Philippines vs. Vietnam | The Race for Economic Dominance in Southeast Asia

Summary

The Philippines and Vietnam, two Southeast Asian economic powerhouses, are on distinct paths to regional dominance. The Philippines, with a colonial past influencing its trade and commerce, has emerged as a technology and services hub. Vietnam, with a history of resilience, has become a manufacturing giant, reducing poverty significantly. Both nations are experiencing strong GDP growth, with the Philippines having a higher nominal GDP but Vietnam's youthful demographic may give it an edge. They are strategically positioned in geopolitics, influencing ASEAN dynamics, with the Philippines' alliances impacting regional security and Vietnam's location affecting maritime governance.

Takeaways

• 🌏 The Philippines and Vietnam are Southeast Asian nations with distinct historical paths but share a common goal of economic growth and regional dominance.
• 🏛️ The Philippines' colonial legacy under Spain and the United States influenced its economic trajectory, establishing it as a trading hub and fostering trade and commerce.
• 🚀 Vietnam's history of resistance against foreign domination shaped its national identity and resilience, leading to its unification and economic reforms post-war.
• 📈 Both countries have experienced rapid economic growth, with the Philippines focusing on high-tech industries and services, while Vietnam excels in manufacturing.
• 💼 The Philippines' service sector, including tourism, healthcare, and education, plays a significant role in its economic strength.
• 🏭 Vietnam has reduced extreme poverty significantly and is known for its manufacturing prowess in textiles, footwear, and electronics.
• 📊 The Philippines has a higher nominal GDP compared to Vietnam, but Vietnam's youthful demographic dividend could provide a competitive edge.
• 🌐 Both nations exhibit strong real GDP growth rates, suggesting promising economic futures with strategic investments and policy reforms.
• 🌉 The Philippines is investing in infrastructure and tax reforms to boost its economy, while Vietnam is diversifying its exports to create a more resilient economy.
• 🔄 Vietnam maintains a more balanced current account, achieving a slight surplus, indicating effective trade flow management.
• 🌎 Both countries play key roles in regional geopolitics, influencing economic partnerships, security cooperation, and regional stability.

Q & A

What are the key economic strengths of the Philippines?

The Philippines' key economic strengths include its historical background in trade and commerce, a pro-trade stance, alliances and trade agreements with global partners, and the emergence of the business process outsourcing (BPO) industry. It also has a service sector spanning tourism, health care, and education.

How has Vietnam's historical journey shaped its economic landscape?

Vietnam's economic landscape has been shaped by its struggle against foreign domination, French colonization, and the unification of North and South Vietnam. Post-war reconstruction and economic reforms, including the policy of 'Doi Moi' in the 1980s, have led to its transformation into an economic powerhouse.

What is the significance of the Philippines' colonial legacy?

The Philippines' colonial legacy under Spain and the United States introduced Western systems and institutions, fostering a foundation for trade and commerce. The Galleon trade established in the 16th century positioned the Philippines as a crucial trading hub.

What economic reforms did Vietnam implement in the late 20th century?

Vietnam implemented the 'Doi Moi' policy of renovation in the 1980s, which opened the country to foreign investment, trade, and market-oriented reforms, leading to rapid economic growth.

How does the Philippines' service sector contribute to its economic growth?

The service sector in the Philippines contributes to economic growth by spanning tourism, health care, and education, further bolstering its economic prowess and attracting foreign investments.

What is Vietnam's comparative advantage in high-tech industries?

Vietnam has a comparative advantage in high-tech industries such as electronics, information technology, and business process outsourcing, which has helped it become a global manufacturing hub.

What are the current nominal GDP figures for the Philippines and Vietnam?

The Philippines has a higher nominal GDP at $374.2 billion in 2022, projected to reach $408.8 billion in 2024. Vietnam has a lower nominal GDP at $350.3 billion in 2022, expected to reach $386.8 billion in 2024.

How does Vietnam's youthful demographic dividend impact its economic growth?

Vietnam's youthful demographic dividend provides a young, skilled workforce that eagerly embraces modernization, which could prove to be a game-changer in sustaining economic growth.

What are the key policy reforms that have helped the Philippines' economic trajectory?

The Philippines has implemented policies such as the 'Build, Build, Build' infrastructure program and the Tax Reform for Acceleration and Inclusion (TRAIN) law to help its economic trajectory.

