The Manhunt by Simon Armitage (detailed analysis)
Summary
TLDRThis script discusses Simon Armitage's poem 'The Manhunt,' part of the 2007 documentary 'Forgotten Heroes: The Not Dead,' which focuses on the experiences of ex-soldiers and PTSD. The poem explores the physical and emotional trauma of a soldier, Eddie Bedo, through the eyes of his wife, Laura. Armitage uses delicate metaphors, sound patterns, and vivid imagery to illustrate the wife's gradual journey of reconnecting with her husband, whose injuries have altered him deeply. The poem reflects themes of healing, patience, and intimacy, emphasizing the long-lasting impact of war on soldiers and their families.
Takeaways
- 💡 The poem *The Manhunt* by Simon Armitage is part of a 2008 collection based on testimonies from ex-soldiers, focusing on their struggles with PTSD.
- 📊 A major study found that 13.5% of Iraq and Afghanistan veterans screened positive for PTSD, with some studies showing even higher rates between 20% and 30%.
- 🎖️ The title *Forgotten Heroes: The Not Dead* highlights how wounded veterans often go unnoticed compared to those who died in combat, suggesting that their lives are in limbo.
- 💔 *The Manhunt* is told from the perspective of Laura, the wife of a veteran, Eddie Bedo, who suffered severe physical and psychological injuries during his service in Bosnia.
- 🎯 The poem traces Eddie’s injuries and psychological scars, metaphorically depicting Laura’s slow and careful attempt to reconnect with her husband after his traumatic experience.
- 🖋️ The structure of the poem comprises 13 couplets, mostly end-stopped, with metaphors and enjambment used to reflect the slow, methodical process of healing.
- 💬 Eddie emphasizes the role of his wife in his recovery, calling her one of his 'biggest saviors,' while Laura reflects on her determination to stick by him despite the challenges.
- 🧠 The poem explores the layers of physical and emotional intimacy, suggesting that Eddie’s scars are barriers to full emotional connection, which Laura gradually navigates.
- 🔍 Armitage employs a range of poetic techniques, including alliteration, assonance, and metaphor, to evoke fragility, pain, and the ongoing impact of war on Eddie’s body and psyche.
- 🚶♀️ The poem’s tone is gentle and quiet, reflecting the care and patience Laura shows as she helps her husband cope with his past and begins to heal emotionally and physically.
Q & A
What is the primary focus of Simon Armitage's collection *Forgotten Heroes: The Not Dead*?
-The collection focuses on the testimonies of ex-soldiers who struggle with PTSD after surviving conflicts. It explores both the physical and psychological wounds they suffer.
What does the title *Forgotten Heroes: The Not Dead* imply about returning soldiers?
-The title suggests that soldiers who return wounded but alive are often overlooked in favor of those who have died in combat. While they survive, they are not necessarily regarded as heroes and are stuck in a kind of limbo, not fully alive.
Who is the speaker in Armitage's poem *The Manhunt*?
-The speaker in *The Manhunt* is Laura, the wife of Eddie Bedo, a veteran who suffered severe physical and psychological injuries during his deployment in Bosnia.
What impact did Eddie Bedo's injuries have on him, according to the poem?
-Eddie's injuries, which included life-threatening wounds to his face, jaw, ribs, lungs, and heart, had a lasting impact on him. He states that he was a different person before he got shot, indicating significant physical and psychological trauma.
How does Laura describe her relationship with Eddie after his injuries?
-Laura describes her relationship with Eddie as one of deep support. She says she’s glad she stuck with him and now believes there's nothing she wouldn’t go through with him.
How does Armitage use structure and form in *The Manhunt* to reflect the couple's journey?
-The poem consists of 13 couplets, with most couplets being end-stopped to evoke the careful and slow progress Laura makes in regaining Eddie's trust. The enjambment in certain stanzas reflects moments of anticipation and emotional depth.
What is the significance of the metaphor 'frozen river' in the poem?
-The 'frozen river' metaphor evokes the scar running through Eddie's face, suggesting coldness and immobility. It reflects both his physical injury and emotional disconnection.
What does the phrase 'blown hinge of his lower jaw' symbolize?
-The 'blown hinge' symbolizes Eddie's physical injury but also his inability to open up emotionally, reflecting his psychological barriers after the trauma.
