Zoning Matters: How Land-Use Policies Shape Our Lives

Summary

Zoning separates land by use, shaping our communities and lives. Initially created to protect public health, zoning has historically been used to segregate people, especially through racial discrimination. Though overt racial barriers are now illegal, modern exclusionary zoning practices still restrict affordable housing, limiting racial and economic diversity and increasing housing costs. This segregation negatively impacts local economies and public health, disproportionately affecting low-income people and communities of color. However, reforming zoning can promote inclusivity, with many communities reexamining their policies to encourage multifamily housing and walkable, diverse neighborhoods.

Takeaways

• 🏙️ Zoning separates land by use, such as commercial, industrial, or residential areas.
• 🏘️ Zoning shapes not only the places where we live but also our access to housing, schools, and parks.
• ⚖️ Originally, zoning aimed to protect public health, like preventing people from living near factories.
• 🚷 Zoning has historically been used to segregate people, particularly by race in the early 20th century.
• 🛑 Although racial zoning was outlawed, exclusionary zoning policies still limit racial and economic diversity.
• 💰 Restrictive zoning raises housing costs, making it hard for low-income workers to live near jobs.
• 🏚️ Zoning often pushes lower-income, multifamily housing closer to highways and polluted areas, impacting health.
• 📉 Economic and racial segregation caused by zoning slows local economic growth and limits upward mobility.
• 🔄 Some communities are reexamining and changing zoning laws to allow more inclusive and walkable neighborhoods.
• 🌍 Thoughtful zoning can connect communities and provide better access to public resources.

Q & A

What is zoning?

Zoning is a method used by communities to separate land based on its use or form, such as dedicating areas for commercial, industrial, or residential purposes.

How does zoning impact communities?

Zoning shapes communities by determining where housing, schools, parks, and other facilities can be located, influencing how people interact with their surroundings and who has access to resources.

Why were zoning codes initially created?

Zoning codes were originally created to protect public health, such as preventing residents from living too close to harmful industries like factories.

How has zoning historically contributed to segregation?

In the early 20th century, zoning ordinances were explicitly used to segregate neighborhoods by race, treating different racial groups as incompatible, similar to incompatible land uses.

What changes occurred in zoning after civil rights legislation was passed?

Civil rights legislation outlawed overt housing discrimination, but explicit racial barriers in zoning were replaced with subtler methods, such as exclusionary zoning policies.

What are exclusionary zoning policies?

Exclusionary zoning policies restrict lower-cost or higher-density housing, which limits racial and economic diversity and increases housing costs.

How do restrictive zoning policies affect access to public resources?

Restrictive zoning policies drive up housing costs, preventing lower-income individuals from accessing affordable housing near public resources like schools, parks, and jobs.

What are the consequences of economic and racial segregation caused by zoning?

Economic and racial segregation slows local economic growth, reduces upward mobility for residents of all races, and negatively affects community cohesion.

How can zoning negatively impact public health today?

Zoning can push multifamily buildings closer to highways and areas with high air pollution, leading to higher exposure to pollutants for low-income residents and people of color.

How can zoning be reformed to benefit communities?

Communities can reform zoning to support inclusive development, such as allowing multifamily housing and promoting walkable neighborhoods, which can help connect people rather than divide them.

Where can people find more information on improving zoning policies?

For more information and resources on improving zoning policies, people can visit urban.org/zoning.

Outlines

00:00

📜 The Role of Zoning in Communities

Zoning is a method that communities use to organize land by its intended use, such as commercial, industrial, or residential. It can dictate how many housing units are built and influence the overall structure of neighborhoods. These regulations shape not only the spaces we inhabit but also our daily lives, determining where key resources like housing, schools, and parks are located and who has access to them.

🏠 The Origins and Impact of Zoning

Initially, zoning codes were created to protect public health, such as preventing people from living near hazardous industrial sites. However, from the beginning, zoning laws also contributed to social divisions, particularly racial segregation. In the early 20th century, zoning was explicitly used to separate people by race, reinforcing the idea that people of different races were as incompatible as homes and factories. Although racial zoning was later outlawed, subtler forms of segregation remain in place through exclusionary policies.

📉 Exclusionary Zoning and Its Modern Consequences

Although civil rights legislation prohibited overt housing discrimination, modern zoning laws still enforce segregation through restrictions on lower-cost or higher-density housing. These policies drive up housing costs, limiting racial and economic diversity and making it difficult for lower-income workers to live near available jobs. This segregation harms local economies, slowing growth and reducing upward mobility for residents of all races.

🌬️ Zoning and Public Health Concerns

Zoning regulations, while originally intended to protect public health, often have the opposite effect. By pushing multifamily housing closer to highways or areas with high pollution, these laws disproportionately affect low-income people and communities of color, increasing their exposure to health risks. As a result, many live in environments that can negatively impact their well-being.

🔄 Rethinking Zoning for Inclusivity

Zoning doesn't have to be divisive. Thoughtfully applied, it can help connect communities rather than separate them. Across the United States, more communities are reexamining their zoning policies to allow for more inclusive and walkable neighborhoods. These changes include reducing restrictions on multifamily housing, increasing density, and improving access to resources for all residents. For more insights, visit urban.org/zoning.

