Symbolism, Lenses and Writing Your First Analysis

moon!
1 Apr 202422:49

Summary

TLDRIn this video, the host, Moon, expresses gratitude for reaching 10,000 subscribers and discusses the importance of critical analysis in literature. They introduce various lenses such as postcolonialism, ecocriticism, new criticism, and post-structuralism, explaining their applications and significance in understanding texts beyond the author's intent. The host also addresses the topic of symbolism, using TS Elliot's 'The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock' as an example, and offers guidance on writing analytical pieces, emphasizing the need for practice to improve analytical skills.

Takeaways

  • 🎉 The video is a part of 'Analysis 101' series aimed at teaching critical analysis of literature and media.
  • 📈 The channel has reached 10,000 subscribers, a significant milestone for the content creator.
  • 🏆 The creator took a break to finish their degree and recover from top surgery, wearing a compression binder during the video.
  • 📚 The video focuses on deepening the understanding of lenses and symbolism in critical analysis.
  • 🤔 It addresses the question of turning evidence into a critical analysis by discussing the first steps and considerations.
  • 🔍 The importance of using critical lenses is emphasized over relying solely on author intent, due to the subjective nature of art and literature.
  • 🌐 Postcolonialism, ecocriticism, new criticism, and post-structuralism are introduced as additional critical lenses for analysis.
  • 🌿 Ecocriticism is highlighted for its interdisciplinary approach to examining the relationship between humans and nature.
  • 🔬 New criticism is presented as a formalist lens that treats literary texts as distinct and studies them with a scientific rigor.
  • 📖 The process of identifying and writing about symbolism is explored, using 'The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock' as an example.
  • ✍️ The video concludes with advice on writing an analytical piece, emphasizing the importance of practice and starting with familiar material.

Q & A

  • What milestone did the content creator, Moon, achieve that they never imagined reaching?

    -Moon achieved 10,000 subscribers, a milestone they never imagined reaching.

  • Why was Moon absent from posting content for a while?

    -Moon was absent because they needed to finish their degree and also took some time off for their top surgery.

  • What is the purpose of the 'dirt' that Moon mentions wearing in the video?

    -The 'dirt' is actually a compression binder that Moon needs to wear for about a week following their top surgery.

  • What is the main focus of the content Moon plans to share with their audience?

    -Moon plans to share content focusing on the most commonly requested topics from the first 'Analysis 101' video, particularly diving deeper into lenses and discussing how to identify and write about symbolism.

  • Why did Moon receive many questions about turning evidence into a critical analysis?

    -Moon received many questions because viewers were struggling with how to take all the evidence they had gathered and start writing an actual critical analysis.

  • What does Moon suggest for viewers who feel confused or left behind in the 'Analysis 101' series?

    -Moon suggests that if viewers feel confused, they should go back and watch the previous videos in the series to better understand the progressively complex content.

  • What is the significance of the blue curtains in the example given by Moon?

    -The blue curtains are used as an example of how readers can interpret subtextual evidence differently based on cultural implications and personal perspectives.

  • Why does Moon emphasize the importance of considering the reader's perspective in literary analysis?

    -Moon emphasizes this because literature is subjective, and different readers may pick up on different subtextual evidence based on their own experiences and cultural backgrounds.

  • What are the four new critical lenses introduced by Moon in the video?

    -The four new critical lenses introduced are postcolonialism, ecocriticism, new criticism, and post-structuralism.

  • How does Moon define symbolism in the context of literary analysis?

    -Moon defines symbolism as the use of words or imagery to represent a specific object or idea, which can be identified and analyzed through the use of critical lenses.

  • What advice does Moon give for starting to write a critical analysis?

    -Moon advises to start with something easy and familiar, make observations, and then dig deeper. They also emphasize the importance of practice in improving critical analysis writing.

Outlines

00:00

🎉 Celebrating Milestone and Upcoming Content

The speaker, Moon, expresses gratitude for reaching 10,000 subscribers and acknowledges the privilege of creating content for a global audience. They've been absent due to completing their degree and recovering from top surgery, wearing a compression binder as part of the recovery. Moon promises a wealth of new content and encourages viewers to like, subscribe, and support through their 'cofi' for tips. The focus will be on analyzing lenses and symbolism, addressing a common question about transforming evidence into critical analysis. Moon emphasizes the complexity of upcoming videos compared to the first in the series, suggesting that viewers revisit previous content if they feel left behind.

05:00

🔍 Exploring New Critical Lenses and Their Overlaps

Moon introduces new critical lenses: postcolonialism, ecocriticism, new criticism, and post-structuralism, noting their potential for overlap. Postcolonialism examines the effects of colonization, especially on the Caribbean, Africa, and India, and can be uncomfortable due to its focus on racism and identity. Ecocriticism looks at the relationship between humans and nature, often interdisciplinary and appearing in various literary forms. New criticism is a formalist approach that treats literary texts as distinct, focusing on their formal aspects and requiring evidence for analysis. Post-structuralism, or deconstruction, aims to break down texts and reject the idea of a single theme or message, often highlighting flaws by pointing out reliance on traditional assumptions.

