Editorial With Sujit Nair | Mistakes BJP Made In Maharashtra | NDA | Mahayuti

HW News English
31 Aug 202425:25

Summary

TLDRIn this editorial, the focus is on the political landscape of Maharashtra, India, highlighting the Bharatiya Janata Party's (BJP) strategic errors from 2014 to 2024. The video discusses how the BJP's overconfidence, perceived arrogance, and the controversial split of the Shiv Sena party led to a significant decline in their popularity and electoral success. It also touches on the role of Sharad Pawar and the potential for further political realignments before the upcoming assembly elections. The narrative promises to delve deeper into these dynamics and their implications in a subsequent episode.

Takeaways

  • 📈 The editorial discusses the significant mistakes made by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in Maharashtra, which could impact their future election outcomes.
  • 🤝 The BJP's partnership with the Shiv Sena, traditionally the dominant party in Maharashtra, started deteriorating after the 2014 elections.
  • 💼 Devendra Fadnavis emerged as a strong BJP leader in Maharashtra, becoming the Chief Minister and leading the party from 2014 to 2019.
  • 🚫 In 2019, overconfidence and perceived arrogance from Fadnavis and other BJP leaders led to a decline in their popularity among Maharashtra voters.
  • 📉 The BJP's decision to break the Shiv Sena by supporting Eknath Shinde's faction was a critical mistake that led to a significant loss of public support.
  • 👎 Maharashtra voters were displeased with the BJP's role in splitting the Shiv Sena, which they viewed as a betrayal of democratic principles.
  • 🗳️ The BJP's alliance with figures from the Nationalist Congress Party (NCP), who were previously labeled as corrupt, further damaged their image in Maharashtra.
  • 💥 The editorial suggests that the BJP's missteps, including the splitting of the Shiv Sena, contributed to their poor performance in the 2024 Lok Sabha elections.
  • 🔍 The discussion also highlights how Sharad Pawar of the NCP may have benefited strategically from the political turmoil and splits within the BJP and its allies.
  • 🔮 The editorial ends by questioning whether the BJP-NCP-Shiv Sena alliance will remain intact before the upcoming assembly elections, hinting at potential further splits.

Q & A

  • What was the main issue with the BJP's strategy in Maharashtra leading up to the 2014 elections?

    -The main issue was the BJP's overconfidence and arrogance, exemplified by Devendra Fadnavis's premature declaration of victory and the party's perceived disregard for its traditional ally, Shiv Sena, which led to a shift in their alliance dynamics.

  • How did the 2014 Assembly Election results impact the relationship between BJP and Shiv Sena in Maharashtra?

    -The 2014 Assembly Election results, where BJP won 122 seats and Shiv Sena won 63, led to a shift in power dynamics. BJP, riding on the Narendra Modi wave, began to challenge Shiv Sena's dominance, leading to tensions and a change in their traditionally cooperative relationship.

  • What was the role of Devendra Fadnavis in the BJP's governance in Maharashtra from 2014 to 2019?

    -Devendra Fadnavis played a pivotal role as the Chief Minister of Maharashtra from 2014 to 2019. He was seen as a powerful leader with full autonomy from the central BJP leadership, focusing on growth and development rather than communal issues.

  • What were the key mistakes made by the BJP that contributed to their decline in Maharashtra?

    -The key mistakes included overconfidence leading up to the 2019 elections, mishandling of the 2019 floods, and the perception of arrogance. Additionally, the party's decision to split from Shiv Sena and form a government with NCP members in 2022 was seen negatively by the public.

  • How did the public's perception of BJP change after the 2022 political developments in Maharashtra?

    -The public's perception of BJP turned negative, especially after the party's involvement in splitting Shiv Sena and forming a government with NCP members, which was seen as a betrayal of democracy and a mockery of the people's mandate.

  • What was the impact of the 2024 Lok Sabha election results on BJP's standing in Maharashtra?

    -The 2024 Lok Sabha election results were disastrous for BJP in Maharashtra, where they won only nine seats, a significant drop from their previous victories. This was largely due to the public's anger towards the party's political maneuvers and perceived arrogance.

  • What is the historical significance of Maharashtra in Indian politics as mentioned in the script?

    -Maharashtra is historically significant as the cradle of Indian politics, having produced key figures like Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar, Gopal Krishna Gokhale, and L. Manas, who laid the foundation for democracy in India. The state takes its democratic values seriously and was deeply affected by the perceived undermining of these values by political parties.