Keywords

💡Zoning

Zoning refers to the process by which communities organize land into different categories based on use or form, such as residential, commercial, or industrial. This practice is central to urban planning and influences the structure of cities. In the video, zoning is shown as both a tool for organizing spaces and one that historically perpetuated segregation by limiting access to certain areas.

💡Exclusionary zoning

Exclusionary zoning refers to regulations that limit the construction of affordable or high-density housing in certain areas, effectively excluding lower-income residents and contributing to racial and economic segregation. The video highlights how these policies raise housing costs and limit access to resources like schools and parks.

💡Public health

Public health is a key concern mentioned in relation to zoning policies. Initially, zoning was introduced to protect public health, such as separating homes from factories. However, the video reveals that current zoning often harms public health by placing low-income communities near highways and pollutants, exacerbating health issues.

💡Segregation

Segregation refers to the enforced separation of different racial or socioeconomic groups within a community. The video describes how early zoning laws explicitly segregated neighborhoods by race, and though these practices were outlawed, modern zoning continues to perpetuate segregation through economic barriers.

💡Civil rights legislation

Civil rights legislation refers to laws that were passed to eliminate overt forms of discrimination, including in housing. In the video, it is mentioned that while racial zoning was outlawed by civil rights laws, these barriers were replaced by subtler forms of exclusion through economic means like zoning regulations.

💡Multifamily housing

Multifamily housing consists of residential buildings with multiple units, such as apartments or condos. The video advocates for zoning reforms that allow more multifamily housing, which could increase affordable housing options and promote diversity in neighborhoods by reducing exclusionary zoning practices.

💡Economic and racial diversity

Economic and racial diversity refers to the inclusion of people from various socioeconomic backgrounds and ethnic groups in a community. The video emphasizes that exclusionary zoning limits this diversity by making housing unaffordable to lower-income families, leading to more segregated communities.

💡Upward mobility

Upward mobility is the ability for individuals to improve their economic status. The video links restrictive zoning policies to limited upward mobility by showing how segregated, high-cost areas reduce opportunities for lower-income residents to access better schools, jobs, and other resources necessary for economic advancement.

💡Local economies

Local economies refer to the economic systems within a specific region. The video explains that economic and racial segregation caused by restrictive zoning can harm local economies, slowing growth and making it harder for all residents to thrive.

💡Air pollutants

Air pollutants are harmful substances in the air that can negatively affect health. The video discusses how restrictive zoning often pushes low-income and minority residents closer to highways and industrial zones, where air pollution is higher, thereby compromising their health despite the original intent of zoning to protect public well-being.

Highlights

Zoning is a way for communities to separate land by use or form.

Zoning shapes not only places where we live but also our lives.

Policymakers initially created zoning codes to protect public health.

Zoning has historically been used to separate not just land uses but people.

In the early 20th century, zoning ordinances were used to racially segregate neighborhoods.

By the late 20th century, civil rights legislation outlawed overt housing discrimination.

Explicit racial barriers were replaced by subtler methods in zoning policies.

Exclusionary zoning policies limit racial and economic diversity and raise housing costs.

Restrictive zoning can exclude people from equal access to public resources like schools and parks.

Low-income workers are often unable to afford housing close to jobs due to restrictive zoning.

Economic and racial segregation leads to slower local economic growth and less upward mobility.

Zoning policies can often push multifamily housing closer to highways and areas with higher air pollution.

Low-income people and people of color are more likely to live in areas that negatively affect health.

Communities are beginning to reexamine and change restrictive zoning rules.

Improved zoning policies can open neighborhoods to more multifamily housing and walkable areas.

Transcripts

♪♪♪

Zoning is a way for communities to separate land by use or form.

For example,

an area could be dedicated to commercial or industrial use,

or there could be a restriction on how many housing units can be built.

Zoning shapes the places where we live,

but it also shapes our lives.

Local zoning regulations determine where we can find housing, schools, and parks, and who gets to use them.

Policymakers initially created zoning codes to protect public health-

for example, to stop residents from getting sick from living too close to factories.

But from the start, zoning has separated more than just land uses.

It has also separated people.

In the early 20th Century,

many communities explicitly used zoning ordinances to racially segregate neighborhoods—

effectively declaring that different skin colors were as incompatible as a family’s home and a smokestack.

By the late 20th century,

civil rights legislation outlawed overt housing discrimination.

But those explicit racial barriers were quickly replaced by subtler methods.

Even today, exclusionary zoning policies that restrict lower-cost or higher-density housing

limit racial and economic diversity and raise housing costs.

By driving up housing costs, restrictive zoning can exclude people from equal access to public resources,

like schools and parks, and leave lower-income workers unable to afford housing close to available jobs.

When regions are more economically and racially segregated,

everyone loses.

Local economies see slower growth and residents of all races are less upwardly mobile.

And finally, despite being created to protect public health,

zoning often pushes multifamily buildings closer to highways and areas with higher concentrations of air pollutants.

As a result, low-income people and people of color are more likely to live in places that could make them sick.

It doesn’t have to be this way.

When done thoughtfully, zoning can connect people and places, not divide us.

Communities across the US are beginning to reexamine the role of zoning and change their restrictive zoning rules—

opening neighborhoods to multifamily housing, walkable densities, and more.

For more information and resources,

and to find out what other communities are doing to improve their zoning policies, go to urban.org/zoning.