"SpaceX Starship is a BIG MISTAKE!", Scientists revealed...

Summary

Elon Musk's SpaceX aims to revolutionize space travel with Starship, a reusable rocket designed to carry 100 passengers and 100 tons of cargo to Mars. Despite the ambitious vision, experts like Dr. Robert Zubrin and Professor Brian Cox express doubts about the technical and logistical challenges, including refueling on Mars and the heat load upon re-entry. However, proponents like Dr. Michio Kaku see it as a necessary step for human survival. The world awaits the first orbital launch test, expected soon, to gauge the feasibility of Musk's multi-planetary species dream.

Takeaways

• 🚀 Elon Musk's SpaceX aims to make space travel as accessible as air travel, with the ultimate goal of sending people to Mars.
• 🛰️ The Starship project, currently under development at the Texas site known as Star Base, is designed to be a reusable rocket system capable of lifting massive payloads into space.
• 🔧 The technical challenges of building an interplanetary spaceship are immense, with refueling and thermal protection being significant hurdles.
• 🌞 Dr. Robert Zubrin, president of the Mars Society, suggests that the first Starships to land on Mars may remain there due to the extensive facilities required for refueling.
• 🔋 Initial missions to Mars are likely to focus on delivering essential cargo, including power generators, batteries, and solar panels, to establish a propellant plant for refueling.
• 👨‍🚀 Dr. Zubrin believes that a smaller crew of about 20 astronauts would be more practical for the initial setup on Mars, rather than the full capacity of 100 passengers.
• 🛰️ Zubrin proposes the idea of a mini version of Starship for Mars exploration, which could have advantages in terms of infrastructure and refueling requirements.
• 🌕 Concerns are raised about the feasibility of landing Starship on the moon or Mars due to the potential for creating large craters from the rocket's exhaust plume.
• 🔥 The stainless steel hull of Starship allows for re-entry from Earth orbit without heat-resistant tiles, but additional thermal protection may be needed for return trips from Mars.
• 🤔 Professor Brian Cox expresses skepticism about the timeline for manned Mars missions, suggesting that even by 2040 it would be surprising to see humans on Mars.
• 🌟 Despite doubts, many scientists and experts recognize the potential of Starship to revolutionize space exploration, with possibilities for deploying rovers, satellites, and telescopes on a larger scale.

Q & A

Who is the CEO of Twitter and the founder of SpaceX?

Elon Musk is the CEO of Twitter and the founder of SpaceX, a rocket company with the goal of sending people to Mars.

What is the vision of Elon Musk for space travel?

Elon Musk envisions making space travel as easy as hopping on a plane, with the ambition of establishing regular, low-cost missions to Mars.

What is the name of the site where Starship is being built?

Starship is being built at a Texas site dubbed 'Star Base'.

What are the components of the Starship system?

The Starship system consists of a giant spaceship on top of a large booster known as 'Super Heavy', both designed to land back on Earth for reuse.

What is the maximum cargo capacity of Starship?

Starship is capable of lifting a hundred metric tons or 220,000 pounds of cargo and people into space.

What is the volume of usable space within Starship?

The volume of usable space within Starship is 1000 cubic meters, large enough to fit the entire disassembled Eiffel Tower.

What is the opinion of Dr. Robert Zubrin on Starship's size and refueling?

Dr. Robert Zubrin, president of the Mars Society and aerospace engineer, believes that Starship's massive size requires a great deal of facilities for refueling, suggesting that the initial Starships on Mars will stay there to begin colonization.

What are the initial cargo deliveries to Mars expected to include?

The initial cargo deliveries to Mars are expected to include power generators, large batteries, and solar panels to build and power a propellant plant for refueling Starship.

What is Dr. Zubrin's view on the number of passengers for the first Starship missions to Mars?

Dr. Zubrin believes that the first missions will not transport 100 passengers; instead, a crew of about 20 astronauts would be safer to prepare for future arrivals of over 50 people.

What is the advantage of building a mini version of Starship according to Dr. Zubrin?

Dr. Zubrin suggests that a mini version of Starship would have a tremendous advantage for exploration architecture because it would require a smaller base for refueling and could be more easily managed.

What are the concerns regarding landing Starship on Mars or the Moon?

Landing a Starship on Mars or the Moon would require pre-built landing pads to manage the plume upon landing, which could otherwise create a crater and pose a risk to the vehicle.

