Review Film "Tanda Tanya" || UTS Pendidikan Multikultural

Summary

The film *Tanda Tanya* explores the complexities of multiculturalism and religious tolerance in Indonesia. It portrays a small community in the Pasar Baru area where three families of different faiths—Confucian, Muslim, and Christian—navigate their daily lives with respect for each other's beliefs. Key themes include pluralism, economic struggle, and personal sacrifice, particularly in scenes that highlight individuals' actions of compassion and selflessness. The film underscores the importance of mutual respect and understanding in fostering peaceful coexistence amidst cultural and religious differences.

Takeaways

• 😀 The film *Tanda Tanya* highlights the reality of living in a multicultural society with diverse beliefs and practices in Indonesia.
• 😀 The movie showcases the complexities of interfaith relationships, especially through three different families with varied religious backgrounds: Konghucu, Islam, and a mix of Christianity and Islam.
• 😀 Pluralism and religious tolerance are key themes, as the characters practice their faiths alongside each other, respecting each other’s differences.
• 😀 The film illustrates how individuals can maintain their religious practices while coexisting in shared spaces, as seen when characters pray and worship in the same room.
• 😀 Economic disparities are explored through the character of Soleh, who struggles with unemployment, leading to personal and relational tensions.
• 😀 Religious respect is depicted when the Konghucu family refrains from selling pork during Ramadan to honor the Muslim community's fasting period.
• 😀 *Tanda Tanya* shows how families navigate differences in belief systems, as seen in the mixed Christian-Muslim family, where one member practices Christianity, and the child practices Islam.
• 😀 The film presents moments of self-sacrifice, like when Soleh finds a bomb in the church and risks his life to protect others, highlighting themes of bravery and altruism.
• 😀 One key scene emphasizes the importance of mutual respect when a character, Hendra, chooses to keep his restaurant open despite opposition from his father, who wants to close it during the holiday season.
• 😀 The film encourages a message of unity and harmony, where differences in culture, race, religion, and beliefs should be acknowledged and respected for peaceful coexistence.

Q & A

What is the primary theme of the film *Tanda Tanya*?

The primary theme of the film *Tanda Tanya* is the portrayal of pluralism, tolerance, and coexistence in a multicultural society. It focuses on how people from different religious and cultural backgrounds can live together harmoniously despite their differences.

How does the film demonstrate the concept of pluralism?

The film demonstrates pluralism by showcasing characters from different religious and cultural backgrounds—such as a Muslim family, a Catholic family, and a Chinese family practicing Confucianism—living and interacting with each other. A significant scene shows characters from different faiths praying in the same room, symbolizing their ability to coexist peacefully.

What role does the restaurant play in the film?

The restaurant, owned by the Chinese family, serves as a central point where the tensions and interactions between different religious and cultural beliefs unfold. It highlights the coexistence of different values, as it is a place where the Muslim character, Soleh's wife, works while practicing her faith, and where conflicts over religious differences arise.

How does the character Soleh's personal struggle reflect broader societal issues?

Soleh's struggle with unemployment and frustration about his inability to provide for his family reflects broader issues of economic inequality and social challenges faced by individuals in a multicultural society. His frustrations also highlight the impact of personal struggles on family relationships and community dynamics.

What is the significance of the scene involving Surya and the church?

The scene involving Surya's decision to perform at a church is significant because it illustrates his personal conviction and respect for others' beliefs. Despite being a devout Muslim, Surya chooses to participate in an event at a church, reflecting the idea that individuals can maintain their strong faith while showing respect for different religions.

What lesson does the film convey through the scene where Hendra decides to open the restaurant during Ramadan?

The scene where Hendra decides to open the restaurant during Ramadan despite his father's objections highlights the tension between business interests and religious respect. It emphasizes the need for understanding and tolerance in the face of conflicting values, as Hendra's decision demonstrates a lack of respect for the Islamic tradition of fasting during Ramadan.

How does the film depict the concept of economic disparity?

The film depicts economic disparity through the struggles of characters like Soleh, who faces unemployment, and Hendra, who grapples with the pressure to maintain the restaurant business. Their financial challenges underscore the tensions within society that can arise due to differences in economic status.

What does the scene where a Muslim group protests at the Chinese restaurant signify?

The scene where a Muslim group protests and destroys the Chinese restaurant represents the breakdown of tolerance and understanding between different communities. It illustrates how social and religious tensions can escalate into violence when mutual respect is not maintained.

How does Soleh's action with the bomb in the church serve as a symbolic moment in the film?

Soleh's action of finding and removing a bomb from a church is a symbolic moment of selflessness and sacrifice. It underscores his willingness to risk his life for the safety of others, reinforcing the film's message of protecting the community and promoting peace, regardless of religious differences.

What is the overall message the film conveys about living in a multicultural society?

The overall message of the film is that it is essential for individuals to respect, understand, and live harmoniously with people from different backgrounds, cultures, and religions. By practicing empathy, kindness, and tolerance, society can overcome its divisions and live in peace, despite its differences.