10:01

🎨 Understanding Symbolism Through Visual and Literary Examples

Symbolism is defined as the use of words or imagery to represent objects or ideas, with visual media providing clear examples like road signs and traffic lights. In literature, symbolism can be identified through the use of critical lenses that focus on specific themes, allowing for the recognition of recurring symbols that align with the chosen lens or theme. The speaker uses T.S. Elliot's 'The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock' to illustrate how symbols like personified time, coffee spoons, and the Eternal Footman reveal the protagonist's mentality and struggles with mortality and self-perception.

15:02

✍️ Crafting the First Analytical Piece: Structure and Tips

The paragraph discusses the process of writing an analytical piece, emphasizing the importance of an introduction and conclusion that highlight key points. The body of the analysis should include an introduction of topics, evidence, and arguments that tie the theme and evidence together. The speaker suggests starting with familiar material and gradually delving deeper, making observations and then exploring beneath the surface. They encourage practice as the best way to improve analytical writing skills, recommending starting with easy examples and progressively challenging oneself.

20:03

🌐 Engaging With the Audience and Wrapping Up Analysis 101 Part Two

Moon concludes by expressing hope that the video met the audience's expectations and mentions that not all requests could be covered but will be addressed in future videos. They share their active presence on Twitter, Tumblr, and Instagram, having given up on TikTok for the time being. The speaker asks viewers to like and subscribe for updates and hints at the continuation of the series, inviting engagement and discussion in the comment section or via direct messages.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Critical Analysis

Critical Analysis refers to the detailed evaluation and interpretation of a work, often a literary one, by examining its themes, symbols, and context. In the video, this concept is central as the speaker discusses various lenses and methods to dissect and understand the deeper meanings in literature, providing examples and strategies for turning evidence into a coherent analysis.

💡Lenses

In the context of literary analysis, 'lenses' are theoretical or critical perspectives through which a text is examined. The video introduces several lenses, such as postcolonialism and ecocriticism, which allow for the exploration of themes like cultural identity and the relationship between humans and nature, respectively. The use of these lenses helps in uncovering subtextual evidence and adding layers to the analysis.

💡Postcolonialism

Postcolonialism is a critical lens that focuses on the impacts of colonization, particularly on cultures of the Caribbean, Africa, and India. The video explains how this lens can be used to analyze cultural identity, language change, and struggles for independence in literature, often revealing uncomfortable truths about racism and privilege.

💡Ecocriticism

Ecocriticism, also known as environmental criticism, is a lens that examines the representation of the relationship between humans and nature in a text. The video suggests analyzing cultural attitudes towards nature, the portrayal of natural issues, and characters that bridge humanity and nature, as ways to explore themes of environmental concern.

💡New Criticism

New Criticism is a formalist lens that emphasizes the study of literary texts as distinct entities, focusing on their formal aspects like themes and aesthetics as objective elements. The video describes how this lens has influenced the way literary analysis is conducted, with an emphasis on evidence and citation to support interpretations.

💡Post-Structuralism

Post-Structuralism, sometimes equated with deconstruction, is a lens that challenges the idea of a single, unified theme or message in a text. The video illustrates how this lens can be used to dissect a text, pointing out its reliance on traditional assumptions and highlighting the complexity of its themes and their intersections.

💡Symbolism

Symbolism is the use of objects or imagery to represent ideas or concepts in a literary work. The video explains how to identify and write about symbolism, using the poem 'The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock' by T.S. Eliot as an example to show how symbols like the personification of time and the Eternal Footman contribute to the poem's exploration of mortality and self-perception.

💡Personification

Personification is a literary device where abstract ideas or inanimate objects are given human qualities or characteristics. In the video, the script uses the example of time being personified in 'The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock' to illustrate how this device can convey the character's feelings about life and mortality.

💡Evidence

In the context of the video, 'evidence' refers to the specific textual details, quotes, or references used to support an argument in a critical analysis. The speaker emphasizes the importance of providing evidence to make an analysis believable and to allow for fact-checking by the audience.

💡Argument

An 'argument' in literary analysis is the central claim or thesis that ties together the theme and evidence to form a coherent interpretation of the text. The video explains that the argument should make up the bulk of the analysis and should logically connect the chosen theme with the supporting evidence.

💡Practice

The concept of 'practice' in the video relates to the idea of improving one's ability to perform critical analysis through repeated attempts and exercises. The speaker suggests starting with familiar texts and gradually delving deeper to enhance analytical skills, emphasizing that practice is key to becoming proficient in critical analysis.

Highlights

Reaching 10,000 subscribers, a significant milestone for the content creator.

Taking a break to finish a degree and undergo top surgery, with a commitment to wear a compression binder post-operation.

The importance of viewer engagement and support through likes, subscriptions, and financial contributions.

