Energy crisis: what can 1973 teach us?

Summary

The video explores how energy has become a powerful weapon in global conflicts, drawing parallels between Russia's invasion of Ukraine and the 1973 Arab-Israeli War. It highlights the severe impacts of energy dependency, with Russia using its gas supplies to Europe as leverage, leading to soaring energy costs and economic crises. The video also emphasizes the urgent need for diversifying energy sources and accelerating the transition away from fossil fuels to ensure energy security and address the growing threat of climate change.

Takeaways

• 😟 Russia's invasion of Ukraine has resulted in over 100,000 deaths and millions displaced, with significant global consequences.
• ⚡ The war has triggered a severe energy crisis, with electricity prices soaring and parts of Europe facing blackouts.
• 🌍 Historical parallels are drawn with the 1973 Arab-Israeli War, where energy was used as a weapon, leading to a global energy crisis.
• 💡 The 1973 oil embargo failed to achieve its political goals but caused severe economic damage, including high unemployment and inflation.
• 🇷🇺 Russia has weaponized its gas supplies, pushing Europe towards a recession by cutting off energy, similar to the tactics used in 1973.
• 🇪🇺 Europe’s reliance on Russian gas has made it vulnerable, with only a few countries like the UK and Lithuania having completely stopped imports.
• 💸 Europe’s switch to alternative energy sources has inadvertently driven up global prices, making energy unaffordable for poorer nations.
• 🔄 The 1973 oil crisis spurred shifts in energy policies, such as the U.S. aiming for energy self-sufficiency and increased use of coal and nuclear power.
• 🌱 Despite current investments in renewable energy, the world remains heavily dependent on fossil fuels, with the ongoing energy transition facing significant challenges.
• ⏳ The urgency of the climate crisis today adds pressure to accelerate the energy transition, but short-term measures to cope with the current energy crisis could slow progress.

Q & A

What is the central theme of the video script?

The central theme of the video script is the use of energy as a weapon, particularly in the context of Russia's invasion of Ukraine and how this mirrors past energy crises, such as the 1973 Arab-Israeli War's oil embargo.

How has Russia's invasion of Ukraine affected global energy markets?

Russia's invasion of Ukraine has led to soaring electricity bills, energy shortages in parts of Europe, and a significant energy crisis as Russia choked off gas supplies to Europe in response to Western sanctions.

What historical event does the script compare the current energy crisis to?

The script compares the current energy crisis to the 1973 Arab-Israeli War's oil embargo, where the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) imposed an oil boycott that led to global economic turmoil.

What lessons from the 1973 oil embargo are relevant to today's energy crisis?

The lessons include the dangers of dependency on a single energy supplier, the importance of diversifying energy sources, and the realization that embargoes may not achieve their intended political goals.

How did the 1973 oil embargo impact the U.S. economy?

The 1973 oil embargo exacerbated inflation, triggered a severe economic crisis, and highlighted the U.S.'s dependency on foreign oil, leading to increased domestic energy production and a shift towards energy self-sufficiency.

What is the significance of the statement that 'oil is a fungible global commodity' in the context of the embargo?

The statement highlights that even during the embargo, oil continued to flow to the U.S. and other nations through alternative routes at higher prices, emphasizing the global interconnectedness of energy markets.

How has Russia managed to continue profiting from oil despite sanctions?

Russia has continued to profit from oil by redirecting supplies through countries like India, where it is refined and sold at higher prices, demonstrating the resilience of global energy trade.

What impact has Europe's search for alternative energy sources had on global markets?

Europe's search for alternative energy sources, particularly LNG, has led to higher global prices, pricing out poorer countries like Bangladesh and Pakistan, and creating a disparity in energy access.

What are the potential long-term risks associated with the current energy crisis?

The potential long-term risks include slowing down the transition to renewable energy due to short-term measures like increased coal use, and a potential setback in efforts to combat climate change.

How does the script suggest the current energy crisis could impact the global energy transition?

The script suggests that while the current energy crisis could slow down the energy transition in the short term, it also serves as a reminder of the urgent need to diversify away from fossil fuels for both energy security and climate reasons.

