Samsung OLED a JOKE in 2024? - S90D & Don’t Buy S95D

Summary

The video discusses a report from a South Korean newspaper suggesting Samsung may be mixing last-generation OLED panels with Quantum Dot OLED panels in their S9D TVs across various sizes. The speaker expresses disbelief and disapproval, comparing it to a 'panel lottery' from the S90C model. They argue that the two panel technologies are significantly different, with Quantum OLED offering brightness and color advantages, while W OLED provides better text clarity and ambient light handling. The speaker is concerned about Samsung selling these as the same product without transparency and urges the company to clarify, advocating for industry pushback to prevent a decline in TV quality akin to the monitor industry's issues.

Takeaways

• 📰 A South Korean newspaper, The L, reported that Samsung might be mixing last-generation Evo W OLED panels with Quantum Dot OLED panels in their S9D series TVs.
• 🎲 This practice, if true, would be unprecedented and could lead to a 'panel lottery' for consumers, affecting sizes from 42 to 77 inches.
• 🚫 The speaker strongly disapproves of this potential practice, stating it's 'totally unacceptable' for Samsung to mix panel technologies without informing consumers.
• 📈 The S90C series had a panel variation issue where some models had brighter panels, but this was within the same technology base.
• 💡 Samsung's response to inquiries was vague, hinting at the possibility of mixed panels but not confirming it, which the speaker interprets as a likely confirmation.
• 📺 The differences between W OLED and Quantum OLED panels are significant, affecting brightness, uniformity, color volume, and ambient light handling.
• 🌟 The speaker prefers the W OLED for its clearer text and better handling in bright ambient light, despite the Quantum OLED's superior brightness and color.
• 🛒 The speaker advises against purchasing the S90D series due to the potential panel inconsistency and recommends the S95D series, despite its matte coating.
• 🔧 The speaker expresses frustration with Samsung Electronics' product quality control and decisions, contrasting with the advanced technology from Samsung Display.
• ✊ The speaker calls for the TV community to push back against this practice to prevent the TV industry from following the monitor industry's negative trajectory.

Q & A

What is the main concern raised in the script about Samsung's S9D TV?

The main concern is that Samsung might be mixing last-generation Evo WOLED panels with their Quantum Dot OLED panels in the S9D TV, which could lead to a 'panel lottery' where customers do not know which type of panel they will receive.

Why is the mixing of different panels in the S9D TV considered unacceptable?

The mixing is considered unacceptable because it could lead to a significant variation in the quality and performance of the TVs, with the WOLED panels and Quantum Dot OLED panels having different characteristics that could affect the viewing experience.

What was the situation with the S90C TV that is mentioned as a precedent?

With the S90C TV, customers had a 'panel lottery' where they could get either an S95B or S95C panel, with the latter being brighter and potentially less prone to burn-in. However, both were Quantum OLED panels, unlike the proposed mix of WOLED and Quantum Dot OLED panels in the S9D.

What is the difference between WOLED and Quantum Dot OLED panels as discussed in the script?

WOLED panels are said to have slightly clearer text and better ambient light handling due to the absence of a magenta tint, while Quantum Dot OLED panels are brighter, have better uniformity, and offer better color volume.

What is the concern about the matte coating on Samsung's S95D TV?

The concern is that the matte coating on the S95D TV might negatively affect the display quality, making it look grainy or 'shitty,' which is a significant drawback for a premium TV.

What is the recommendation for those looking to buy a premium TV at a reasonable cost?

The S90C is recommended as a premium TV at a reasonable cost, but the script suggests caution due to the potential 'panel lottery' with the S9D.

What was Samsung's response to the reports about panel mixing in their TVs?

Samsung's response was vague, stating that they are continually evolving their TV portfolio to provide premium experiences, without directly addressing the specific concerns about panel mixing.

What is the call to action for the TV community regarding this issue?

The call to action is for the TV community to push back against this practice and for Samsung to clarify whether the S90D will be Quantum Dot OLED only, to avoid a situation where customers are uncertain about the quality of the TV they are purchasing.

What is the comparison made between the TV and monitor industry in the script?

The script compares the potential for the TV industry to become as problematic as the monitor industry, which has had issues with poor quality and expensive prices, and is only now starting to improve.

What is the mention of Ruo's HDMI cable and how does it relate to the discussion?

Ruo's HDMI cable is mentioned as a product that can deliver high-quality connections for TVs and monitors, but it is a separate topic from the main discussion about Samsung's TV panels and is likely included as a sponsored message.