Addressing the most common requests from the first Analysis 101 video, focusing on lenses and symbolism.

The challenge of turning evidence into a critical analysis and the first steps in writing.

The complexity of subsequent videos in the Analysis 101 series and the suggestion to revisit previous content if confused.

Discussion on the importance of considering author intent and the role of subjectivity in literary analysis.

The use of critical lenses to uncover subtextual evidence beyond the author's conscious intent.

Exploring the concept of postcolonialism as a lens to analyze the effects of colonization on literature.

Introduction to ecocriticism, focusing on the relationship between humans and nature in literature.

New criticism as a formalist lens emphasizing the study of literary texts as distinct from other forms of text.

Post-structuralism, or deconstruction, as a lens that challenges the idea of a single theme or message in a text.

The significance of symbolism in literature and how it can be identified and analyzed.

Using specific lenses to identify recurring symbols and their deeper meanings in a text.

The process of writing an analytical piece, including structuring an introduction, evidence presentation, and argument development.

The recommendation to practice analysis by starting with familiar texts and gradually delving deeper.

Invitation for viewers to share their thoughts and engage in discussion about the texts and analysis methods presented.

Transcripts

play00:00

hi I'm Moon and welcome back to analysis

play00:02

[Music]

play00:08

101 I want to thank you all so much for

play00:11

10,000 subscribers this is a goal that I

play00:13

never imagined I could possibly reach

play00:16

it's a huge privilege to be able to make

play00:17

and post this content and to have people

play00:19

from all across the world watch it and

play00:21

interact with it as well and I'm just so

play00:23

grateful to all of you thank you I've

play00:25

been gone a while because I needed to

play00:26

finish my degree and also take some time

play00:28

off for my top surgery and this dirt is

play00:30

actually a compression binder that I

play00:31

need to wear for the next week or so so

play00:33

you have to promise not to judge me for

play00:34

how weird it looks and I actually ended

play00:36

up being away for a lot longer than I

play00:38

wanted to be but I have so much content

play00:41

that I'm really excited to share with

play00:42

you guys and I appreciate everyone who's

play00:44

waited this long for another part in

play00:46

this series and remember that if you

play00:47

like my content and you want to support

play00:49

me the best way to do that is by liking

play00:51

this video and subscribing to my channel

play00:53

and if you're feeling extra generous you

play00:54

can also check out my cofi as well and

play00:56

maybe send me a tip today we're going to

play00:58

focus on the most commonly requested

play01:00

topics from the first analysis 101 video

play01:03

you guys really wanted me to dive deeper

play01:04

into lenses and also talk about how to

play01:06

identify and write about symbolism and

play01:08

one question in particular has popped up

play01:10

a lot not only in the comments of that

play01:12

video but also across my other socials

play01:14

and in my DMs and that question is

play01:16

always along the lines of I have all of

play01:18

my evidence I just don't know how to

play01:20

turn it into an actual critical analysis

play01:23

how do you take everything that you have

play01:25

and start actually writing how do you

play01:27

take that first step all of these topics

play01:28

are really cool and I'm I'm certain that

play01:30

you're going to find them really

play01:31

interesting but a thing to note is that

play01:33

they're a lot more abstract than the

play01:34

last ones and I just want to take this

play01:36

time to note that as we continue through

play01:38

this analysis 101 series each video is

play01:41

going to be a bit more complex than the

play01:43

last one which is to say that if you're

play01:44

confused and feel a little bit left

play01:46

behind I suggest that you go back and

play01:47

watch the video before this and this

play01:49

will be true not only for this part of

play01:50

the series but for the rest of it as

play01:52

well so if you watch video one and two

play01:54

and you feel confused when you start

play01:55

video 4 maybe go back and watch video 3

play01:58

it's just a suggestion and I'm sure that

play02:00

this isn't going to be a problem for

play02:01

most of you because so many people have

play02:03

been begging me for a part two but look

play02:05

to be honest I expected that part one

play02:07

would just flop and be a sad stand alone

play02:09

yet here we are I've already talked for

play02:10

long enough about nothing so let's get

play02:12

into

play02:16

it first I want to talk about critical

play02:18

lenses because you guys really loved

play02:20

them last time but before I introduce

play02:21

you to a couple more I want to address a

play02:23

really good question that someone asked

play02:25

me in the comments of the last video and

play02:27

that question was why not just focus on

play02:29

the author intent and meaning why use

play02:31

something like a critical lens while it

play02:33

is important to consider the author's

play02:35

perspective and experiences when we're

play02:37

analyzing their work you'll remember

