
Highlights
Energy access for all and environmental protection are interconnected and critical global challenges.
Balanced diets, like balanced energy sources, are important. Both herbivores and carnivores contribute to sustainability.
Local solutions for food production, like solar-powered irrigation, can help improve sustainability in farming.
Farming and food production have a significant environmental impact, including soil depletion, water usage, and air pollution.
Energy poverty affects nearly half the global population, limiting access to education and economic opportunities.
Cleaner energy sources like solar and wind are growing, but they currently cannot meet the rising global energy demand.
A diverse energy mix, including coal, oil, gas, nuclear, and renewables, provides energy security and sustainability.
Emerging economies face severe energy and economic poverty, but access to energy is critical to improving their quality of life.
The wealthier regions of the world have cleaner air, while poorer regions suffer from pollution due to the inability to invest in environmental cleanup.
Economic development and population growth drive increased energy demand, particularly in Asia and Africa.
There is no truly 'renewable' energy; all energy production, including renewables, has an environmental impact.
Global CO2 emissions are heavily driven by production and consumption imbalances between wealthy and emerging nations.
Reducing fossil fuel reliance in emerging economies is challenging due to affordability and reliability concerns.
Energy is vital for improving living standards, from health care to education, and empowering communities globally.
Civil dialogue and cooperation are essential in addressing the dual challenge of energy access and environmental sustainability.
Transcripts
[Music]
hi
the dual challenge
energy access for all
and environmental protection
sounds easy
but it's not
my wife allison
has a food science degree
she knows what food is
and therefore when i sneak that bowl of
ice cream at night
it's not without some guilt
when i when i go back to bed
so intra kale
i mean i love kale
salads and soups and it's nutrients and
and vitamins but it's not very dense i'd
have to eat a lot of kale
to get the energy that i need every day
in calories
inner cow i like cow too
but i'd have to eat a lot of cow and
there's protein it's pretty good for me
but it and it's really dense
so is one good and
one bad
is it team
herbivore against team carnivore
what about the omnivores
where do they fit in
the reality is probably some sort of a
balanced diet is pretty good for us and
i'm always going to sneak in that ice
cream okay
we can have local solutions for cal
we can have local solutions for kale
this is farmer john who i spent time
with in africa solar panel lifting water
from an aquifer
and he now grows vegetables in his
garden and sells them in local markets
but we're dense
there's a lot of people in the world
it takes dense solutions
dense cattle
dense kale
in fact
the impacts of farming for
feeding our food
and eating ourselves are real
fertilizers and
pesticides and herbicides
and you think about soil depletion in
the water there the air quality and the
emissions are large from farming
food impacts the environment a lot
okay so i had this brilliant idea we
should we should probably just end food
you know clean up the environment
um
well i smile when i say we're not gonna
end food
but we do need to work to continue to
clean up the environment related to food
it's the energy and the environment
challenge
and it's not simple but food's not the
only thing we get
energy from in fact our homes and our
phones our our pets and our jets
our heaters and our beaters uh water and
daughters and sons and everything they
wear
our packs and our snacks
you know our games and our frames the
paste and the waste
we have lights in sight we have
our noses and our our clothes
and our wheels and our meals everything
in our lives everything in our lives
depends on energy
everything
so when you come back to the basics the
light the food
the water and the homes that we take for
granted many in the world can't about
half the people this little girl i met
in ecuador she told me her dreams on the
bed where she sleeps with her parents
dirt floors open air
and she tied a friendship bracelet on me
that i never took off till it literally
fell off
in ethiopia i met a grandfather
who has grandkids and he had tears in
his eyes when he told me they will have
something he's never had school and
they're all starting in the second grade
because they've never been in school
before
in vietnam i met with thon who lives in
severe poverty
those three frying pans are her wind
turbine
a little bit of electricity she carries
her crippled son across that plank every
morning on her back so he can go to a
school
in kenya
light bulbs dangle from a church that
doubles as a school and these kids walk
across mounds of garbage and polluted
water and soil every day in their
uniforms
i've been in 60 countries i've seen the
most severe wealth
and the most severe poverty
and everywhere the worst environments in
the world are where it's poor
they can't afford to clean it up in
nepal sanukanchi is cooking over wood
indoors
and like three billion other people who
cook with dung and wood
we visited the sunny memorial hospital
where kids die every week from lung
diseases
and moms from cancer and they get
cataracts three billion people it kills
three million people every year
that's as many as covet 19 killed in
2020
every single year
so when he brought her an electric
cooktop she had a huge smile and she
said i can't read but my daughter can
and she'll help me understand how to use
this