What does the metaphor 'parachute silk of his punctured lung' convey?
-The metaphor 'parachute silk' conveys the fragility of Eddie's physical state and the life-threatening nature of his injuries, as a punctured parachute can no longer function properly.
How does the poem depict Laura’s emotional journey in understanding Eddie’s trauma?
-The poem shows Laura's journey as methodical and patient, gradually moving from superficial physical scars to the deeper emotional pain. By the end, she comes close to fully understanding him, but acknowledges that complete understanding may never be achieved.
Outlines
📝 The Origins of 'The Manhunt' and PTSD in Veterans
The poem 'The Manhunt,' written by Simon Armitage, was first aired in a 2007 Channel 4 documentary 'Forgotten Heroes: The Not Dead' and later published in a 2008 collection of the same name. The collection focuses on veterans' testimonies, particularly those suffering from PTSD. Research has shown that PTSD affects many veterans, with studies reporting rates as high as 30%. The title alludes to the underappreciated plight of wounded veterans who are often overlooked in favor of fallen soldiers. While these veterans survive physically, their experiences leave them in a state of emotional limbo, unable to fully engage with life. 'The Manhunt' specifically highlights the struggles of a returning soldier, Eddie Bedo, through the perspective of his wife, Laura.
💔 Eddie Bedo's War Injuries and the Poem's Themes
Eddie Bedo, a veteran of the Bosnian conflict, describes the horrific injuries he sustained in detail, including a bullet that tore through his face, neck, and body, leaving lasting physical and psychological scars. This poem differs from others in the collection by featuring his wife, Laura, as the speaker. Through her eyes, we witness how Eddie's injuries transformed him, and the poem explores the painstaking journey Laura undertakes to reconnect with him. Eddie emphasizes the crucial support Laura provides, explaining that he couldn't function without her, highlighting the emotional toll war takes on families.
🌿 Laura's Gentle Persistence and Intimacy
The poem is structured in 13 couplets, divided into five sentences, with most couplets end-stopped to create a rhythmic pace, reflecting Laura's slow, careful progress in regaining her husband’s trust. As Laura traces the physical damage Eddie endured, she metaphorically follows the emotional scars left by the war. The enjambment in the 11th and 12th stanzas signals the tension and anticipation Laura feels as she approaches understanding the deeper source of Eddie's trauma. Simon Armitage employs a mix of sound patterns such as alliteration, consonance, and oblique rhyme to convey the poem's emotional complexity and tenderness.
🚶♀️ Emotional Depth in the Poetic Journey
As Laura moves through the stages of Eddie's physical recovery, the language in the poem reflects her increasing understanding of his emotional pain. Armitage uses metaphor and martial language to evoke Eddie’s lingering connection to war, such as 'phase' and 'bullet.' Despite reaching physical intimacy with Eddie, Laura’s journey toward emotional closeness is much more delicate. The poem’s use of gentle, caring language and martial metaphors reflects the difficulty of dealing with trauma, and how healing occurs in careful, methodical steps. This emotional distance between physical and emotional intimacy is explored with metaphors like 'the frozen river' and the delicate imagery of touching Eddie’s scars.
🧠 Scars of War and Emotional Healing
Laura’s journey to reconnect with Eddie continues as she carefully touches his physical scars, symbolizing the emotional wounds he has yet to reveal. The poem highlights the fragility of Eddie’s body through metaphors like 'porcelain collarbone' and 'fractured rudder,' indicating the emotional and physical impact of his injuries. Laura’s careful actions, described using polysyndeton and assonance, show her determination and patience in supporting Eddie. Each verb, such as 'handle' and 'hold,' conveys a sense of gentleness, while the martial imagery of parachutes and rudders illustrates Eddie's lingering disconnection from his former self.
🪡 Rebuilding Trust and Emotional Intimacy
Laura begins to feel closer to Eddie as she metaphorically binds his ribs and helps him heal emotionally. The use of climbing imagery, such as 'rungs of his broken ribs,' indicates the progress she’s made in mending his emotional wounds. Armitage emphasizes the fragility of Eddie’s emotional state through sound patterning and the shift in verbs from 'would let' to 'could,' marking Laura’s increasing confidence in helping her husband. As the poem progresses, Laura begins to feel Eddie’s emotional hurt, metaphorically depicted through his 'grazed heart,' showcasing her empathy and deepening emotional connection.
