Documentary on COAL: Mining, History and Future Outlook

Summary

The video explores the history and impact of coal as an energy source, highlighting its long-standing use and controversies. It discusses the types of coal, their formation, and their applications, while also addressing the environmental and health concerns associated with coal mining and combustion. The narrative traces the evolution of coal mining technology and its global usage, emphasizing the ongoing reliance on coal in developing countries and the challenges in transitioning to cleaner energy sources. The video concludes with a reflection on coal's role in the past and its uncertain future in the context of global efforts to combat climate change.

Takeaways

• ⚡ Coal has a long history as an energy source but is controversial due to its impact on air pollution and climate change.
• 🌍 Coal begins as plant matter in prehistoric swamps, transforming over time through heat and pressure into various types of coal.
• 📊 There are four main categories of coal: lignite, sub-bituminous, bituminous, and anthracite, each with different carbon content and uses.
• 🚂 Coal has played a crucial role in powering the Industrial Revolution and continues to be a significant energy source worldwide.
• 💀 Coal mining has been historically dangerous, with many lives lost over the centuries due to accidents, explosions, and poor working conditions.
• ⚙️ Modern coal mining uses advanced machinery like continuous miners, long wall mining machines, and dragline excavators, making the process more efficient and safer.
• 📉 Coal use in the UK has significantly decreased over the years, though it still contributes to a portion of the country's energy consumption.
• 🌱 Transitioning to cleaner energy sources like nuclear, wind, and solar is essential, but many developing nations still rely heavily on coal for economic reasons.
• 🌐 Global efforts to combat climate change, such as the Paris Climate Agreement, emphasize the need to reduce coal consumption and shift towards carbon-neutral energy.
• 🔔 The Commodity Culture series covers the history and culture of commodities and natural resources, encouraging viewers to subscribe for more episodes.

Q & A

What are some of the main concerns associated with the use of coal as an energy source?

The main concerns associated with the use of coal as an energy source include air pollution and climate change due to the release of carbon dioxide and other harmful substances when coal is burned.

What did economist Thomas Sowell mean by 'There are no solutions, there are only trade-offs' in the context of coal energy?

Thomas Sowell's quote implies that while coal is a reliable source of energy, its use comes with significant drawbacks, such as environmental damage. Thus, using coal involves balancing the benefits of energy production against the costs to the environment.

What are the four different categories of coal, and how do they differ in terms of carbon content and energy density?

The four categories of coal are lignite (25-35% carbon, least energy dense), sub-bituminous (35-45% carbon), bituminous (45-86% carbon), and anthracite (86-97% carbon, highest energy density). Anthracite is the most energy dense and pollutes the least, while lignite is the least energy dense and has higher moisture content.

What historical significance does coal have in terms of technological progress and energy generation?

Coal has been a crucial energy source for centuries, driving technological progress, especially during the Industrial Revolution. It powered factories, transportation, and was essential in smelting iron, contributing significantly to industrial and economic development.

How has coal mining evolved from ancient times to the modern era?

Coal mining has evolved from primitive pickaxes and candles in dangerous conditions to modern techniques using advanced machinery such as continuous miners, long wall mining, and surface mining, which significantly reduce the risks and increase efficiency.

What impact did the Mines and Collieries Act of 1842 have on coal mining practices?

The Mines and Collieries Act of 1842 forbade women and boys under the age of 10 from working in mines, following a tragic accident that highlighted the dangers of child labor in mining. This act was a significant step towards improving safety and working conditions in coal mines.

How did the Great Smog of London in 1952 influence coal-related policies?

The Great Smog of London in 1952, caused primarily by coal smoke, resulted in thousands of deaths and led to the enactment of the Clean Air Act of 1956 in the UK. This act mandated the use of smokeless fuels and measures to reduce emissions, significantly influencing coal-related policies and public health measures.

Why is coal still considered a necessary part of the energy picture for developing nations?

Coal is still necessary for developing nations because it provides a cost-effective and reliable source of energy. Developing nations need to use coal to improve their economic situation and gradually shift to more sustainable energy sources as their economies grow.

What are some of the dangers historically associated with coal mining?

Historical dangers of coal mining included methane gas explosions, suffocation from choke damp, flooding, and physical strain from heavy labor in confined spaces. These hazards made mining one of the most dangerous professions.

What advancements in coal mining technology have been made since World War II?

