Meski Dihujat, Konten Mandi Lumpur Terus Diproduksi

CNN Indonesia

19 Jan 202301:38

Summary

TLDRThe video script discusses a controversial trend on TikTok where users, facing criticism for 'online begging,' utilize the live feature to ask for donations. Despite the backlash, they claim it's a new style of earning, akin to panhandling, but with the use of smartphones and data plans as their 'capital.' The script also features elderly individuals in Lombok, Indonesia, who are drawn to this method, believing they can earn significant income by simply washing in front of a camera for 12 hours, highlighting the desperation and the innovative, albeit controversial, ways people are turning to social media for financial support.

Takeaways

📱 TikTok users are using the live feature for new ways to ask for money.
💸 The method is controversial and criticized as online begging.
👵🏻 Elderly women in a village are attracted by the prospect of earning money by performing simple tasks on camera.
💧 The task involves scooping water for 12 hours to earn money.
🏡 This is happening in a small house in a village in Lombok Tengah, West Nusa Tenggara, Indonesia.
🤔 The elderly women are motivated by the lack of other income sources and the potential to earn significant money.
📈 The content creator defends the practice, stating it requires an investment and is not mere begging.
📱 They argue that using a smartphone, data, and a pond are the 'capital' needed for this endeavor.
🎥 The process involves a bit of acting to attract the attention of netizens and increase viewership.
👥 The ultimate goal is to attract more viewers and likes on the platform.

Q & A

What is the main activity being discussed in the script?
-The main activity being discussed is the act of people, particularly elderly women, bathing in a river and live-streaming it on TikTok to gain likes and monetary donations from viewers.
What is the public's reaction to this activity as mentioned in the script?
-The public's reaction is mixed, with many criticizing it as a form of online begging, despite the participants receiving likes and monetary support.
Why are the elderly women participating in this activity?
-The elderly women are participating because they are attracted by the prospect of earning money by simply bathing in the river for 12 hours in front of a camera.
What financial benefits do the participants claim to receive from this activity?
-The participants claim that they can earn a significant amount of money, with one mentioning the possibility of earning one million rupiah from a single session.
How does the content creator respond to the criticism of their activity?
-The content creator rejects the label of online begging, arguing that creating such videos requires an initial investment and that not everyone can do it, implying it requires some skill or effort.
What is the initial investment mentioned by the content creator?
-The initial investment mentioned includes the cost of a smartphone, data plan, and the setup for the bathing area.
What is the primary goal of the content creator according to the script?
-The primary goal of the content creator is to attract more viewers and attention from netizens to increase the popularity and potential earnings from their live streams.
What is the location where the elderly women are being recorded?
-The location is a simple house in the village of Setanggor, Kecamatan Praya Barat, Kabupaten Lombok Tengah NTB.
What is the script's implication about the accessibility of this activity to others?
-The script implies that this activity is not accessible to everyone, as it requires certain resources and a bit of acting to attract the audience.
How does the script describe the situation of the elderly women before they started this activity?
-The script describes the elderly women as being in a situation where they have no money and no land to work on, suggesting a lack of other income-generating opportunities.

Outlines

00:00

📱 'Begging' Through Live Streaming on TikTok

The script discusses a controversial trend on TikTok where individuals use the live streaming feature, typically for selling, to instead ask for donations from viewers. This method has been criticized as a new form of online begging. Despite the backlash, the trend continues to gain traction as some users find it effective. The script also mentions elderly women in a village in Lombok, Indonesia, who line up to be filmed in a simple house, claiming they can earn a significant amount of money by just scooping water for 12 hours in front of a camera. The content creator defends their actions, arguing that they are not begging but investing in their content creation, using their smartphones and data as capital to attract viewers and generate income.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Live Streaming

Live streaming refers to the real-time broadcasting of video content over the internet. In the context of the video, it is mentioned as a platform where individuals use the live feature to interact with viewers, often for selling products or, as in this case, to ask for donations. The script highlights the controversial use of live streaming for soliciting financial support, which has drawn criticism.