  • How did the split within Shiv Sena and the formation of a new party impact Maharashtra's political landscape?

    -The split within Shiv Sena and the formation of a new party led by Eknath Shinde, who joined hands with BJP, created a significant shift in Maharashtra's political landscape. This move was met with public disapproval and is believed to have contributed to BJP's poor performance in the 2024 elections.

  • What is the significance of the 'laughing' incident involving the Chief Minister and Devendra Fadnavis in Maharashtra politics?

    -The 'laughing' incident, where the Chief Minister and Devendra Fadnavis were seen mocking the split in Shiv Sena, became a symbol of disrespect for democracy and the voters. This incident significantly damaged the image of both BJP and Devendra Fadnavis in the eyes of the public.

  • What are the potential implications of the political developments in Maharashtra for the upcoming Assembly elections?

    -The political developments, including the split in Shiv Sena and the public's negative perception of BJP, could lead to a significant shift in the upcoming Assembly elections. There is speculation about potential further splits or realignments within the political parties before the elections, which could reshape the political landscape of Maharashtra.

Outlines

00:00

📜 Introduction to Maharashtra Politics

The video script begins with an introduction to an editorial discussing the political landscape of Maharashtra, India. The speaker promises a detailed analysis of the mistakes made by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in the state, which allegedly cost them the Lok Sabha elections and could potentially affect the assembly elections. The editorial is set to be a comprehensive guide to Maharashtra politics, covering the period from 2014 to 2024, and is divided into two parts. The first part focuses on the BJP's mistakes, while the second part will discuss the role of Sharad Pawar and the possibility of a split in the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) in Maharashtra.

05:02

🔍 The Shift in BJP's Strategy and its Consequences

The second paragraph delves into the political strategy of the BJP under the leadership of Devendra Fadnavis during the 2014 Maharashtra Assembly elections. It discusses how the party decided to challenge the long-standing dominance of Shiv Sena and contest the majority of the seats independently. This move led to a split in their alliance, with Shiv Sena aligning with the BJP post-elections to form a government, where Shiv Sena played a junior role. The paragraph also highlights how Fadnavis's leadership was instrumental in the BJP's rise in Maharashtra, with the party focusing on growth and development rather than communalism.

10:02

🌪 The Downfall of BJP in Maharashtra

The third paragraph outlines the factors that contributed to the BJP's decline in Maharashtra. It starts with the overconfidence displayed by Fadnavis before the 2019 elections, which was perceived negatively by the public. Additionally, the paragraph discusses the impact of the floods in the state and the party's perceived arrogance, leading to a shift in public perception. The narrative continues with the BJP's victory in the 2019 Lok Sabha elections and the subsequent assembly elections, where despite winning a significant number of seats, the party's image began to suffer due to internal conflicts and strategic missteps.

15:03

🏆 The Rise of Uddhav Thackeray and BJP's Mistakes

This paragraph highlights the rise of Uddhav Thackeray as a popular leader during his tenure as Chief Minister, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. It contrasts this with the BJP's strategic errors, including the decision to split the Shiv Sena party, which led to a significant backlash from the public. The paragraph discusses how the BJP's actions, particularly the visual of their leaders laughing about the split, damaged their image and support base in Maharashtra. It also sets the stage for the discussion in the next episode about the BJP's further mistakes and the potential for a split in the NDA before the upcoming assembly elections.

20:04

🏛 The Impact of Democracy and Corruption on BJP's Fortunes

The fifth paragraph provides a deeper understanding of Maharashtra's political culture and its aversion to perceived undermining of democratic principles. It discusses how the BJP's actions, including the split of Shiv Sena and the alliance with NCP despite past corruption allegations, affected their public image. The paragraph also touches on the broader implications of these actions on the BJP's performance in the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, suggesting that the party's fortunes were significantly impacted by their handling of political alliances and the public's perception of their integrity.

25:04

📲 Closing Remarks and Preview of Next Episode

The final paragraph serves as a conclusion to the current episode and a preview for the next. It summarizes the key points discussed so far, including the BJP's strategic missteps and their impact on the party's political standing in Maharashtra. The speaker also teases the upcoming discussion about Sharad Pawar's role and the potential for further splits in the political alliances before the assembly elections. The paragraph ends with a call to action for viewers to download a news app for a smarter and faster news experience.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Maharashtra Politics

Maharashtra Politics refers to the political activities, parties, and governance within the Indian state of Maharashtra. The video discusses the dynamics between various political parties such as the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), Shiv Sena, Nationalist Congress Party (NCP), and Indian National Congress. The script highlights how these parties have interacted and influenced state politics, particularly in the context of elections and alliances.

