Apakah Mercedes Benz Lebih Awet Dari Pada BMW ??

FUSE BOX

6 Aug 202410:01

Summary

TLDRThe video script discusses the reliability of BMW and Mercedes-Benz cars, addressing the controversy surrounding their maintenance issues. It compares the electrical complexities and engine problems of both brands, noting that while BMW has a reputation for more plastic parts leading to unreliability, Mercedes faces higher maintenance costs. The script also touches on the improvements in BMW's reliability rankings and the impact of specific engine models like BMW's N20 and the newer B48. It concludes by emphasizing that reliability is subjective and often depends on the individual car's condition, suggesting that both brands have their strengths and weaknesses.

Takeaways

😀 The video discusses the controversy over the reliability of BMW and Mercedes-Benz, suggesting that opinions may vary based on personal experiences with the cars.
🏁 Many BMW owners who have experienced car troubles tend to agree with the video's content, while those without issues may disagree.
🛠️ Both BMW and Mercedes-Benz are known for their complex electrical systems, which can lead to maintenance challenges and potential reliability issues.
🔋 Despite similar electrical complexity, Mercedes-Benz is considered slightly more reliable in this aspect compared to BMW.
🚗 BMW has been reported to have more engine-related problems than Mercedes-Benz, especially with the use of excessive plastic components.
🏆 However, BMW still ranks higher in terms of reliability, placing 9th in a list of reliable cars, while Mercedes-Benz ranks 29th.
📉 A significant drop in Mercedes-Benz's reliability ranking is attributed to issues with their latest models and the use of engines supplied by Renault.
💰 The cost of maintaining and repairing Mercedes-Benz cars is significantly higher than that of BMW.
🔧 Both BMW and Mercedes-Benz face technical issues after the warranty period, but the nature and frequency of these issues can be subjective and vary between individual cars.
🚀 BMW has made improvements in its use of plastic components, collaborating with Toyota to create the Supra MK5 and Z4, which incorporate fewer plastic parts.
🌟 Mercedes-Benz is traditionally seen as a more luxurious brand, with even its entry-level models offering a touch of opulence, while BMW is known for its sporty character and driving experience.
🏁 The conclusion suggests that the reliability of BMW and Mercedes-Benz is subjective and largely depends on individual car conditions and luck, rather than the brand as a whole.

Q & A

What is the main topic of the video script discussing?
-The main topic of the video script is comparing the reliability and longevity of BMW and Mercedes-Benz cars.
Why do some viewers agree with the video's content?
-Some viewers agree with the video's content because they are BMW owners who have experienced car issues, validating the points made in the video.
Why might other viewers disagree with the video's content?
-Other viewers might disagree because they are also BMW owners but have not experienced the issues mentioned, leading them to believe the video's claims are not universally applicable.
What is a common question people ask when considering European cars?
-A common question people ask is which brand, Mercedes or BMW, is more durable or reliable over time.
What are some of the issues with BMW's electrical systems mentioned in the script?
-The script mentions that BMW's electrical systems are complex and prone to failure, making maintenance difficult.
How does the script compare the electrical systems of BMW and Mercedes-Benz?
-The script states that while both BMW and Mercedes-Benz have complex electrical systems, Mercedes-Benz's systems are slightly more reliable than BMW's.
What material is said to make BMW engines less reliable than Mercedes-Benz engines?
-The script suggests that the use of more plastic components in BMW engines makes them less reliable than Mercedes-Benz engines.
According to the script, which car brand ranks higher in terms of reliability?
-According to the script, BMW ranks higher in terms of reliability compared to Mercedes-Benz.
What is one of the main issues with Mercedes-Benz engines as discussed in the script?
-One of the main issues with Mercedes-Benz engines mentioned in the script is problems with the electrical systems and the use of engines supplied by雷诺.
What is the script's view on the maintenance costs of luxury cars like BMW and Mercedes-Benz?
-The script suggests that luxury cars like BMW and Mercedes-Benz are more expensive to maintain and repair compared to regular cars.
What does the script suggest about the perception of BMW and Mercedes-Benz in terms of luxury and sportiness?
-The script suggests that Mercedes-Benz is traditionally seen as more luxurious, while BMW is considered sportier and more fun to drive.
How does the script address the issue of reliability in older BMW and Mercedes-Benz models?
-The script indicates that older Mercedes-Benz models are more reliable, described as 'like a tank', while older BMW models tend to have more issues and are less reliable.
What advice does the script give regarding the use of BMW and Mercedes-Benz cars?
-The script advises using these cars while the warranty is still valid and to be prepared for potential maintenance issues after the warranty period.

Outlines

00:00

🚗 Controversial Car Brand Debate: BMW vs Mercedes

The script starts with a discussion on a potentially controversial topic: the reliability of BMW and Mercedes cars. It mentions that while some viewers may agree with the content, others may not, and this is often influenced by their personal experiences with the brands. The video aims to compare the longevity and reliability of BMW and Mercedes-Benz, both considered luxury European car brands. It highlights that luxury cars are more expensive to maintain and repair, but are still sought after by millionaires for their comfort, performance, and prestige. The script also points out that while both BMW and Mercedes have complex electrical systems, which can lead to maintenance issues, Mercedes seems to have a slight edge in reliability, although the difference is not significant.