Advancements in coal mining technology since World War II include the development of continuous mining machines, long wall mining methods, and surface mining with dragline excavators. These technologies have significantly increased efficiency and safety in coal mining operations.

Outlines

00:00

⛏️ The History and Impact of Coal

Coal, a major energy source, has a long history and deep controversies due to its environmental impact. While it's been a reliable energy performer, it raises concerns about air pollution and climate change. The episode explores the sustainability and future of coal in electricity generation. Coal's formation began with prehistoric plants transforming over millions of years into different coal types, each with varying carbon content and uses, from electricity generation to metallurgy.

05:05

💡 The Dangers and Evolution of Coal Mining

Early coal mining was perilous, claiming many lives, with miners facing dangers from methane explosions, suffocation, and flooding. Primitive tools and hazardous conditions made it a deadly occupation. Women and children also faced harsh conditions, dragging heavy coal carts in near darkness. Over time, regulations improved safety, and technological advancements like continuous and long wall mining increased efficiency and reduced risks.

10:09

🌫️ Historical Use and Pollution from Coal

Coal usage dates back to ancient civilizations and gained prominence as forests were depleted. The Industrial Revolution saw a massive increase in coal mining, causing severe air pollution and health issues, such as the Great Smog of London in 1952. This led to the Clean Air Act of 1956, aiming to reduce coal's harmful emissions. Despite its decline in some regions, coal remains a significant energy source, particularly in developing countries transitioning to cleaner technologies.

15:10

🌍 Coal's Role in Modern Energy and Future Prospects

Coal continues to play a crucial role in global energy production, especially in developing nations needing affordable electricity. Efforts to reduce coal consumption and shift to renewable energy sources are underway, with goals to limit global warming. However, coal remains part of the energy landscape for now, supporting economies and technological advancements. The episode concludes by highlighting the ongoing relevance and eventual phase-out of coal in the journey toward carbon neutrality.

Keywords

💡Coal

Coal is a fossil fuel that has been a primary source of energy for centuries. The video discusses its historical use, reliability, and the controversies it faces due to its impact on air pollution and climate change. It also covers the transformation process from plant matter to coal and the different types of coal.

💡Air Pollution

Air pollution refers to the harmful substances released into the atmosphere from burning coal. The video highlights concerns about coal's contribution to air pollution and climate change, emphasizing the trade-offs involved in its continued use for electricity generation.

💡Trade-offs

Trade-offs are the compromises made when choosing between different options. The video quotes economist Thomas Sowell, noting that there are no perfect solutions, only trade-offs, particularly when it comes to balancing the benefits of coal for energy production against its environmental impact.

💡Electricity Generation

Electricity generation is the process of producing electric power. The video explains how coal has been a major source of electricity generation, detailing the percentages of coal used and its significance in the energy mix. It also questions the sustainability of coal in future energy production.

💡Types of Coal

Types of coal include lignite, sub-bituminous, bituminous, and anthracite, each with varying carbon content and energy density. The video explains the characteristics and uses of each type, from electricity generation to metallurgical purposes.

💡Carbon Neutral

Carbon neutral refers to balancing the amount of carbon dioxide emitted with an equivalent amount removed from the atmosphere. The video discusses the goal of reducing carbon emissions and how developing nations need to use coal to improve their economies before shifting to cleaner energy sources.

💡Coal Mining

Coal mining is the process of extracting coal from the earth. The video covers its dangerous history, including the risks and fatalities associated with early mining practices, and modern methods like continuous mining, long wall mining, and surface mining.

💡Industrial Revolution

The Industrial Revolution was a period of rapid industrial growth that heavily relied on coal for energy. The video mentions how coal powered machinery, transportation, and the means of production, leading to significant technological advancements.

💡Great Smog of London

The Great Smog of London was a severe air pollution event in 1952 caused by coal smoke, leading to thousands of deaths. The video uses this example to illustrate the health impacts of coal use and the resulting Clean Air Act of 1956 to reduce emissions.

💡Clean Air Act of 1956

The Clean Air Act of 1956 was legislation passed in the UK to control air pollution. The video explains how it was enacted in response to severe pollution events like the Great Smog of London, mandating the use of smokeless fuels and reducing emissions from chimneys.

Highlights

Coal has a long history and deep controversy as an energy source, being one of the earliest sources of energy.

Economist Thomas Sowell's quote: 'There are no solutions, there are only trade-offs,' applies to the sustainability of coal.