play02:38

that a historical lens does this really

play02:40

well it's sometimes really hard for us

play02:43

as readers to empathize with or even

play02:45

understand and it just comes back to the

play02:46

fact that all art including literature

play02:49

is entirely subjective something that

play02:52

sticks out to me might not be that

play02:54

important to you and vice versa that's

play02:56

just how it works so we use specific

play02:58

lenses that interest us to pick up on

play03:01

the subtextual evidence that the author

play03:02

has left behind we can use a classic

play03:04

example and imagine that you're reading

play03:06

a text where the character is sitting in

play03:08

a room and the only thing that's

play03:10

described about that room is that there

play03:11

are blue curtains half covering the

play03:13

window now because of the cultural

play03:15

implications that are associated with

play03:17

the color blue for me it's very easy to

play03:19

assume that these curtains are supposed

play03:21

to signify a depressed or saddened state

play03:24

of the character and we can read into

play03:25

them even further by thinking about

play03:27

their shape how much they cover the

play03:29

window whether or not they clash with

play03:31

any of the other internal Decor but the

play03:33

question then becomes did the author

play03:35

actually intend to leave behind all that

play03:38

information by just describing the

play03:39

curtains as blue and to answer this I

play03:42

want to share with you one of my

play03:43

favorite Tumblr posts of all time

play03:45

sometimes it doesn't matter if the

play03:47

author intended for the blue curtains to

play03:49

have meaning sometimes the author grew

play03:51

up in a society where colors have

play03:52

learned associations and subconsciously

play03:54

applied those associations in the text

play03:57

sometimes a reader who grew up in the

play03:59

same Society or who has studied a

play04:01

certain Society is able to pick up upon

play04:03

those associations and it enhances the

play04:05

story sometimes recognizing the

play04:07

associations that can be made

play04:08

consciously or subconsciously within a

play04:11

text Will Reveal a hidden layer of real

play04:13

world context about the author sometimes

play04:15

the curtains are just blue and sometimes

play04:17

the reason an author has chosen to use a

play04:19

goblin race as its evildoers is rooted

play04:21

in anti-Semitism do you see what I'm

play04:22

saying I don't think people in general

play04:24

realize how much power they have when it

play04:26

comes to consuming any kind of media and

play04:29

not to be like kids these days but I can

play04:31

access literally any movie any music any

play04:34

book at any time anywhere and it's

play04:38

really easy when things like this are so

play04:40

accessible to forget just how important

play04:42

they are I just think that in general

play04:44

it's a shame that people treat Books and

play04:45

Music in particular as accessories to

play04:47

fit into a certain social group and

play04:49

people are doing that instead of

play04:50

actively thinking about what media

play04:52

they're consuming but that's besides the

play04:54

point anyway you are going to have your

play04:56

own opinions about what I just said what

play04:58

seems the most important to you out of

play05:00

everything did anything in particular

play05:01

stick out did it all make sense the

play05:03

message that I'm trying to get across

play05:05

probably won't 100% align with what you

play05:08

learned and that's essentially the

play05:09

reason that constructing your own

play05:11

analysis is really important and you

play05:12

shouldn't just listen to everything that

play05:14

the author thinks anyway lenses let's go

play05:18

so in the last video we looked at

play05:20

psychoanalytic feminist Marxist and

play05:22

queer lenses today I want to talk you

play05:24

through postcolonialism ecocriticism new

play05:26

criticism and post structuralism and

play05:29

something that I can't remember whether

play05:30

or not I mentioned in the last video is

play05:32

that these lenses can really overlap

play05:34

quite a lot in fact it's quite rare to

play05:36

look at a text and only be able to apply

play05:39

one lens to anything at a time let's

play05:41

start with postcolonialism this is the

play05:43

lens that I really hated throughout high

play05:45

school because we used it in literally

play05:48

everything but I have grown to

play05:49

appreciate this lens even if the subtext

play05:51

that you can uncover tends to be quite

play05:53

depressing like his name suggests

play05:55

postcolonialism focuses on the effects

play05:57

of colonization particularly British

play05:59

colonization of the Caribbean Africa and

play06:02

India and something that I definitely

play06:03

forgot to mention last time is that

play06:05

lenses tend to be created in response to

play06:07

literature or literary movements so

play06:09

postcolonialism first existed as a genre

play06:12

of text that was created by those who

play06:14

had been affected by colonization and

play06:17

that developed into a lens which can now

play06:18

be used on any text including those that

play06:20

are written by colonizers and while the

play06:23

overall idea of discussing colonization

play06:25

seems quite simple there are so many

play06:27