💡Tik Tok

Tik Tok is a social media platform known for its short-form videos. It is highlighted in the script as a place where the live streaming practice of asking for donations has gained attention and sparked debates. The platform's live feature is central to the video's narrative, showing how it can be used for various purposes, including those that are controversial.

💡Netizens

Netizens are individuals who participate in online communities and social media platforms. In the script, netizens are mentioned as the audience who watch the live streams and potentially react or contribute financially. The term is used to describe the broader community that engages with the content creators on Tik Tok.

💡Donations

Donations are voluntary contributions of money or other resources to support a cause or individual in need. The video script discusses the act of requesting donations during live streams, which is a central theme of the controversy. It raises questions about the ethics and motivations behind asking for financial support online.

💡Controversy

Controversy refers to a situation that involves significant disagreement, often resulting in public debate. In the context of the video, the act of soliciting donations through live streams on Tik Tok has become controversial, with many netizens criticizing it as a form of online begging.

💡Online Begging

Online begging is the act of requesting money or financial assistance through the internet, often via social media or live streaming platforms. The script mentions this term as a criticism leveled against those who use live streaming to ask for donations, suggesting it is viewed negatively by some as a form of exploitation.

💡Capital

In the video script, 'capital' is used to refer to the resources or assets needed to start or maintain a business or activity. The content creator argues that they have invested 'capital' in the form of smartphones, data plans, and other resources to produce their videos, which counters the accusation of online begging.

💡Engagement

Engagement in the context of social media refers to the interaction between content creators and their audience. The script implies that to gain more viewers and attention, content creators might resort to controversial methods, such as asking for donations live, to increase engagement and visibility on platforms like Tik Tok.

💡Likes

Likes on social media platforms, including Tik Tok, are a form of user feedback indicating approval or enjoyment of the content. The script mentions that despite the controversy, the live streaming practice continues to receive likes, suggesting that there is an audience that supports this type of content.

💡Content Creation

Content creation refers to the process of producing material intended for consumption on digital platforms. In the script, content creation is discussed in the context of live streaming, where individuals create videos to attract viewers and potentially solicit donations, highlighting the diverse ways people monetize their online presence.

💡Ethics

Ethics involve moral principles that govern a person's or group's behavior. The video script touches on ethical considerations regarding the use of live streaming for financial gain, particularly when it involves asking for donations, which some view as exploitative or inappropriate.

Highlights

Live streaming in Bandung is being used to solicit donations, a new method criticized as online begging.

Despite criticism, the trend of asking for 'give' during live streams on TikTok continues to gain popularity.

In Lombok Tengah, elderly women line up to participate in a video recording for potential earnings.

The job involves stirring water for 12 hours in front of a camera, which is claimed to be lucrative.

Participants are attracted by the promise of earning a significant amount of money without traditional means.

One participant mentioned earning one million in a single play, indicating high earnings potential.

The content creator rejects the label of online begging, arguing that there is an investment involved.

The investment mentioned includes the use of a smartphone, data plan, and the creation of a pond as part of the setup.

Not everyone can replicate this method, suggesting a certain level of skill or resources is required.

The creator aims to attract attention from netizens to increase the number of viewers.

The ultimate goal is to attract more viewers through the use of the live feature on TikTok.

The method is described as a new style of 'begging' that leverages social media platforms.

The live streaming feature, typically used for selling, is repurposed for soliciting donations.

The criticism highlights a moral debate about the ethics of online fundraising.

The elderly women's participation suggests a demographic shift in those engaging with new media.

The video content is created with the intention of generating income without traditional farming or labor.

The creator's defense of their method indicates a perceived need for validation and understanding.

The use of the term 'begging' is contested, with the creator emphasizing the effort and investment involved.

The live streaming setup is described as requiring a significant initial outlay, including equipment and infrastructure.