💡BJP

The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) is one of the major political parties in India. In the video, it is discussed as a key player in Maharashtra's politics, having significant influence and power. The script mentions the BJP's rise and fall in terms of popularity and election outcomes, emphasizing the party's strategies and mistakes, such as overconfidence and perceived arrogance, which impacted its performance in the state.

💡Shiv Sena

Shiv Sena is a regional political party based in Maharashtra, known for its strong regionalist stance. The video script describes the party's relationship with the BJP, their alliance, and subsequent split. It discusses how Shiv Sena's decisions, such as breaking away from the BJP to form a government with NCP and Congress, shaped the political landscape of Maharashtra.

💡NCP

The Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) is a center-left political party in India, which is significant in Maharashtra's politics. The script mentions NCP's role in forming alliances and governments in the state, particularly in coalitions with the Congress party and later with Shiv Sena after the split with BJP. The NCP's image and actions are discussed in the context of corruption allegations and their impact on public perception.

💡Alliance Split

An alliance split refers to the dissolution of a political partnership between parties. In the video, the term is used to describe the breakup of the long-standing alliance between the BJP and Shiv Sena, which led to significant political realignments in Maharashtra. The script explores the consequences of this split, including the formation of new governments and the impact on voter sentiment.

💡Lok Sabha Elections

Lok Sabha Elections are the democratic elections held to constitute the lower house of India's Parliament. The video discusses the BJP's performance in the Lok Sabha elections of 2014, 2019, and 2024, highlighting how the party's strategies and the political climate in Maharashtra influenced its success or failure in these national elections.

💡Overconfidence

Overconfidence in the script refers to the attitude of political leaders or parties when they are excessively sure of their success without adequate justification. It is mentioned as one of the mistakes made by the BJP's leadership in Maharashtra, particularly in the context of the 2019 assembly elections, where the party's overconfidence may have contributed to a loss of voter support.

💡Chief Minister

The Chief Minister is the head of the government in each of India's states. The video script discusses various Chief Ministers of Maharashtra, including their popularity, governance, and the public's perception of their actions. It also touches upon how the role and decisions of the Chief Minister can significantly influence the political climate and election outcomes in the state.

💡Corruption

Corruption in the context of the video refers to the misuse of power for personal gain, particularly in politics. The script mentions corruption allegations against certain political figures and parties, such as the NCP, and how these allegations affected public trust and election results. It also discusses the BJP's association with figures perceived as corrupt and the implications for the party's image.

💡Public Perception

Public perception is the general view or opinion that the public has about a person, event, or situation. In the video, public perception is discussed as a critical factor in political success or failure, with examples such as the BJP's perceived arrogance and the impact of the Chief Minister's actions on how the party was viewed by the voters of Maharashtra.

💡Assembly Elections

Assembly Elections are held to form state legislative assemblies in India. The video script details the BJP's performance in Maharashtra's assembly elections, including the party's strategies, the number of seats won, and the impact of these outcomes on the state's political landscape. It also discusses the implications of these elections on the BJP's alliances and governance.

Highlights

Introduction to the editorial discussing the political landscape of Maharashtra and the BJP's mistakes.

Analysis of the BJP-Shiv Sena alliance and its impact on Maharashtra politics.

Discussion on the possibility of a split in the BJP-Shiv Sena alliance in Maharashtra.

Historical overview of Maharashtra politics from 2000 onwards, focusing on the dominance of Shiv Sena and BJP.

The rise of Narendra Modi and its influence on Maharashtra's political dynamics.

2014 Assembly Election results and the shift in power dynamics within the BJP and Shiv Sena.

Devendra Fadnavis's leadership and its effect on BJP's popularity in Maharashtra.

The 2019 Lok Sabha election results and the BJP's overwhelming victory.

The aftermath of the 2019 Assembly Elections and the formation of the Maha Vikas Aghadi government.

Uddhav Thackeray's popularity as Chief Minister and his handling of the COVID-19 pandemic.

The BJP's strategic error in splitting the Shiv Sena and its consequences.