ways that you can delve into this kind

play06:29

of analysis you could talk about

play06:31

cultural identity including forced

play06:32

identity changes lost Identity or

play06:35

diasporic identity you could talk about

play06:37

language change and here I want to note

play06:39

that postcolonialist works are written

play06:41

in English which is the colonizers

play06:43

language you could write about struggles

play06:45

for independence from literal battles to

play06:47

institutionalized racism or you could

play06:49

talk about internalized racism

play06:51

xenophobia Etc and specifically look at

play06:53

how this is portrayed within the text by

play06:55

the author is it accidentally there or

play06:57

did they put it there on purpose you to

play06:59

look at this lens can be more

play07:01

uncomfortable for some people to use

play07:02

than others because some people are

play07:04

dealing with trauma that stems from

play07:06

racism and some people like myself were

play07:08

born into privilege and using a

play07:10

postcolonial lens or reading a

play07:12

postcolonial book will most likely mean

play07:14

that you have to face that trauma or

play07:16

privilege head on and that can be a

play07:19

really weird experience if you're unable

play07:21

to think critically about racism and

play07:23

internalized racism in particular this

play07:25

lens is going to be really difficult for

play07:27

you to use but this lens is deep deeply

play07:29

interesting especially if you're in a

play07:31

position where you can talk about how

play07:32

your own experiences relate to it so I

play07:35

really highly recommend that you try it

play07:37

next we have ecocriticism or

play07:39

environmental criticism which focuses on

play07:41

the way that the relationship between

play07:42

nature and humans is depicted and

play07:45

ecocritical texts tend to be

play07:46

interdisciplinary and they appear in

play07:48

fiction and non-fiction forms and like

play07:51

the postcolonial lens ecocriticism

play07:53

appears to be rather simple at first but

play07:55

there are so many angles that you can

play07:57

approach this argument from for example

play07:59

you could focus on cultural attitudes

play08:00

towards nature and maybe compare

play08:02

multiple cultures including your own and

play08:04

this approach very easily goes hand in

play08:07

hand with the postcolonial lens so if

play08:08

you're willing to try two new lenses at

play08:10

the same time I really recommend these

play08:12

two or maybe you could focus on the way

play08:14

that issues within nature are portrayed

play08:16

so you could focus on the way that

play08:17

characters react to big issues within

play08:20

nature itself so like natural disasters

play08:22

for example or you could choose to focus

play08:24

on characters who are in between

play08:25

humanity and nature and look at how they

play08:28

are portrayed and treated through out

play08:29

the text could be a character who's more

play08:31

rooted in our reality so someone like an

play08:33

environmental scientist or it could be a

play08:35

Fantasy character like The Lorax for

play08:37

example personally I love ecocriticism

play08:40

and I was thinking about it from way

play08:42

before I even cared about literature or

play08:43

knew what a critical lens was and of all

play08:45

the possible stories that you could use

play08:47

this lens on I would recommend to you

play08:49

princess monoke Ka of the great snow sea

play08:51

or Fern Gully some of you will

play08:53

definitely have recognized those names

play08:55

and all of them bring an element of

play08:57

fantasy that just ties in with the

play08:58

ecocriticism lens so well next we have

play09:01

new criticism which is a really

play09:03

interesting one because it's totally

play09:04

different to any of the other lenses

play09:06

that we've discussed so far it's a type

play09:07

of formalist lens which states that

play09:09

literary texts should be totally

play09:11

distinguished from any other text and it

play09:14

states that because of this literary

play09:16

texts should be studied differently to

play09:18

do this new criticism assigns formal

play09:20

aspects to literary texts which makes

play09:22

this lens about a scientific as you can

play09:24

get when you're discussing specific

play09:26

themes or Aesthetics because themes and

play09:28

Aesthetics when they're viewed through

play09:29

new criticism lens become more than just

play09:31

subjective ideas they become formal

play09:34

assets of a literary work and look to be

play09:37

honest I got really overwhelmed when I

play09:39

was looking into this lens and what it

play09:41

was but then I came to a really

play09:43

important realization new criticism

play09:45

isn't only a type of formalist lens it

play09:48

is the formalist lens and it gained so

play09:50

much popularity in the 1960s that it

play09:52

changed the literary world forever and

play09:55

we still use it in all of our analyses

play09:57

today you can tell when someone is using

play09:59

new criticism lens just by checking

play10:01

whether or not they include any evidence

play10:03

and that's kind of a given nowadays

play10:05

you'll notice that in all of my analyses

play10:06

that I post on here I have as much

play10:09

information as I possibly can whenever I

play10:11

provide you with a snippet of text for

play10:13

