Comparing Philips Warm White & Multicolor Mini Christmas Lights to VINTAGLO & Menards Vintage LED

Summary

In this Christmas lighting review, the speaker compares Philips, Menard's, and Vintag Glow mini LED twinkle lights, critiquing their color temperature and twinkle effects. Philips and Menard's LEDs are criticized for their harsh blue glow and lack of the 'shimmer' effect that makes incandescent lights more appealing. The Vintag Glows, while lacking twinkling, are preferred for their warmer, more natural light. Incandescent twinkle lights are hailed as the best option for their warmth and authentic shimmer, offering greater value compared to higher-priced LEDs, especially when considering their superior aesthetic qualities.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speaker reviews different Christmas lights, comparing Philips, Menards, and vintage incandescent options.
• 😀 The main focus of the review is the color warmth and twinkle effect of various light sets.
• 😀 Philips LED mini twinkle lights are criticized for having a harsh, blue LED glow, which is not ideal for warm holiday lighting.
• 😀 Menards' vintage LED twinkle lights are compared to Philips', with similar color issues, but with a different design.
• 😀 Incandescent twinkle lights are praised for their warmer, more natural glow, which is preferred over LEDs.
• 😀 The vintage glow LEDs from Menards are considered the best option for achieving a warmer, more authentic holiday light effect.
• 😀 The speaker emphasizes that the twinkle effect in incandescent lights is more dynamic, with varying brightness levels, creating a shimmering effect.
• 😀 The Philips LED twinkles are seen as 'cringey' and overly bright, with a harsh color that doesn't blend well with natural surroundings.
• 😀 While Philips does offer a 'classic glow' LED option, it still doesn’t compare to the warmth and authenticity of vintage incandescent lights.
• 😀 The speaker suggests that if you are looking for inexpensive twinkle lights, the $3 warm white twinkle lights from Target are a much better value than the more expensive Philips and Menards options.
• 😀 Despite lacking the twinkle effect, the vintage incandescent lights provide the best warmth and color, making them the top choice for holiday lighting.

Q & A

What is the main focus of this video?

The main focus of the video is a comparison of various Christmas lights, specifically Philips mini LED twinkles, Menards mini LED twinkles, and vintage glow LED lights. The video also compares them with traditional incandescent twinkle lights.

What is the primary criticism of the Philips mini LED twinkles?

The Philips mini LED twinkles are criticized for having a harsh and overly pink color that doesn't resemble warm incandescent lighting. The reviewer finds them 'LED cringey' and not suitable for a warm, festive atmosphere.

How do the Menards mini LED twinkles compare to the Philips ones?

The Menards mini LED twinkles are similar to the Philips ones in terms of color, being described as 'not the right color.' Both sets are criticized for having an overly blue, harsh LED glow, making them less desirable compared to other options.

What makes the vintage glow LEDs stand out in comparison to the Philips and Menards lights?

The vintage glow LEDs stand out due to their warm, soft light color, which resembles incandescent bulbs more closely. The reviewer notes that these lights have a more natural, pleasant glow compared to the harsher LEDs from Philips and Menards.

What is the difference between twinkle and non-twinkle lights mentioned in the video?

The twinkle effect refers to lights that blink or flicker intermittently, while non-twinkle lights remain steadily on. The video contrasts the twinkle effect of the incandescent lights with the steady glow of the vintage glow LEDs, which do not have a twinkle option yet.

How do the incandescent twinkle lights compare to the LED versions?

The incandescent twinkle lights have a more natural shimmer effect because some bulbs stay on while others blink. This creates a dynamic brightness change, which the LEDs lack. The LEDs, including the Philips and Menards sets, have a steady twinkle effect that doesn't replicate the shimmer of incandescent bulbs.

Why does the reviewer prefer the vintage glow LEDs over other options?

The reviewer prefers the vintage glow LEDs because they provide a warm and natural color that is more fitting for a cozy, festive atmosphere. Despite lacking a twinkle effect, the warmth of the light is seen as a significant advantage over the harsh, cold LED glow of the Philips and Menards lights.

What is the reviewer's opinion on paying more for the LED twinkle lights?

The reviewer believes that paying more for LED twinkle lights, like the Philips ones at $16, is not worth it, especially when cheaper options, such as the $3 warm white twinkles from Target, provide better value and a more desirable effect.

What is the key feature that makes the incandescent twinkle lights superior to LED versions?

The key feature of incandescent twinkle lights is the shimmer effect, where some bulbs stay on while others blink, creating a dynamic brightness change. This effect is missing in the LED versions, making them less realistic and less appealing to the reviewer.

How does the reviewer feel about the Philips mini LED twinkles overall?

Overall, the reviewer is not impressed with the Philips mini LED twinkles. Despite trying them out, they are considered too harsh, with a color that is not warm enough for the festive atmosphere the reviewer is seeking. The Philips lights are deemed not a good option compared to other available products.