Minecraft Kids Content Is Absolutely Terrifying

Summary

The video script delves into the concerning rise of inappropriate and exploitative content on YouTube, particularly targeting young children through Minecraft-related videos. It highlights how some creators use shocking and suggestive themes to garner views, often impersonating trusted family-friendly brands. The script criticizes YouTube's apparent inaction despite the platform's guidelines and the potential harm to children's mental health. It calls for awareness, parental monitoring, and potential media attention as solutions to curb this exploitative content.

Takeaways

• 😀 Minecraft kids content on YouTube is a popular and profitable niche, but it has been overtaken by creators producing low-quality and inappropriate content.
• 🔍 The video discusses the shift in the Minecraft kids content community from wholesome to exploitative, with some creators using shock value to gain views.
• 🎥 The script highlights the issue of 'AAL school' and similar channels that impersonate trusted brands to produce inappropriate content for children.
• 👀 There's a concern about the impact of violent and sexually suggestive content on the development and mental health of young viewers.
• 💰 The video points out the financial incentives for creators to produce such content, with billions of views translating to significant ad revenue for YouTube.
• 🚫 YouTube's response to this issue is criticized as insufficient, with the platform appearing to prioritize revenue over child safety.
• 🔗 The script mentions the use of direct messaging features by some creators, raising questions about their intentions and the potential risks to children.
• 📉 There's a call for better regulation and monitoring of YouTube content aimed at children, as well as a warning to parents about the potential dangers.
• 🔍 The video suggests that without significant media attention or a change in YouTube's policies, the situation is unlikely to improve.
• 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 As a precaution, the video advises parents to monitor their children's online activities or consider alternative, safer forms of entertainment.

Q & A

What is the main issue discussed in the video script?

The main issue discussed is the proliferation of inappropriate and exploitative content on YouTube, particularly within the Minecraft kids content niche, which targets young audiences with shocking, violent, and sexually suggestive imagery for profit.

What changes have occurred in the Minecraft kids content community according to the script?

The script suggests that the Minecraft kids content community, which was once wholesome, has been overrun by creators producing low-quality, exploitative content that exposes children to inappropriate themes for the sake of gaining more views and ad revenue.

Why is the content considered 'low effort' as mentioned in the script?

The content is considered 'low effort' because it is described as 'mind numbing slop' that is hastily produced to capitalize on shock value and controversial themes, rather than providing quality, educational, or entertaining value to the audience.

What role does the YouTube algorithm play in the spread of this content as per the script?

The YouTube algorithm is mentioned as being manipulated by creators who use shocking titles, thumbnails, and content to gain more clicks and views, thereby getting their videos recommended alongside genuine family-friendly content.

What is the significance of YouTube Kids in the context of this issue?

YouTube Kids is significant because it is a platform where children under the age of five often consume content, making it a target for creators who want to exploit the algorithm and expose children to inappropriate content for profit.

How does the script describe the impact of this content on children?

The script describes the impact as potentially traumatic and damaging to the development of young children, who are in formative years and can be negatively influenced by violent and sexually suggestive content.

What is the role of advertisers and monetization in this issue according to the script?

Advertisers and monetization play a central role as the script suggests that the revenue generated from ads displayed on these videos incentivizes YouTube and content creators to overlook the inappropriate nature of the content.

Why does the script mention the creator's previous video on this subject?

The script mentions the creator's previous video to highlight the overwhelming support it received and the numerous personal stories of horror from viewers, which motivated the creator to delve deeper into the issue.

What is the 'Rabbit Hole' referred to in the script?

The 'Rabbit Hole' is a metaphor used in the script to describe the deep and disturbing revelations about the extent of the problem with inappropriate kids content on YouTube, which is worse than initially imagined.

What action does the script suggest viewers or parents can take in response to this issue?

The script suggests that parents monitor what their children watch online or consider deleting the YouTube app to prevent exposure to inappropriate content, recommending alternative, safer content for children.

Outlines

00:00

🎮 Minecraft Kids Content Controversy

The paragraph discusses the evolution of Minecraft kids content on YouTube from wholesome to exploitative. It highlights the shift from content creators with good intentions to those producing low-quality, inappropriate, and shocking content for profit. The speaker feels compelled to investigate further due to audience support and personal obligation, hinting at uncovering even more disturbing aspects of this niche.