The public's reaction to the perceived arrogance of the BJP and its impact on the 2024 Lok Sabha elections.

The role of regional issues like the Maratha agitation in influencing the political scenario.

The BJP's decline in the 2024 Lok Sabha elections and the factors contributing to it.

The public's perception of the BJP's actions as an insult to democracy and its electoral implications.

预告下一集内容:探讨Sharad Pawar的角色以及BJP是否能够从分裂他的党派中获益。

预告下一集内容:讨论在马哈拉施特拉邦议会选举前,NDA或Maha Vikas Aghadi是否会分裂。

Transcripts

play00:00

namaskar welcome to another episode of

play00:03

editorial today is a very longish

play00:06

editorial so bear with me but it's going

play00:08

to be interesting I promise you that's

play00:10

one number two is today I talk about um

play00:14

the mistakes btia Jan party made in

play00:18

Maharashtra the mistake that costed them

play00:20

Lok SAA and the mistake that could

play00:23

possibly also caus them assembly

play00:26

elections so that's what we are going to

play00:28

talk about we are also going to discuss

play00:32

whether is there a possibility of

play00:35

bhattia janata party and NCP Shi

play00:39

Alliance splitting in Maharashtra so

play00:43

it's a it's a longest topic it's a lot

play00:46

of stories it's a it's going to be a

play00:48

beginner's guide to Maharashtra politics

play00:51

we are going to go into depth about

play00:53

Maharashtra politics like I said going

play00:55

to be interesting but slightly longish

play00:57

so what we intend to do is we'll do it

play00:59

in two parts

play01:00

first part we will cover the mistakes

play01:03

committed by bhattia janata party in

play01:05

Maharashtra we will talk about the

play01:07

superar of bhara janata party and bhara

play01:11

janata party's image taking a nose Drive

play01:13

in Maharashtra and in the next episode

play01:16

we will talk

play01:18

about the role sharat Paar played the

play01:22

role sharat PA played and the advantage

play01:26

that sharat Paar got out of all of this

play01:29

that happened between 2014 and 2024

play01:33

that's what we'll talk about and then we

play01:35

will discuss whether is there a

play01:38

possibility of a split in mahui or NDA

play01:43

of Maharashtra that is BJP shiena and U

play01:46

NCP in Maharashtra is there a

play01:48

possibility of a split that's my

play01:51

editorial let's get right to the

play01:56

show let's start from the beginning

play01:58

let's understand what Maharashtra

play01:59

politics is was and could be all this we

play02:04

will talk today and then we will come to

play02:06

our question whether NDA or mahui as it

play02:10

is called in Maharashtra whether NDA

play02:13

will see a split before the assembly

play02:16

elections so let's start from the

play02:21

beginning you see first and foremost is

play02:24

Maharashtra there were two sets of

play02:26

parties one was the bhattia janata party

play02:31

and

play02:32

shivaa and in this bhartia janata party

play02:36

and Shiva yti or this this partnership

play02:39

shivaa was the dominant political party

play02:42

mind you when it came to Maharashtra on

play02:45

the other hand there was NCP nationalist

play02:48

congress party and Congress this is that

play02:52

is your Indian National Congress this

play02:55

was the second set and I'm talking about

play02:57

two 2000 onwards I'm not talking about

play03:00

old story I'm talking to you about 2004

play03:03

2009 onwards story so this is how

play03:08

Maharashtra looked one where shiena was

play03:11

dominant and sha btia janata party

play03:14

second where where

play03:17

Congress was kind of dominant but shat

play03:21

PA was equally dominant and you had the

play03:24

NCP Congress Yi so this was how

play03:27

Maharashtra looked this was true till

play03:31

2014 now starts the

play03:35

story in

play03:37

2014 bhattia janata party mind you

play03:40

before till then had no great face in

play03:43

Maharashtra they had promod Mahajan who

play03:46

passed away they had gopinath Mund who

play03:48

incidentally passed away in 2014 so

play03:51

there was no major uh major leaders BJP

play03:55

leaders in

play03:56

Maharashtra uh and shivaa also had lost

play04:01

balasai takre by then so it was udh

play04:03

takre who was now on the chair and that

play04:07

was how the situation was as far as BJP

play04:10

shiena is concerned and Congress

play04:13

Congress was battered battered in 2014

play04:17

was battered by Mr Anna aare who thought

play04:20

of anti-corruption and who wanted to

play04:22

fight anti-corruption all then and after

play04:24

that of course he forgot about it but

play04:26

then he was fighting anti-corruption and

play04:28

all and of course Mr Arin krial was with

