Will Rail Nationalisation Work?

Summary

The UK's rail system faces high costs and poor service, prompting the Shapps Williams plan to nationalize railways under Great British Rail. Both Conservative and Labour governments support this initiative, aiming to improve the rail franchising system introduced in 1996. The Labour government plans to establish Great British Railways by the end of the Parliament, focusing on cutting waste, enhancing passenger standards, and introducing digital season tickets and an automatic delay repay system.

Takeaways

• 🚂 The UK's rail transport is known for being expensive and often more costly than plane tickets to other countries, with an inconsistent and poor-quality experience.
• 🎟️ The previous Conservative government, along with the Rail Review led by Keith Williams, proposed the 'Williams-Shapps Plan' to address rail issues, which included plans for nationalization under 'Great British Rail'.
• 🔄 There is a consensus between the previous and current UK governments on the establishment of Great British Railways, as confirmed in the recent King's speech.
• 📚 The script takes a historical perspective, explaining the shift from nationalized British Rail to the current franchising system in 1996.
• 💷 The franchising system has faced issues with private companies going bankrupt, leading to the government stepping in as the operator of last resort.
• 🛤️ The government became the largest rail operator in the UK due to taking over franchises that had become unsustainable, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic.
• 🔄 The Williams-Shapps review recommended the creation of Great British Railways, which would be government-operated and own the infrastructure but not the trains.
• 📉 The Labour government plans to continue with the establishment of Great British Railways, waiting for existing franchise contracts to expire before nationalizing them.
• 🚫 While pursuing nationalization, the Labour government will not nationalize rail freight companies or hinder Open Access operators like Hull Trains and Lumo.
• 💼 Labour has proposed further changes, such as cutting waste, creating a Passenger Standards Authority, introducing digital season tickets, and an automatic delay repay system.
• 📝 The new government has introduced the Railway Services Public Ownership Bill as a starting point for establishing Great British Railways, but it has not yet become law.

Q & A

What is the main issue with the UK's rail transport system as described in the script?

The UK's rail transport system is criticized for being expensive, with fares sometimes higher than plane tickets to other countries, and the service is often overcrowded, late, or cancelled, providing poor value for money.

What was the 'Shapps Williams Plan' proposed by the Conservative government to address the rail transport issues?

The 'Shapps Williams Plan' aimed to nationalize the railways under a new company called Great British Rail, which would own the infrastructure and be responsible for running and planning passenger rail services.

What is the current stance of the Labour government on the 'Shapps Williams Plan'?

The Labour government agrees with the Conservatives on the plan and is committed to continuing the process of establishing Great British Railways, as mentioned in the recent King's speech.

What was the UK's passenger rail network like before 1996?

Before 1996, the UK's passenger rail network was nationalized under British Rail, and it was in the process of transitioning to the current rail franchising system.

How does the rail franchising system work?

The government offers contracts to private companies for groups of rail routes, including both profitable and less profitable ones. The successful franchises are required to operate all routes within their franchise to ensure connectivity for smaller towns.

What is the 'Operator of Last Resort' and why has it become relevant?

The 'Operator of Last Resort' is a term used when the government steps in to operate a rail franchise because the franchisee has gone bust or is unable to meet the terms of their contract. It became relevant as many franchisees failed, forcing the state to intervene.

How did the COVID-19 pandemic impact the rail franchising model?

The COVID-19 pandemic made the franchising model unsustainable, as franchisees had to run routes regardless of passenger numbers, which were significantly reduced due to lockdown restrictions.

What changes did the government implement in response to the pandemic's impact on the rail franchising model?

The government ended the contract system, allowing operators to transfer all revenue and cost risks to the state while receiving a small management fee for continuing to run the services, essentially a form of temporary nationalization.

What responsibilities would Great British Railways take on according to the Williams Review?

Great British Railways would own the infrastructure, receive fare revenue, run and plan timetables for passenger rail, and take back control of all railway tracks, simplifying the network of responsibilities related to rail infrastructure.

What are some of the Labour government's additional plans for the rail system beyond the creation of Great British Railways?