💣 The Psychological Trauma Beneath the Surface
Laura’s exploration of Eddie’s psychological trauma reaches a pivotal moment when she pictures the bullet lodged in his chest, described as a 'fetus of metal.' The juxtaposition of life and destruction through this metaphor reveals the depth of Eddie’s emotional wounds. As Laura traces the emotional source of his pain, the imagery of a 'sweating unexploded mine' reflects the volatility of his trauma. The tension builds as Laura nears the core of Eddie’s suffering, with every nerve in his body 'tightened and closed' around his emotional scars, indicating the potential danger if she missteps.
🎯 Nearing the Emotional Core
In the poem’s final sentence, Laura comes close to understanding the full extent of Eddie’s trauma. The repetition of 'then and only then' suggests that even after a long, careful journey, the emotional distance remains significant. Laura’s metaphorical hunt for Eddie’s true self—trapped by war trauma—ends with her acknowledging that complete empathy may be impossible. The almost-but-not-quite rhymes in the final lines echo this realization, reinforcing the idea that the journey to emotional intimacy is never fully complete.
📚 Conclusion and Next Steps
The video concludes by encouraging viewers to leave comments with any questions and to subscribe for more content on English language and literature topics. The speaker offers further discussions on exam techniques and in-depth analysis of literary texts, inviting engagement from the audience.
🔖 More Literature and English Language Content
The video wraps up by mentioning future discussions on English literature texts and examination strategies, aimed at students seeking to deepen their understanding of key topics in language and literature.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡PTSD (Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder)
💡Veteran
💡The Manhunt
💡Simon Armitage
💡Physical and Psychological Scars
💡Laura
💡Enjambment
💡Rhyme Scheme
💡War Imagery
💡Limbo
Highlights
The poem 'The Manhunt' explores the physical and psychological wounds sustained by soldiers, seen through the eyes of a wife helping her husband recover from severe injuries.
Eddie Bedo, the veteran in the poem, suffered life-threatening injuries in Bosnia, including damage to his jaw, ribs, lung, heart, and other vital areas.
The poem uses vivid metaphors like 'frozen river' and 'blown hinge' to describe Eddie's scars and his emotional isolation after the trauma.
The speaker, Eddie's wife Laura, plays a critical role in his healing, patiently working through both physical and emotional scars.
The structure of the poem, 13 stanzas of couplets, mirrors Laura's methodical and slow progress in reconnecting with her husband.
The use of enjambment in key stanzas reflects Laura's increasing anticipation and emotional connection with Eddie as she understands his pain more deeply.
Armitage employs sound techniques like alliteration, consonance, and assonance to give the poem cohesion and lyrical quality, enhancing its emotional depth.
The poem does not follow a formal rhyme scheme but uses perfect rhymes in the beginning to suggest the 'easy' part of recovery, contrasting with the complex emotional layers explored later.
Armitage contrasts sexual intimacy with deeper emotional and physical intimacy, showing that trust and healing take time.
The poem's martial semantic field, with words like 'phase' and 'bullet,' emphasizes the ongoing influence of war on Eddie’s rehabilitation and daily life.
The metaphor of the 'unexploded mine' buried in Eddie’s mind symbolizes his unresolved psychological trauma, which could still cause harm.
Armitage uses repetition of the phrase 'only then' to show how Eddie's wife can only progress in her efforts when he is ready, symbolizing the delicate nature of recovery.
The title 'The Manhunt' conveys the wife’s patient search for her husband’s true self, which has been lost in the aftermath of war.
The poem ends on a poignant note, suggesting that despite Laura's efforts, complete emotional healing remains elusive.
The juxtaposition of life-giving and destructive imagery, such as the 'fetus of metal,' highlights the tension between Eddie's survival and his ongoing suffering.