05:00

👀 The Exploitation of YouTube Kids

This paragraph delves into the prevalence of Minecraft videos on YouTube Kids, an app with over 600 million downloads. It criticizes parents for using the app as a passive entertainment source without supervision, leading to children being exposed to inappropriate content. The paragraph contrasts a creator who produces safe content with another who uses deceptive tactics to gain views, including impersonating trusted creators and producing violent or sexual content.

10:01

📉 The Downward Spiral of YouTube Shorts

The speaker explores the even more concerning issue of 'Minecraft animation shorts' on YouTube, which are often softcore pornography masked as family-friendly content. These videos exploit the YouTube algorithm and the short format's limitations to gain massive views. The paragraph criticizes the platform for not taking action against this content, despite its clear violation of community standards.

15:01

🚫 YouTube's Inaction and Creator Censorship

This paragraph discusses the experiences of creators who have tried to expose the issues with inappropriate children's content on YouTube. Despite their efforts to censor sensitive material, their videos are demonetized, while the original problematic content remains monetized. The speaker questions YouTube's motives, suggesting the platform might be turning a blind eye due to the significant revenue generated by these channels.

20:02

🧠 The Lasting Impact on Children's Development

The paragraph addresses the serious developmental and psychological effects of exposing young children to violent and suggestive content. It references studies that show such exposure can lead to trauma and brain development issues. The speaker also shares comments from individuals who have been negatively affected by this content, emphasizing the urgent need for change.

25:04

💸 The Financial Incentive Behind Inappropriate Content

This paragraph examines the financial incentives that drive creators to produce inappropriate content for children. Despite YouTube's efforts to clean up the platform, the speaker argues that the system is easily exploited, and the potential for profit is a significant factor in the persistence of this issue. The paragraph also highlights the ease with which a single person can operate multiple channels to produce such content.

🔍 Uncovering the Operators Behind the Content

The speaker investigates the individuals behind these channels, uncovering one operator's multiple channels and their attempts to communicate with young viewers outside of YouTube. The paragraph raises questions about the intentions of these operators and the potential dangers they pose to children. It also discusses the broader implications of this issue and the difficulty in resolving it.

Keywords

💡Minecraft kids content

Minecraft kids content refers to videos and other media created around the popular game Minecraft, specifically targeting a younger audience. In the video, this term is used to discuss the evolution of this content from wholesome and educational to exploitative and inappropriate, with some creators using shock value and controversial themes to attract views and generate revenue.

💡YouTube algorithm

The YouTube algorithm is the system that YouTube uses to recommend videos to its users. The video discusses how some creators manipulate the algorithm by using provocative titles, thumbnails, and content to gain more views and clicks, which in turn leads to higher ad revenue. This practice is criticized for potentially exposing children to inappropriate content.

💡Demonetization

Demonetization on YouTube refers to the removal of ads from a video, which means the creator will not earn revenue from it. The script mentions that some creators who expose the issues with kids' content on YouTube have faced demonetization, suggesting a possible bias or flaw in the platform's content moderation and revenue systems.

💡Impersonation channels

Impersonation channels are those that mimic or impersonate well-known and trusted content creators to deceive viewers, especially children, into watching inappropriate content. The video describes how these channels use familiar characters in shocking or violent ways to gain views, exploiting the trust that children have in those characters.

💡YouTube Shorts

YouTube Shorts is a feature that allows users to create and watch short, vertical videos on YouTube. The video script highlights how Shorts can be exploited to display inappropriate content to children, as the platform's algorithm may recommend such content based on the video's initial seconds, which can be misleadingly family-friendly.

💡Ad revenue

Ad revenue is the income generated from advertisements displayed on videos. The video discusses the financial incentives behind creating inappropriate kids' content, suggesting that the high view counts on such videos translate into significant ad revenue for creators, which may be a motivating factor for the proliferation of such content.

💡Content Farms

Content Farms in the context of the video refers to operations that mass-produce low-effort, low-quality content aimed at generating ad revenue. These farms often use automation and exploitative tactics to produce a high volume of videos with minimal cost, some of which are targeted at children and may contain inappropriate material.