example and evidence goes hand in hand

play10:15

with this lens because the most

play10:16

important aspect of a scientific

play10:18

discussion is that people can go ahead

play10:20

and fact check you and when the audience

play10:22

can ensure that you're basing your

play10:24

claims around real aspects of the text

play10:26

it makes your analysis more believable

play10:28

so to use a new criticism lens just

play10:30

continue as you were but make sure that

play10:32

you site your sources that is incredibly

play10:34

important now let's move on to the last

play10:36

lens of this video which is post

play10:37

structuralism it's sometimes called

play10:39

deconstruction and this lens is again

play10:42

super different to any of the other

play10:43

lenses that we've discussed so far

play10:45

because the aim of this lens is to tear

play10:46

apart the text or deconstruct it and

play10:48

reject the idea that there is a single

play10:51

theme or message at the center of

play10:53

everything so this is basically the

play10:55

villain of lenses if you will and when

play10:57

you're using this you want to be paying

play10:58

very close attention to all of the

play11:00

themes within the text and how they

play11:02

intersect with one another it's the idea

play11:04

of taking something apart to understand

play11:06

what makes it work and how it runs and

play11:08

pointing out that it isn't just one

play11:10

thing that makes the whole machine run

play11:12

it's lots of little things that link

play11:13

together and often post structural lists

play11:16

will focus on pointing out the flaws of

play11:17

the text usually by pointing out that it

play11:19

relies way too heavily on traditional

play11:21

assumptions to move the story along the

play11:23

best example that I can think of to

play11:25

utilize this lens in would be in a work

play11:27

that's been translated across languages

play11:29

because often those translations aren't

play11:31

100% accurate and the cultural meaning

play11:34

is changed or completely lost so it

play11:36

makes sense to its new audience and I'd

play11:38

like to challenge any of you who have a

play11:40

story that you really like that was

play11:41

originally written in a different

play11:42

language to go back to that text and

play11:44

have a closer look at it is there any

play11:47

wording that seems a bit strange

play11:48

something that doesn't really make a lot

play11:50

of sense something that really stuck out

play11:51

to you and for anyone who wants a text

play11:53

suggested to them I have two links in

play11:55

the description that you can go check

play11:57

out the first is Hell screen by OCT word

play11:59

andos and the second is the Moon Over

play12:01

the Mountain by atsushi Nakajima and

play12:03

what's interesting about both of these

play12:04

stories is that they're retellings but

play12:06

hell screen is the retelling of a

play12:08

Japanese story and the Moon Over the

play12:10

Mountain is the retelling of a Chinese

play12:12

story and if you've noticed anything

play12:13

strange and especially if you've gone

play12:15

ahead and tried to figure out why I

play12:16

would love to hear your observations as

play12:18

well now let's move on to symbolism

play12:20

because this is another topic that was

play12:21

really heavily requested in the last

play12:28

video firstly what is symbolism it's a

play12:31

word that we hear all the time but it's

play12:32

rarely ever defined symbolism is the use

play12:35

of words or imagery to portray a

play12:37

specific object or idea and the best way

play12:39

to understand how symbolism works is by

play12:41

looking at visual media particularly

play12:42

Road sides and costume design take this

play12:45

sign for example it indicates that you

play12:47

should drive carefully because there are

play12:48

potentially kangaroos on the road ahead

play12:50

of you and also look at traffic lights

play12:52

for example green means go yellow means

play12:54

slow down and red means stop and you'll

play12:57

notice that these lights don't say go

play12:59

slow down or stop but we have a cultural

play13:02

understanding that green is a good color

play13:04

and yellow and red are warning colors

play13:06

and that's one reason why road signs at

play13:08

least in Australia follow this color

play13:10

scheme we have green signs that give us

play13:12

place names and directions yellow signs

play13:14

that give us warnings and red signs that

play13:17

say stop and when we turn our attention

play13:19

to other forms of visual media you'll

play13:20

notice that color plays a really

play13:22

important role I've already talked

play13:24

extensively about costume design in

play13:27

Bongo stay dogs so if this is something

play13:28

that interests you I'd suggest you go

play13:30

check out that video but for the rest of

play13:32

you let's just move on now how do you

play13:34

identify symbolism the best way is

play13:37

definitely to use a lens of your choice

play13:40

because remember when we're looking at a

play13:41

text through a lens we're paying

play13:43

attention to really important things

play13:45

that match up with a certain theme so

play13:46

when you're using a feminist lens you're

play13:48

looking at how gender roles are

play13:49

portrayed within the story when you're

play13:50

using an ecocriticism lens you're

play13:52

looking at the relationship between

