How nationalism and globalism can coexist | Wanis Kabbaj

Summary

The speaker explores the dichotomy between nationalism and globalism, questioning the need to choose one over the other. They argue that people can simultaneously hold nationalistic pride and a global identity, citing examples of how many national traditions are shaped by global influences. The talk challenges the audience to rethink binary thinking and consider how to embrace both nationalism and globalism effectively.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speaker humorously illustrates the extreme and negative labels associated with both 'nationalist' and 'globalist' on social media, highlighting the intense debate surrounding these ideologies.
• 🌐 The script poses a fundamental question of our time: whether to prioritize nationalism or globalism, and how this choice affects various aspects of society.
• 🏛️ Nationalism is defined as a devotion to one's nation, often prioritizing national interests over international ones, and is seen by some as essential for maintaining social stability.
• 🌍 Globalism, on the other hand, focuses on global economic and foreign policy operations, aiming to address large-scale issues that transcend national borders.
• ⚔️ The speaker points out the historical dangers of extreme nationalism, referencing the devastating effects of 20th-century fascisms.
• 🏙️ Globalists argue that global governance is necessary to tackle global problems like climate change, terrorism, and refugee crises, which cannot be addressed by individual nations alone.
• 🌟 The speaker, having lived in multiple continents, questions the binary choice between nationalism and globalism, suggesting that it's possible to have multiple identities and loyalties.
• 🤔 The script challenges the audience to rethink the dichotomy between nationalism and globalism, proposing that we should not have to choose between loving one's country and caring for the world.
• 🌈 The speaker uses examples from history and culture to show that many elements of national identity have been influenced by or originated from outside sources, emphasizing the role of globalization in shaping national traditions.
• 🌟 The script concludes with a call to action for creative, nonbinary solutions that embrace both nationalism and globalism, rather than forcing a choice between them.

Q & A

What are the two main ideologies discussed in the script?

The two main ideologies discussed in the script are nationalism and globalism.

How are the terms 'nationalist' and 'globalist' portrayed on social media according to the script?

On social media, the terms 'nationalist' and 'globalist' are portrayed with strong negative connotations, often associated with derogatory labels and intense criticism.

What is the definition of nationalism given by Collins in the script?

According to the script, Collins defines nationalism as a 'devotion to one's nation' and also as a 'doctrine that puts national interests above international considerations.'

What concerns do globalists have about nationalism as mentioned in the script?

Globalists are alarmed that self-centered nationalism can turn ugly, as seen in 20th-century fascisms, leading to bloody wars, millions of deaths, and immeasurable destruction.

What is the definition of globalism according to the Oxford Living Dictionary in the script?

The Oxford Living Dictionary defines globalism as 'the operation or planning of economic and foreign policy on a global basis.'

What are some of the global issues that globalists argue can only be addressed through global governance?

Globalists argue that global governance is necessary to tackle issues like nuclear proliferation, the global refugee crisis, climate change, terrorism, and the consequences of superhuman AI.

Why does the speaker question the need to choose between nationalism and globalism?

The speaker questions the need to choose because they believe that people already have multiple identities and that it is possible to love one's country and care for the world simultaneously.

What percentage of people in the World Values Survey felt 'very proud' or 'quite proud' of their country?

According to the World Values Survey mentioned in the script, 88.5 percent of people felt 'very proud' or 'quite proud' of their country.

How does the speaker suggest we should approach the relationship between nationalism and globalism?

The speaker suggests that instead of choosing between nationalism and globalism, we should seek creative, nonbinary solutions that allow us to embrace both ideologies.

What is the speaker's perspective on the relationship between national identity and globalization?

The speaker believes that many key ingredients of national identities come from outside national borders, and that globalization can actually help national traditions to be questioned, regenerated, and reinterpreted, keeping them vibrant and relevant.