Outlines

00:00

⚔️ Putin's Energy War: Beyond Rockets and Bombs

The Russian invasion of Ukraine, led by President Vladimir Putin, has resulted in massive casualties and displacement. However, this conflict extends beyond military attacks—it is also an energy war. Russia's actions have caused electricity shortages in Ukraine and high energy costs across Europe. This energy crisis is reminiscent of past events, such as the Arab-Israeli War of 1973, which triggered an oil embargo by OPEC and led to severe economic consequences. Today, Russia is using its control over gas supplies as a weapon, threatening to push Europe into recession and repeating history by leveraging energy as a means of political pressure.

05:00

🛢️ Lessons from the 1973 Oil Embargo: Will History Repeat?

In response to Western sanctions following its invasion of Ukraine, Russia has reduced gas supplies to Europe, causing an energy crisis reminiscent of the 1973 oil embargo, when Arab nations stopped selling oil to Western countries supporting Israel. The embargo initially caused economic hardship but ultimately failed to achieve its political goals, as oil remained available through other markets at higher prices. The current situation shows similar patterns, with Europe still obtaining Russian oil indirectly. This highlights the importance of supply diversification and reducing dependency on single energy sources.

10:01

🌍 Energy Crisis and Market Shifts: The Need for Diversification

Europe's ongoing energy crisis, exacerbated by Russia's reduction of natural gas supplies, has led to the search for alternative energy sources, particularly LNG (Liquefied Natural Gas). However, this has created unintended consequences, such as Western nations outbidding poorer countries for energy resources, highlighting the global inequality in energy access. The 1973 oil embargo taught the world about the dangers of reliance on single suppliers, prompting some nations, like the U.S., to focus on domestic energy production. However, Europe remained heavily dependent on Russian energy, which has now backfired amid geopolitical tensions.

🚢 The Push for Energy Security Amidst Global Crisis

Europe's shift from Russian gas to alternative energy sources, such as LNG, has raised concerns about unintended impacts on less affluent countries. Western nations have increased their energy security by paying premiums for energy supplies, while developing countries struggle to afford the rising costs. The 1973 oil crisis showed the necessity of diversifying energy sources and investing in new technologies, but the world has not fully applied these lessons. Today, the urgency to move away from fossil fuels is compounded by the threat of climate change, requiring accelerated action and innovation in renewable energy.

Keywords

💡Energy War

The term 'Energy War' refers to the strategic use of energy resources, such as oil and gas, as a tool of geopolitical influence or conflict. In the context of the video, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine is framed as not only a military conflict but also an 'Energy War' where Russia leverages its control of energy supplies to Europe as a weapon to exert economic pressure, reminiscent of historical energy crises like the 1973 oil embargo.

💡1973 Oil Embargo

The 1973 Oil Embargo was an event where Arab members of OPEC stopped selling oil to the U.S. and other Western nations to protest their support for Israel during the Arab-Israeli war. This resulted in a global energy shock, causing economic recession and inflation. The video draws parallels between the 1973 embargo and Russia’s current use of energy as a weapon, highlighting how energy crises have historically shaped global politics.

💡OPEC

OPEC, or the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries, is a group of oil-producing nations that collaborate to regulate oil production and prices. In the 1973 crisis, OPEC, led by its Arab members, imposed an oil embargo on the U.S. The video uses OPEC as an example of how control over energy resources has been wielded in geopolitics, comparing it to Russia’s manipulation of its natural gas supplies.

💡Natural Gas

Natural gas is a crucial energy resource that Russia used as a tool in its conflict with Europe during the Ukraine invasion. By throttling the supply of natural gas, Russia created an energy crisis across Europe, driving prices up and forcing countries to seek alternative energy sources. The video contrasts this situation with the oil-focused crisis of the 1970s, showing how natural gas has become a critical factor in today’s energy landscape.

💡Energy Security

Energy security refers to a country's ability to secure a stable and affordable supply of energy without relying too heavily on foreign sources. The video emphasizes how the U.S. and Europe have learned hard lessons about energy security from the 1973 oil crisis and the current conflict with Russia, showing the risks of over-reliance on single suppliers, such as Europe’s past dependence on Russian gas.

💡Energy Transition

Energy transition describes the shift from fossil fuels, like oil and natural gas, to renewable and cleaner energy sources, such as wind, solar, and nuclear power. The video highlights the urgency of this transition due to both the energy crisis and climate change, suggesting that the world needs to accelerate its move away from fossil fuels to avoid future vulnerabilities and environmental disasters.