Transcripts
the manhunt or laura's poem
along with eight other poems by simon
armitage
first aired in a channel 4 documentary
entitled
forgotten heroes the not dead in the
winter of 2007
and later appeared in a collection of
the same name in 2008
most of the poems are inspired by the
testimonies of ex-soldiers
focusing on flashbacks that they have
struggled to forget
although they may have physically
survived the conflict
they now suffer from ptsd or
post-traumatic stress disorder
in one major study of 60 000 iraq and
afghanistan veterans
13.5 percent of both deployed and
non-deployed veterans screened positive
for ptsd
although other studies have shown higher
prevalence rates of 20 to 30 percent
the title of the collection forgotten
heroes the not dead
alludes to the way in which those who
are wounded but return
are not necessarily regarded as heroes
often overlooked in favor of those who
have died in combat
if someone is not dead logically they
are alive
but this word has positive connotations
of vitality and exuberance
through his choice of words armitage
appears to suggest that their existence
is a type of limbo
where they may be not dead but they are
also
not fully alive either unable to
participate completely
in everyday life
this poem differs from the others in the
collection in that the speaker is not an
ex-soldier
but returning veteran eddie bedo's wife
the laura of the title
eddie suffered life-threatening and
life-changing physical and psychological
injuries
while deployed in bosnia which he
catalogues in the documentary
and which armitage refers to in the poem
itself
eddie describes how a round hit him in
the face
and entered just beneath his eye
traveling through his cheek
and blowing out the corner of his bottom
jaw
it then went down his neck nicking the
carotid artery in the process
before bouncing off the shoulder blade
and collarbone
shattering both of them
it also broke his ribs puncturing his
lung and scarring the back of his heart
before it ricocheted off his rib cage
going through his lower diaphragm
scraping his stomach and puncturing his
intestine
before coming to rest by his kidney
he explains that this has had a lasting
impact on him
stating that he was a different person
before he got shot
this poem explores the impact of the
physical and psychological wounds
sustained during conflict
seen through the eyes of those at home
to whom these veterans return
and the way in which laura was able
through quiet and dogged determination
to rediscover and reconnect with a
husband who has been irreparably altered
by his physical and psychological scars
eddie explains her importance to him
fortunately my wife is one of my biggest
saviors
i really couldn't function without her
she's everything
i confess my sins tell her my fears
explain my emotions share my nightmares
and she doesn't have to understand
she just has to listen and she does
laura adds i'm glad i stuck with it
because i don't think i'd ever leave now
i don't think there's anything now that
i wouldn't stand up
and go through with him
the poem comprises 13 stanzas each of
which is a couplet
and these make up five sentences of
varying lengths
most couplets are end stopped with a
comma or a full stop
which forces the reader to pause
slightly between stanzas
and evokes the way in which laura is
compelled to take her time of
each step to gain her husband's trust
before moving on to both greater
physical and emotional
intimacy
in the first sentence the reader follows
the speaker's journey downwards
as she traces the more superficial
physical paths of destruction wrought by
the bullets through her husband's body
in the second sentence she is finally
able to travel upwards
and simultaneously more deeply
suggesting that she has made enough
progress to begin to help him rebuild
emotionally
armitage employs enjambment in both
stanzas 11 and 12
which allows the reader to move more
quickly suggesting laura's anticipation
and apprehension as she gets closer to
understanding the source of her
husband's psychological pain
which has changed him from the person
she knew before
there's no formal rhyme scheme although
armitage does employ perfect
single or masculine rhyme in the first
three stanzas to create rhyming couplets
perhaps to suggest that the first bit is
the easy bit
and at the end of the third sentence in
the tenth stanza
perhaps to suggest the end of the
bullet's destructive path
armitage exploits other sound patterning
techniques in the remaining stanzas
such as alliteration consonants
assonance pararime
oblique rhyme and anto necklaces
to give the poem a sense of cohesion and
continuity
while perhaps simultaneously
communicating the increasing complexity
and sensitivity as the speaker delves
deeper
into her husband's psyche the tone of
the poem is quiet and gentle
reflecting the care and tenderness with
which the speaker explores and
tends first to his physical and then his
psychological scars
the poem has no formal metrical
structure but it is given a lyrical
rhythmical quality by armitage's
extensive use of polycindaton
and anaphora with the repetition of the
anapistic
only then did he dumb
which highlights the painstaking nature
of the speaker's attention
as she only gradually moves on to the
next phase when her husband allows her
to