💡Appropriate content

Appropriate content refers to media that is suitable for a particular audience, in this case, children. The video contrasts the concept of appropriate content with the exploitative and inappropriate content found on some Minecraft kids channels, emphasizing the importance of safeguarding children from harmful material.

💡Child safety algorithms

Child safety algorithms are systems designed to filter out inappropriate content from being shown to children. The video script criticizes the effectiveness of these algorithms on YouTube, arguing that they are easily circumvented by creators looking to exploit the platform for financial gain.

💡Mental health issues

Mental health issues are problems that affect how a person thinks, feels, behaves, and handles stress and daily life. The video suggests that exposure to inappropriate content at a young age can lead to lasting trauma and mental health problems, emphasizing the serious consequences of the content discussed.

Highlights

Minecraft kids content on YouTube is popular but has been overtaken by low-quality and inappropriate content.

Some YouTubers produce content with shocking violent and sexually suggestive imagery for more views.

The video discusses the exploitative nature of some Minecraft content creators targeting children.

Oper GX is highlighted as a browser that helps the creator edit videos efficiently.

Oper GX's GX mods feature allows for extensive customization of the browser experience.

The video explores the dark side of Minecraft kids content, including potential psychological impacts on children.

A channel called apmau is presented as a better example of kid-friendly Minecraft content.

The video discusses the monetization of inappropriate children's content on YouTube.

The YouTube Kids app is criticized for recommending inappropriate content to children.

The video creator calls out specific channels that use manipulative strategies to gain views.

The video discusses the potential trauma and brain development issues caused by watching violent and suggestive content at a young age.

The video highlights the lack of action from YouTube despite awareness of the problem.

The video suggests that YouTube's algorithm and monetization model may be complicit in the spread of inappropriate content.

The video discusses the creator's previous video on the subject and its reception.

The video mentions the potential legal and ethical issues surrounding the content on YouTube Kids.

The video concludes with a call to action for viewers to monitor children's content consumption and potentially remove the app.

Transcripts

[Music]

Here We Go

[Music]

Again Minecraft kids content is among

some of the most popular and profitable

niches on the YouTube platform and has

been ever since the game came out it's

what I and probably you if you're

watching this video consumed in some

capacity growing up however somewhere

along the way things changed and what

once was a community filled with

wholesome YouTubers mostly who made

their content with good morals and

intentions in mind has now been almost

completely overrun by selfish vultures

who abuse this Niche daily spitting out

low effort mind numbing slop content

that constantly exposes their viewers to

all sorts of shocking violent and

sexually suggestive imagery for a few

extra clicks all of this was covered in

my previous video on the subject however

what I didn't mention was that I left a

lot of things out in that video

disgusting harrowing things that

probably would have gotten my channel

completely demonetized but after seeing

the overwhelming support for my last

video and the infinite amount of people

commenting their personal horrifying

stories with this content I feel

obligated to get to the bottom of this

Rabbit Hole a rabbit hole worse than you

and I could have ever imagined

[Music]

but first allow me to introduce today's

sponsor oper GX it's no secret that my

videos including this one take hundreds

of hours of editing to produce and in

order to keep me entertained while

editing I like to watch a lot of YouTube

videos on my second monitor probably

like how you're watching this video

right

now don't think I don't see you but for

the longest time I had a major problem

in which my old browser was taking up so

much RAM to show these videos where it

would often literally crash my computer

however after switching to oper GX and

using features such as GX control which

allows you to limit how much RAM and CPU

your tabs can use I've been able to edit

for hours and watch my boy Sam suck in

peace with no issues now I know what

you're thinking Caleb I've already heard

of Opera GX and I know that they have

other amazing features such as a

built-in VPN and ab locker and force

dark mode that works on any page but did

you know that oper GX now literally has

infinite customization this is thanks to

their new feature GX mods where in just

a few simple clicks you can access and

download any of the thousands of

pre-made mods that are available in

their store allowing you to change

things like your wallpaper background

music and keyboard and browser sounds to

a theme that maybe represents your

favorite

game or have everything be a metal

[Music]