What is Professor Brian Cox's view on the timeline for manned missions to Mars using Starship?

Professor Brian Cox doubts that manned missions to Mars will happen by 2029 as predicted by Elon Musk, and he believes that it is more plausible to see humans on Mars by the 2040s at the earliest.

What are the potential benefits of Starship's capabilities for space exploration?

Starship could enable the deployment of larger and heavier instruments more often and at a lower cost, potentially revolutionizing astronomy, planetary science, and Earth observation.

What is the general consensus among scientists regarding Starship's potential?

While some scientists express concerns and doubts, the majority are in favor of Starship, recognizing its potential to push the frontiers of space exploration and its innovative approach to space transportation.

Outlines

00:00

🚀 The Ambitions and Challenges of SpaceX's Starship

Elon Musk's SpaceX aims to revolutionize space travel with its Starship project, designed to transport humans to Mars and beyond. The colossal spacecraft, capable of lifting 100 metric tons of cargo, is touted to make space travel as routine as air travel. However, the project faces significant challenges, such as the need for extensive facilities to refuel the massive vehicle, as noted by Mars Society President Dr. Robert Zubrin. Zubrin suggests that initial Mars missions will likely be limited to a crew of 20 astronauts, rather than the full 100 passengers, to ensure safety and prepare for future larger groups. He also highlights the technical difficulties of landing on Mars and the Moon, due to the potential for the Starship's exhaust to create large craters. Despite these hurdles, many in the scientific community, including Dr. Makio Kaku and Neil deGrasse Tyson, recognize the merit in Musk's vision, emphasizing the importance of pushing the boundaries of space exploration and the potential for Starship to enable cheaper and more frequent space missions.

05:01

🌌 The Future of Space Exploration and Public Opinion on Starship

The script discusses the public and scientific perspectives on SpaceX's Starship and the broader implications for space exploration. While some, like Professor Brian Cox, express skepticism about the timeline for manned Mars missions, others see the potential for Starship to transform our approach to space. Dr. Kaku emphasizes the necessity of becoming a multi-planet species as an insurance policy for humanity's survival. Even self-proclaimed SpaceX critic Neil deGrasse Tyson acknowledges the project's merits and the possibility of it achieving more than just orbital flight. The script concludes by inviting viewers to share their thoughts on the feasibility of becoming a multi-planetary species and the role of Starship in this endeavor. It underscores the importance of public support and engagement in the advancement of space exploration technologies.

Keywords

💡Elon Musk

Elon Musk is the CEO of SpaceX and is known for his ambitious goals in space exploration and technology innovation. In the script, Musk's vision for space travel is highlighted, particularly his aim to make it as accessible as air travel. His influence is central to the theme of the video, which discusses the future of space travel and colonization.

💡SpaceX

SpaceX is a private aerospace manufacturer and space transportation company founded by Elon Musk. The script discusses SpaceX's mission to revolutionize space travel by reducing costs and making interplanetary travel a reality, specifically mentioning the company's Starship project.

💡Starship

Starship is a spacecraft being developed by SpaceX for missions to Mars and beyond. The script describes its capabilities, such as lifting heavy cargo and passengers into space, and its potential role in Mars colonization. It also mentions the challenges associated with its size and the technical difficulties of landing and refueling such a massive vehicle.

💡Mars colonization

Mars colonization refers to the hypothetical establishment of human settlements on Mars. The script touches on this concept as a goal of SpaceX's Starship project, discussing the logistics of delivering equipment and supplies to Mars to prepare for human arrival.

💡Interplanetary travel

Interplanetary travel is the movement between planets within a solar system. The video's theme revolves around the feasibility and challenges of interplanetary travel, with a focus on SpaceX's efforts to make it a reality through the Starship project.

💡Reusable rockets

Reusable rockets are spacecraft that can land and be launched again, reducing the cost of space travel. The script mentions the reusability of the Starship and its booster, Super Heavy, as a key innovation in making space travel more affordable.

💡Dr. Robert Zubrin

Dr. Robert Zubrin is the president of the Mars Society and an aerospace engineer. His perspective is sought in the script for his insights into the technical and logistical challenges of the Starship project, including the difficulties of refueling such a large spacecraft on Mars.

💡Propellant plant

A propellant plant in the context of the script refers to a facility on Mars that would produce the necessary fuel to refuel the Starship for its return trip to Earth. This concept is integral to the discussion of establishing a sustainable Mars colony.