💡Inflation

Inflation is the rise in prices of goods and services, reducing the purchasing power of money. In the 1973 oil crisis, inflation was exacerbated by soaring energy prices, leading to a global recession. The video compares this to today’s energy crisis, where rising oil and gas prices have similarly contributed to inflation, placing additional economic pressure on both consumers and governments.

💡Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG)

Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) is natural gas that has been cooled to liquid form for ease of storage and transport. The video explains how Europe has turned to LNG imports as a way to reduce its dependency on Russian gas. However, this shift has had unintended consequences, such as pricing poorer nations out of the LNG market as Europe pays premium prices to secure its energy supplies.

💡Fossil Fuels

Fossil fuels, such as oil, coal, and natural gas, are energy sources formed from the remains of ancient organisms. The video discusses how the global economy's reliance on fossil fuels has made it vulnerable to geopolitical disruptions, like the 1973 oil embargo and Russia’s current manipulation of energy supplies. It also highlights the ongoing challenge of reducing dependence on these resources in the face of climate change.

💡Energy Crisis

An energy crisis occurs when a significant disruption in the supply of energy resources causes price spikes, shortages, or other economic instability. The video details the current energy crisis caused by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the subsequent sanctions, comparing it to the 1973 oil crisis. It underscores how such crises can have widespread economic and political ramifications, influencing global markets and policy decisions.

Highlights

Russia's invasion of Ukraine has caused over 100,000 deaths and displaced millions of people.

Beyond the battlefield, Russia is also waging an energy war, causing electricity bills to soar across Europe.

The Arab-Israeli War of 1973 triggered an energy crisis when OPEC imposed an oil embargo, raising prices by over 300% in one year.

Russia responded to Western sanctions by cutting off gas supplies to Europe, threatening to push the continent into recession.

The 1973 oil embargo demonstrated the geopolitical power of energy dependence, showing the risks of relying on a single supplier.

During the 1973 oil crisis, American oil imports from OPEC fell by nearly half, leading to economic downturns globally.

Oil is a fungible commodity, meaning that even during embargoes, it finds its way to markets at higher prices through middlemen.

Russia is currently making more money from oil than before the Ukraine invasion, partly due to the redirected sales through countries like India.

Europe is still heavily dependent on Russian energy, despite attempts to diversify supplies during the Ukraine crisis.

The energy crisis has exposed the vulnerability of countries that rely too much on single sources of energy.

The 1973 oil shock led the U.S. to prioritize energy self-sufficiency and diversify its energy sources.

The ongoing energy crisis could potentially slow down the global transition away from fossil fuels due to immediate needs to stabilize energy supply.

The current energy crisis is more globalized than the 1970s crisis, with interconnected markets transmitting shocks worldwide.

There is a renewed urgency to accelerate the transition to renewable energy due to the dual threats of energy security and climate change.

The reliance on fossil fuels comes with significant geopolitical and environmental costs, emphasizing the need for diversified and sustainable energy sources.

Transcripts

it was unprovoked but this is what

Russian President Vladimir Putin

Unleashed on Ukraine

Russia's invasion of Ukraine has left

over 100 000 dead and millions of people

displaced

but Vladimir Putin's War goes far beyond

rockets and bombs

this war is also an energy War

electricity bills are soaring work is

continuing in Ukraine to restore

electricity parts of Europe are going

dark that has resulted in really bad

disaster we're at a moment in history

now where energy has become a weapon

but we've been here before

[Music]