The Labour government plans to cut waste, claw back shareholder dividends, create a new Passenger Standards Authority as a watchdog, introduce digital season tickets, and establish a new automatic delay repay system.

What has the Labour government done so far in terms of implementing the plans for the rail system?

They have introduced the new Passenger Railway Services Public Ownership bill, which is a starting point for establishing Great British Railways, but it has not yet become law.

Outlines

00:00

🚂 UK Rail System Overhaul: The Shapps Williams Plan

This paragraph discusses the high costs and poor service quality of the UK's rail transport system, which often outprices air travel. It outlines the Shapps Williams plan, a nationalization initiative proposed by the Conservative government and supported by the Labour government, aiming to establish a new company called Great British Rail. The plan seeks to address the issues of an overcrowded, unreliable, and expensive rail system by centralizing control under the government. The paragraph also provides historical context, explaining the shift from nationalized British Rail to the current franchising system in 1996, which has led to numerous bankruptcies and government intervention as the operator of last resort.

05:01

🛤️ Labour's Commitment to Great British Railways and Future Rail Reforms

The second paragraph details the Labour government's agreement with the Conservatives on the establishment of Great British Railways, as mentioned in the King's Speech. The Labour government plans to wait for existing rail franchise contracts to expire before transitioning them under government control, forming part of the nationalized entity. While some operators like Open Access will continue to operate independently, the Labour government intends to go beyond mere nationalization by cutting waste, reclaiming shareholder dividends, establishing a Passenger Standards Authority, introducing digital season tickets, and setting up an automatic delay repay system. The paragraph also notes the limited progress made so far, with the introduction of the Railway Services Public Ownership bill and the Labour government's aim to have Great British Rail operational by the end of the current parliamentary term.

Keywords

💡Nebula

Nebula is a streaming service co-owned by the creators of the video and other content creators. It is mentioned at the beginning and end of the script as the sponsor of the video. The service offers original content and ad-free viewing of videos like the one being described, with a special offer for new subscribers mentioned in the transcript.

💡Rail Transport

Rail transport in the UK is the main subject of the video, discussing its current state, issues, and proposed changes. The script describes it as 'strange and expensive,' highlighting problems such as high costs, overcrowding, and unreliability compared to other forms of transportation.

💡Nationalization

Nationalization refers to the process where the government takes control of industries or services. In the context of the video, it discusses the plan to nationalize the UK's rail system under a new company called Great British Rail, which is a key part of the proposed reforms.

💡Shaps Williams Plan

The Shaps Williams Plan is a proposal for reforming the UK's rail system, named after the then Transport Secretary Grant Shapps and the head of the Rail Review, Keith Williams. The plan suggests significant changes to how the railways are operated, including the creation of Great British Rail.

💡Franchise System

The franchise system is the current model of UK rail operation where private companies operate routes based on contracts with the government. The script describes issues with this system, such as companies going bust and the government having to step in as the operator of last resort.

💡Operator of Last Resort

The term 'Operator of Last Resort' is used when the government steps in to run rail services because the private franchise holder is unable to do so. The script mentions this occurred with several franchises, including TransPennine Express, highlighting the failure of the franchise system.

💡COVID-19 Pandemic

The COVID-19 pandemic is mentioned as a factor that exacerbated the problems of the franchise system. With travel restrictions reducing passenger numbers, the script explains that the model became unsustainable, leading to government intervention.

💡Great British Railways

Great British Railways is the proposed government-operated company that would own the infrastructure and manage the timetables and fares for passenger rail services. The script discusses its role in the future of UK rail transport and how it would centralize control over the network.

💡Network Rail

Network Rail is the current company responsible for maintaining the UK's railway tracks. The script mentions that under the new plan, Great British Railways would take back control of the tracks to simplify the network of responsibilities.

💡Open Access Operators

Open Access Operators are companies that run trains on selected routes independently from the franchises. The script notes that the Labour government would still allow these operators to continue, indicating a partial rather than complete nationalization of the rail system.

💡Passenger Standards Authority

The Passenger Standards Authority is a proposed watchdog for the new Great British Rail system. The script suggests it would ensure standards are maintained, showing the government's intention to improve the passenger experience.