Coal begins as a prehistoric plant in a swamp, transforming into an energy-rich rock over millions of years due to heat and pressure.

There are four categories of coal: lignite, sub-bituminous, bituminous, and anthracite, each with varying carbon content and uses.

Bituminous coal, with 45 to 86 percent carbon, is the main form of coal produced in the U.S.

Anthracite contains 86 to 97 percent carbon, has the highest heating value, and is smokeless and least polluting.

Sulfur content in coal varies based on its formation environment, with freshwater environments producing low sulfur coal.

Coal mining has been one of the more dangerous professions historically, with significant fatalities, especially in the U.S.

Early coal mining involved primitive tools and dangerous conditions like methane gas explosions and suffocation.

The Mines and Collieries Act of 1842 in the UK forbade women and boys under ten from working in mines after a tragic accident.

Modern coal mining includes continuous mining, long wall mining, and surface mining, using advanced machinery.

Ancient civilizations, including the Romans and Chinese, used coal mainly for heat, pottery, and smelting.

The Clean Air Act of 1956 in the UK was enacted to protect citizens from coal dust and toxic particles in the air.

Despite a decline in coal use, it remains a significant source of power, especially in developing countries.

Developing nations rely on coal for energy before they can afford to shift to less harmful energy sources like nuclear power.

China, the top consumer of coal, is working towards reducing coal consumption and advancing nuclear, wind, and solar energy.

The Paris Climate Agreement aims to phase out coal use to limit global warming to well below 2 degrees Celsius.

Transcripts

Of all the energy sources  currently in use on planet earth,  

none have such a long history or deep controversy  as coal. As one of the earliest sources of energy,  

coal has proved to be a reliable performer  over time but carries some concerns when  

it comes to air pollution and climate  change. As economist Thomas Sowell put it:  

"There are no solutions, there are only  trade-offs." and so when it comes to producing  

the electricity that we all enjoy as a part of  our modern lifestyle, is the trade-off of coal  

sustainable? How much of the electricity generated  today is powered by coal and will it ever become  

obsolete? We seek to answer these questions and  more on today's episode of Commodity Culture.

Coal begins its life as a giant  plant in a prehistoric swamp  

hundreds of millions of years ago, before  even the mighty dinosaur roamed the earth.  

As that plant, and many others around it, dies  and become submerged in the swampy environment,  

geological forces subject them to heat and  pressure over time. This causes the dead plant  

matter to transform. What began as a moist and low  carbon form of peat is now energy and carbon dense  

coal and a sort of life and death cycle has taken  place. From living plants, to dead plant matter,  

and then into an energy rich rock that is at  the heart of humanity's rapid technological  

progress over the ages. Now depending on how  much time has passed since the swampy peat matter  

began its metamorphosis, it will have turned  into one of four different categories of coal.  

Lignite contains 25 to 35 percent carbon and  is the least energy dense form of coal. It is  

a crumbly substance and is high in moisture so has  a sub-optimal heating value. It is mostly used to  

generate electricity but it can also be converted  into a form of synthetic natural gas, chemically  

similar in most respects to the real thing, and  so can be substituted or used interchangeably.  

Sub-bituminous coal bumps the carbon up  a notch with a 35 to 45 percent quantity.  

The average age of this variety of coal is  at least 100 million years old, but averages  

a very elderly 251 million years of age. The  last note I'll make on sub-bituminous is that  

it's also mostly used for electricity generation.  Bituminous coal starts to really bring the carbon  

with a density of 45 to 86 percent. This is  the main form of coal produced in the U.S.,  

accounting for approximately 48 percent of U.S.  coal production, as of 2019. In addition to  

following in its siblings footsteps and being used  for electricity, it also is a raw material for  

making the fifth category of coal, which doesn't  exist naturally, called coking coal. Coking  

coal is made use of as a fuel and a reducing  agent in smelting iron ore in a blast furnace.  

Anthracite contains 86 to 97 carbon and has the  highest heating value amongst all ranks of coal,  

and is also smokeless and pollutes the least.  

It is mainly used for metallurgical purposes  but also finds some use as a heating fuel. All  

the varieties of coal contain sulfur in varying  degrees, which releases toxins into the air when  

burned. Interestingly, the sulfur content  is dictated by the environmental conditions  

in which the coal was created. Freshwater  environments breed low sulfur coal,  

while brackish swamps and marine influenced  environments produce a high sulfur variety.  