What are the key policy reforms that have helped Vietnam's economic trajectory?

Vietnam has implemented policies such as the 'Doi Moi' economic reforms and the promotion of foreign direct investment (FDI) to help its economic trajectory.

How do the Philippines and Vietnam's geopolitical positions influence their economic partnerships?

The Philippines' strategic location along major international sea routes and Vietnam's bordering the South China Sea provide them with access to vital sea lanes and marine resources. Their geopolitical positioning influences economic partnerships, security cooperation, and regional stability.

Outlines

00:00

🌏 Economic Rivalry in Southeast Asia

The video script discusses the economic competition between the Philippines and Vietnam in the Southeast Asian region. Both countries have distinct historical paths that have shaped their economic development. The Philippines, with a colonial legacy from Spain and the United States, has a foundation in trade and commerce, established by the Galleon trade in the 16th century. It became independent in 1946, which led to national economic policies and foreign trade relations, making it a manufacturing and agricultural powerhouse. The BPO industry emerged in the late 20th century, solidifying its position as a technology and services hub. Vietnam, on the other hand, has a history of resistance against foreign domination, which has shaped its national identity. French colonization in the 19th century introduced modern infrastructure and trade networks. Post-war reconstruction and economic reforms in the late 20th century turned Vietnam into an economic powerhouse, with a focus on foreign direct investment and manufacturing, reducing extreme poverty significantly.

05:04

📈 Economic Outlook and Demographic Advantage

The script compares the economic outlook of the Philippines and Vietnam, highlighting their nominal GDP and growth rates. The Philippines has a higher nominal GDP but Vietnam's youthful demographic dividend could be a game-changer. Both countries exhibit strong real GDP growth rates around 6.00% to 6.90%, indicating robust economic performance. The Philippines' strategic investments in high-tech industries and Vietnam's focus on manufacturing and foreign direct investment drive their economic expansion. Vietnam has a more balanced current account, achieving a slight surplus, while the Philippines experiences deficits, indicating higher reliance on imports. The Philippines is focusing on developing infrastructure and enhancing the business climate, while Vietnam is working on diversifying its exports to create a more resilient economy.

10:05

🌐 Geopolitical Roles and Regional Impact

The final paragraph discusses the geopolitical roles of the Philippines and Vietnam in Southeast Asia. The Philippines, with its strategic location along major international sea routes, has attracted global powers interested in the Indo-Pacific region. It is a long-time ally of the United States and plays a significant role in regional security and maritime governance. Vietnam, bordering the South China Sea, has access to vital sea lanes and marine resources. Its history of territorial disputes has shaped its geopolitical outlook. Vietnam engages in regional forums and organizations to promote cooperation and address challenges. Both countries play pivotal roles in initiatives like ASEAN's economic integration and the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP). The analysis suggests Vietnam as a potential leader in shaping Southeast Asia's future, but acknowledges the dynamic nature of the region where unforeseen events could alter the trajectory of both nations.

Keywords

💡Southeast Asia

Southeast Asia refers to the geographical region comprising of 11 countries including the Philippines and Vietnam. In the video, Southeast Asia is highlighted as a dynamic region where economic powerhouses like the Philippines and Vietnam are emerging. The video discusses how these countries are vying for regional dominance through their economic growth and strategic trade orientations.

💡Economic Powerhouses

Economic powerhouses are nations with strong economies that have significant influence on the global economic stage. The video positions the Philippines and Vietnam as such, emphasizing their high-tech industries, manufacturing prowess, and strategic trade orientations as key factors in their rise.

💡Historical Paths

Historical paths refer to the unique sequences of events that have shaped a nation's development. The video discusses how the Philippines and Vietnam have embarked on distinct historical paths, each with pivotal events that have influenced their economic trajectories.

💡Colonial Legacy

Colonial legacy refers to the lasting effects of a nation being under colonial rule. The video mentions the Philippines' colonial legacy under Spain and the United States, which introduced Western systems and institutions that fostered a foundation for trade and commerce.

💡Galleon Trade

The Galleon trade was a 16th-century trade route that connected Asia, the Americas, and Europe. The video notes that the Philippines, being a part of this trade, was positioned as a crucial trading hub, which has historical implications for its economic development.

