Милов про развал путинской экономики

Комментарии экспертов

29 Aug 202407:14

Summary

TLDRThe video script discusses the Russian economy's challenges, focusing on the Central Bank's monetary policy and its impact on inflation and economic stability. It highlights the upcoming September meeting where a potential interest rate hike to 20% is anticipated, causing market concerns. The speaker speculates on the government's budget plans and military spending, suggesting a possible increase in the deficit. The script also touches on the criticism of the Central Bank's policies, the potential for a more compliant figure to lead the bank, and the broader economic implications of continued fiscal stimulus, warning of high inflation rates reminiscent of Turkey or Argentina.

Takeaways

📈 The speaker anticipates an increase in the Central Bank's key interest rate to 20%, reflecting a general expectation in the market.
📉 There's a notable decline in the market, with indices such as the Rgbi government bond index falling, indicating a pessimistic outlook.
🏛 The Central Bank, led by Elvira Nabiullina, is preparing for a potential banking crisis that has been long anticipated but seems to be approaching now.
🗓️ September 13th is highlighted as a key date, possibly for a Central Bank meeting, while the end of the month might bring clarity on the government's budget plans for the next year.
💵 The discussion suggests that the military budget will likely increase, leading to larger deficits, which could be influenced by decisions on continuing military operations or seeking a ceasefire.
💸 The high interest rates are already having a negative impact on the economy, with no signs of rates decreasing in the near future.
🍇 There was no seasonal decrease in prices for fruit and other products, with inflation showing no signs of slowing down in August.
🤔 The speaker questions the Central Bank's understanding of the economy, suggesting that their forecasts and plans are unrealistic and not based on a clear grasp of economic mechanisms.
💬 There's criticism of the Central Bank's policies, with some arguing that they should lower interest rates to make credit more accessible and stimulate the economy.
🚨 The speaker warns of potential high inflation scenarios if the government continues to inject budget funds into the economy without a clear monetary policy direction.

Q & A

What is the significance of September 13th for Russia's economy?
-September 13th marks a meeting of the Central Bank of Russia where a decision on raising the interest rate is expected. It is considered a critical point, as many anticipate the rate will be increased to around 20%, affecting various economic factors.
Why are the markets falling according to the script?
-The markets, including the government bond index (RGBI), are falling due to the anticipation of an interest rate hike by the Central Bank. This suggests that economic conditions are worsening, and there are no positive expectations in the near future.
What does the speaker mention about the banking crisis in Russia?
-The speaker references a forecast from a center led by Belousov's brother, warning of an impending banking crisis. This crisis has been long anticipated, and the speaker suggests it is now close to materializing.
What are the potential implications of the interest rate rising to 20%?
-An interest rate of 20% would indicate that no economic improvement is expected, as high rates negatively affect credit availability and overall economic activity. Hopes for rate reductions and economic recovery would be diminished.
How has inflation in Russia behaved recently?
-Contrary to typical seasonal declines, inflation has not decreased during August. Prices for fruit and vegetables, which usually lower inflation, did not have the expected effect, leading to consistent price increases throughout the month.
What are the expectations for the 2025 economic outlook?
-The speaker suggests that the Russian government is struggling to plan beyond the short term, with forecasts for 2025 being uncertain. The lack of predictability in factors such as currency exchange rates and inflation makes long-term planning difficult.
What role does military spending play in Russia's current economic situation?
-Military spending and the large deficits it creates are seen as a significant factor in Russia's economic difficulties. The Central Bank has pointed to these expenditures as a major contributor to inflation.
What criticism is being levied against the Central Bank's policies?
-Critics, including prominent figures like Chemezov, argue that the Central Bank's monetary policies, such as high interest rates, are exacerbating economic problems without solving inflation, which remains persistently high.
What scenario does the speaker predict if the Central Bank changes its leadership?
-The speaker predicts that if a more lenient figure replaces the Central Bank's current leadership, it could lead to a relaxation of monetary policy. This would potentially mirror the hyperinflation scenario of the early 1990s, with rapidly rising prices and economic instability.
What is the potential consequence of monetary policy loosening in Russia?
-If the monetary policy is loosened while budgetary spending continues at high levels, the speaker warns of hyperinflation similar to the crises seen in countries like Turkey or Argentina, with inflation potentially reaching tens or even hundreds of percent.

Outlines

00:00

📉 Economic Outlook and Central Bank's Dilemma

The paragraph discusses the Russian economy's challenges, focusing on the Central Bank's upcoming meeting on September 13th, where a potential interest rate hike is anticipated. The speaker suggests that markets are already reacting negatively to the expectation of a rate increase, with government bond indices falling. The paragraph also touches on the broader economic context, including the potential for a banking crisis, the impact of military spending on the budget, and the uncertainty surrounding Putin's plans for the next year. The speaker expresses skepticism about the government's economic forecasts and the effectiveness of their monetary policy, highlighting the difficulty in managing inflation and the ruble's value.