armitage uses words which form a martial
semantic field
such as phase parachute silk
bullet and mine which suggests the
continuing influence of war
over his rehabilitation and post army
life
the title the manhunt has negative
connotations of fugitive criminals
and the active and aggressive organized
search by law enforcement or the
military to capture them and bring them
to justice
eddie is not however physically missing
but emotionally unreachable
struggling to come to terms with
permanent disfigurement and tortured by
the experiences and memories locked
inside him
as we read the poem we realize that
although the speaker's hunt is indeed
active and methodical
it is anything but aggressive as she
gently and assiduously searches for the
man
used here metaphorically to mean his
sense of self
that he is now
the poem starts after the first
phase after passionate nights and
intimate days
the word phase is a military term used
to describe how longer operations are
subdivided into shorter periods
which each have an intermediary tactical
objective
each phase is part of a serial chain of
logically connected activities
which have a definite end goal
the choice of this word immediately
indicates that the couple are on a
journey
which will go through carefully executed
stages
and which will not progress until each
phase is successful
the first phase is sexual contact it is
only when the couple have been sexually
intimate
that her husband will allow laura to
move on to the next phase
which is to be physically intimate as
only then would he let me trace
the frozen river which ran through his
face
this would on first consideration seem
contradictory
after all what is sexual intimacy if it
is not physically intimate
the way in which she is prepared for
sexual contact before allowing her to
touch his scars however
suggests that there are levels of
physical intimacy which go deeper than
sex
his physical scars bear witness to the
trauma he has suffered
and are a direct link to a level of
emotional intimacy that he is just not
ready for yet
note the poem's first instance of the
phrase only then
and the use of the conditional mood here
would let
which both suggest her ability to
proceed further
only when certain conditions have been
met
she is an active participant but only to
the extent to which he
allows her note the way that armitage
then goes on to use a series of
metaphors to describe eddie's injuries
the frozen river which ran through his
face with its illusions of whiteness and
immobility
vividly evokes the long thin ridge of
scar tissue
where the bullet first struck him before
traveling through his cheek
which the speaker gently traces with her
fingertips
the beauty of the natural imagery in
this metaphor suggests her total and
loving acceptance of his changed
appearance
the poem continues only then would he
let me explore the blown hinge of his
lower jaw
not only does this image refer to his
physical injuries
but also perhaps to his inability to
open up and speak about his feelings
the next three stanzas complete the
first sentence
and handle and hold the damaged
porcelain collarbone
and mined and attend the fractured
rudder of shoulder blade
and finger and thumb the parachute silk
of his punctured lung
each couplet begins with an anaphoric
and polysynthetic
and further picked up by the ands
connecting the pairs of verbs in the
first line of each couplet
note how each verb conveys a sense of
gentleness and care
which armitage enhances through his
choices sounds
the aspirated a breathy sound in hinge
is picked up in the alliterative handle
and hold
the oblique internal rhyme of mind and
attend
and further consonants of the heavy d
sound in handle
hold damaged fractured rudder
and shoulder blade means that the reader
is compelled to articulate these lines
slowly and with care
the metaphor porcelain used to describe
her husband's collarbone
evokes not only its whiteness but its
delicacy and fragility
a rudder is a flat piece which is
attached to the stern of a boat
to enable it to be steered
armitage's use of the metaphor fractured
rudder
to describe his shoulder blade perhaps
suggests that he feels directionless and
no longer in control of his own life
armitage captures not only the fragility
and delicacy of his punctured lung
through the metaphor parachute silk
which can be held between a finger and
thumb
but also the life-threatening nature of
his injuries
if a parachute is punctured it is no
longer able to hold air
and so plummets to earth
these stanzas while not employing single
or masculine rhyme as in the first three
stanzas
make use of assonance with the long o
sounds in hold and
bone and short uh sounds in
thumb and lung as well as consonants
with the d sounds at the end of a tend
and blade
to maintain the poem's lyrical quality
the second sentence is notably shorter
at just two stanzas this time
only then could i bind the struts and
climb the rungs of his broken ribs and
feel the hurt of his grazed heart
there's a sense that we've moved on to
the next phase of laura's own
military-style operation now
note that she has taken on more autonomy
before she could only act when he would
let her
but now she becomes more confident and
proactive
indicated by the modal auxiliary verb
could
which is the past tense of can as she is
