Republic vs. Democracy - What Is The Real Form of the U.S. Government
Summary
TLDRThe script discusses the distinction between democracy and republic, emphasizing the U.S. Founders' intent to establish a republic governed by law rather than majority rule. It clarifies misconceptions about the political spectrum and explains the pitfalls of anarchy and oligarchy. The script highlights the importance of constitutional moderates in preserving freedom and the dangers of unchecked democracy, which can devolve into oligarchy, as history has shown with the Roman Republic's decline.
Takeaways
- 🗽 The script emphasizes the distinction between a democracy and a republic, highlighting that the U.S. was founded as a republic, not a democracy.
- 🌐 It clarifies that the political spectrum is misunderstood, suggesting that it should be viewed as a scale from no government power (far right) to total government power (far left).
- 🏛 The script argues that the U.S. Constitution represents a 'constitutional moderate' government, limited to its proper role of protecting the rights of the people.
- 👥 It points out that forms of government like monarchy or dictatorship are not truly ruled by one person but by a group, making them a type of oligarchy.
- 🔒 The concept of anarchy is discussed as unstable and ultimately leading to the rise of a new form of government, often an oligarchy, rather than being a permanent state.
- 👮♂️ The necessity of some form of government for maintaining order and freedom in society is asserted, with the founding fathers agreeing on this point.
- 🏛️ The script explains that a republic is defined by law, not the will of the majority, and is where the government's power is limited to protect individual rights.
- 🤔 It questions the stability of democracy, suggesting that it can lead to the 'tyranny of the majority' and is not restrained, potentially infringing on individual rights.
- 📜 The founding fathers' intention to avoid a democracy and establish a republic is underscored, with references to their writings and the absence of the word 'democracy' in key U.S. documents.
- 🏛️ The script uses the example of a lynch mob to illustrate the difference between the mob rule of a democracy and the rule of law in a republic.
- 🌍 It concludes by stating that the U.S. has a choice to maintain its republic or risk descending into an oligarchy, reflecting on historical examples of the downfall of democracies.
Q & A
What was Benjamin Franklin's immediate response when asked about the form of government the Constitutional Convention had given the United States?
-Benjamin Franklin responded with 'A republic, ma'am, if you can keep it.'
Why is the distinction between a democracy and a republic important for understanding the American system?
-The distinction is important because a democracy is based on majority rule, which can lead to the tyranny of the majority, whereas a republic is governed by law, protecting individual rights and limiting government power.
What is the confusion about the political spectrum that the script addresses?
-The script addresses the confusion that places groups like Communists on the far left and fascists or dictators on the far right, with moderates in the middle. It clarifies that a more accurate spectrum would show government power ranging from zero on the far right to 100% on the far left.
What type of government is considered to be at the extreme right and far left of the political spectrum according to the script?
-At the extreme right, there is no government (anarchy), and at the far left, there is total government, such as communism, socialism, Nazism, and fascism.
What is the role of a constitution in the context of the political spectrum discussed in the script?
-A constitution, like the one of the United States, represents a government limited to its proper role of protecting the rights of the people, placing it in the middle of the political spectrum where constitutional moderates advocate for limited government.
What are the basic forms of government mentioned in the script?
-The basic forms of government mentioned are monarchy or dictatorship, oligarchy, democracy, republic, and anarchy.
Why does the script argue that monarchy or dictatorship is not truly ruled by one person?
-The script argues that behind every monarchy or dictatorship, there is always a group that supports the leader, such as a council of nobles or bureaucrats, indicating that it is actually ruled by a group, not an individual.
What is the script's argument against anarchy as a form of government?
-The script argues that anarchy, or the absence of government, leads to a lack of law and order, which in turn restricts freedom and requires individuals to constantly guard their life, liberty, and property.
What is the difference between democracy and republic as explained in the script?
-Democracy is the rule of the majority, which can be flawed because it is not restrained and can lead to the oppression of minorities. A republic, on the other hand, is governed by law, ensuring that the rights of individuals are protected and that the government is limited.