05:02

🗣️ Criticisms of the Central Bank's Monetary Policy

This paragraph delves into criticisms of the Central Bank's monetary policy, particularly the high interest rates that are not yielding the desired economic benefits. The speaker points out the Central Bank's struggle to control inflation and the lack of progress in making credit more accessible. The paragraph also mentions a financial congress held by the Central Bank in July, where the dilemma of high inflation despite high interest rates was discussed. The speaker anticipates a potential scandal in the fall if the Central Bank continues with its current policies, leading to calls for a change in leadership. The paragraph concludes with a historical reference to a similar situation in 2015, where a change in the Central Bank's leadership led to a relaxation of monetary policy and rapid inflation.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Economy

The economy refers to the system of production, distribution, and consumption of goods and services in a country or region. In the video, the economy is discussed in the context of the Central Bank's decisions on interest rates and their impact on the market, inflation, and economic growth. The speaker mentions how the Central Bank's policies can influence the overall economic health and stability.

💡Interest Rate

An interest rate is the percentage at which interest is charged on loans or earned on deposits. In the script, the speaker discusses the Central Bank's potential decision to raise the interest rate to 20%, which is a significant move that can affect borrowing costs, investment, and the overall economic climate. The video suggests that high interest rates can have negative impacts on economic activity.

💡Inflation

Inflation is the rate at which the general level of prices for goods and services is rising, and subsequently, the purchasing power of currency is falling. The video script mentions inflation as a key concern, with the speaker discussing how the Central Bank's policies aim to control it. The speaker also highlights the lack of seasonal decrease in prices, indicating persistent inflationary pressures.

💡Budget

A budget is a financial plan that outlines proposed revenues and expenditures for a particular period. In the context of the video, the speaker talks about the new budget being presented to the government, which could include significant military spending. The budget's impact on the economy and the potential for increased deficits are discussed as critical factors influencing economic policy.

💡Deficit

A deficit occurs when an entity's expenditures exceed its revenues, resulting in a need for borrowing to cover the shortfall. The video script refers to budget deficits as a significant issue, particularly in relation to military spending. The speaker suggests that the budget deficits could lead to higher interest rates and economic challenges.

💡Central Bank

A central bank is an institution that manages a country's monetary policy, including setting interest rates, controlling the money supply, and overseeing the financial system. In the video, the Central Bank's role in managing the economy through interest rate decisions is a central theme. The speaker discusses the potential for the Central Bank to raise interest rates and the implications of such a decision.

💡Military Budget

A military budget refers to the allocation of funds for defense and military-related activities. The video script mentions the possibility of an increased military budget, which could have significant implications for the overall budget and economic policy. The speaker speculates on the potential for higher military spending and its impact on the economy.

💡Economic Crisis

An economic crisis is a period of negative economic growth, typically characterized by high unemployment, low business activity, and falling asset prices. The video script references a potential banking crisis and economic downturn, with the speaker discussing the Central Bank's awareness of these risks and the challenges in managing them.

💡Monetary Policy

Monetary policy refers to the actions of a central bank or monetary authority that influence the availability and cost of money and credit to help promote economic stability and growth. In the video, the speaker critiques the Central Bank's monetary policy, suggesting that it is not effectively managing inflation or supporting economic growth.

💡Inflation Rate

The inflation rate is a measure of how quickly the general level of prices for goods and services is rising over time. The video script discusses the inflation rate as a critical indicator of economic health, with the speaker noting that the Central Bank's policies have not successfully controlled inflation, leading to ongoing economic challenges.

💡Economic Forecasting

Economic forecasting is the practice of making predictions about the direction and strength of economic activity. In the video, the speaker criticizes the Central Bank and government's economic forecasting, suggesting that their predictions have been inaccurate and that they struggle to plan effectively for the future.

Highlights

Discussion about the beginning of a new economic season starting in September and its implications.

Mention of the Central Bank's meeting on the 13th and the likelihood of raising the interest rate.

Market reactions to the potential interest rate hike, including falling indices and government bond prices.

Analysis of the Central Bank's actions and the economic outlook by the head of the Center for Macroeconomic Analysis and Short-term Forecasting, brother Beloussov.

Expectations of a banking crisis that has been anticipated for a long time and its potential arrival.

The significance of the 13th of September as a key date for economic decisions.

Speculation on the budget being introduced to the State Duma around the end of September and its implications for the economy.

Debate on whether the government will continue the war or seek a ceasefire, and its impact on the economy.

Discussion on the likelihood of an even larger military budget and increased deficits.

The impact of high interest rates on the economy and the lack of positive movement.

Criticism of the Central Bank's policies and their effectiveness in controlling inflation.

The Central Bank's press conference in July and the questions raised about interest rate decisions.

The challenges faced by the financial planning authorities due to the uncertainty of the economic situation.

Comparison of economic forecasts at the beginning of the year with the current reality and the need for short-term planning.

The potential for a scandal in the fall if the interest rate is raised to 20% and the ensuing economic and political consequences.

Criticism of the Central Bank's policies by prominent business figures and the calls for a change in leadership.

The dilemma of the Central Bank's monetary policy and the debate over easing restrictions to stimulate the economy.

The risks associated with a softening of monetary policy, including high inflation rates and economic instability.

The call for support to combat the influence of Putin and his propaganda through sponsorships and contributions.