play04:30

him and all of that was happening so

play04:32

Congress NCP was

play04:34

almost they almost knew that they are

play04:37

not going to come back and as far as BJP

play04:39

is concerned BJP was riding on the

play04:45

Narendra Modi

play04:47

wave now first thing that happened in

play04:50

2014 first thing that happened in 2014

play04:54

is a new

play04:56

leadership and under the leadership the

play04:59

new leader ship which was dendra Fat's

play05:01

leadership and under dendra Fat's

play05:04

leadership btia janata party started

play05:07

thinking why should we give shiena the

play05:10

Big Brother treatment balasai Tak is no

play05:13

more now the big draw is Mr Narendra

play05:17

Modi Narendra Modi is a BJP man why give

play05:20

too much impetus to shivaa so 2014

play05:25

Assembly

play05:27

Election Mr dendra

play05:32

told brother and brother that

play05:35

it now we will get the majority Stakes

play05:39

as far as uh assembly elections are

play05:41

concerned we will fight the majority

play05:43

seats you fight the minority seats sh

play05:46

said what is wrong with you how can that

play05:48

be we have always fought you know Lo SAA

play05:51

you got the majority Vian SAA we got the

play05:54

majority why why are you changing the

play05:56

games of the rules but said boss yeah is

play06:00

over so now what happened in 2014 BJP

play06:04

got 122 seats just almost 288 is the

play06:09

total strength and 145 is the magic

play06:12

number so so somewhere down the line BJP

play06:15

got 122 sha came up with 63 Inc Indian

play06:19

National Congress got 42 NCP got 41 so

play06:23

this was what the state is and mind you

play06:26

they were fighting separately now in the

play06:28

assembly elections UD Tak was not

play06:30

fighting with dendra patn then there was

play06:34

this whole Theory whether shiv will join

play06:37

shiv will not join shivana wants to join

play06:40

shiv doesn't want to join in the

play06:41

meantime BJP said you want to join or

play06:43

not I am going to start they went up

play06:46

they they took oath and dendra was made

play06:49

the first Chief Minister of bhattia

play06:51

janata party in Maharashtra after that

play06:54

shat PA who's always known to be

play06:57

absolutely uh brilliant in capitalizing

play07:00

on opportunities shat said problem we

play07:03

are supporting you unconditionally you

play07:06

take our support and you stand you run

play07:08

your party no problem we will

play07:09

unconditionally support you okay and

play07:14

uh sh till then was not very comfortable

play07:17

but take yes no yes no yes no finally

play07:21

compromise happened sha joined aligned

play07:23

with their 25y old partner that is bhara

play07:27

janata Party formed the government she

play07:29

was was the junior party very very

play07:31

Junior party with no major portfolios

play07:33

and all so Shiana was the junior party

play07:35

btia janata party ruled and all of a

play07:39

sudden dendra fnav became a huge leader

play07:45

first time such popular Dynamic powerful

play07:50

leader from bhartia janata party in

play07:52

Maharashtra that is dendra pavz now let

play07:55

me tell you something about dendra fnav

play07:57

regime from 2014 to 2019

play08:02

you see dendra fnav was one of the most

play08:05

powerful Chief ministers that

play08:07

Maharashtra actually ever saw because

play08:10

what used to happen is I'll tell you

play08:12

what used to happen is most of the

play08:13

Congress Chief

play08:15

ministers most of the Congress chief

play08:17

minister had their Central Command

play08:19

guiding them so a lot of decisions were

play08:23

made by the high command in Delhi for

play08:26

Maharashtra so the Maharashtra chief

play08:28

minister end of the day was reporting

play08:30

into high

play08:32

command as far as shivaa chief minister

play08:35

happened Naran R and Manor josi there to

play08:38

Bas Tak was controlling their decision

play08:40

and he openly said the remote control is

play08:42

with me but somehow Mr Narendra Modi had

play08:48

tremendous Trust on dendra fnav and one

play08:51

is told that dendra fnav had full

play08:54

freedom to go and do what he wants in

play08:57

Maharashtra and to a very major extent

play09:00

he did a good job from 2014 to

play09:04

2019 he was focused on growth he didn't

play09:08

divert too much in communalism and all

play09:10

of that he was focused on growth mind

play09:13

you I'm talking about 2014 to

play09:17

2019 now came

play09:21

2019

play09:23

and bhartia janata party started

play09:27

committing a few grave errors

play09:29

error number one

play09:37

[Applause]