💡Manufacturing and Agricultural Powerhouse

The term refers to a nation that excels in both manufacturing and agricultural sectors. The video highlights the Philippines' rise as such in the post-war era, embracing a pro-trade stance and forging alliances and trade agreements with global partners.

💡Business Process Outsourcing (BPO)

BPO refers to the practice of contracting a company to manage a specific business task. The video mentions the emergence of the BPO industry in the Philippines in the late 20th century, which solidified its position as a technology and services hub, attracting foreign investments.

💡Demographic Dividend

A demographic dividend refers to the economic growth potential that arises when a nation has a large, young, working-age population. The video suggests that Vietnam's youthful demographic dividend might be a game-changer, with a young skilled workforce that eagerly embraces modernization.

💡Foreign Direct Investment (FDI)

FDI is an investment made by a firm or an individual in one country into business interests located in another country. The video discusses how Vietnam's strategic focus on attracting FDI and developing its manufacturing sector has propelled it forward as a global manufacturing hub.

💡Infrastructure

Infrastructure refers to the basic physical and organizational structures needed for the operation of a society or enterprise. The video notes that the Philippines has launched an infrastructure development program known as 'Build, Build, Build' to enhance the business climate and attract more investments.

💡Geopolitics

Geopolitics is the study of how geography influences international politics. The video discusses the geopolitical positioning of the Philippines and Vietnam in Southeast Asia, influencing economic partnerships, security cooperation, and regional stability.

Highlights

The Philippines and Vietnam are emerging economic powerhouses in Southeast Asia.

The Philippines has a colonial legacy that influenced its economic development.

Vietnam's history of resistance has shaped its unity and economic landscape.

The Philippines declared sovereignty in 1946, opening up economic policies and foreign trade relations.

Vietnam's unification in 1976 led to post-war reconstruction and economic reforms.

The Philippines is a technology and services hub, attracting foreign investments.

Vietnam is a global manufacturing hub with a focus on high-tech industries.

The Philippines' service sector, including tourism and healthcare, bolsters its economic strength.

Vietnam's manufacturing sector includes textiles, footwear, and electronics.

The Philippines has a higher nominal GDP than Vietnam, indicating a larger economic size.

Vietnam's youthful demographic dividend could be a game-changer for its economy.

Both countries exhibit strong real GDP growth rates around 6.00% to 6.90%.

The Philippines is focusing on developing infrastructure and enhancing the business climate.

Vietnam is working on diversifying its exports to create a more resilient economy.

The Philippines' economic growth is driven mostly by domestic demand.

Vietnam's economic reforms and promotion of FDI have helped its economic trajectory.

The Philippines' strategic location along international sea routes attracts global powers.

Vietnam's location bordering the South China Sea provides access to vital sea lanes and marine resources.

Both nations play pivotal roles in initiatives like ASEAN's economic integration and RCEP.

Vietnam stands as the frontrunner with the potential to lead in shaping Southeast Asia's future.

Transcripts

in the heart of the dynamic Southeast

Asian region lies a compelling contest

between two Rising economic powerhouses

the Philippines and Vietnam

embarking on distinct historical paths

both Nations have emerged with diverse

strengths and growth prospects vying for

regional dominance

with high-tech Industries manufacturing

prowess and strategic trade orientations

they have set the stage for an

exhilarating race to the top

[Music]

[Music]

thank you

the historical background of both the

Philippines and Vietnam is replete with

pivotal events and turning points that

have profoundly influenced their

economic trajectories

Philippines

the Philippines Colonial Legacy under

Spain and the United States has left an

indelible mark on its Economic

Development

the introduction of Western systems and

institutions during colonization

fostered a foundation for trade and

commerce

The Galleon trade established in the

16th century facilitated connections

between Asia the Americas and Europe

positioning the Philippines as a crucial

trading hub

fast forward to the 20th century the

Philippines struggle for independence

from American rule culminated in its

sovereignty declaration in 1946.