pipe for some reason the choice is yours

and it's as simple as clicking this mods

tab here and searching the mod mod store

for the one you prefer my favorite

recently has got to be this Minecraft

fireplace which honestly brings such a

cozy Vibe perfect for accompanying my

late night gaming or editing sessions

but probably the best part about GX mods

is that you can mix and match them like

I did here when I downloaded this

lavender purple key switches mod to

change all of my typing noises to sound

like

this which is just so satisfying I could

honestly listen to it all day and if

that's not enough for you Opera GX has

so many more helpful features like their

own version of chat gbt built into the

sidebar so if you ever need help with

some homework research or in my case

some inspiration for editing this

thing's got your back not to mention all

of your bookmarks and extensions can

just Port right over so why not try it

out today download oper GX for

completely free right now and support

the channel by going to oper gx. g/b Sal

2 or simply click the link in the

description thank you to them for

sponsoring this video and now it's time

to go down the rabbit hole

all right guys you ready to have the

scariest night of our Liv I am all

righty let's figure out where to go

first the video you just watched is from

a channel called apmau apmau is one of

the many content creators on this

platform who makes Minecraft videos

specifically cater towards a very young

audience upon first glance this content

might seem pretty cringeworthy and

that's because it is I was originally

going to make this comparison to the

Minecraft youtubers I watched growing up

but honestly especially compared to them

this content is very hard to watch but

despite this there's still one reason

all of these channels old and new have

stuck to and continue to churn out

familyfriendly orientated Minecraft

content money while you and I may never

watch an afound video in our lives there

is clearly a massive younger audience

for it not necessarily on YouTube but

rather it's subsidiary app YouTube kids

in a census done back in 2021 the United

States government discovered that around

75% of households with children under

the age of five owned some sort of

tablet for their kids and in 2023 it was

reported that YouTube kids had over 600

million individual downloads with that

number growing exponentially each year

unfortunately it's becoming increasingly

common nowadays for newer parents to

rely on apps like this as a way to keep

their child entertained without having

to put in any actual effort letting them

sit and watch hours of content

unsupervised under the guise that it's a

complete safe way for them to consume

content and the result channels like

apmau earning almost half a billion

views and millions of dollars each month

fortunately for us apmau is one of the

better examples out of this whole Niche

she does things by the books and aside

from it being a little cringey their

content is educational suitable and safe

for kids apmau school on the other hand

is absolutely unacceptable they too make

Minecraft related videos targeted

towards children

however the methods in which they gain

their views are a little different

instead of building a reliable and

trustworthy brand that both parents and

the young viewers who watch can trust

they resort to imitating an already

well-known and trustworthy

family-friendly content creator and

uploading content that uses their

original characters in all sorts of

sexually suggestive or straightup

violent ways for shock value in order to

get more clicks this manipulative

strategy tricks the YouTube algorithm

into recommending them alongside videos

of the real content creator they're

impersonating sometimes resulting in

these fake videos gaining Millions more

views than the original I mean this

channel alone has made roughly over

$100,000 in just a short year and a half

they've been posting content they also

have

$118,000 subscribers which is more than

me so uh please subscribe and of course

AAL school is just one small example of

the many perpetrators who make money

this way pretty much every Minecraft

kids YouTuber you can think of has one

if not multiple of these garbage filled

impersonation channels made using their

brand all the which are individually

made with this sole purpose of

generating insane amounts of money

inadvertently exposing a plethora of

disgusting and inappropriate themes in

their content to millions of unexpecting

children included but not limited

to take off the take off the take off

the Wii take off the money phone take

off the car take off the and the white

take off the take

[Music]