The arab-israeli War of 1973 sent an

energy shock reverberating around the

globe the organization of petroleum

exporting countries imposed its boycott

and within a year raise prices more than

300 at the height of the Embargo half a

million people were thrown out of work

so what lessons can we learn from an

energy crisis 50 years ago

foreign

Russian troops invaded Ukraine in

February 2022 the West imposed sanctions

Russia responded by choking off its gas

supplies to Europe Russia could

single-handedly push Europe into

recession Vladimir Putin is holding the

trump card Europe is facing a worsting

energy crisis ahead of winter

but holding energy to Ransom isn't a new

trick in 1973 the Arab members of the

organization of petroleum exporting

countries or OPEC stopped selling oil to

America and other Western nations in a

bid to stop them supporting Israel in

the arab-israeli war the Embargo caused

immediate economic pain around the world

but it didn't have the impact OPEC was

looking for the lessons from the 1970s

oil shocks such as the oil embargo uh in

the early part of the 1970s is that they

don't work

by the early 70s 83 percent of America's

oil imports came from the Middle East

creating an unhealthy dependency

security is part of the energy policy

for any country in the world but before

1973 the U.S didn't seem to be very much

preoccupied by this particular part of

the energy policy nobody was so much

thinking about the potential negative

outcomes of these import dependency when

war broke out news headlines were

dominated by the Arab oil producers

attempts to use this dependency to force

a change in America's foreign policy

they will reduce oil production by five

percent a month until the Israelis

withdraw from occupied territories

for Western governments it was a

potentially devastating blow energy

Economist Philip ferlegger worked as a

consultant during the crisis and advised

numerous administrations the Embargo

occurred at a point where the economy

was already Fragile the country was

confronting uh serious inflation the

Arab embargo in 1973 then

exacerbated the inflationary impact and

tipped everything into a serious

economic crisis

energy had become a weapon

the world economy was utterly reliant on

oil in the 1970s we were at a moment of

inflection when the Middle Eastern

producers were ready to seize power in a

sense over the oil markets back from the

West particularly the United States

up until the 1950s America had been

self-sufficient in energy production and

while it remained a big oil producer as

the century progressed it simply didn't

make enough for its own needs the

balance of power in global oil markets

had shifted and America's Reliance on

imports from the Middle East meant its

economy paid the price

the U.S economy was facing tremendous

difficulties there was deficit of oil

and oil products so there was also a

deficit of gas the resource-rich

countries they suddenly realized that

they can affect the situation by

restricting oil supplies 1973 dramatized

U.S dependence on foreign oil

during the Embargo American oil imports

from OPEC fell by nearly half over the

next few years the price quadrupled

the impact of the embroidery from the

higher oil prices was felt Global by the

end of 1974 we were in a pretty severe

recession

but despite the bleak

a crisis

MIT was quoted in The Economist at the

time saying that if the Arabs don't sell

a soil somebody else will

Adeline was right America might have

paid more but the oil still flowed

the Arab refused to sell oil to a

handful of countries like the United

States for their support of Israel but

they continued to sell oil to other

countries and so once the oil made its

way to Marketplace those cargos were

redirected at a higher price with

middlemen profiting along the way to the

markets that needed that oil

prices went up

but the United States did get the oil it

needed just five months in OPEC lifted

its embargo without the US changing its

stance on the conflict or running out of

oil and the reason is oil is a fungible

global commodity every barrel of oil is

connected with every other barrel of oil

even though there's some minor

differences in grade and refining

qualities basically oil will get to

Market as long as there's demand

50 years old the West is learning the

same thing again

despite attempting to switch energy

supplies Europe is still getting oiled

for Russia only via India where it's

refined from crude and sold at a higher

price Russia is actually making more

money from oil today than it was before

the war hi

I'm Christian on The Economist European

economics editor we've written a lot

about the energy crisis over the past

few months and how it may affect the

world if you'd like to know more click

the link

foreign Russia is now making more money

from oil highlights another lesson the

world has failed to learn from the oil

crisis of the 17th

diversity of supplies being overly

reliant on a single supplier the way

that Germany relied on Russia for 55 of

its natural gas a couple of years ago

that is a a short ticket to lack of

security so diversify your suppliers

the oil shock of 1973 spurred a change

in the way the U.S government in

particular viewed energy security

let this be our national goal

at the end of this decade in the Year

1980

the United States will not be dependent

on any other country for the energy we

need

America began to increase domestic oil

production and started down the long

road back to energy self-sufficiency but

Europe didn't follow suit

in 2021 a quarter of all its energy came

from Russia leaving the continent badly

dependent on a hostile State the energy

shock that we're living through now

really began with natural gas in the

run-up to and during the Ukraine war

Russia squeezed Europe very badly

cutting off most of its supplies via

pipeline to Europe of natural gas in

2021 the EU imported approximately 83