Coal, like all fossil fuels, is composed of  carbon and hydrogen. When combusted, the carbon  

forms harmful carbon dioxide and the hydrogen  becomes water. Coal has a greater quantity of  

carbon than say, oil or natural gas, and so  causes more damage to the environment overall.

When we trace the history of coal mining back  from when it was first brought out of the earth  

until today, a lot of people had to give their  lives to pave the way for energy generation,  

making it one of the more dangerous professions  over the ages. In fact, from 1900 to 2020,  

an estimated 104,895 people perished while mining  coal in the U.S. alone, according to the United  

States Department of Labor, but considering that  archaeological evidence after approximately 3490  

BC shows early surface coal mining in China, the  number of lives lost worldwide throughout history  

is undoubtedly a far bigger number. in the  first underground coal mines, miners toiled with  

primitive pickaxes and only a meager candle to  light the area. The candle also proved dangerous  

however, as it could cause pockets of methane gas  trapped in the earth, referred to as fire damp,  

to ignite and explode, bringing certain death  to any miner in the vicinity of the blast.  

Choke damp was another major concern, a form of  stale air that could suffocate miners to death.  

Add to that the potential risk of flooding, which  can and did happen regularly, and we can see that  

it was sometimes a roll of the dice for miners on  a daily basis to determine if they lived or died.  

It was also very common to be in a permanent state  of strain and injury from toiling with such heavy  

weight through awkwardly spaced mining shafts so  overall, life kind of sucked for early era miners.  

Now it wasn't just the men that risked  their lives, women and children had some  

of the worst of it, being forced to crawl  on their hands and knees in tight areas  

of almost total blackness, with a rope tied  around their bodies from which they dragged  

extremely heavy carts of recently mined coal.  They got this job because they were smaller in  

stature and more easily able to fit in the various  crevices of the mine but they sometimes never saw  

daylight at all except on sundays, as they were  underground from before sunrise to after sun down.  

In 1842 the Mines and Collieries Act was passed  in the United Kingdom, which forbade women of any  

age and boys under the age of 10 from working  in a mine. This came to pass after a mining  

accident caused by steam overflow due to violent  thunderstorms left 26 children dead at a mine in  

the UK. Now the initial solution to the problem of  explosive gas was a special class of miners called  

firemen, who wrapped themselves in protective  clothing and took shelter under panels of wood  

before purposefully igniting trapped gases with  a long torch or a candle drawn on a string. They  

needed to do this multiple times per day to ensure  the mine shafts were kept clear of explosive gases  

while the miners extracted coal. To say this  job was stressful would be an understatement  

indeed. The coking of coal was first implemented  in 1740, for the smelting of iron and this made  

it much more economically feasible to produce  it, resulting in a boom for the iron industry.  

The iron created by coking coal was then  used to build more effective implements  

and technology to mine more coal. Modern coal  mining has come a long way and consists mainly  

of three methods. Continuous mining employs remote  controlled monstrous machines with foot long teeth  

called continuous miners to break through the  earth and extract the coal. These devices can  

extract as much coal in one minute as used  to take an entire day back in the 1920s.  

Long wall mining was first  introduced in the late 1950s  

and has evolved a lot since that time. Like  continuous mining, long wall relies on special  

machinery. Now it's a little tough to explain so  here's a definition from the dictionary of energy:  

a mining method in which very long rectangular  blocks of coal are defined during the development  

stage of the mine and then extracted in a single  continuous operation by an automated cutting head,  

moving parallel to the coal face. Surface mining  became a viable method following world war 2 and  

eliminated a lot of the risks associated with  underground mining by once again employing huge  

machines, but this time to strip away earth and  reveal coal seams that lie closer to the surface.  

These machines, called dragline excavators, are  considered the world's largest land-based machines  

and are a spectacular sight to behold. Surface  mining is done in large open areas of land  

where coal seams can be readily identified that  don't require going deep underground to uncover.

In the days of ancient Greece, the great  philosopher Aristotle described a rock that burns.  