but it's okay I have a

gun we just tied you to the bed just

don't shout and everything will be fine

we're going to the girls house we knock

them out and then tie them to the bed we

take scissors and cut their

clothes but like I said I've already

discussed this before in my previous

video however what I was very stupid to

neglect at the time was that long form

video isn't the only form of media a

person can consume on this platform with

the other obviously being YouTube shorts

to which I've come to learn not only has

all of the same problems but for a

myriad of reasons is actually so much

worse by doing as little as searching up

Minecraft in the YouTube search bar we

can find a plethora of different

channels posting these quote unquote

Minecraft animations in the shorts tab

all with preview images that if left

uncensored would probably get this video

demonetized and all with tens times

hundreds of millions of views each the

main difference between anything I've

talked about in the past and these quote

unquote Minecraft animation shorts is

the way in which the content gets

recommended to viewers as mentioned

previously the most common strategy for

these fake quote unquote familyfriendly

channels to lure in new viewers is to

create the most shocking and attention

grabbing title and thumbnail they can

whether that be by using gruesome

violent or sexually suggestive imagery

in order to stand out in the viewers

recommendation feed in comparison to

other videos subsequently resulting in

more clicks more views and more money

after all that's the only reason they

even exist in the first place however

YouTube shorts work a little differently

since YouTube limits their shorts to a

maximum length of only 60 seconds as

well as having no support for custom

thumbnails these channels instead lure

the viewers in with the actual content

of the video and yeah very quickly it

becomes apparent that these quote

unquote animations are just straight

softcore pornography using Minecraft to

mask itself as familyfriendly content to

bypass the YouTube kids algorithm to get

like I said tens sometimes hundreds of

millions of views each not to mention

the fact that these channels

specifically abuse the system and take

advantage of the way YouTube shorts are

set up everyone knows that YouTube

shorts has this sort of Boom scroll SL

infinite scroll interface where instead

of giving the viewer a bunch of random

recommendations and then allowing them

to specifically choose what kind of

content they want to consume the app

practically just shoves a bunch of

random videos in the viewer's face

without a voice and no matter how much

they might not be interested they will

always watch at least a small portion of

it before scrolling away channels like

113 know this and that's why they made

sure to put Minecraft characters that

look like this in the very first second

of each video it's not even like they're

trying to hide it this channel Alex and

Steve animation which has 5.3 million

subscribers and over 1.6 billion views

not only does the exact same thing but

they also have a direct link to a

patreon account that creates fully nfw

drawings and videos accessible by

anybody with just one click the craziest

thing is this isn't even the first time

someone's spoken out about these issues

a handful of creators have already made

similar videos both calling out YouTube

on this massive problem as well as

encouraging Their audience to mass

report any bad channels they've

mentioned but every time YouTube

manually demonetizes and shadowbans the

video and the algorithm specifically for

showcasing clips of all the nasty things

these channels upload in fact friend of

the Channel and fellow YouTuber the Mr

Epic uploaded two separate videos

calling out these channels to YouTube

while taking the extra step to manually

blur and censor anything that might be

considered non- Advertiser friendly yet

still despite his best efforts both

videos would get demonetized all the

while the original content that was

being used in his video and all of the

channels related to it are not only

still active but continue to remain

fully monetized as well so basically I'm

just wondering what happened with those

two videos that got demonetized can you

kind of explain the situation around

that first one which I uploaded last

year that one was demonetized after

about I think 2 days interestingly what

happened was rather than the video just

outright being like sto being pushed and

sto being showed it actually like did

this weird thing I haven't seen before

where it like intentionally blurred the

thumbnail I had seen that happen before

but I was like oh oh well that sucks the

second video I then uploaded which was

only a few months ago now I was a lot

more careful like I went out of my way

to censor even more interestingly this

time I actually got more information

because uh I had like a partner manager

who I got around the time and uh he gave

me an update saying that basically it

was the thumbnail once again despite me

obviously censoring it more than the

original thumbnails but also this one 2

second clip of like I don't even know

what characters they are they're like

some weird like Kids characters in like

a somewhat provocative looking position

from another YouTube video mind you and

uh that was basically it and this was

after a human reviewer Plus my partner

manager pushing to get it um un AG

restricted and nothing could change so

yeah and at this point you may be

wondering why why would YouTube despite

obviously having the resources and

ability to do so still not take any

action to fix this glaring issue with

YouTube and YouTube kids but at the same

time actively silence anyone who decides

to speak out and make a video about it

well we can't be certain but my personal

theory is that YouTube has been aware of

it the whole time

[Music]