Highlights

The UK's rail transport system is criticized for being expensive and often providing poor value, with trains being overcrowded, late, or cancelled.

The 'Williams-Shapps Plan' was devised by the Conservative government to address rail issues, proposing the nationalization of railways under 'Great British Rail'.

There is a rare point of agreement between the previous and current UK governments on the establishment of Great British Railways, as mentioned in the King's speech.

The UK's passenger rail network transitioned from nationalization under British Rail to a rail franchising system in 1996.

The rail franchising system involved contracts awarded to private companies for groups of rail routes, including both profitable and less profitable ones.

Many rail franchisees have gone bankrupt, forcing the government to step in and operate the services themselves, known as the 'Operator of Last Resort'.

The government described the franchising system as flawed due to companies overpromising and underdelivering, leading to state intervention.

The COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated the sustainability issues of the franchising model, as operators had to run routes irrespective of passenger numbers.

The government temporarily nationalized the rail system by ending the contract system and transferring revenue and cost risk to itself.

The Williams-Shapps review recommended the creation of Great British Railways, an organization to be operated by the government and own the infrastructure.

Great British Railways would also take on the responsibility for railway tracks, simplifying the network of responsibilities related to rail infrastructure.

The Labour government plans to continue the creation of Great British Railways, allowing for natural expiration of franchise contracts before nationalization.

Open Access operators and rail freight companies will not be nationalized, indicating a partial rather than complete nationalization of the rail system.

The Labour government has proposed further changes, such as cutting waste, creating a Passenger Standards Authority, and establishing a new automatic delay repay system.

The new government has introduced the Railway Services Public Ownership bill, a starting point for establishing Great British Railways, though it has not yet become law.

Starmer aims to have Great British Rail operational by the end of the 5-year Parliament, indicating a timeline for the implementation of these changes.

Nebula is a streaming service co-owned with creators, offering original content and ad-free viewing of The Daily Report videos, with a discount for new members.

Transcripts

this video was brought to you by nebula

now anyone from the UK will know just

how strange and expensive our rail

transport is getting from one major city

to another can often cost more than a

plane ticket to another country and it's

not as though the experience is value

for money trains are often overcrowded

late or downright cancelled the previous

conservative government knew this and in

an attempt to address it the then

transport secretary Grant shaps came up

with a plan alongside the independent of

the rail review Keith Williams this plan

known uninventive as the shaps Williams

plan for rail was effectively to

nationalize the railways under a new

company called Great British Rail and

this appears to be one of the very few

points of agreement between the previous

and current government as labor have

committed themselves continue with the

process of establishing Great British

Railways with it even being mentioned in

the recent King's speech so in this

video we're going to have a look at how

the passenger rail system currently

operates in the UK the issues with this

and how labor plans to change it in the

[Music]