Why did the founding fathers of the United States avoid creating a democracy as described in the script?
-The founding fathers avoided creating a democracy because they recognized its potential for mob rule, anarchy, and eventual tyranny under an oligarchy. They aimed to create a republic with limited government to protect individual rights and freedoms.
What historical example does the script provide to illustrate the difference between a democracy and a republic?
-The script uses the example of a lynch mob in the old west. In a democracy, the mob might vote to hang a gunman without a trial, whereas in a republic, the law would require a fair trial and the unanimous decision of a jury to execute justice.
What did the founding fathers of the United States believe about the word 'democracy' in relation to their new government?
-The founding fathers believed that 'democracy' was not a suitable term for their new government, as they intended to create a republic where the government was limited by law, not by the whims of the majority.
What was the script's explanation of the Roman Republic's transition to an oligarchy?
-The script explains that the Roman Republic transitioned to an oligarchy due to the people forgetting the essence of freedom, which is the proper limitation of government power. As government power grew, individual freedoms receded, leading to the eventual collapse of the republic and the rise of the Caesars.
Outlines
🗽 The Essence of American Republic vs. Democracy
This paragraph discusses the misunderstanding between democracy and republic in the context of the American political system. It clarifies that the United States is founded as a republic, not a democracy, with a government limited by law. The script also addresses the misconception about the political spectrum, explaining that it should be viewed as a scale from no government (anarchy) to total government (communism, socialism, etc.), rather than the traditional left-right spectrum. It emphasizes the importance of constitutional moderates and the rule of law to protect individual rights, contrasting it with the potential tyranny of majority rule in a democracy.
🏛 The True Meaning of Democracy and Republic
The second paragraph delves into the definitions of democracy and republic, highlighting the pitfalls of majority rule in a democracy and the importance of law in a republic. It uses the example of a lynch mob to illustrate the difference between the two systems, where a republic's adherence to law and fair trial rights prevents unjust actions that a democracy might allow. The paragraph also discusses the historical perspective of the founding fathers, who intentionally avoided creating a democracy and instead established a republic to safeguard personal security and property rights. It cites the Federalist Papers and other historical documents to underscore the founders' disdain for democracy and their preference for a government ruled by law.
🎶 The Downfall of Democracy and the Rise of Oligarchy
The final paragraph of the script, set to music, summarizes the historical progression from republic to democracy and ultimately to oligarchy, as seen in the fall of Rome. It warns that democracy is not a stable form of government and can lead to the rise of an elite ruling class. The script emphasizes the importance of maintaining the American republic to prevent the tyranny of the few, as envisioned by Benjamin Franklin. It concludes with a playful interaction, suggesting the gravity of the topic while maintaining an engaging tone.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Republic
💡Democracy
💡Oligarchy
💡Constitutional Moderates
💡Political Spectrum
💡Anarchy
💡Majority Rule
💡Rule of Law
💡Lynch Mob
💡Federalist Papers
💡Roman Republic
Highlights
Benjamin Franklin's famous response about giving America a republic, not a democracy.
The common misconception that the U.S. is a democracy rather than a republic.
The clarification of the political spectrum, distinguishing between government power and political ideologies.
The definition of a republic as a government limited by law, in contrast to a democracy ruled by majority.
The historical prevalence of oligarchy as the most common form of government throughout history.
The critique of anarchy as a form of government, highlighting its instability and potential for chaos.
The explanation of how the proper amount of government leads to greater freedom for citizens.
The analysis of the flaws in democracy, where majority rule can infringe upon individual rights.
The founding fathers' intention to establish a republic, not a democracy, in the U.S. Constitution.
The importance of law in a republic to protect individual rights and limit government power.
The comparison between a lynch mob in a democracy and the rule of law in a republic.
The absence of the word 'democracy' in the U.S. Constitution and the Declaration of Independence.