and down in columbia these kids about
half of them will die before they reach
adulthood of things that wouldn't kill
us
dysentery tooth infections
they're coming in from the hills and the
agrarian villages to try to get into
schools we brought first solar there
you can see the panels on the left the
arwaco village of gonchuqua
and that last night when we turned on
those lights i was with the mama the
chief
they'd never seen each other at night
except over fire
it was one of the most remarkable
moments of my life
this shows global income the wealth in
the world the yellows are severe poverty
and they're emerging they're trying to
emerge and and as they do that sauna
conchi and people the three billion who
cook like her and the kids that are
trying to get into schools around the
world
and you see
grandfathers and kids coming out of the
bush literally out of the bush
carrying their kids on their backs and
getting first electricity
it's about half the people in the world
that are trying to emerge now into
economic
situations like we have they need
affordable energy
they need to be able to afford something
the developing world has energy but it's
not reliable to them it comes and goes
and that's a big part of latin america
and eastern europe and parts of russia
and other places in the world
four of every five people live in
emerging and developing economies today
four out of every five now the rich
world us
the blue it's not that extensive is it
we want it clean
and in fact if you look at air quality
in the world for example
the green is where it's the cleanest
where's that where it's rich
the worst air quality is where
where it's poor
they can't afford to clean it up
transitions are happening all over the
world different paces in different
circumstances
severe economic poverty increases to the
right and severe energy poverty
increases up
latin america is doing pretty well
they're coming out of the severe of both
much greater population in asia more
severe energy and economic poverty and
africa another 1.1 billion people severe
in both you see this relationship of
getting access to energy and coming out
of economic poverty but it presents a
dilemma a paradox
energy won't end poverty
but you can't end poverty without energy
data must be used to tell the truth
not to call to action
okay no matter how noble the intentions
hans rosling said that in his wonderful
book factfulness
no matter how noble the intentions i
testified to the u.s senate in their
first climate hearing about a year ago
and we talked about the difference
between completely factual
and factually complete
factually complete is seeking the truth
which is very hard to do
yes there's low density food and there's
low density energy solar wind and
biomass and batteries are very low
density high density energy or coal oil
natural gas and nuclear it's not
judgmental it's physics
it's hundreds of times denser
okay
renewable
fossil and nuclear
just as a balanced diet
you know comes from a good mix so does
energy
we see a diverse energy mix provides
energy security
all working together and every leader on
the planet is looking for security for
their people
now let's look at global energy
consumption by energy type first coal
and oil they're still growing globally
they're very dense
but they make a lot of co2
natural gas and nuclear growing globally
they're very dense they make less co2
renewables are growing globally
hydro leads and solar and wind are
coming on and they don't make much co2
okay very little you'll hear you've
probably learned solar and wind are
going faster than any other resource
it's completely factual look at the
growth rates of solar and wind in the
world
what would make it factually complete
scaling it let's scale them the same
there is solar and wind it's right in
the data
kind of discouraging but it doesn't even
keep up with the growth and demand for
energy globally and it's growing very
quickly that's one of the realities of
energy so we code these colon oil and
green gas and nuclear renewables
and gas and nuclear dense
clean er
work hand in hand yet coal oil are still
60 percent of the world's energy why is
that they're affordable and reliable
if you look by region
you see north america and europe we've
been flat in our energy demand for
almost three or four decades asia is
growing tremendously the rest of the
world
the emerging poor world is just getting
started
now
population and economic development
drive energy demand they always have and
that's why this is happening
the emissions from that should be no
surprise then north america and europe
were actually coming down asia is
growing tremendously
and the rest of the world is just
getting started in their emissions
largely driven by coal
we built on it the uk germany so is
china and many parts of asia today it's
affordable and reliable to them but
there's another reason let's build this
graph together
the oecd is the club of rich nations
we're in it
and the non-oecd above that red line
countries consume more than they produce
below the red line they produce more
than they consume so let's start with us
the u.s we consume more than we produce
and we make about 5 billion tons of co2
from humans anthropogenic every year
china makes 10 billion tons of co2 but
they produce more stuff than they
consume
in fact most of the non-oecd produces
their producers most of the rich
countries we consume
we say what send us our stuff
check what you're wearing today
where's it come from and what do we
effectively say back
emit our co2
will be
green and you
make it cheap
and emit for us
is that a zero emissions strategy it
seems to be these days how many
atmospheres are there in the world
there's one
just one and it's really efficient more
