Where did God come from ? - Best answer Dr. Kent Hovind vs Reinhold Schlieter Debate

ghitamoldovan

17 Jul 201603:25

Summary

TLDRThe speaker addresses the philosophical inquiry into the nature of God and the relationship between the spiritual and material realms. They argue that the concept of God, as understood in the Bible, transcends time, space, and matter, and thus cannot be limited by them. The speaker challenges the idea that a spiritual force cannot influence the material world, using emotions and human reasoning as examples of spiritual elements that affect our physical existence. They assert that God, being the creator of the universe, must exist outside of it, unaffected by the constructs of time, space, and matter.

Takeaways

🕰 The concept of God in the script is one that is not bound by time, space, or matter, suggesting a divine being that exists outside of the physical universe.
🌌 The script argues that time, space, and matter are interconnected and must have come into existence simultaneously, as they are interdependent.
📜 The Bible is referenced as stating that God created time, space, and matter, implying a divine origin for the universe.
🔄 The idea of a 'Trinity of Trinity's' is introduced, suggesting a complex, interconnected nature of time, space, and matter.
🤔 The script challenges the idea that a spiritual force cannot impact a material universe, using human emotions and consciousness as examples of non-material influences on the physical world.
🧠 It questions the reliability of human reasoning if the brain is considered to be a random collection of chemicals, implying that there might be more to consciousness than mere chemistry.
💭 The discussion suggests that if God could be fully understood by the human brain, then God would not be infinite or worthy of worship.
📖 The script implies that philosophical debates about the nature of God and the universe have been ongoing, referencing past discussions about spiritual and material matter.
👼 A rhetorical question is posed about how many angels can dance on the tip of a pen, which is a playful way to discuss the nature of spiritual matter and its relation to physical space.
⏳ The speaker emphasizes that the God they worship is not limited by human understanding or the constraints of the physical world.

Q & A

What is the philosophical issue the speaker is addressing?
-The speaker is addressing the philosophical issue of reconciling the existence of a timeless, spaceless, and immaterial God with the material universe.
How does the speaker define the concept of God in relation to time, space, and matter?
-The speaker defines God as being outside of time, space, and matter, unaffected by them, and as the creator of all three.
What is the significance of the phrase 'in the beginning' in the context of the speaker's argument?
-The phrase 'in the beginning' signifies the creation of time, space, and matter simultaneously, as per the speaker's interpretation of the Bible.
How does the speaker refute the idea that a spiritual force cannot affect a material universe?
-The speaker refutes this idea by questioning how material processes alone can account for immaterial phenomena such as emotions and rationality.
What is the 'Trinity of Trinity's' mentioned by the speaker?
-The 'Trinity of Trinity's' refers to the interconnectedness of time (past, present, future), space (length, width, height), and matter (solid, liquid, gas), all of which were created simultaneously.
Why does the speaker argue that if God were limited by time, space, or matter, He would not be God?
-The speaker argues that God must be unlimited by time, space, or matter because these are creations and God, as the creator, must be beyond His creation.
What is the speaker's stance on the ability of the human brain to reason if it is just a collection of chemicals?
-The speaker challenges the idea that the human brain, if merely a collection of chemicals, can be trusted to produce reliable reasoning and thoughts.
How does the speaker respond to the question of where God comes from?
-The speaker responds by stating that the question assumes a limited God, whereas the God he worships is not limited by time, space, or matter.
What is the speaker's view on the capacity of the human brain to comprehend the infinite nature of God?
-The speaker believes that if the infinite nature of God could be fully comprehended by the human brain, which is limited, then God would not be worthy of worship.
What is the analogy used by the speaker to illustrate the creator's relationship to creation?
-The speaker uses the analogy of a computer's creator not being inside the computer, to illustrate that God, as the creator, is not contained within the universe.
What is the speaker's perspective on the debate format that requires addressing one question at a time?
-The speaker seems to be slightly frustrated with the debate format, as he prefers to address multiple aspects of the topic in a more fluid manner.

Outlines

00:00

🤔 Philosophical Inquiry on God's Origin and Influence

The speaker begins with a philosophical dilemma regarding the consistency of being honest and the concept of God. They question the origin of God and how a spiritual force can impact a material universe. The speaker recalls a previous discussion about the nature of spiritual and material matter, using the example of angels and a pen to illustrate the point. The conversation shifts to a debate format, where the speaker is asked to address two questions: the story of the universe's beginning and the impact of a spiritual force on matter. The speaker clarifies that the concept of God they discuss is not bound by time, space, or matter, as per the Biblical view. They argue that time, space, and matter are interdependent and must have been created simultaneously, with God being the creator who exists outside of these dimensions. The speaker challenges the idea that a spiritual force cannot affect a material body, using emotions and rationality as examples of spiritual influences on the material brain.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡God

In the context of the video, 'God' refers to the supreme being as understood in the Abrahamic religions, particularly in the Christian tradition. The speaker argues that God is not bound by time, space, or matter, which is a common theological perspective. The video discusses the concept of God's existence being outside of and unaffected by the physical universe, which is a central theme in monotheistic religions.