this newfound Freedom opened doors for

National Economic policies and foreign

trade relations Paving the way for the

nation's economic expansion

the post-war era witnessed the rise of

the Philippines as a manufacturing and

agricultural Powerhouse in Southeast

Asia

it embraced a pro trade stance forging

alliances and trade agreements with

Global Partners

moreover the emergence of the business

process Outsourcing BPO industry in the

late 20th century solidified the

Philippines position as a technology and

services Hub attracting foreign

investments and fostering economic

growth for this year what matters is

really domestic consumption and that is

what the Philippines has for that reason

I think 2023 will be rather good for the

Philippines compared to the rest of the

region Vietnam's historical Journey has

been marked by various turning points

beginning with its struggle against

foreign Dominion

from ancient times Vietnam's resistance

against Chinese occupation shaped a

sense of unity and national identity

fostering a resilient spirit that would

reverberate throughout its history

the arrival of European colonizers

notably the French in the 19th century

had a profound impact on Vietnam's

economic landscape

the French colonization introduced

modern infrastructure trade networks and

education albeit with exploitative

elements

the mid-20 30th century was a critical

juncture for Vietnam as it battled

against French colonial rule and later

entered into a prolonged conflict with

the United States during the Vietnam war

the War caused significant Devastation

but it also led to the unification of

North and South Vietnam in 1976

establishing the Socialist Republic of

Vietnam

post-war reconstruction and economic

reforms in the late 20th century paved

the way for Vietnam's transformation

into an economic Powerhouse

the government's policy of DOI Moy

renovation in the 1980s opened the

country to foreign investment trade and

market-oriented reforms spurring rapid

economic growth

Vietnam's strategic focus on attracting

foreign direct investment and developing

its manufacturing sector propelled it

forward as a global manufacturing Hub

Vietnam reduced extreme poverty from 50

just 25 years ago to 3 percent today

blessed with a comparative advantage in

high-tech Industries such as Electronics

information technology and business

process Outsourcing the Philippines

thrives as a technology and services hub

its service sector spanning tourism

health care and education further

bolsters its economic prowess

I believe the Philippines can be a

virtual economy by 2050 and that's the

forecast of the Goldman Sachs and HSBC

Vietnam on the other hand excels in

manufacturing boasting an impressive

lineup of textiles Footwear and

electronics

as a major agricultural exporter with

strengths in rice coffee and seafood

Vietnam displays a diversified approach

to economic growth and we're focused on

huge opportunities that are available on

our Market you know just mentioning

Revenue as well 16 Union Revenue growth

growing 25 in all markets outside of

Vietnam so we're very pleased with the

result

the Philippines

higher nominal GDP at

374.2 billion dollars in 2022 projected

to reach 408.8 billion dollars in 2024.

Vietnam lower nominal GDP at 350.3

billion dollars in 2022 expected to

reach

386.8 billion dollars in 2024.

the Philippines holds a higher nominal

GDP compared to Vietnam signifying a

larger overall economic size

however Vietnam's youthful demographic

dividend might prove to be a game

changer with a young skilled Workforce

that eagerly Embraces modernization

Vietnam charts a course toward future

prosperity

based on the data from the imf's world

economic Outlook 2023 both the

Philippines and Vietnam exhibit strong

real GDP growth rates hovering around

6.00 percent to 6.90 percent during the

specified years

these growth rates indicate robust

economic performance and suggests that

both countries have promising economic

futures

economic growth Theory further supports

their growth prospects with the

Philippines strategic investments in

high-tech Industries and Vietnam's focus

on manufacturing and foreign direct

investment forming formidable drivers of

economic expansion

nevertheless Vietnam's demographic

Advantage complemented by its robust

export performance gives it an edge in

sustaining growth in 2023 and then the

recovery continues in 2024 when we

expect growth to be around 5.86 in 2024.