play13:54

humanity and nature and how they are

play13:55

portrayed and as you do this you're

play13:57

going to notice that there are specific

play13:58

Sy symbols that you can associate with

play14:00

your lens or theme and often but not

play14:03

always these symbols will recur they'll

play14:05

pop up again and again and again so

play14:07

let's say that we're analyzing a text

play14:09

through a psychoanalytic lens we would

play14:11

want to pay close attention to our

play14:12

character state of mind and our goal

play14:14

this time is to focus on the symbolism

play14:16

that is used to do that so let's work

play14:18

through an example together this is one

play14:20

of my favorite poems of all time it's

play14:21

called the Love Song of J Alfred

play14:23

proofrock by TS Elliot and we're only

play14:25

going to look at two exerpts for this

play14:27

example but I've linked the full poem in

play14:29

the description as well and as a hint

play14:30

this is going to feature heavily in the

play14:32

Poetry analysis video so if you want to

play14:34

have a little look through and do your

play14:35

own analysis first you can go ahead and

play14:37

do that now to me the most interesting

play14:39

thing about proof rock is that he thinks

play14:41

very highly and very poorly of himself

play14:43

at the same time and throughout this

play14:45

poem which we can imagine is like an

play14:47

entry into his journal we notice that

play14:49

he's also really struggling with the

play14:51

idea of his own mortality and both of

play14:53

these exerpts use imagery or symbolism

play14:55

to describe the ever ongoing cycle of

play14:57

life let's have a look at exerpt 1 first

play14:59

for I have known them all already known

play15:01

them all have known the evenings

play15:03

mornings afternoons I have measured out

play15:05

my life with coffee spoons I know the

play15:07

voices dying with a dying fall beneath

play15:10

the music from a far the room so how

play15:12

should I presume it's suggested here

play15:13

that proof Rock knows the mornings

play15:15

evenings and afternoons Elliot has

play15:18

personified time he's given it human and

play15:20

animal qualities not only in this

play15:22

excerpt but throughout the poem and this

play15:24

is our first symbol he also says I have

play15:27

measured out my life with coffee which

play15:29

creates a very specific image of how

play15:32

this character lives his life his life

play15:34

seems secluded and lonely and not at all

play15:37

exciting it's the kind of life where the

play15:38

number of coffee spoons that he used

play15:40

indicate how many days have passed so

play15:43

this becomes our second symbol now let's

play15:46

look at exerpt 2 and the afternoon the

play15:48

evening sleep so peacefully smoothed by

play15:50

long fingers asleep tired or it mingers

play15:54

stretched on the floor here beside you

play15:56

and me should I after tea and cakes and

play15:59

ises have the strength to force the

play16:00

moment to its crisis but though I have

play16:03

wept and fasted wept and prayed though I

play16:05

have seen my head grown slightly bald

play16:07

brought in upon a platter I am no

play16:08

prophet and here is no great matter I

play16:10

have seen the moment of my greatness

play16:12

Flicker and I have seen the Eternal

play16:13

footman hold my coat and Snicker and in

play16:16

short I was afraid here we see more of

play16:18

the personification of time the evening

play16:20

is described in the way that you would a

play16:22

domestic dog or cat and there are lots

play16:24

of tiny interesting little details and

play16:26

symbols within this passage but I'm

play16:27

going to leave it to you and skip to the

play16:29

very end where we see a reference to a

play16:31

cultural icon the Eternal footman is

play16:33

supposed to represent the Grim Reaper

play16:35

this is one of my favorite lines in the

play16:37

entire poem because it's so creepy but

play16:39

again it gives us a really good insight

play16:41

into proof Rock's mentality he thinks

play16:43

about his own death so much that he has

play16:45

personified it so these symbols the

play16:47

personification of time the Grim Reaper

play16:49

and coffee spoons are easier for us to

play16:51

spot when we use the psychoanalytic lens

play16:53

because we're paying really close

play16:54

attention to proof Rock's mentality and

play16:56

we're able to conclude that he's a very

play16:58

anxious individual may be driven a

play17:00

little bit crazy by loneliness and he

play17:02

has no self-confidence to speak of now

play17:05

as we're thinking about that poem and

play17:06

moving on to how to write your first

play17:08

analytical piece I want you to know that

play17:10

it's extremely unlikely that you'll ever

play17:13

uncover absolutely everything hidden

play17:15

within a text even if you want to I

play17:18

promise that if you go into reading

play17:19

something trying to think of every

play17:21

single lens and every single symbol it's

play17:23

not going to go well it's just not going

play17:24

to compute and look it's really easy to

play17:27

get overwhelmed when you're trying to

play17:28

decide if your Focus will be on a

play17:29

character or a plot point or a symbol

play17:31

when I'm trying to decide exactly what I

play17:33

want to analyze I kind of end up like

play17:34

that

play17:37

[Music]

