DEEPSEEK vs CLAUDE vs CHATGPT: The TRUTH About AI Writing in 2025 (Watch Before Creating Content)

Summary

In this video, the creator compares three AI writing tools—Deep Seek, ChatGPT, and Claude—by testing them on three tasks: generating catchy titles and hooks, brainstorming ideas, and writing content. The creator evaluates each AI's ability to come up with creative ideas and their effectiveness in mimicking the creator's writing style. The results show that while all three tools provide similar outcomes, Claude outperforms the others by producing content that best matches the creator's voice. The video concludes by recommending the use of Claude for writing content that feels authentic and engaging.

Takeaways

• 😀 DeepSeek has disrupted the AI industry, but the question is whether it can actually mimic your writing style and produce better content than other AI tools like ChatGPT or CLA.
• 😀 The script compares three AI models—DeepSeek, ChatGPT, and CLA—by evaluating their ability to help generate article titles, brainstorm ideas, and write content.
• 😀 The first test involves generating blog post titles. DeepSeek provides titles that address audience problems (e.g., 'How to Post Daily Without Burning Out'), ChatGPT gives more straightforward titles, and CLA offers creative but sometimes cryptic angles.
• 😀 DeepSeek excels at understanding the audience's pain points, while CLA provides different perspectives, focusing on analyzing how others succeed, such as 'How Top YouTubers Create Content Without Burnout.'
• 😀 For brainstorming content, DeepSeek, ChatGPT, and CLA all suggest similar strategies for creating content, but CLA stands out by offering novel ideas like 'Leveraging Automation' and 'Building a Minimal Viable Production System.'
• 😀 In the outline phase, all three AIs provide ideas, but they remain fairly generic, such as recommending 'Batch Recording' or 'Repurposing Content.' DeepSeek and CLA offer repetitive ideas around templates and workflows.
• 😀 When asked to mimic the user's writing style, DeepSeek's output lacks the personal touch, starting with unnecessary introductions and feeling robotic.
• 😀 ChatGPT produces more concise and step-by-step content that better matches the user's style but still lacks some personality and personal connection.
• 😀 CLA shines in mimicking the writing style with a more engaging, personal tone, incorporating conversational elements and examples tailored to the user's unique voice.
• 😀 CLA emerges as the winner in this comparison for mimicking the user's writing style, being more adaptable and natural compared to DeepSeek and ChatGPT, which fall short in terms of personal connection.

Q & A

What are the three key areas being compared in the video?

The video compares three AI tools (DeepSeek, ChatGPT, and Claude) based on their ability to generate blog post titles/hooks, brainstorm ideas, and write better content.

How does DeepSeek approach generating blog post titles?

DeepSeek generates titles that address the audience's problems and provide solutions, such as titles focusing on avoiding burnout or making uploads consistent despite a busy schedule.

What is the unique aspect of Claude's approach to generating blog post titles?

Claude is more creative and comes up with diverse angles, such as focusing on how top YouTubers manage content creation or using specific frameworks.

How does the AI tool ChatGPT perform in generating titles?

ChatGPT provides concise and straightforward titles, focusing on the basics like overcoming challenges and improving consistency in uploading daily YouTube videos.

What aspect of AI-driven idea brainstorming is highlighted in the video?

The video highlights that while all three AI tools offer similar ideas for improving content creation, they often suggest generic strategies like using content calendars or templates. The brainstorming lacks deeper originality.

What does the video suggest about AI's ability to write blog post content?

The video demonstrates that while AI can write content, the writing quality varies. Claude is identified as the best at mimicking the writer's personal style, while DeepSeek and ChatGPT fall short in replicating the desired tone and style.

How does batch recording play a role in the content creation process according to the video?

Batch recording is presented as a strategy for creating multiple videos in one session, saving time and maintaining consistency without needing to film daily.

Why does the creator recommend using AI for content generation, despite some drawbacks?

AI is recommended for content generation because it helps writers produce content more quickly and efficiently. However, it still requires human intervention for improving creativity and tone.

What conclusion is drawn about the AI tools after testing their writing capabilities?

Claude is considered the best tool for replicating the writer's personal style, surpassing both DeepSeek and ChatGPT, which are less effective at mimicking the writer's voice.

What is the main takeaway from the video regarding writing with AI?

The main takeaway is that AI can help you write better content faster, but to achieve the best results, you must combine AI's capabilities with your personal touch, refining the output to match your voice.