💡Heat shield

A heat shield is a protective layer designed to withstand high temperatures, especially during re-entry into a planet's atmosphere. The script discusses the need for specialized heat shields for the Starship when returning from Mars due to the higher heat loads compared to Earth orbit.

💡Brian Cox

Professor Brian Cox is a renowned physicist who expresses skepticism in the script about the timeline of manned missions to Mars using the Starship. His viewpoint adds to the debate on the feasibility and timing of such ambitious space exploration projects.

💡Multi-planetary species

The concept of a multi-planetary species refers to humanity spreading out and establishing a presence on multiple planets. The script concludes with the idea that the Starship project could contribute to this vision, with Dr. Michio Kaku and Neil deGrasse Tyson expressing support for the project's potential.

Highlights

Elon Musk, the latest owner and CEO of Twitter, founded SpaceX two decades ago to someday send people to Mars.

Musk aims to make space travel as easy as hopping on a plane, emphasizing the epic nature of space exploration.

Starship, being built at a Texas site dubbed Starbase, consists of a giant spaceship on top of a large booster known as Super Heavy.

Both Starship and Super Heavy can land back on Earth for reuse, reducing costs significantly.

The entire vehicle can lift 100 metric tons (220,000 pounds) of cargo and people into space on a regular low-cost mission.

The volume of usable space within Starship is 1,000 cubic meters, large enough to fit the entire disassembled Eiffel Tower.

Dr. Robert Zubrin, Mars Society president and aerospace engineer, highlights the challenge of refueling Starship due to its massive size.

Initial Mars missions will likely involve Starships staying on Mars to start the colonization effort.

Early missions may deliver vital equipment and possibly robots to prepare for human arrivals.

Setting up a propellant plant on Mars will require large solar panels, potentially covering six to ten football fields.

Dr. Zubrin suggests that early Mars missions will have crews of about 20 astronauts to set everything up.

Zubrin also believes a smaller version of Starship might be advantageous for exploration missions.

Landing Starship on the Moon or Mars presents challenges due to the potential for large plumes and craters.

Zubrin argues that landing pads must be built on the Moon and Mars to handle Starship's landing impact.

Starship's stainless steel hull allows it to handle re-entry from Earth orbit, but Mars missions require reinforced thermal protection.

Professor Brian Cox doubts the feasibility of manned missions to Mars by 2029, suggesting the 2040s as a more plausible timeline.

Despite skepticism, notable physicists like Dr. Michio Kaku and Neil deGrasse Tyson support the vision of becoming a multi-planet species.

Starship's success could revolutionize space exploration, allowing for more frequent, cost-effective, and larger missions.

SpaceX aims to achieve a launch cost of ten dollars per kilogram of cargo, making space access more affordable.

The potential for deploying multiple rovers and large space telescopes could greatly advance astronomy, planetary science, and Earth observation.