play17:39

c but knowing the things that you need

play17:42

to talk about is the best way to narrow

play17:44

down what kind of lens you're going to

play17:46

use for example and in the first

play17:47

analysis 101 video I talked a little bit

play17:49

about the basic things that you should

play17:51

include but I didn't talk about

play17:53

everything so let's get into that

play17:57

now the way that you write your analysis

play18:00

will depend on the kind of evidence that

play18:01

you want to show and whether or not you

play18:03

need to comply to any specific standards

play18:05

I know that literature teachers love to

play18:07

ask people to use the teal and ticker

play18:09

methods because they're really easy to

play18:10

remember but assuming that you're

play18:11

writing these in your spare time or you

play18:13

don't have to follow a specific set of

play18:15

Standards not every single paragraph has

play18:17

to be topic evidence explanation link

play18:19

you can Verge out and make it more

play18:21

interesting you'll need an introduction

play18:23

and a conclusion at the beginning and

play18:25

the end and the role of the introduction

play18:27

is to introduce the text that you're

play18:29

analyzing but also to highlight the

play18:31

important points that you'll be making

play18:32

throughout the analysis you'll notice

play18:34

that I did that in the beginning of this

play18:36

video so I think that's a pretty good

play18:37

example honestly you can go back and

play18:39

check that if you want and your

play18:40

conclusion gives you the chance to

play18:42

highlight all of your important points

play18:44

one more time you want to draw your

play18:45

audien's attention to everything that

play18:47

you've just shown them so that they take

play18:49

away the most important pieces of

play18:50

information and we don't write

play18:52

conclusions because we think our

play18:53

audience is stupid we write them because

play18:55

we imagine that they're possibly

play18:57

forgetful every everything else is

play19:00

totally up to you here are the three

play19:01

things that you need and as long as they

play19:03

make sense and it flows really well they

play19:05

can be put in any order that you like

play19:06

number one you want to introduce the

play19:08

topic or topics that you'll be

play19:09

discussing in each part of your analysis

play19:12

and this part can be as long or as short

play19:13

as you like but give us a little bit of

play19:15

an overview of what you'll be discussing

play19:16

in depth two you want as much evidence

play19:19

as you can possibly give them without it

play19:20

being too much if you're highlighting a

play19:22

specific quote for example you don't

play19:24

want to put in the entire paragraph you

play19:26

just want to take out the important

play19:27

context and make sure that you site your

play19:29

sources as well so include page numbers

play19:31

volume numbers line numbers anything

play19:34

that can make it as easy as possible for

play19:36

your audience to fact check you and

play19:38

three you need an argument and this

play19:39

should make up the bulk of what you're

play19:42

writing I talked a bit in my last video

play19:43

about what an argument is and in this

play19:45

context it should tie together your

play19:47

theme and your evidence so that

play19:49

everything makes sense take those three

play19:51

things wrap them up in a bundle and you

play19:53

have a single paragraph or chapter or

play19:55

whatever it is that you're writing and

play19:56

depending on how long those paragraphs

play19:58

or chapters are you'll want three to

play20:01

four of them in each analysis if you're

play20:03

doing something in short form then one

play20:04

or two is plenty but still this all begs

play20:07

the question how do you take your

play20:09

thoughts and ideas and turn them into a

play20:12

critical analysis and this really isn't

play20:15

an easy question to answer because at

play20:17

this stage for me it feels like

play20:19

everything's just laid out in front of

play20:20

me for me it's very natural when I want

play20:22

to analyze something all of the symbols

play20:24

and important parts pop up in front of

play20:26

my eyes and I just have to talk about

play20:28

them and I know that this isn't the

play20:29

answer that you all really want but the

play20:31

best way to get better at this is by

play20:33

practicing when I was in your 12 there

play20:35

was a period of like 3 weeks where my

play20:37

literature teacher wanted us to write an

play20:38

essay every day and I don't think I did

play20:41

it every day but I really tried did I

play20:43

get any better no but to be fair I was

play20:45

studying for three other subjects at the

play20:46

same time and she was being extra harsh

play20:48

on me because I needed to practice but

play20:50

you know whatever now practicing doesn't

play20:52

mean that you have to write an essay

play20:54

every day it doesn't have to be

play20:56

difficult in fact I would really

play20:57

recommend that you start with something

play20:59

that's really easy to you and then try

play21:01

to dig a little bit deeper you can look

play21:03

into an example that we've worked

play21:04

through together you can look at a book

play21:05

that you're studying at school maybe

play21:07

your favorite story of all time it's

play21:09

okay to start by looking at the surface

play21:11

making some observations and then

play21:13

digging a little bit deeper and if you

play21:15

wanted to talk to me or anyone else in

play21:17

the comment section about some

play21:18

observations that you're making try any

play21:20

of the three texts that I've Linked In

play21:22

the description you've got a pretty wide

play21:23

variety of choices there they're all

play21:25

really different they have really

play21:26

different themes and ideas and of course

play21:28

if you don't want to talk about your

play21:29

ideas publicly you can send me a DM on

play21:31

any of my platforms or you can send an

play21:33

anonymous ask via Retros spring or

play21:35

Tumblr I'm really excited at the idea of

play21:37

seeing your thoughts because these three

play21:38

texts are ones that I really love and

play21:41

that brings us to the end of analysis

play21:43

101 Part Two I really hope that this is

play21:45

everything you guys wanted I know I

play21:47

couldn't get to every request but they

play21:48

will feature in future videos in between

play21:51

these longer video posts I'm much more

play21:53

active on Twitter Tumblr and Instagram

play21:55

I've kind of given up on Tik Tok for now

play21:57

if you go to my profile you see exactly

play21:59

why but it's the whole thing and because

play22:00

I've got such a huge following on there

play22:02

I'm still going to post important

play22:03

updates like when I post new videos for

play22:05

example so please give this video a like

play22:07

if you want to that would mean a lot to

play22:09

me subscribe if you want to that would

play22:10

also mean a lot to me and I'll see you

play22:12

in the next one

play22:14

[Music]

play22:27

bye

play22:34

[Music]

play22:47

n

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Etiquetas Relacionadas
Critical AnalysisLiterature StudyPersonal NarrativeSymbolism GuideFeminist LensEcocriticismPostcolonialismNew CriticismPost-StructuralismAnalytical WritingTS Elliot
¿Necesitas un resumen en inglés?