05:01

🔍 Deep Dive into BMW and Mercedes Reliability Issues

This paragraph delves deeper into the specific issues faced by BMW and Mercedes vehicles. It contrasts the reliability of BMW's electrical systems with Mercedes', noting that while both are complex, Mercedes appears to have a more reliable electrical system. The script also discusses the problems associated with BMW's engines, particularly the N20 engine, which had numerous issues until the introduction of the B48 engine in 2017. Mercedes, on the other hand, has faced issues with its electronics and the recent recall of nearly 300,000 SUVs due to a problem with the 'karat'. The paragraph also touches on the quality of engines supplied by external manufacturers for some Mercedes models and the issues with Mercedes' own 9G-Tronic gearbox. The summary concludes with a subjective note on reliability, suggesting that individual luck and the specific unit one gets plays a significant role in the perceived reliability of these cars.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Controversial

Controversial refers to matters that are subject to significant disagreement or debate. In the video's context, it is used to describe the content that may be seen as debatable due to presenting facts that some viewers might find disagreeable. For example, the script mentions that the content might be controversial, but it's actually factual, implying that the controversy arises from differing perspectives among viewers.

💡BMW

BMW is a German multinational corporation producing luxury vehicles and motorcycles. The video discusses the reliability and maintenance issues of BMW cars, contrasting them with Mercedes. For instance, the script talks about BMW users who are satisfied and dissatisfied with their vehicles, highlighting the brand's reputation for certain technical issues.

💡Mercedes-Benz

Mercedes-Benz is a German luxury automobile brand, often compared with BMW in terms of luxury and performance. The video script compares the reliability and longevity of Mercedes-Benz with BMW, discussing various technical issues and their impact on the brand's reputation.

💡Reliability

Reliability in the context of the video refers to the dependability and consistency of a vehicle's performance over time without frequent breakdowns. The script explores the reliability of BMW and Mercedes-Benz, mentioning that while both have issues, BMW ranks higher in a reliability ranking.

💡Luxury Cars

Luxury cars are vehicles that provide a high level of comfort, advanced features, and prestigious branding, often at a higher cost. The video discusses BMW and Mercedes-Benz as luxury car brands, emphasizing their appeal to millionaires and the higher costs associated with their maintenance.

💡Technical Issues

Technical issues refer to problems related to the mechanical or electrical aspects of a vehicle. The script delves into the technical issues faced by BMW and Mercedes-Benz, such as electrical problems and engine issues, which affect the vehicles' reliability.

💡Maintenance

Maintenance is the process of keeping a vehicle in good condition through regular checks and repairs. The video mentions that luxury cars like BMW and Mercedes-Benz are more expensive to maintain and repair, which is a significant factor in their overall cost of ownership.

💡Electrical Systems

Electrical systems in vehicles consist of all the electrical components and circuits that control various functions. The script points out that BMW has complex electrical systems, which can lead to more maintenance issues compared to Mercedes-Benz, although both brands have sophisticated electrical components.

💡Plastic Components

Plastic components are used in vehicles for various parts, but their use can affect the vehicle's durability. The video script notes that BMW uses more plastic in its engines than Mercedes-Benz, which may contribute to perceived unreliability in certain BMW models.

💡Sporty

Sporty, in the context of cars, refers to the performance-oriented and dynamic driving characteristics. The script contrasts the sporty nature of BMW with the luxurious comfort of Mercedes-Benz, suggesting that BMW is more fun to drive, while Mercedes-Benz is more about comfort and prestige.

💡Warranty

A warranty is a guarantee provided by the manufacturer that covers the cost of repairs for a certain period or mileage. The video mentions that both BMW and Mercedes-Benz are protected by warranties when new, but after the warranty period, the vehicles may start facing technical issues that require costly repairs.

Highlights

The video discusses the controversial topic of comparing the reliability of BMW and Mercedes cars.

The content is based on facts, but opinions on the video's stance vary among viewers.

BMW owners with problematic cars tend to agree with the video, while those with reliable BMWs disagree.

Mercedes owners with non-problematic cars are likely to disagree with the video's content.

The video addresses the common debate of which European car brand, BMW or Mercedes, is more durable.

Both BMW and Mercedes are luxury car brands known for their comfort, performance, and prestige.

Luxury cars are more expensive to maintain and repair compared to regular vehicles.

Despite high maintenance costs, millionaires still prefer luxury cars for their comfort and image.

Both BMW and Mercedes have complex electrical systems, making them more prone to technical issues.

Mercedes is considered slightly more reliable in terms of electrical systems compared to BMW.

BMW engines have more reported issues than Mercedes, but this does not mean Mercedes is without problems.

Mercedes does not use as much plastic in their engines as BMW, which might contribute to its reliability.

BMW ranks higher in reliability ratings compared to Mercedes Benz.

The video provides specific examples of BMW engine issues, such as the N20 engine's problems before 2017.

Mercedes has faced issues with their electronic systems and had to recall nearly 300,000 vehicles due to a problem with their airbags.

The latest models of Mercedes, particularly the A, CLA, and C class, have engines supplied by Renault which may not match Mercedes' quality standards.

Mercedes' own 9G-Tronic transmission has been reported to be prone to damage.

BMW sources their gearboxes from ZF and installs specific software to ensure compatibility with their engines.

The video suggests that the reliability of BMW and Mercedes cars is subjective and depends on individual car conditions.

Older Mercedes models are described as being like tanks, durable and resistant to various conditions.

In contrast, older BMW models are said to have more issues and are less reliable than Mercedes.

The video concludes that the reliability of BMW and Mercedes cars is similar, and the choice between them depends on personal preference and driving style.

BMW is known for its sporty driving experience, while Mercedes is known for its luxury and comfort.