than the ocean it's circulating
greenhouse gases this isn't a solution
for climate change it's the mark of an
educated mind to be able to entertain a
thought without accepting it
aristotle said that
not me i think he was talking about
critical thinking civil dialogue
entertaining thoughts without having to
accept him climate change is really
important in the world
but it's not the only thing
the land
the air and the water are pillars of our
environment
these work together they are very
interconnected
we can't go too far in one without
potentially harming the other
so we come back to clean and dirty what
you've probably learned or might have
learned
and the dirty is dirty
okay you manufacture the stuff you mine
and drill for it you you handle the
water and move it around and eventually
we burn it
we featured this in our first film
switch the pros and the cons a massive
coal mine
fracking hydraulic fracturing to lift
oil and gas from the earth what do you
do with a nuclear waste
a big coal power plant outside of
houston very dense makes electricity for
half of the city
big impacts
big and positive ones too how about the
clean stuff
it turns out it has the exact same
things
we have to mine and manufacture the
metals to build the panels and turbines
and batteries we have to produce it
using a lot of land
transmitted and eventually where does it
go
here's a giant mine i visited in montana
let's zoom in to get a feel for scale
that's a drilling rig and a front end
loader across it it produces metals
copper that goes into wind turbines
here's a lithium mine
there are a lot of those in the world
and they're going to be a lot more to do
what
power our electric vehicles this is the
floor bed of a sedan
there are seven thousand batteries in
that one car
each bigger than your cell phone a
little bit let's do some arithmetic
seven thousand
one point four billion vehicles in the
world to we have 8 billion people almost
if we electrify half of those it's going
to be 4.9 trillion
new batteries
to make 4.9 trillion just for half would
take 37 years if we could make 250 000
batteries a minute
24 7 365.
and where do they go
when they wear out you know they do
you have cell phones where do they go
where do the panels go i visited this a
decade ago in southern spain where do
those panels go which are also toxic
same place as the wind turbine blades
this is a hundred wind turbine blades
being buried
they're cut into thirds by a giant earth
mover
they're inert but they'll be there
forever
we have 40 000 wind turbine blades in
texas now
and they are wearing out
we will bury them
it's a conundrum the sun and the wind
are renewable but the panels turbines
and batteries are not
you're not going to like me
there's no renewable energy
it all takes earth resources we make it
and we put it back in the earth we've
got to do it really well the reality is
large-scale energy systems have
large-scale environmental impacts
humans do
so come back to our map
the wealth in the world watch the
yellows and reds as i fade this into a
satellite view at night of the earth
you can see where the lights are on and
where they're off they're off where it's
poor they don't have much energy
here's our color codes the distribution
of energy around the world colon oil
nuclear natural gas and yellow let's
scale them first
this is how much is actually consumed
so you can see where where the lights
are on now and you know why they have
energy and we could get rid of the coal
and oil the high co2
asia and africa have to work hard to do
that
europe and the us were about halfway
there nuclear natural gas and renewables
about halfway there and others too
different mixes but some still say no
we've got to get rid of natural gas and
nuclear as well what is left
and how quickly is it growing can we do
that
should we do that
that's
ten percent of the world's energy left
what happens if we darken the world's
lights by 90
does that look like the future to you
it looks like the past to me
got to turn the world's lights on
everything in the world depends on
energy what happens if you gave up 90
percent of what you have
if we turn the lights on and bring
energy for a billion people hunger
clothing shelter clean water
another education health care
and the refrigerations and vaccines that
go without the rights and empowerment of
women they go for the water they're
cooking indoors
they don't get to go to the schools when
their male counterparts do often
population is directly tied to education
and energy
immigration and migration away from
autocrats
it's happening in the world today
right there the largest migration since
the end of world war
ii
the ability to invest in the environment
from a healthy economy and to mitigate
and adapt to climate change if i bring
all that together
we have the tools to begin to address
the dual challenge
now
it's not easy
no one owns the truth
we just seek it
shaming is destructive
civil dialogue is vital in these
conversations
energy and environment they have to be
addressed together or both will fail
it's not simple the dual challenge but
it's solvable and i know you will solve
it if
we act as one team
let's get on the same page
and together
we can better the world
thanks
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
you
Voir Plus de Vidéos Connexes
Weshalb ich aufgehört habe mich über VERSCHWÖRUNGSTHEORIEN zu informieren
Welche Energieformen gibt es?
Dieser ALTCOIN EXPLODIERT!!!
Supreme Tyler The Creator Collab...I CANT BELIEVE IT!
3 Quick Cards with ME!! - There's an energy that might cause you to puff yourself up.. Ignore it...
📜 NON FARE MAI SESSO CON UNA PERSONA SENZA PRIMA GUARDARE QUESTO VIDEO!
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)