future before we start if you haven't

already please consider subscribing and

ringing the bell to stay in the loop and

be notified when we release new videos

now to understand all of this we need to

go way back to

1996 back then the UK's passenger rail

network was in the process of going from

being naal alized under British Rail to

the current rail franchising system now

basically the government offered

contracts to private companies for

groups of rail routs now some of these

roots were profitable EG popular

commuter routs others less so like roots

that connect smaller towns with few

passengers to larger cities the deal was

that the successful franchises would

have to operate all routs within their

franchise so as not to deprive smaller

towns of their vital rail connections

now this system has been in operation

ever since with each franchise being

auctioned off to the highest bidder now

the issue has been that many of these

franchisees have gone bust meaning that

the government has had to operate the

franchise themselves this is known as

them becoming the operator of Last

Resort in fact last year for the first

time since the rail franchise system was

introduced the biggest rail operator in

the UK was actually the government after

it became the operator of last sort for

Trans penine Express that meant that the

government was running six different

rail franchises across the UK London

Northeastern Railway Southeastern

Northern transport for Wales Scott Rail

and now trans penine Express to put it

bluntly it quickly became clear that the

franchise system wasn't working

franchisees were not meeting the terms

of their contracts and even the

government themselves described the

system as flawed essentially this was

because companies were forced to over

promise in order to get the franchise

but in the end they underd delivered and

the state was forced to step in and what

made things even worse was the covid

pandemic as the franchisees had to run

the routes irrespective of Passenger

numbers and with covid regulations

preventing people from being able to

leave their homes the franchising model

effectively became unsustainable as such

the government stepped in and simply

ended the contract system with them

giving all operators the chance to

transfer all re revenue and cost risk to

the government with the franchisees

being paid a small management fee in

return for continuing to run the

services in essence this was temporary

nationalization although even at the

time it was understood that it could be

the beginning of the end for the

franchise system as a whole with the

shfs Williams review on the horizon it

was understood that the franchise system

as we knew it was unlikely to continue

and as it turned out this was exactly

the case with the shs Williams review

suggesting the biggest shakeup in how

passenger rail operates in the UK since

1996 specifically they recommended the

creation of Great British Railways an

organization that would be operated by

the government the organization would

own the infrastructure though would not

own the actual trains themselves they'd

received the fair revenue and run and

plan the timetables for passenger rail

it's important to note too that great

prsh Railways would also take on the

responsibility for other elements of the

railways back in the the late 1990s the

responsibility for railway tracks was

given to a new private company known as

rail track a few years later this was

moved to another company known as

Network rail who are still responsible

for the railway tracks in the UK to this

day in order to simplify the chaotic

network of responsibilities related to

rail infrastructure in the UK Great

British Railways would take back control

of all of the railway tracks now this

was the plan under the last conservative

government but what does the current

government want to do with it well as we

mentioned in the introduction the labor

government are actually kind of in

agreement with the conservatives on this

they've committed to continuing the

creation of Great British Railways with

it even being mentioned in The King's

Speech in order to do this they plan to

wait until the contracts for the

franchises expire naturally at which

point they'll be taken under government

control and will eventually all be made

part of the nationalized Great British

Railways now it's worth noting that the

labor government will still allow Open

Access operators such as whole trains

and lumo continue operating these

operators work independently from the

franchises and run trains on only

selected routes nor will labor

nationalize rail freight companies so

while labor would pursue nationalization

it would not be an absolute complete

nationalization of all things trains

aside from this though there are some

signs that labor are planning on going

further in some aspects they've

suggested that they'll try and cut waste

and will claw back shareholder dividends

some something that could save around

2.2 billion additionally they'll create

a new passenger standards Authority

which will act as a watchdog for the new

Great British Rail as well as creating

digital season tickets across the

network and establishing a new automatic

delay repay system these change likely

won't be implemented until later but do

at least show signs that labor has plans

to further change the system Beyond just

simply the creation of the new Great

British Railway anyway this is what the

government has planned to do but what

have they actually done so far well

they've only been in office for around 2

months so to be frank not all that much

they have introduced the new passenger

Railway Services Public ownership bill

which is a starting point for

establishing Great British Railways but

it's not yet become law now to be fair

starma has simply stated that his aim is

to have Great British Rail operational

by the end of the 5-year Parliament so

he does still have a fair while to go

yet now you can keep diving deeper into

this and other news stories over on

nebula where the TDR team creates the

most important news videos from around

the world saving you from a deluge of

bad news and helping you pay attention

to what really matters this means no

more feeling out of touch on nebula news

the dldr team act as your guide through

the media landscape sharing the news

that we're paying attention to and

helping you to find the stories that

matter and avoid burnout now if you

don't know already nebula is a streaming

service that we co-own with a bunch of

your favorite creators there you can

watch original content like real life

laws incredible series War Room which

every month runs you through a whole

load of ongoing conflicts keeping you in

the loop you can also watch every TDR

video on nebula ad free and in many

instances before they land on YouTube if

you're not a member already then you can

click the link in the description to

sign up now and if you do you'll get 40%

of an annual plan by using our link plus

nebula will know that you came from us

which really helps us out we've got some

great feedback from existing members on

the nebula news features so I hope you

enjoy the effort that we're putting into

nebula news