Porsche Cayman 718 GT4: How Porsche's Arrogance Created a Bargain

Summary

In this video, the host reminisces about the launch of the Porsche Cayman GT4 and its significance, noting how it was a highly anticipated car that exceeded expectations. The script discusses the evolution of the Cayman, from its modest power output to the powerful GT4 variant. It critiques Porsche's strategy with the 718 Cayman GT4, suggesting mismanagement of customer expectations due to dealer practices, which led to inflated prices and speculation. The host praises the 718 GT4 for its performance, handling, and value, recommending it as a worthy choice for driving enthusiasts, despite its initial market challenges.

Takeaways

• 🚗 The Porsche Cayman GT4 is a highly regarded sports car that was initially seen as a more balanced and enjoyable drive compared to the 911.
• 🌟 The original Cayman GT4 (981 generation) was an instant hit and became a sought-after model due to its limited production run.
• 🛠️ Porsche made some controversial changes with the 718 Cayman GT4, including replacing the iconic naturally aspirated Flat 6 engine with a turbocharged four-cylinder engine.
• 💨 The 718 Cayman GT4 features a 4.0L engine that produces 420 horsepower and 310 lb-ft of torque, which is a significant upgrade from its predecessor.
• 🏎️ The GT4 offers a thrilling driving experience with strong low-end torque and a responsive engine that pulls hard from low RPMs.
• 🔧 Porsche's decision to introduce the GT4 with a manual transmission option was a nod to driving purists, although PDK was later offered.
• 📈 The 718 GT4 was produced for a longer period than the original, which led to a more abundant supply and a less frenzied market for the car.
• 📉 The increased production and availability of the 718 GT4 resulted in a more stable resale market compared to the original GT4, where prices were inflated due to scarcity.
• 🚦 The car's gearing is long, which allows for high-speed cruising but limits the engine's high-rev experience on public roads.
• 🤔 The script suggests that the 718 GT4 was mismanaged in terms of customer expectations and dealer practices, leading to a loss of potential customers who sought alternatives.
• 👍 Despite the controversy and market dynamics, the 718 GT4 is praised as a fundamentally brilliant car that offers a great driving experience and is worth considering for driving enthusiasts.

Q & A

What was the significance of the original 981 generation Porsche Cayman GT4?

The original 981 generation Porsche Cayman GT4 was significant because it was the first time Porsche built a Cayman to its full potential, which was something enthusiasts had been wanting for a long time.

Why did the 718 Cayman GT4 initially feel somewhat forgotten after its launch?

The 718 Cayman GT4 initially felt somewhat forgotten because a few things happened that overshadowed its release, and it was shortly discontinued, leading to a perception that it was already outdated.

What were the key differences between the 981 and 718 Cayman GT4 models?

The key differences included the engine change from a naturally aspirated Flat 6 to a turbocharged four-cylinder engine in the 718, and the introduction of a new 4.0L engine in the 718 GT4 that was a heavy reworking of the 3.0L twin-turbo engine found in other Porsche models.

Why did the first generation Cayman GT4 become a sought-after car?

The first generation Cayman GT4 became sought-after because it was relatively limited in production, leading to high demand and people paying over the list price for it.

How did the Porsche dealers contribute to the mismanagement of customer expectations for the 718 GT4?

Porsche dealers contributed to the mismanagement of customer expectations by not being transparent about the production numbers of the 718 GT4, leading to speculation and inflated prices, which later normalized as the car's availability became clear.

What is the narrator's opinion on the 718 Cayman GT4's performance and driving experience?

The narrator believes the 718 Cayman GT4 is fundamentally brilliant, offering a great driving experience with a powerful engine, good looks, and excellent handling, making it a satisfying car even for the most discerning petrol heads.

Why did the Porsche Cayman GT4's price stability not meet initial expectations?

The price stability of the Porsche Cayman GT4 did not meet initial expectations because of the dealers' practices of preferential treatment and speculation, which led to inflated prices that later normalized as the car's true availability became apparent.

What alternative cars does the narrator suggest to the owner of the 718 GT4 who is considering a change?

The narrator suggests considering an older first-generation Audi R8 V10 as an alternative to the 718 GT4 for its supercar status and mighty engine, acknowledging the owner's preference for special and interesting cars.

How does the 718 GT4 compare to its predecessors in terms of steering and engine?

While the 718 GT4 does not match the Lotus in terms of steering precision or the old GT3s in terms of engine character, it offers more than enough in every department to satisfy, with a communicative chassis and a strong, responsive engine.

What is the narrator's view on the practicality and packaging of the 718 GT4?

The narrator views the 718 GT4 as practical and well-packaged, with a good boot space, visibility, and a comfortable interior, making it an excellent road car.