💡Philosophically consistent

This term refers to the idea of having a coherent and logical set of beliefs or principles. The video script implies that being philosophically consistent is important for understanding complex concepts like the nature of God and the universe. The speaker uses this term to critique the idea of a limited God, suggesting that a truly infinite and supreme being cannot be confined by human logic or understanding.

💡Honest person

The term 'honest person' in the script suggests someone who is truthful and sincere. It's used to emphasize the speaker's commitment to exploring and expressing the truth about the nature of God and the universe. The speaker's honesty is contrasted with the perceived limitations of human understanding, suggesting that while the speaker strives for honesty, the full truth may be beyond human comprehension.

💡Spiritual force

A 'spiritual force' in the video refers to a non-physical or divine power that is believed to influence or interact with the material world. The speaker challenges the idea that a spiritual force cannot impact the material universe, suggesting that such a force is responsible for the creation of the universe and all that is within it. This concept is central to many religious and philosophical discussions about the origins of existence.

💡Material universe

The 'material universe' is the physical reality that we can observe and interact with, consisting of matter and energy. The video discusses how a spiritual force, such as God, can have an impact on this material universe. The concept is central to the debate about the relationship between the spiritual and physical realms and how they might interact.

💡Time, space, and matter

These are fundamental aspects of the universe as understood in physics and cosmology. In the video, the speaker argues that time, space, and matter are interconnected and must have been created simultaneously. This is used to support the idea that God, being outside of these dimensions, is the creator of the universe.

💡Continuum

A 'continuum' in the video refers to the idea that time, space, and matter are interdependent and cannot exist independently of one another. The speaker uses this concept to argue against the possibility of God being limited by these dimensions, as they are part of the created order and not the creator.

💡Trinity

The 'Trinity' in the video is a theological concept in Christianity that describes the nature of God as three persons—Father, Son, and Holy Spirit—coexisting in one being. The speaker mentions 'Trinity of Trinity's' to emphasize the complexity and depth of God's nature, which is beyond human understanding.

💡Emotions

Emotions such as love, hatred, envy, and jealousy are mentioned in the video to illustrate the non-material aspects of human experience. The speaker questions how these can exist if the brain is merely a collection of chemicals, suggesting that there is more to human consciousness than just the material brain, hinting at a spiritual dimension.

💡Rationality

Rationality refers to the ability to think logically and make decisions based on reason. In the video, the speaker challenges the idea that rational thought can be solely attributed to material processes in the brain, suggesting that there might be a spiritual or divine aspect to human reasoning that transcends the physical.

💡Angels

Angels are mentioned in the video as a metaphor for spiritual beings that exist outside of the material realm. The speaker uses the rhetorical question about how many angels can dance on the tip of a pen to illustrate the idea that spiritual matter does not occupy physical space, contrasting it with material matter.

Highlights

The concept of God being beyond time, space, and matter is introduced.

The philosophical debate on the consistency of being honest and philosophically consistent is mentioned.

The question of God's origin is addressed with a reference to the Bible's perspective on creation.

The idea that time, space, and matter are interdependent and must exist simultaneously is presented.

The Bible's creation narrative is summarized in ten words, emphasizing the trinity of time, space, and matter.

The concept of a Trinity of Trinity's is introduced to describe the complexity of time, space, and matter.

The necessity for God to be outside of time, space, and matter to be considered God is argued.

The debate format's requirement to address one question at a time is mentioned.

The question of how a spiritual force can impact a material universe is posed.

The example of emotions as a spiritual force that affects the material body is used to illustrate the point.

The challenge to trust reasoning processes if the brain is a random collection of chemicals is raised.

The idea that a limited God would not be worth worshiping is expressed.

The debate's focus on the beginning of the universe and the impact of spiritual matter on material man is highlighted.

The philosophical question of how many angels can dance on the tip of a pen is mentioned as a reversal experience.

The importance of God being unaffected by the universe to maintain divine status is emphasized.

The debate's structure and the speaker's wish for Quartz are briefly touched upon.