Today we know that rock as coal. Coal was used by  many ancient civilizations: the Roman empire, the  

Hopi Indians in early America, and the Chinese, to  name a few. It was mainly used as a source of heat  

but was also employed in baking, pottery, and  the burning of funeral pyres. As early as 1215,  

sea coal began to be traded around Scotland and  the north east of England, where it was used by  

artisans for lime burning, metal working, and  smelting. Sea coal was often washed ashore from  

deposits below sea level and collected by hand to  be traded. As forests were stripped bare of wood  

for heating and the construction of ships, the use  of coal became a necessity and so a quest began to  

mine it in earnest. If you think air pollution  is bad in some parts of the world nowadays,  

as coal rose to prominence in towns and cities  back then, it produced a black smog so dense that  

entire neighborhoods were sometimes enveloped,  making it impossible to see clearly. Visibility  

turned out to be the least of people's worries  however, as inhaling such vast amounts of coal  

smoke killed many citizens before efforts were  made to reduce and clean up its use. In fact,  

as recently as the 1950s, there were public health  disasters resulting from the burning of coal and  

the Great Smog of London swept over its namesake  city in 1952, primarily driven by coal use.  

The government reported 4,000 deaths officially,  but i've learned enough about how governments  

operate to place far more trust in the more  recent research that indicates 10 to 12,000  

civilian deaths from the killer clouds of coal  dust. This crisis, and many others over the ages  

since coal came into regular use in the 13th  century, led to the Clean Air Act of 1956. The  

act was enacted by the parliament of the United  Kingdom as a means of protecting the citizens from  

coal dust and other toxic particles in the air  by mandating smokeless fuels, such as charcoal,  

and included measures to reduce emissions  of dust, grit, and gases from chimneys. The  

Industrial Revolution, spurred on by improvements  in technology, brought about a massive increase in  

the amount of coal being mined, with production  growing rapidly in response to this new demand.  

Coal was indeed king when it came to this era,  and continued to reign in the western world for  

a long time to come. British poet William Blake  famously described coal-powered cotton mills  

as dark satanic mills, and indeed the constant  churning of smoke and layer of black soot on  

everything must have given many areas of England  a dreary and intimidating atmosphere. Nonetheless,  

there was no other substance that could produce  energy as efficiently or as cheaply as coal  

and it powered not only the means of production,  but also transportation. Great imposing steamships  

and sturdy railway locomotives were powered with  great success, especially considering the existing  

technology of the time. It also fueled engines  that drained water from coal mines, contributing  

to another full circle journey for the black rock,  as it was turned into steam to power the engines  

and allow miners to travel even deeper into the  earth, thus increasing their total haul of coal.  

Coal has provided a large amount of total  energy production in the UK over the years  

and even though its use fell from  156.89 million metric tons in 1970  

all the way down to 900,000 metric tons in  2019, it still remains a large source of power,  

accounting for approximately nine percent of  total energy consumption in the United Kingdom.

We've been focusing quite a bit on the UK because  they have a longer recorded history of coal use  

than pretty much any other European  country but coal was, and continues to be,  

a large source of energy in the developing world  and despite all the hate it gets, it is still a  

necessary piece of the overall energy picture if  we ever hope to get to a carbon neutral future.  

This is because to upgrade to a technology like  nuclear power, which is the most cost-effective  

and efficient low-carbon source of energy on  planet earth at present, developing nations  

need to climb the energy ladder and evolve their  energy production by improving their country's  

economic situation before they can afford to shift  to a less environmentally harmful energy source.  

As of 2019, the top consumer of coal was China,  although they are currently striving very hard  

to advance nuclear, wind,  and solar energy production,  

with plans to reduce the CO2 intensity of its  gross domestic product by 60 percent by the  

year 2030. President Xi has committed to reduce  coal consumption starting in 2026 but many other  

countries do not have that option if they want  to have access to electricity in the years ahead.  

A recent two-day virtual summit on tackling  climate change, hosted by the white house  

and involving all the countries who have  agreed to the Paris Climate Agreement,  

has placed a big emphasis on a global shift  towards carbon neutral energy production,  

with an ambitious, and some would say lofty goal,  of limiting global warming to well below 2 degrees  

celsius. Phasing out of using coal is a key part  of achieving that goal. As civilization moves  

forward, there will come a time when coal will be  just a fleeting memory but for now, it still has a  

role to play in our global energy economy. Thanks  for watching Commodity Culture, and see you next  

time. Commodity Culture is a series that covers  the history and culture surrounding commodities  

and natural resources. If you enjoyed this  episode and want to see more, please subscribe  

and hit the bell notification to ensure you  are always alerted of the latest episodes.