able to help
him to heal by metaphorically binding or
bandaging
the struts of his broken ribs
a strut is a rod or bar which is a
supporting part of a framework
and armatures is creating the image of a
ladder up which
is able to move as she climbs the rungs
of his broken ribs
here the sound patterning is slightly
more complex
employing assonance in the long i sounds
of
bind and climb and in the short uh
sounds of struts and rungs the
alliteration of
bind and broken and rungs and ribs
as well as the almost perfect rhyme of
lung and rungs
across the stanza break to create a
sense of cohesion
her developing empathy is clear as she
is able to now feel the hurt of his
graced heart
here the image is clearly to do with the
injury he sustained
but it also works on a metaphorical
level
suggesting the emotional pain that he is
suffering
note the para rhyme of hurt and heart
she's getting closer to him all the time
although she is not quite there yet
the third sentence is also two stanzas
long
skirting along only then could i picture
the scan
the fetus of metal beneath his chest
where the bullet had come to rest
the phrasal verb skirting along suggests
that she is tentative and hesitant
she stays at the edges unwilling to jump
straight in
the metaphor fetus of metal to describe
the bullet's final resting place is
sinister
armitage himself explains that he wanted
to capture the moment of shock as the
bullet is located
the word fetus denotes an unborn baby
and usually has positive connotations of
new life
but the juxtaposition of a word which
describes a living being comprising
human flesh
with the uncompromising coldness of
metal
suggests this bullet has the potential
to cause further harm and damage later
on
once more armitage employs single or
masculine rhyme here
the finality and completeness of which
perhaps reflecting
the way in which the bullet's
destructive journey has finally come to
an end
the fourth sentence extends over the
next five lines
then i widened the search trace the
scarring back to its source to a
sweating unexploded mine buried deep in
his mind
around which every nerve in his body had
tightened and
closed note how the sentence begins then
rather than only then the lack of the
adverb
only implying her complete autonomy
and suggesting that she has gained her
husband's total trust
once more the verb traced is used but
this time it has changed in meaning
a form of repetition known as
antonequasis
in a second stanza it was used to evoke
the way in which the speaker physically
traced
with her fingertips the superficial
scarring of his face
now she is tracing or finding through
investigation the source or deep-rooted
cause of his scarring here meant
metaphorically to mean emotional
suffering
and is an indication of just how far the
pair have come on their journey
armitage now employs enjambment across
stanza breaks to give the poem momentum
as the speaker gets ever closer to her
quarry
the source of his pain appears to be a
sweating unexploded mind buried deep in
his mind
a mine is a type of bomb that is placed
on or just below the surface of the
ground
which detonates on contact with a person
or a vehicle
the adjective sweating is probably an
allusion to the night sweats and terrors
which are a symptom of ptsd
but the word also has connotations of
something that is festering beneath the
surface
this in conjunction with the adjective
unexploded
suggests that it still has the potential
to cause further destruction
and injury there's an implication that
if she does not metaphorically tread
carefully
she runs the risk of unwittingly
detonating the mine
which could bring about a violent
outburst of rage
or breakdown as a self-defense mechanism
every nerve in his body has tightened
and closed
around these memories in an attempt to
keep them locked away
the almost but not quite identical
sounds of mind and mind
here are another indication of just how
close laura is in her quest
and armitage's own words to defuse him
as one would a bomb
the final sentence is one line long it
is short and to the point
then and only then did i come close
even after a long and painstaking
journey of discovery through the
building of intimacy and trust
she still has yet to find him totally
note in another example of antoniquezis
the repetition of closed and close
here which has an almost identical rhyme
with a harsher sound in the former and
the softest
sound in the latter there's a suggestion
that unless we have had these
experiences at first
hand our empathy can only ever be
incomplete
and this is echoed in the almost but not
quite rhyming of this final couplet
thanks for watching
if you have any questions please let me
know in the comments section below
and i'll do my best to answer them don't
forget to subscribe to my channel for
more videos on english language topics
and exam techniques
and english literature texts
Weitere ähnliche Videos ansehen
The Road Not Taken by Robert Frost: Summary and Literature Analysis
Phân tích TÂY TIẾN - phần I - Thầy Linh Mega Văn - Seri bài giảng Flipbook Ngữ Văn 12
Strangers Forever - Poem Analysis
Street Dog
Detailed Line By Line Explanation of INVICTUS a poem by William Ernest Henley
Analysis of ‘Poem at Thirty-Nine’ by Alice Walker
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)