RDR1 Vs RDR2: Which Is The Better Game?

Summary

This video compares *Red Dead Redemption 1* and *Red Dead Redemption 2*, highlighting the key differences in characters, story, and game design. The video argues that while *RDR1* is a classic, *RDR2* surpasses it in virtually every aspect. The main characters—Arthur Morgan and John Marston—are analyzed, with Arthur’s personal growth in *RDR2* being a standout element. The villains, Micah and Milton, are seen as more developed compared to Agent Ross. The video concludes that *RDR2* offers a deeper, more immersive story, making it the superior game.

Takeaways

• 😀 Micah and Milton are seen as more developed antagonists compared to Agent Ross, who lacks depth in *Red Dead Redemption 1* (RDR1).
• 😀 Agent Ross is considered a utilitarian character who uses others for his own gain, but his limited development reduces his impact on the story.
• 😀 Arthur Morgan is hailed as a much stronger and more central character than John Marston, whose storyline in *Red Dead Redemption 1* is more about redemption and family.
• 😀 *Red Dead Redemption 2* (RDR2) focuses heavily on Arthur's personal growth, making it an integral part of the game's narrative.
• 😀 The story of *Red Dead Redemption 2* is praised for its complexity, with established relationships and dynamics between characters that create a more immersive experience.
• 😀 *Red Dead Redemption 1* has a more linear and traditional narrative, while *Red Dead Redemption 2* feels more dynamic with deeper character interactions.
• 😀 The development of the gaming engine in *Red Dead Redemption 2* allowed for a more detailed, expansive, and immersive story than in *Red Dead Redemption 1*.
• 😀 The presence of multiple antagonists in *Red Dead Redemption 2* (Micah, Milton, and Dutch) enriches the narrative, providing more varied conflicts compared to the singular antagonist in RDR1.
• 😀 The slow start of *Red Dead Redemption 2* is justified by its deeper character development and world-building, which enhances the overall storytelling experience.
• 😀 Despite *Red Dead Redemption 2* being a superior game in many respects, *Red Dead Redemption 1* is still appreciated for its place in gaming history and its role in setting up the franchise.

Q & A

Why is Agent Ross considered less developed compared to Micah and Milton?

Agent Ross is seen as less developed because he is only introduced in the last two chapters of *Red Dead Redemption 1*. While Micah and Milton have complex motivations and a deeper presence throughout *Red Dead Redemption 2*, Ross is portrayed as a one-dimensional antagonist who uses people and discards them when no longer needed.

How does Milton's approach to handling dirty work differ from that of Micah?

Milton prefers to avoid getting his hands dirty by using others, like Micah, to carry out actions. However, when he must get involved, he goes as far as possible. This is in contrast to Micah, who is much more hands-on and willing to engage in violent acts for his own gain.

Why is Arthur Morgan considered a better protagonist than John Marston?

Arthur Morgan is seen as a better protagonist because *Red Dead Redemption 2* revolves entirely around his character development. The game focuses on his journey from a hardened outlaw to someone seeking redemption. In contrast, John Marston's role in *Red Dead Redemption 1* is more about dealing with his past mistakes rather than evolving throughout the story.

What makes the story of *Red Dead Redemption 2* more complex compared to *Red Dead Redemption 1*?

The story of *Red Dead Redemption 2* is more complex because it starts with established relationships and ongoing tensions between characters like Arthur, Micah, Dutch, and John. Players get to witness the dynamics of these relationships evolve, whereas *Red Dead Redemption 1* is more linear, with backstory and relationships being revealed progressively.

How do the relationships between characters impact the storytelling in *Red Dead Redemption 2*?

In *Red Dead Redemption 2*, the relationships between characters play a crucial role in shaping the story. Players interact with characters who already have histories and tensions, allowing for a deeper exploration of their personalities and motivations. This adds emotional depth and makes the story feel more immersive.

What is the central theme of *Red Dead Redemption 2*, according to the video?

The central theme of *Red Dead Redemption 2* is Arthur Morgan's personal growth and redemption. The game explores his transformation from a hardened outlaw to someone who strives to become a better person, emphasizing the importance of moral choices and change.

How does *Red Dead Redemption 2* improve upon the story structure compared to *Red Dead Redemption 1*?

*Red Dead Redemption 2* improves upon the story structure by starting with pre-existing conflicts and relationships. This contrasts with *Red Dead Redemption 1*, where John learns about his past and the characters around him in a more linear fashion. This allows for a richer narrative where players experience complex interactions and evolving dynamics.

What role does Micah play in *Red Dead Redemption 2* compared to Agent Ross?

Micah plays the role of a primary antagonist in *Red Dead Redemption 2*, with a significant personal conflict with Arthur Morgan. He is more hands-on and directly involved in the gang's actions. Agent Ross, on the other hand, is more of a secondary antagonist in *Red Dead Redemption 1*, only becoming important near the end of the game.

Why is *Red Dead Redemption 2* considered one of the best fictional stories ever told?

*Red Dead Redemption 2* is considered one of the best fictional stories because it offers a deeply emotional and intricate narrative. The game allows players to witness Arthur Morgan’s transformation and the relationships he shares with others, making it a compelling and immersive experience. The game's attention to detail and emotional payoff in character development adds to its storytelling excellence.

What is the significance of the slow start in *Red Dead Redemption 2*?

The slow start in *Red Dead Redemption 2* is significant because it helps establish the complex world and characters. Players are introduced to a range of pre-existing relationships and dynamics, which require time to unfold. This slower pacing ultimately helps players build a deeper connection with the characters and the story as the game progresses.