Why do horn players have TERRIBLE rhythm? | Q+A

Summary

In this video, the host explores the rhythmic complexity of triplets and quintuplets, discusses the late timing of horn sections, and the potential reasons behind it. They also touch on the presence of beatboxing in the New York music scene, offer tips for making guitar solos sound unique, and delve into advanced music theory with a discussion on resolving complex chords. The host shares personal anecdotes, including their channel's growth and the decision between living in LA or New York for a musical career. They also address the perception of video game music, the challenges of playing music with a hand injury, and the impact of digital audio workstations on music accessibility.

Takeaways

• 🎶 The logic behind the 'super fast q and a' song is the superimposition of triplets against quintuplets, creating a unique rhythmic feel.
• 🎷 Horn sections often play behind the beat due to a focus on improvisation over rhythm, and possibly due to their training in following visual cues in school band programs.
• 🗣️ Beatboxing as a solo art has a presence in the New York music scene, with artists like Jean Shinozaki incorporating it into orchestral settings.
• 🎸 To make guitar solos sound less like guitar solos, try playing on a single string to break away from typical guitar licks and muscle memory.
• 🎵 The favorite contemporary composer of the 21st century mentioned is Louis Cole, highlighting the appreciation for modern musical innovation.
• 🏙️ The discussion on whether to stay in New York for the music scene or move to LA for industry opportunities reflects the balance between artistic community and career advancement.
• 🍗 A humorous aside about Peruvian chicken and Inca Kola adds a personal touch, showing the speaker's cultural interests beyond music.
• 🎹 Christian Lee is praised for his unique approach to harmony and piano playing, demonstrating the value of individuality in music.
• 🔍 The 'alphabetical rule' in music notation explains the use of double sharps and double flats, providing insight into the logic behind Western music theory.
• 🎮 Video game music is discussed as a legitimate art form, with creators working to canonize it alongside traditional musical genres.

Q & A

What is the main concept behind the super fast Q and A song?

The main concept is superimposing triplets against quintuplets, creating a rhythmic interplay where the vocal rhythm is in triplets and the groove and bassline are in quintuplets.

Why do horn sections often sound slightly behind the beat?

Horn players tend to focus more on improvisation than rhythm, which can lead to a laid-back feel. Additionally, horn players often start in school band programs where they follow visual cues rather than dictating the groove.

How does beatboxing fit into the New York music scene?

Beatboxing has a strong presence in New York City, with groups like the Beatbox House performing at venues like Rockwood Music Hall, creating a full band sound with just vocal percussion.

What is one way to make guitar solos sound less like traditional guitar solos?

Focusing on the vertical side of the instrument by playing solos on a single string can lead to a different, more un-guitaristic feel, as suggested by the exercise in 'The Advancing Guitarist' by Mick Goodrick.

Who is a favorite contemporary composer mentioned in the script?

Louis Cole is mentioned as a favorite contemporary composer, known for his unique approach to harmony and emotion in music.

How can a musician resolve a complex chord like A6 sharp 5 sharp 9 11?

To resolve a dissonant chord like A6 sharp 5 sharp 9 11, one can resolve all the voices within the chord by a half step, creating a new chord that follows the cadential patterns of the western harmonic canon.

What is the 'alphabetical rule' in western music notation?

The alphabetical rule states that for every seven-note scale, each note must be named in alphabetical order, leading to the use of double sharps and other unusual note names to maintain this sequence.

What advice is given for musicians who want to pursue a career in music but are based in LA?

While New York has a vibrant music scene, LA is the center of the music industry with more job opportunities. It's suggested that LA is where the industry is, making it a better place for career advancement.

How does the script address the perception of video game music as not 'real music'?

The script suggests that the perception of video game music as not 'real music' is similar to the historical view of film music. It points out that it takes time for new art forms to be accepted and that platforms like YouTube are helping to canonize and celebrate video game music.

What is the significance of the alphabetical rule in naming notes in western music?

The alphabetical rule ensures that note names are consistent and predictable, which is crucial for reading and writing music. However, it can lead to unusual note names like double sharps and has implications for naming chords and scales.