I mean think about it these channels

generate billions of views and by proxy

an unfathomable amount of money this

revenue is generated entirely from the

money advertisers pay to have their ads

displayed on these videos which honestly

can be a problem in itself I'm sure

Apple would be just delighted to know

that their ad is getting placed on a

video in where a popular children's

character gets buried live like what

YouTube splits this ad Revenue with the

Creator giving 55% of the share to them

and keeping 45% for themselves once you

start to factor in the hundreds of other

channels uploading the same

inappropriate content that simply

haven't been documented yet most likely

thousands if we include the accounts

outside of the Minecraft n posting the

same if not even worse content with

other well-known characters you can

start to paint the picture of Why

YouTube theoretically might want to turn

a blind eye it makes up a small but no

chunk of their revenue each year in

YouTube's eyes throwing all morals

ethics and damage this content is

inflicting on the millions of children

who use this platform every single day

getting rid of it means that YouTube

would be passing up a significant amount

of money and we all know they would

never do that YouTube ads are getting

worse so YouTube is testing serers side

ads on YouTube which means that instead

of using an ad blocker on YouTube to

bypass the annoying ad that you get uh

you're going to be forced to watch it so

instead they decided to take the much

easier route of ignoring the problem for

as long as possible knowing they have

plausible deniability cuz they could

just blame their algorithm or something

like that oh we had no idea this was

such a big problem it's just an issue

with our algorithm and quietly rake in

massive amounts of money while

simultaneously silencing individual

creators who make videos attempting to

expose and raise awareness about this

issue because unfortunately we are a

much smaller and easier Target to deal

with my if my videos which are like more

sensored than the ones online are

getting flagged and the human Reviewer

is saying that hey this is not

appropriate we can't have this and how

are like complete full channels allowed

to exist right like they need to fix

their human review system and either

allow my content or they need to block

other content that I'm I've increasingly

censored right like it can't be this

weird Middle Ground where somehow my

videos are being censored yet the other

ones are

[Music]

