Huawei Watch 3: A Scientific Review

Summary

The video provides an in-depth review of the Huawei Watch 3, evaluating its health and fitness features including SpO2 measurement, heart rate tracking, GPS accuracy, and step counting. While the watch generally performs well in SpO2 and GPS tracking, it falls short in sleep tracking and heart rate accuracy during intense activities. The reviewer compares it to alternatives like the Mi Watch and Fitbit, ultimately recommending other devices for better performance in specific metrics. Overall, the review highlights the watch's appealing design but questions its value given the mixed results in key health features.

Takeaways

• 😀 The Huawei Watch 3 measures SpO2 values closely aligned with dedicated monitors, but sometimes struggles with accuracy during flights.
• 😀 GPS tracking showed mixed results, with some accurate routes and occasional deviations through buildings.
• 😀 Step counting was generally accurate, with the watch slightly overcounting steps compared to manual counts.
• 😀 Heart rate monitoring was average, performing well during some activities but struggling during others like cycling.
• 😀 Sleep tracking was notably poor, leading to unreliable sleep metrics.
• 😀 The watch displayed a good interface and aesthetic, but this does not compensate for its health tracking shortcomings.
• 😀 Overall performance in key health metrics (sleep, heart rate) was not satisfactory compared to competitors.
• 😀 Alternatives like the Me Watch or Fitbit devices perform better for tracking sleep and heart rate.
• 😀 For accurate heart rate during exercise, using a chest strap like the Polar H10 is recommended.
• 😀 The review concluded that the Huawei Watch 3 is not recommended due to its high price and underwhelming performance in critical areas.

Q & A

What health metrics does the Huawei Watch 3 track?

The Huawei Watch 3 tracks several health metrics including SpO2 levels, heart rate, sleep patterns, GPS tracking, and step counting.

How accurate are the SpO2 measurements from the Huawei Watch 3?

The SpO2 measurements are generally accurate at ground level, but the watch struggles to consistently detect low oxygen levels during flights.

What were the findings related to GPS accuracy during cycling?

GPS tracking showed inconsistencies, with some routes deviating from the actual path. The accuracy improved on the return journey but still displayed occasional errors.

How does the Huawei Watch 3 perform in step counting?

The watch tends to overcount steps slightly but performs comparably to other devices in controlled testing.

What issues did the reviewer encounter with sleep tracking?

The sleep tracking feature was described as poor and unreliable, leading to dissatisfaction with the watch's overall performance.

What is the reviewer's opinion on the heart rate monitoring capabilities?

The heart rate monitoring was found to be average, with inconsistencies noted during activities such as cycling and weight lifting.

What alternatives does the reviewer suggest to the Huawei Watch 3?

Alternatives include the Mi Watch for budget-conscious buyers, the Apple Watch for accurate heart rate tracking, and Fitbit devices for better sleep tracking.

What are the overall recommendations for potential buyers of the Huawei Watch 3?

The reviewer does not recommend the Huawei Watch 3 due to its high price and underwhelming health features compared to alternatives.

How does the Huawei Watch 3 compare to the Galaxy Watch 4 in step counting?

Both watches performed similarly in step counting, but the Huawei Watch 3 slightly overcounted while the Galaxy Watch 4 tended to undercount.

What is the significance of the reviewer’s testing method for the step count?

The reviewer manually counted steps in controlled segments to provide a clear comparison between the watch's count and actual steps taken, ensuring accuracy in evaluation.