both countries

economies relying on exports to fuel

economic growth

Vietnam maintains a more balanced

current account even achieving a slight

surplus of 0.1 percent of GDP in 2024

which signifies its ability to

effectively manage trade flows

on the other hand the Philippines

experiences current account deficits

indicating higher Reliance on Imports

than exports

with only two percent of We Are

spending only two percent of our GDP for

infrastructure that's why we suffer in

comparison with with our Asian neighbors

and so we launched this what I call

initially golden age of infrastructure

now we're spending something like five

to six percent while the Philippines has

comparative advantages and services in

high-tech Industries its trade deficit

could impact its ability to dominate

southeast Asia economically

Philippines is focusing on developing

infrastructure and enhancing the

business climate to attract more

investments in its high-tech Industries

and services

whereas Vietnam is working on

diversifying its exports to reduce

Reliance on specific sectors creating a

more resilient economy

by strengthening its manufacturing and

agricultural sectors Vietnam can bolster

its Competitive Edge and attract more

foreign direct investment

the Philippines has implemented a number

of specific policies that have helped

its economic trajectory including the

build build build infrastructure program

and the tax reform for acceleration and

inclusion train law

the Philippine economy is driven mostly

by domestic demand okay and so we

although there's a global

headwind it does not affect us too much

Vietnam has also implemented a number of

specific policies that have helped its

economic trajectory including the doimoy

economic reforms and the promotion of

foreign direct investment FDI

infrastructure in Vietnam today remains

well behind many other developing

countries and there's still a lot of

work to do if you look at the airports

the roads and especially the rail both

the Philippines and Vietnam are

continuing to implement reforms that are

aimed at further boosting economic

growth and creating jobs

by leveraging their respective policy

environments and harnessing their

comparative advantages these two nations

are poised to shape the economic

landscape of Southeast Asia for years to

come

positioned strategically in Southeast

Asia both the Philippines and Vietnam

hold key roles in Regional geopolitics

influencing the Dynamics of the asean

region and Beyond

their geopolitical positioning has

implications on economic Partnerships

security cooperation and Regional

stability

the Philippines as an archipelagic

Nation with over 7 600 Islands boasts a

strategic location along major

International sea routes

this Geographic Advantage has attracted

the attention of various Global Powers

seeking to strengthen their presence in

the indo-pacific region

in his book Asia's new geopolitics

essays on reshaping the indo-pacific

renowned scholar muthya alagapa notes

that the Philippines location has made

it an important player in discussions on

Regional security and Maritime

governance

furthermore the Philippines alliances

and Partnerships have a significant

impact on its geopolitical stance

being a longtime Ally of the United

States the country has aligned itself

with America's vision of a free and open

indo-pacific as highlighted in the book

the indo-pacific region security

governance edited by David Brewster

this partnership plays a crucial role in

Regional security and fosters a balance

of power amidst increasing competition

among major players in the region

on the other hand Vietnam's strategic

location bordering the South China Sea

provides access to vital sea lanes and

abundant Marine Resources

Vietnam's history of territorial

disputes and interactions with its

neighbors especially China have shaped

its geopolitical Outlook

[Music]

the book Vietnam's foreign policy under

doimoy by Ramsay's aimer further

elaborates on Vietnam's policy of

multilateral Engagement to address

Regional issues and maintain stability

Vietnam has also been actively involved

in Regional forms and organizations such

as asean and the east Summit to promote

cooperation and address shared

challenges

its proactive approach to Regional

integration and diplomacy is outlined in

Vietnam's Foreign Relations dynamics of

change edited by Carlisle a Thayer and

Ramsey's aimer

as emerging Powers both the Philippines

and Vietnam seek to nurture positive

relations with their neighbors while

safeguarding their sovereignty and

territorial integrity

their commitment to Regional stability

and cooperation has led them to play

pivotal roles in initiatives like

asean's economic integration and the

regional comprehensive economic

partnership rcep

these geopolitical considerations are

integral to their pursuit of economic

prosperity and Regional dominance

as they navigate the complexities of

geopolitics their strategic positioning

and engagement with global players will

play a vital role in shaping the

trajectory of Southeast Asia's future

after a comprehensive analysis of the

Philippines and Vietnam's economic

strengths demographic advantages trade

orientation policy environments and

geopolitical positioning

it becomes evident that Vietnam stands

as the front runner with the potential

to lead in shaping Southeast Asia's

future

however it's important to acknowledge

that this analysis represents a snapshot

in time and the course of events could

still take unexpected turns

as with any Dynamic and rapidly evolving

region unforeseen events global economic

shifts or changes in political

Landscapes could alter the trajectory of

both Nations

[Music]

geopolitical Dynamics in the

indo-pacific trade disruptions

technological advancements or natural

disasters are just a few examples of

factors that could impact the economic

journey of the Philippines and Vietnam

thank you for watching don't forget to

like comment and subscribe for more

in-depth coverage of more countries stay

informed and we'll see you in our next

video