percent of its natural gas around 45 of

which came from Russia as Russia

throttles Europe's gas supplies in

retaliation to sanctions supply

shortages sent prices skyrocketing

around the globe and as Vladimir Putin

threatens to cut oil production in

response to Western embargoes and price

caps there are fears the price of oil

could also get out of control now

there's some obvious similarities

between the oil shocks of the 1970s and

the energy crisis we're going through

today gasoline prices are high oil

supplies are tight and

presidents and prime ministers in the

west are under pressure to curb

inflation the scourge of the age once

again but Today's Energy Market is a

very different beast from 50 years ago

because we're hyper connected now

globally that means that shocks in one

place are transmitted much more

throughout the world that means that

we're more likely to see a globalized

shock in the crisis of the 70s gas was a

useful alternative to oil this time

around it's part of the problem

Russia exercised natural gas as a weapon

against Europe by choking supplies and

is threatening to do the same with oil

despite the recent drops in wholesale

prices consumer European gas costs

surged to unprecedented levels in 2022

177 percent higher than they were just

two years ago

Europe is trying to reduce its Reliance

on Russian gas but only two countries

have completely halted Imports Britain

which gets most of its gas from Norway

and Lithuania which has replaced its

Russian gas with supplies from America

but Russian gas is still finding its way

to Europe

for some years Europe will still

continue to use some Russian gas but the

bigger share of Europe's gas

increasingly will come from Imports by

sea that is LNG liquefied natural gas

where that natural gas is Frozen at

source and put on a special ship and and

said to be re-gassified on European

Shores but the West search for

alternative energy suppliers has had

unintended consequences one of the

tensions has been exposed by the energy

crisis of 2022 is the hypocrisy of

Europe basically gobbling up the world's

LNG paying heavy premiums to make sure

its own markets were well supplied

Western countries with Deep Pockets are

outbidding poorer ones for fuel

countries like Bangladesh Thailand and

Pakistan have been priced out of the

global LNG Market cutting them off from

the energy they need and more

importantly the global South stands to

suffer disproportionately if the West

ignores another lesson

the 1973 Oil Embargo not only showed

America the risks of relying on imported

oil but also the need to invest in other

sources of energy one of the outcomes of

that was a massive switch to color other

countries followed suit I think the

Germans would not and and the Polish and

other countries in Europe would have not

used as much coal had this policy not

happen the French on the other hand

moved rapidly ahead with nuclear power

you saw the beginning of solar power

across the world

for a few years it looked like the world

might be at the start of an energy

transition it triggered some things that

were positive that is a move towards

conservation for example fuel economy

standards for cars in America and some

other policies that did have positive

effect you might think a rise in Energy

prices would encourage a shift away from

fossil fuels but the oil shock of the

70s demonstrates it's not quite that

simple despite investing in Research

into renewable energies it was more

profitable to develop technologies that

made more efficient use of oil rather

than replace it altogether

today however the stakes are much higher

today the situation is much more

urgent than it was in 1970s we have the

climate threat the urgency of action

which the world has to make immediately

the current transition from

fundamentally fossil fuel based energy

towards something that comes after

decarbonized energy would take decades

and decades but we don't have that time

so it's the first time in human history

because of climate change we are

accelerating that pace dramatically

trying to do it in a decade or two

and that is unprecedented

[Music]

but the bigger Point here especially as

we think about climate change and

dealing with the energy transition is

diversify off of fossil fuels and find

Alternatives in power generation it can

be a new generation of nuclear wind

solar geothermal but as winter

approached and it looked like the energy

crisis could cause tens of thousands of

extra deaths across Europe and possibly

more in 2024 governments were forced to

look at Immediate Solutions there is a

risk that the short-term measures taken

by governments to cope with the energy

shock

like relying more on coal in the short

term in Europe to keep the lights on or

that kind of price subsidies that have

been offered in a number of countries

that actually end up encouraging more

energy use I think there is a risk that

this will slow down the energy

transition and could even lead us to go

sideways or backwards for some years

that is the great danger even with the

added threat of environmental

catastrophes there is a risk the lessons

of History will go unheeded the world

has learned some lessons from the

Embargo of 1973 but at the same time the

depth of this understanding wasn't

sufficient today we do not have time to

waste but despite the world's failure to

fully acknowledge the existential threat

there remains hope the gift we can take

from Russia's use of energy as an oil

weapon is that it seems to have reminded

the world which is getting very

complacent about the energy transition

that it's not just about climate it's

also about energy security and

affordability that our addiction to

fossil fuels comes with a very heavy

price

I'm Vijay Vegas Warren I'm the global

energy and climate Innovation editor of

The Economist

to see more of our coverage of

geopolitics and energy please click the

link and don't forget to subscribe