not in my previous video I touched on

the proven and Lasting side effects that

watching this content from such a young

age can do to an individual in the long

term multiple Studies have proven that

children's ages 0 to8 the primary target

of both YouTube kids and these channels

are in the most formative years of their

life everything they do learn and

consume in these years play a huge part

into shaping the type of person they'll

be for the rest of their lives this is

why traditional kids programming such as

PBS Kids always ends with a positive

educational and age appropriate lesson

being learned it's because all shows on

the network are specifically designed to

support a child's development in these

crucial years and promote healthy

positive behavior as seen in their

official educational guidelines but you

know a platform isn't properly regulated

and is quickly becoming more popular

than traditional programming YouTube and

YouTube kids studies show that children

exposed to violent and suggestive media

at such a young age can develop lasting

trauma and create serious damage to the

development of the brain and that's

exactly what's reflected in in the

comments of my last video ever since I

was N9 I've been exposed to sexual

content on YouTube and ever since then

my life has gotten a lot worse I keep

getting random headaches and can't focus

on one thing for more than 60 Minutes at

a time I've also had a lot of memory

losses due to this content and have

sadly developed Antion not me but my

friend used to watch these videos he

developed a severe eviction it took him

months to stop when I was little a bunch

of these Minecraft and elate videos

popped up and from then for 8 years I

have I am one who was exposed this this

is an extremely big problem is really

effective messes with the mind bro I

used to watch this and it's given me

horrible trauma and got me addicted to I

just turned 18 a week ago and YouTube

back in 2016 2017 messed me up in such a

big way I struggled with so much

depression and being exposed to so much

vile content ruined my perception on

myself and how I act subconsciously and

I've lost a lot of my most important

years in lessons where I should have

been properly taught about that stuff

when I was

ready in their official blog post from

February 2021 YouTube announced that the

YouTube kids app had over 35 million

weekly users since then the app has

almost doubled its total number of

downloads so if we do a little bit of

math here accounting for both of these

numbers and other things like Trends and

higher user engagement this means that

every day the estimated 70 to 80 million

users of this platform have a good

chance of being exposed to these kinds

of videos and then having to deal with

the life-altering longlasting effects as

a result

at first glance people might point the

blame at the individuals running these

disgusting channels and while they are

definitely at fault here I believe it's

actually YouTube that should be held the

most responsible on any social media

platform there will always be malicious

people looking to exploit the system for

their own personal gain however as long

as the platform is aware of this and

actively tries to fix and prevent those

exploits from happening then the

situation can be managed effectively

however YouTube hasn't exactly had the

best track record record of doing

that in 2017 parents began to complain

that strange videos were popping up on

YouTube kids so lately every time I go

on YouTube there's these really strange

videos showing up on my trending page I

mean they seem to be aimed at young kids

but they're super creepy and disturbing

these videos almost always use what are

otherwise household family-friendly

characters such as Spider-Man and Elsa

doing a variety of blatantly

inappropriate or disturbing things but

tagged in such a way as to circumvent

YouTube's child safety algorithms and

appear on the homepage of YouTube kids

this phenomenon would not go unnotice as

more and more of these channels began to

pop up all with hundreds of millions of

views each the number of concerned

parents complaining and demanding a fix

from YouTube began to significantly

increase and eventually this disturbing

Trend would catch the attention of major

news outlets who would also begin to

raise their alarm Bells via a bunch of

extremely well-written articles if you

ever let your child watch YouTube videos

we have got a warning for you some

people are creating disturbing cartoons

making them appear kid-friendly only to

get your children to watch inappropriate

content that's all covering an event

commonly referred to as elate yet

despite receiving mainstream attention

Mass reports and millions of individual

complaints YouTube did almost nothing to

fix the situation until November 27th of

that year when in a buzzfeed article

YouTube finally announced they were

cracking down on the problem removing

over 150,000 of these inappropriate

videos and demonetizing over 2 million

more please note that this announcement

while positive and overall a pretty big

win for the platform just so happened to

occur only 3 days after a bunch of Major

Brands and advertisers had pulled out

due to the entire Scandal YouTube years

later would also get fined $170 Million

by the FTC partially for having such a

glaring issue with their quote unquote

kids content and child safety rules as a

result of this YouTube would also update

their guidelines to ban any

inappropriate use of quote family

entertainment characters and also

Implement a brand new labeling system

forcing creators to decide whether or

not their videos are made for kids if a

video is determined to be made for kids

it will lose a majority of features that

normal videos have such as the comment

section and most importantly

personalized ads and a majority of AD

Revenue but if that's the case then how

are these channels which are clearly

targeted towards children still able to

make so much money and the answer is

about as simple as it is aggravating to

be honest it really doesn't matter what

option the Creator chooses as both types

of content even ones specifically marked

as not for kids actively get recommended

through the YouTube kids app as long as

the video looks family friendly enough

in the eyes of the algorithm by loading

up the thumbnail with a bunch of bright

colors and swapping out any potentially

dangerous words like with prank or with

love curse it will get recommended just

a same and there's a really easy way to

prove this that you can do yourself just

go to literally any of the channels I've

mentioned so far click on a random video

and take a look at the engagement on the

actual video for example this video has

213,000 views yet only 1100 likes and

only 40 comments this is because when

you watch a video on YouTube kids it

doesn't have any of the extra buttons or

features it only allows you to watch the

video but since the video is still

coming from YouTube it still counts as a

view and the only engagement that's

actually getting left on the video is

from other kids using the regular

YouTube app probably using their parents

account and yeah it's pretty easy to

tell by the quality of the comments here

kind of funny how even though YouTube

implemented these supposed changes to

make the platform safer it appears it's

now easier than ever to run one of these

content Farms due to its simple editing

style low production costs hell even the

recent developments in AI technology

specifically for voice lines and text to

speech it's no problem for a single

person with no moral comass and enough

free time to start operating a network

of these channels pumping out dozens of

these videos a week all while facing

absolutely zero public repercussion or

backlash and remaining completely

Anonymous in other words it's the

perfect

crime but let's take a step back for a

moment and explore a rather outlandish

question what if the owner actually

wants to be

found this is Neil for the sake of

anonymity that's obviously not his real

name but as you can probably guess by

now Neil makes a living by owning and

operating one of these Minecraft kids

content Farms however for many reasons

we'll dive into shortly they might just

be the worst of the worst because it's

one thing to upload this disgusting

content with the goal of monetary gain

but what's even more worrying and truly

vile is owning channels like these than

trying to communicate with your audience

and lure them off the

site earlier this year on January 26th a

YouTuber named named the beak uploaded a

video showcasing his discovery of a very

strange set of channels which

impersonate characters from The Amazing

digital circus a very popular children's

animated series on YouTube which for

whatever reason has absolutely taken off

and garnered over half a billion views

in just the first two fulllength

episodes in other words it's just

another example of these channels

exploiting familiar and trusted

family-friendly characters for views and

tricking children into watching content

that is all but familyfriendly let's

take a quick look at what Neil thinks is

acceptable to

[Music]