James Madison's view on the dangers of democracy and the necessity of a republic for personal security and property rights.
The historical examples of Greek city-states and the Roman Republic to illustrate the evolution of government forms.
The Roman Republic's transition from a republic to a democracy and eventual oligarchy under Caesars.
The final message that Americans must choose to maintain their republic or risk becoming an oligarchy.
The humorous musical interlude highlighting the importance of the choice between a republic and an oligarchy.
Transcripts
when Benjamin Franklin exited the
Constitutional Convention he was asked
by a woman sir what have you given us
his immediate response was a republic
ma'am if you can keep it yet most
Americans today have been persuaded that
our nation's governmental system is a
democracy and not a republic the
difference between these two is
essential in understanding americanism
and the American system
before we discuss political systems
however it's helpful to address the
confusion that has been spread about the
political Spectrum many have been led to
believe that the political Spectrum
places groups such as Communists on the
far left fascists or dictators on the
far right and political moderates or
centrists in the
middle however a more accurate political
Spectrum will show government having
zero power on the far right to having
100% power on the far left at the
extreme right there is no government the
extreme left features total government
under such labels as communism socialism
Nazism fascism princes potentates
dictators Kings any form of total
government those who claim that Nazis
and fascists are right-wing never Define
their terms this amounts to spreading
confusion toward the middle of the
political Spectrum can be found the type
of government limited to its proper role
of protecting the rights of the people
that's where the Constitution of the
United States is those who Advocate such
a form of government are really
constitutional moderates so let's
analyze the basic forms of government
they are monarchy or dictatorship ruled
by one oligarchy ruled by a few
democracy ruled by a majority Republic
ruled by law and Anarchy which is ruled
by no one in discussing these five we'll
see that they can be narrowed down to
even
fewer looking first at monarchy or
dictatorship this form of government
doesn't really exist in the practical
sense it's always a group that puts one
of its members up front a king has his
Council of nobles or Earls and every
dictator has his bureaucrats or
commissars the Men Behind the Scenes
this isn't ruled by one even though one
person may be the visible leader it's
ruled by a group so let's eliminate
monarchy dictatorship because it never
truly
exists oligarchy which is ruled by group
is the most common form of government in
all history and it is the most common
form of government today most of the
nations of the world are ruled by a
powerful few and therefore oligarchy
remains at the other end we find anarchy
which means without government some
people have looked over history and
found that many of its worst crimes were
committed by governments so they decided
that having no government might be a
good idea but this is a mistake because
as the the ancient Greeks stated without
law there can be no
Freedom our founding fathers agreed and
held that some amount of government is a
necessary force in any civilized orderly
Society in a state of Anarchy however
everyone has to guard life liberty and
property and the lives of family members
everyone must be armed and movement is
severely restricted because one's
property has to be protected at all
times
civilized people have always hired
someone to do the guarding a sheriff a
police force or some branch of
government once law enforcement was in
place the people were Freer they could
leave their property work in the fields
and so on in short the proper amount of
government makes everyone
Freer there are some who Advocate
Anarchy however not because they want no
government but because they don't like
what they have they use Anarchy as a
tool for revolutionary change the
condition of Anarchy is very much like a
vacuum where something rushes in to fill
it these calculating anarchists work to
break down the existing government with
rioting killing looting and terrorism
tragically the people living in such
chaos often go to those best able to put
an end to it and beg them to take over
and restore order and who was best able
to put an end to the chaos the very
people who started it the anarchists who
created the problem then create a
government run by them an oligarchy
where they have total power this is
exactly what happened in Russia that led
to Lenin taking total power and in
Germany where Hitler's Brown Shirts
created the chaos that brought him to
power but Anarchy isn't a stable form of
government it's a quick transition from
something that exists to something
desired by the power hungry it's a
temporary condition and because it isn't