play09:47

this the Arrogant overconfident dendra

play09:53

FZ went out and said

play09:56

me I will come back I will come back

play09:59

which which means he almost anticipated

play10:02

he almost concluded the result before

play10:05

the voters before the before the actual

play10:08

voting everything he concluded he said

play10:10

I'm coming back like it or not I'm

play10:12

coming back now this was clubbed with a

play10:16

lot of other things too this was clubbed

play10:19

with a few raids which happened to

play10:21

people like Hassan mush ironically asan

play10:24

mush currently is with bhartia janata

play10:26

party's NDA or whatever mauti and all

play10:29

that so a couple of raids and all of

play10:31

that that was one grave error because

play10:36

people in MRA started wondering

play10:41

thata but the chief minister is over

play10:44

confident that he will come back anyway

play10:47

T that was one point the second point

play10:49

was another Factor where there was

play10:52

floods in Maharashtra and the number two

play10:56

the person who was seen as number two of

play10:58

bhara

play11:00

this was a reaction from

play11:06

[Applause]

play11:20

him this was a reaction from him when uh

play11:23

farmer actually wanted to know more

play11:26

about what flood relief is that farmer

play11:28

going to get and the minister said wait

play11:32

there this actually these pictures these

play11:36

images started ping the Maharashtra

play11:41

bhara janata party as an arrogant party

play11:44

something similar to what happened in

play11:46

2024 with Bara janata party nationally

play11:49

people started perceiving Bara janata

play11:51

party to be an arrogant party this was

play11:54

the beginning of the fall of bhartia

play11:57

janata party in Mahar ra now to be fair

play12:01

to them bhartia janata party in loksabha

play12:05

sweeped loksabha in 200 19 BJP won 23

play12:09

seats in the loks SAA sha who was

play12:11

fighting with BJP won 18 Indian National

play12:14

Congress won NCP 4 so 41 out of 48 seats

play12:18

was with the bhartia janata party shivaa

play12:23

so they did well but when it came to

play12:27

assembly things were not very good but

play12:29

Bara janata party won 105 remember

play12:31

earlier on they had won 122 they won 105

play12:34

shiena of course the number of seats

play12:36

contested then was also more that two

play12:39

has to be taken into consideration sha

play12:41

won 56 Indian National Congress won 44

play12:45

and NCP W

play12:47

54 now this was the point in time where

play12:49

there was a lot of talks of NCP and uh

play12:52

and BJP coming together NCP trying to

play12:56

you know kind of wo BJP and uh try to

play12:58

make make a party try and throw out shua

play13:01

BJP seems to have said no we will not

play13:03

throw out sha and then you know finally

play13:06

the deal in workout and shua and BJP

play13:09

were together as it was NCP and Congress

play13:12

was together as it was and

play13:15

finally shivaa decided to take revenge

play13:21

Shiva decided to take revenge and after

play13:23

the election after the assembly election

play13:25

where shua and BJP fought together where

play13:28

technically they could have won won 161

play13:30

seats and I told you the magic number

play13:32

was 145 they won 161 seats and UD

play13:37

Tak post the poll said I don't want to

play13:42

be partners with you because you had

play13:43

told me that you will make me the chief

play13:45

minister which was always the deal

play13:47

because right from time in Memorial the

play13:49

assembly was ours and lo SAA was yours

play13:53

me assembly was sha and Loa was BJP now

play13:57

you changed you changed because that

play13:58

time helped you now I'm changing because

play14:00

that this time it is helping me I am not

play14:02

going to join with you I would rather go

play14:04

with Congress and NCP form something

play14:06

called as

play14:08

mahavi and form the government and

play14:11

actually that is what happened in

play14:14

2019 tables turned and mavas aari came

play14:18

into existence shivaa NCP and Congress

play14:22

came together and bhartia janata party

play14:25

who mind you had had had actually

play14:29

declined ncp's offer to come together

play14:32

because they thought that they should

play14:34

not ditch their old partner shiena they

play14:37

were all alone and these three people

play14:39

came together formed a government now

play14:43

things took a different turn from there

play14:46

udav takre was perceived to be a very

play14:48

popular chief minister people liked udav

play14:51

takre that was the time of covid and

play14:53

during covid UD takre would come in

play14:56

front of his people in Maharashtra and

play14:59

he would sit and talk to people in

play15:01

Maharashtra he was very transparent

play15:03

about whatever is happening in

play15:04

Maharashtra so people liked him whether

play15:07

his administration was good bad ugly and

play15:09

all is not what I'm trying to say I'm

play15:11

not judging anything I'm just telling

play15:13

you what happened lame man uh like I

play15:17

told you I going to tell you what

play15:18

exactly the story happened people

play15:20

started liking UD Tak TK but there was

play15:24

also a bunch of people who had

play15:26

tremendous amount of sympathy for Bara

play15:29

janata party tremendous amount of

play15:31

sympathy why because shaa had ditched

play15:34

Bara janata party and actually they had

play15:36

this split was after it was it was a

play15:39

pre-o Alliance but they split after the

play15:42

polls once they won the

play15:44

numbers so things were standing as is

play15:47

and

play15:48

then then the biggest mistake that BJP

play15:53

should have never done in Maharashtra

play15:56

happened look at this shot B CC

play16:13

[Applause]