Transcripts

two decades ago the latest owner and CEO

of Twitter Elon Musk founded SpaceX a

rocket company to someday send people to

Mars and he has said for years that he

will make space travel as easy as

hopping on a plane as he stood in front

of a gleaming steel spaceship it was

tempting to start believing him it's

really going to be pretty epic to see

that thing take off and come back must

set but that's the hypnotic nature of

such showcases the flashiness of the

affair the giddy confidence of the host

these can almost Allied the unspoken

hitch here that building an

interplanetary spaceship is really

really difficult could Starship be a big

mistake let's see what famous scientists

and Engineers have said about that very

subject

Starship which is being built at a Texas

site dub star base consists of a giant

spaceship on top of a large booster

known as super heavy both can land back

on Earth so they can be reused reducing

cost the entire vehicle is capable of

lifting a hundred metric tons or 220 000

pounds of cargo and people into space on

a regular low-cost Mission the volume of

usable space within Starship is a

whopping 1000 cubic meters that's big

enough to fit in the entire Eiffel Tower

disassembled for most this massive size

is admirable however the Mars Society

president and aerospace engineer Dr

Robert zurban said that a problem with

Starship is that because it's so massive

it takes a great deal of facilities to

be able to refuel it so I anticipate

that the few Starships at first land on

Mars will stay on Mars

to begin the Mars colonization effort

the rocket company's Mission would be to

deliver a massive amount of cargo

including vital equipment to Mars and

possibly robots with capability to set

everything up before the first human

arrives part of the first deliveries to

Mars could include supplies like power

generators large batteries and solar

panels that would Aid to build and power

a propellant plant to refuel Starship so

it could eventually come back to earth

zurban pointed out that would take six

to ten football fields of solar panels

and that's just enough to refuel

Starship within a 500-day stay on Mars

Starship is capable of carrying a

hundred passengers plus a hundred tons

of cargo zurban believes the first

missions will not transport 100

passengers that a crew of about 20

astronauts to set everything up is safer

to prepare for future arrivals of over

50 people zurban says building a mini

version of Starship to send to Mars has

a better advantage to sending it and

bringing it back to Earth it would have

a tremendous Advantage for an

exploration architecture because it

would need a big base in order to refuel

and come back he musk was adverse to

that he feels that developing one thing

is much better than developing two

things but zurban believes SpaceX is

capable of building both versions of the

Starship a full scale and a mini

especially seeing how quickly they

develop things besides he explained that

Landing a Starship on Mars will have

some issues zurban believes Landing a

Starship on the moon will not work

because it will have a gigantic plume

upon landing and it would blow a crater

he says it wouldn't land it will dig a

crater and follow over explaining that

both the moon and Mars need to have

landing pads built beforehand to land a

massive vehicle such as Starship so they

can take the plume of the Starship on

Mars is a bit of a less problem but it's

still a major problem if that can't be

resolved then he may be forced to go to

the mini Starship route zurban further

stated in order to land a Starship on

the moon someone has to go there first

and build a landing pad so it's not

blowing debris all over the place and

building a crater to fall into that's

not good architecture it just isn't

zurban believes there's also other

issues with the Starship architecture

for instance the Starship is a stainless

steel hull and he can do the entry from

Earth orbit from that because it's a low

ballistic coefficient which reduces the

heat load so he can do this with a steel

ship without heat resistant tiles or

anything of this sort but coming back

from Mars is a much higher heat load

than coming back from Leo so he has to

make specialized starships that are

reinforced thermal protection adding

that Earth to Earth version of Starships

would work

surface-to-surface transportation is

great

besides the famous Professor Brian Cox

also doubt Starship abilities must said

manned missions would happen by 2029 on

Starship but Cox doesn't see that as

plausible SpaceX is a remarkable company

they did do something astonishing was

just transforming the economics of space

flight you never know with them they're

really good Engineers but my guess is

must prediction is optimistic

Professor Cox said he'd also not go to

Mars tomorrow even if SpaceX technology

existed I'd be surprised to see anyone

there before the 2040s at the earliest

although I'd love to be wrong he said I

think it's even more difficult than

going to the moon was in the 60s Apollo

was at the edge of our capabilities in

the 60s it was right at the edge of

available technology and I think Mars is

perhaps even slightly beyond that at the

moment I wouldn't be surprised if we've

started sending the infrastructure

within the next 10 years well these

doubts are completely understandable as

Starship isn't real yet all eyes will be

on the first orbital launch test

expected sometime in the coming months

even if it is a success no one knows

whether SpaceX will be able to achieve

its vision of launching the Rockets

daily and reusing them many times also

unsettled is whether a market will

materialize for a rocket that could put

so much into orbit gladly while some

scientists are worried about Starship

the majority are in favor even

world-renowned physicist Dr makio Kaku

agrees with musk opinion as an insurance

policy we have to make sure that humans

become a two-planet species and now of

course Elon Musk has revived this Vision

by talking about a multi-planet species

even Neil deGrasse Tyson who calls

himself one of spacex's biggest critics

also believes that must SpaceX Starship

orbit project has more Merit and has a

higher chance of going Beyond orbital

flight the concept of SpaceX is we want

to send people to places it's an effort

to push that limit the frontier of

exploring space Starship could fly

bigger and heavier instruments more

often and much more cheaply if spacex's

projections of ten dollars per kilogram

cargo launch costs are to be believed on

Mars they could deploy Rovers not as

one-offs but in herds space telescopes

could grow and fleets of satellites and

low earth orbit could become commonplace

astronomy planetary science and Earth

observation could could all boldly go go

better than they ever have before and

that just about wraps it up for today's

episode what do you think about Starship

can we become multi-humanity don't

forget share your ideas on the comments

section because your support it

motivates us to create more quality

video and for that we thank you so much

and hope to see you next time

[Music]

thank you

[Music]

foreign

[Music]