permanent we eliminate it as
well the word democracy comes from two
Greek words deos meaning people and
catean meaning to rule democracy
therefore means the rule of the people
majority rule this of course sounds good
but suppose the majority decides to take
away one's home or business or children
obviously there has to be a limit the
flaw in democracy is that the majority
isn't
restrained if more than half the people
can be persuaded to want something in a
democracy they
rule what about Republic
well that comes from the Latin res
meaning thing and Pua meaning public it
means the public thing the
law a true Republic is one where the
government is limited by law leaving the
people
alone America's Founders had a clean
slate to write on they could have set up
an oligarchy in fact there were some who
wanted George Washington to be their
King but the founding fathers knew
history and they chose to give us the
rule of law law in a republic not the
rule of a majority in a democracy why
let's demonstrate the difference in the
setting of the old
west consider a Lynch Mob In a Democracy
35 horseback Riders Chase one loone
gunman they catch him and they vote 35
to1 to hang him democracy has triumphed
and there's one less gunman to contend
with now consider the same scenario in a
republic the 35 horseback Riders Catch
the gunman and vote 35 to1 to hang him
but the sheriff arrives and he says you
can't kill him he's got his right to a
fair trial so they take the gunman back
to town a jury of his peers is selected
and they hear the evidence and the
defense and they decide if he shall hang
does the jury even decide by majority
rule no it has to be unanimous or he
goes free the rights of the government
aren't subject to majority rule but to
the law this is the essence of a
Republic many Americans would be
surprised to learn that the word
democracy does not appear in the
Declaration of Independence or the US
Constitution nor does it appear in any
of the Constitutions of the 50 states
the founders did everything they could
to keep us from having a
democracy James Madison rightly known as
the father of the Constitution wrote in
essay number 10 of The Federalist
Papers democracies have ever been
spectacles of turbulence and contention
have ever been found incompatible with
personal security or the rights of
property and have in general been Ur in
their lives as they have been violent in
their
deaths Alexander Hamilton agreed and he
stated we are a Republican government
real Liberty is never found in despotism
or in the extremes of
democracy Samuel Adams Aigner of the
Declaration of Independence stated
democracy never lasts long it soon
wastes exhausts and murders
itself the founders had good reason to
look upon democracy with contempt
because they knew that the democracies
in the early Greek city States produced
some of the wildest excesses of
government imaginable in every case they
ended up with mob rule then Anarchy and
finally tyranny under an
oligarchy during that period in Greece
there was a man named Solen who urged
creation of a fixed body of law not
subject to majority whims but where the
Greeks never adopted Sand's wise Council
the Romans did based on what they knew
of Sand's laws they created the 12
tables of the Roman law and in effect
built a republic that limited government
power and left the people
alone since government was limited the
people were free to produce with the
understanding that they could keep the
fruits of their labor in time Rome
became wealthy and the Envy of the
world in the midst of Plenty however the
Roman people forgot what Freedom
entailed they forgot that the essence of
freedom is the proper limitation of
government When government power grows
people Freedom
recedes once the Romans dropped their
guard power seeking politicians began to
exceed the powers granted them in the
Roman
Constitution some learned that they
could elect politicians who would use
government power to take property from
some and give it to others agriculture
subsidies were introd educed followed by
housing and Welfare programs inevitably
taxes Rose and controls over the private
sector were imposed soon a number of
Rome's producers could no longer make
ends meet and they went on the
Dole productivity declined shortages
developed and mobs began roaming the
streets demanding bread and circuses
from the government many were induced to
trade freedom for
security eventually the whole system
Came Crashing Down they went from a
republic to a democracy and ended up
with an oligarchy under a progression of
the
[Music]
Caesars thus democracy itself is not a
stable form of government instead it is
the gradual transition from limited
government to the unlimited rule of an
oligarchy knowing this We As Americans
are ultimately left with only two
choices we can keep our Republic as
Franklin put it or we will inevitably
end up with an oligarchy a a tyranny of
the
elite
hey is this my
turn you want me to sing
now
okay wow
[Music]
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)