play16:31

he shivaa was split Shiva was split akna

play16:35

shind was pulled out a lot of people who

play16:38

joined akna shind didn't from shivaa

play16:40

didn't join because they were in line

play16:42

with akna sh's ideology and all that

play16:44

they joined akna shind because they

play16:45

would be safe from Ed and it and and and

play16:48

that is why people joined people like

play16:50

pratab sik Etc joined them because it is

play16:54

a safe so they joined him and shivaa was

play16:59

split akna shind went and joined hands

play17:02

with bhartia janata party they formed

play17:06

the new government so the shivaa the

play17:09

actual name and style of shivaa was

play17:12

given nna shind now the election

play17:14

commission granted that and the Shiva

play17:17

bhartia janata party Alliance happened

play17:19

and they formed the government in

play17:22

2022 the reason I wanted you to see that

play17:24

picture

play17:26

wherein the chief minister the current

play17:28

chief minister was seen as laughing

play17:31

about how he managed to break shiena he

play17:34

managed to take almost 40 mlas with him

play17:37

from

play17:38

Shiva that picture was something that

play17:42

Maharashtra didn't expect and

play17:44

Maharashtra didn't accept either they

play17:47

didn't expect it they didn't accept it

play17:50

you see when I went around just before

play17:53

2024 elections I went around to vid to

play17:58

to West Mar asra and some parts of Conan

play18:02

to do my little research on what things

play18:04

are and how things are we realized that

play18:06

one of the things that came through very

play18:08

clearly is this particular shot every

play18:10

farmer every rural maharash especially

play18:14

that one spoke to remembered that shot

play18:18

where they were laughing in the assembly

play18:20

about how they split a political party

play18:23

which the people had

play18:25

elected somewhere down the line the

play18:28

people people believed that the joke was

play18:30

not on Shiva the joke was on the

play18:33

voter that one shot and dendra fnav seen

play18:39

as The Mastermind who was sitting next

play18:41

to him and made all this happen was not

play18:45

seen very fairly this man called dendra

play18:49

f whose popularity had shot up and he

play18:51

had actually become a very very popular

play18:54

leader in Maharashtra his popularity

play18:56

started nose diving this possibly was

play19:00

one of the biggest reasons why what

play19:03

happened in 2024 happened the the

play19:08

bhartia janata party that had won 23

play19:11

seats in 2014 Loa election the btia

play19:15

janata party that had won 23 seats in

play19:18

2019 elections Loa elections one that

play19:23

same Bara janata party won nine seats

play19:27

nine seats not even double nine seats in

play19:31

the Loa election in

play19:34

2024 btia janata party crashed bhartia

play19:39

janata party was destroyed and mind you

play19:42

in our qualitative research that we did

play19:45

people were not so much so anti-

play19:48

Narendra Modi or angry with Narendra

play19:50

Modi as much possibly they were angry

play19:53

with the Maharashtra bhartia janata

play19:56

party and especially Mr dendra f

play19:59

there was anger amongst people now to

play20:03

understand why exactly

play20:06

maharash refused btia janata party I

play20:11

need to take you through a small

play20:12

background of Maharashtra you see

play20:14

Maharashtra if you go to see is the

play20:17

Cradle of Indian politics mind you

play20:20

Maharashtra is a land that gave birth to

play20:24

people like Dr babasai edar to people

play20:28

like gopal Krishna go the political Guru

play20:30

of Mahatma Gandhi to people like L Mana

play20:35

tur these are people who laed the

play20:38

foundation of democracy in India

play20:41

Maharashtra doesn't take its democracy

play20:44

lightly and that same Maharashtra felt

play20:48

