The Verdict For MTG FOUNDATIONS.

Summary

MTG Foundations is generating buzz with its mix of reprints, new cards, and anime-inspired artwork, but the real question is whether it will maintain long-term appeal. While the set has a strong initial reception, including cards like Doubling Season and Feldon’s Cane, experienced players may already own many of the reprints, limiting the product’s appeal. Despite moderate pre-order sales, local retailers report sluggish interest, suggesting a slow burn for the set. Ultimately, while it could attract casual players and collectors, the set's future success hinges on sustained demand beyond the initial launch period.

Takeaways

• 😀 MTG Foundations has generated excitement with its initial launch, but players remain uncertain if it will have long-term appeal.
• 😀 The set combines new cards and reprints, with a focus on nostalgia and artwork that appeals to a broad audience, including anime-style cards.
• 😀 Pricing for MTG Foundations is steep, with *Jump Booster Boxes* at $139.95 CAD and *Collector Booster Boxes* priced at $339.95 CAD, leading to concerns about wallet fatigue.
• 😀 Pre-order sales have been moderate, with the *Play Booster Box* seeing 1,000 sales in a month, while *Collector Boxes* and *Jump Boosters* are lagging behind.
• 😀 Despite the moderate pre-order numbers, local store sales have been low, with minimal interest from local retailers, especially in *Collector Boxes*.
• 😀 The set includes fan-favorite reprints like *Doubling Season* and *Feldon's Cane*, which will attract long-time players looking for specific cards.
• 😀 The artwork, especially the anime-style cards, is likely to attract collectors and players looking for unique visuals to enhance their decks.
• 😀 Some players argue that the set is not designed for long-time collectors but rather for newer players or those interested in unique art and ‘bling’ cards.
• 😀 The *Collector Booster Boxes* offer the most flashy and desirable cards, making them the primary product for collectors seeking high-value items.
• 😀 While MTG Foundations may have a solid launch, its long-term success depends on whether players continue to engage with the set and purchase boxes beyond the initial excitement.
• 😀 The video concludes with a mixed review—while the set looks promising, its pricing, timing, and market reception could impact its long-term profitability.

Q & A

What is the primary concern about MTG Foundations from the perspective of the speaker?

The main concern is whether MTG Foundations will have enough appeal to players for them to return and purchase more after the initial release. The speaker questions whether it will become a long-lasting product or just a short-lived release.

What are 'sweeteners' in the context of MTG Foundations?

In this context, 'sweeteners' refer to cards with attractive artwork or themes, like anime-inspired designs, which are included to draw in players, even if the cards aren't highly valuable. These sweeteners help make the set appealing to a wider audience.

What are the different types of booster boxes available for MTG Foundations, and how do their prices compare?

The MTG Foundations product includes several types of booster boxes: Jump Booster Boxes ($139.95 CAD), Play Booster Boxes ($199.95 CAD), and Collector Booster Boxes ($339.95 CAD). The Collector Booster Boxes are the most expensive, containing the flashier, high-demand cards.

How does the speaker feel about the pricing of MTG Foundations, particularly the Collector Booster Boxes?

The speaker expresses concern about the high price of the Collector Booster Boxes, especially given that many players already own the reprinted cards. However, they acknowledge that the inclusion of desirable cards like Doubling Season may justify the cost for some players.

What is the impact of reprints on MTG Foundations, according to the speaker?

Reprints in MTG Foundations may appeal to newer players who missed the original prints but are less exciting for long-time players who already own these cards. Reprints help ensure the product remains relevant, but the speaker notes that hardcore collectors may not be the primary target audience.

What issue does the speaker raise regarding the timing of the release?

The speaker critiques the timing of the MTG Foundations release, noting that players may be experiencing 'wallet fatigue' at the end of the year, which could impact sales. The product's release may have been poorly timed in terms of when players have money to spend.

How does MTG Foundations perform in terms of pre-sales?

MTG Foundations has shown some success in pre-sales, with the Play Booster Box selling around 1,000 copies and Collector Booster Boxes moving 700 units. However, local retailers report poor sales, especially in smaller regions, although this may change as more spoilers are released.

What is the speaker's verdict on the MTG Foundations set overall?

The speaker gives MTG Foundations a pass, acknowledging that while the product looks good on paper and contains desirable cards, its success will depend on how it performs in the long run. They believe that singles and the Collector Boxes will drive most of the sales.

What does the speaker mean when they say the product casts a 'wide net'?

By 'casting a wide net,' the speaker refers to the strategy of including a variety of cards—such as reprints, new cards, and cards with different artwork styles (like anime art)—to appeal to a broad range of players, even those who may already own some of the cards.

How does the speaker feel about the role of hardcore Magic players in the success of MTG Foundations?

The speaker suggests that although hardcore Magic players may not be the target audience for MTG Foundations, their support is crucial to the product's overall success. Without this core group purchasing the product, it may struggle to achieve mass-market success.