post every single thumbnail every single

video on all of these channels

completely violate YouTube's content

guidelines however this isn't even the

weirdest part in his video the beak

discovered that both of these channels

advertised a link which invited anybody

who clicked on it the ability to

directly message Neil on telegram a

messaging platform Infamous for its

overwhelming focus on privacy with

messages sent over there having endtoend

encryption and being for the most part

completely untraceable yet some time

after the beaks video was posted the

owner suddenly removed these telegram

links and change the contact email for

both of the pomy and Jack's channels

interesting now I'm not trying to assume

the worst here but I really can't find a

reasonable explanation as to why an

owner of multiple channels which make

over sexualized Minecraft content

targeted towards very young children

would ever need to include a direct

messaging feature in their About Me

section and more importantly why would

they feel the need to delete the

telegram link almost immediately after

being exposed about it while assumptions

can be made we may never truly know the

answer I was still pretty curious about

this Neil guy though so I did a bit more

digging around eventually I had the idea

to paste the Channel's original email

address into the YouTube search bar

which brought me to a whole bunch more

of these channels that he owned

impersonating even more YouTubers like

apmau and Meen then I decided to try the

same tactic with this new email and

found yet another impersonation Channel

he owned which contains another sketchy

link this time leading to a Kofi page

that sells NSFW content of their

characters which of course comes with

another direct messaging feature and

just to confirm that despite all the

changes these channels are still owned

by the same person they both use the

exact same AI text to speech voices and

music in their videos pomy please lather

up with the washcloth and also this part

of my back okay Jax but you're already

very clean you have no idea how long

I've been waiting for this jump onto my

bed and strip off all your clothes the

thumbnails have the exact same very

specific art style as if you know they

were commissioned by the same artist the

titles are all very similar often using

the same set of keywords across all

channels like what is he planning and

what is he up to also all of the

channels were created roughly around the

same time in mid to late 2023 it's a

common theme for all of these YouTube

automation people and content Farms to

start all of their channels at once and

that's exactly what happened here with

the Jax and hasbin hotel Channel even

being created on the same day and most

importantly the NSFW Kofi page has perks

listed in Russian writing which just so

happens to be the exact same language

Neil's real first name is displayed on

his old telegram

[Music]

link inappropriate imitation channels

wildly obscene thumbnails abhorent

YouTube shorts weird content Farm owners

that advertise NSFW patreons and direct

messaging features the long repeated

negligence of YouTube and the result of

it all the potential danger and long-

Lasting mental health issues of millions

of children around the world this is the

Minecraft kids content Rabbit Hole yet

one unanswered question remains what

does the endgame of this issue look like

will it ever reach a boiling point will

YouTube ever step in and how do we fix

this well I think either a that uh too

many of the people making the videos

will end up getting falsely flagged or

demonetized and then they just stop

making the videos cuz they can't make

money from it anymore or B it somehow

gets like significant media attention to

the point where they actually decide to

take action because I feel like right

now no no one really knows about this

stuff or really cares right you never

hear about it so I think those are the

two options I don't think anything's

really going to change because I I feel

like they don't have any reason to

change anything right and there it is

YouTube at this current moment throwing

all morals and ethics aside has no

reason to change or fix this issue not

exactly the resolution you and I were

probably hoping for but unfortunately

it's the honest truth if you're somehow

a parent or sibling of someone who might

be at risk of this content my best

advice would be to Simply monitor what

they're watching online and if that's

too hard just delete the app entirely

and let them watch like Arthur or

something I don't know and lastly thank

you for watching

[Music]

oh