insulted when they saw these ministers

play20:52

the chief minister dendra fnav sitting

play20:54

there and laughing about how the Destro

play20:58

destroyed democracy in Maharashtra while

play21:01

to be very fair shivas too breached the

play21:05

tenants of democracy in Maharashtra sha

play21:08

to Bree the tenant when they jumped from

play21:11

a preo alliance with bhattia janata

play21:13

party and joined hands with Congress and

play21:15

NCP they did that but the point is the

play21:18

visual that went through the visual of

play21:21

the sitting chief minister mocking the

play21:24

split in the party and dendra fnav who

play21:28

was seen as The Mastermind this visual

play21:30

actually damaged dendra fnav and btia

play21:33

janata party more than anybody else the

play21:37

advantage that BJP could have got

play21:40

because of what Shi did to them in

play21:43

2019 by by breaching their pre-o

play21:45

Alliance the advantage and the sympathy

play21:48

that BJP could have got BJP lost it by

play21:51

breaking Shiva in 2022 2024 BJP had to

play21:56

pay the price possibly BJP would have

play21:59

done much better in 2024 had they gone

play22:03

alone than what they did by splitting

play22:07

Shiva and

play22:09

NCP adding to all of this Zang pel and

play22:14

marata arakan agitation took a huge toll

play22:18

on btia janata party's prospects in

play22:21

loksabha and finally bhartia janata

play22:25

party and their NDA or whatever Maui was

play22:30

had to face a very very humiliating

play22:32

defeat in the Lok SAA

play22:34

2024 you see another reason why people

play22:38

were not very very comfortable with BJP

play22:41

and people were not very happy with BJP

play22:43

is because after a few few days after

play22:46

the prime minister of India had said

play22:49

that the most corrupt party 75,000 cror

play22:51

of

play22:52

corruption

play22:55

NCP NCP

play23:04

[Music]

play23:06

State Cooperative Bank

play23:10

goala Maharashtra Cai gotala

play23:29

the party which has done is NCP they

play23:31

broke NCP bhia janata party managed to

play23:34

break NCP and take people like Ajit

play23:37

pawar take people like pul Patel who are

play23:40

allegedly seen as the most corrupt

play23:43

people in NCP all those most corrupt

play23:47

faces were taken into BJP or the BJP

play23:50

aligned with them we spoke about the

play23:52

mistakes that btia janata party made in

play23:55

2014 to 2019 and till 2022 the mistakes

play24:00

that Bara janata party made now tomorrow

play24:03

let us talk in our second episode about

play24:07

sharat Chandra Paar what happened when

play24:11

bhattia janata party tried

play24:15

to split or take advantage of sharat

play24:19

Chandra pawar did BJP manage to take

play24:22

advantage of sharat Chandra Paar by

play24:24

splitting his party or was sharat Paar

play24:27

trying to actually ensure he gets the

play24:31

benefit of his party being

play24:33

split this is what we'll discuss

play24:35

tomorrow we'll also discuss tomorrow

play24:38

whether before the assembly elections

play24:40

which they say could happen between any

play24:43

anytime between November and December

play24:45

before the assembly elections in

play24:47

Maharashtra will there be a split in NDA

play24:50

or mahui that is the BJP shivaa NCP

play24:55

combined will there be a split this is

play24:57

what we will talk in my tomorrow's

play24:59

episode so see you tomorrow at 10 p.m.

play25:04

namaskar stay ahead with our Cutting

play25:06

Edge news app instantly access the

play25:09

latest shorts in just 1 minute and

play25:11

breaking news in just 50 words download

play25:14

now for a smarter faster news experience

play25:22

[Music]

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Etiquetas Relacionadas
Maharashtra PoliticsBJP MistakesElection AnalysisPolitical AlliancesNDA SplitShiv SenaCongress PartyNCP CorruptionDemocracy DebateChief Minister
¿Necesitas un resumen en inglés?