EV vs ICE Debate - Grow Up People!!

Summary

In this video, the host discusses the Eevee versus Ice debate and shares his experience with Toyota's first full-fledged electric vehicle, the bz4x, which is also branded as a Subaru. He highlights the challenges of charging electric vehicles (EVs), especially without a home charger, and addresses the polarizing nature of the EV community. The host also delves into the impact of using air conditioning on EV range, comparing it to internal combustion engine vehicles. He emphasizes the importance of having an open and mature conversation about EVs, acknowledging that while they are not suitable for everyone, they offer a viable option for many. The video aims to clarify misconceptions and promote a balanced view of EVs in the automotive market.

Takeaways

• 🚗 The Toyota bz4x is Toyota's first full-fledged electric vehicle, shared with Subaru.
• ⚡ The vehicle's charging time from 30% to 100% is approximately 1 hour and 35 minutes at a Genie Point charger.
• 🔥 The debate over electric vehicles (EVs) versus internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles is ongoing and polarizing.
• 🌡️ The use of climate control in EVs can significantly impact range, as demonstrated by a 31-mile drop on a hot day.
• 🤔 The video creator is a car journalist who assesses vehicles without bias towards the type of fuel they use.
• 🏠 The creator lives in a flat without a home charger, making EV ownership inconvenient for him.
• 📈 There is a learning curve and new experiences associated with EVs, even for seasoned car reviewers.
• 🔄 The range loss due to AC usage in EVs can be compared to that of ICE vehicles, with some suggesting an 8-10% reduction for ICEs.
• 📱 Preconditioning an EV can help manage range by setting the climate control while the car is plugged in.
• 🌍 The video creator emphasizes the importance of understanding individual needs and scenarios when considering an EV or ICE vehicle.
• 🗣️ The video highlights the sensitivity and defensiveness of some EV proponents, which may not be helpful in promoting EV adoption.

Q & A

What is the debate mentioned in the video about?

The debate mentioned in the video is about the comparison between Eevee and Ice, which seems to be a metaphor for electric vehicles (EVs) and internal combustion engine vehicles (ICEs).

What is the Toyota bz4x and why is it significant?

The Toyota bz4x is Toyota's first full-fledged electric vehicle, which is also shared with Subaru, making it significant as it represents a major step by a traditional automaker into the EV market.

What was the range of the car after charging for about five minutes?

After charging for about five minutes, the car's range increased from 30% to 40%, with an indicated range of 94 miles.

What issue did the car's climate control cause that was discussed in the video?

The car's climate control consumed a significant amount of battery power, causing a drop of about 31 miles in the indicated range just by switching it on to full.

What was the purpose of the video posted on the Brown Car Guy's Facebook page?

The purpose of the video was to share an observation about the impact of using the climate control on the EV's range and to spark a discussion about how this compares to an ICE vehicle.

What was the temperature like on the day the car's climate control was tested?

The temperature was very hot, with temperatures above 30 degrees Celsius, which is considered quite hot for the UK.

What was the range drop when the AC was turned on during a drive on a milder day?

On a milder day with the car in motion, the range dropped by about 12 miles when the AC was turned on.

What was the response to the video on different social media platforms?

The video received various responses, with Facebook having the most engagement. YouTube, Instagram, and TikTok also had viewers who generally took the video as a genuine inquiry and tried to answer the question posed.

What misconceptions about EVs were highlighted in the video?

Some misconceptions highlighted include the belief that EVs are more likely to catch fire than ICE vehicles, and that EVs are difficult to operate or require extensive knowledge about preconditioning.

What was the general sentiment towards the discussion of EVs in the Facebook comments?

The sentiment towards the discussion of EVs in the Facebook comments was polarizing, with some people being very defensive and others expressing strong negative opinions about EVs.

What advice does the video creator give for the discussion around EVs?

The video creator advises that the level of discussion around EVs should be raised from shouting matches to more mature and pragmatic conversations that consider the day-to-day realities of people and their needs.