My parents make me take pictures 📸 for memories. Photography permissible? #Assim assim al hakeem

Summary

The video discusses the permissibility of photography in Islam, emphasizing the distinction between photographing inanimate objects and living creatures. Scholars generally agree that capturing images of landscapes, mountains, or nature is halal. However, photographing humans and animals is debated, with some scholars arguing it mimics Allah's creation, while others permit it under specific conditions. Photos should be halal, not depicting indecent content, and privacy must be respected, especially with regard to hijab. Even if photos are stored securely, they can still be at risk, so caution is advised.

Takeaways

• 😀 Photography of landscapes, objects, and non-living things is universally considered halal by scholars.
• 😀 Photography of living creatures, such as humans and animals, is more controversial and often deemed not permissible by scholars.
• 😀 Some scholars believe photographing living beings is permissible, arguing that it's a reflection of Allah's creation rather than a mimicry.
• 😀 Photography is compared to seeing a reflection in a mirror or a Xerox of a signature, emphasizing that the photo is still a reflection of the original.
• 😀 Scholars who permit photography of living creatures assert that the photos must be halal, meaning the subjects and content should adhere to Islamic guidelines.
• 😀 It's not permissible to take photos of people who are not dressed modestly, as it goes against the principles of hijab.
• 😀 Even photos of family members, such as wives, daughters, or sisters, are not permissible if they violate the concept of hijab.
• 😀 There is a security concern about digital photos, as they can be accessed even after being deleted or after formatting the device.
• 😀 Despite the argument that phones and devices can be secured, it is advised to be cautious, as photos can still be hacked or retrieved.
• 😀 The script advises a safe approach, stating it’s better to avoid photography of living beings to ensure compliance with Islamic principles.

Q & A

Is it permissible to take photographs of inanimate objects, such as mountains and oceans?

Yes, photography of inanimate objects like mountains, oceans, and gardens is universally accepted as permissible by scholars.

What is the main issue with taking photographs of living creatures, including humans and animals, in Islam?

The main issue is that many scholars believe photographing living creatures imitates the creation of Allah, which is considered impermissible. Some scholars permit it, arguing that photography reflects Allah's creation rather than mimicking it.

Why do some scholars argue that photography of living creatures is permissible?

Some scholars argue that photography is not a direct imitation of Allah's creation but rather a reflection, similar to seeing one's image in a mirror or a photocopy of one's signature. As a result, they permit it under certain conditions.

What conditions must be met for photography to be considered halal, according to some scholars?

For photography to be halal, the subject must not be photographed in a manner that violates modesty. This includes avoiding indecent or inappropriate contexts, such as photographing a man in a non-coveted state or a woman violating the principles of hijab.

Is it permissible to photograph one's family members, such as wives or daughters?

While photographing family members, including wives and daughters, is technically allowed by some scholars, it is discouraged because it could violate the purpose of hijab and modesty. Photography of women, especially in private settings, raises concerns about privacy and modesty.

How do privacy and security concerns impact the permissibility of taking and storing photographs?

Privacy and security concerns are significant when it comes to photography. Even if a device is secured, there is a risk that photos can be hacked or retrieved later. Scholars advise being cautious and consider the risks associated with storing sensitive or private images.

Can you take photographs of children?

Yes, taking photographs of children is generally permitted, as they do not pose the same concerns regarding modesty as adults. However, care should still be taken to avoid using the images inappropriately.

What is the difference between photographing a reflection in a mirror and taking a photograph of a human?

Some scholars view a photograph of a human as a reflection of Allah’s creation, similar to seeing a reflection in a mirror or water. While this analogy permits photography in certain contexts, it still depends on the intention and purpose of the photograph.

Why is there concern about taking photographs of women, even if they are family members?

The concern stems from the principle of hijab and the importance of maintaining modesty in Islamic teachings. Taking photographs of women, even within a family, might compromise their modesty and privacy, especially if the photographs are shared or misused.

What should one do to ensure that the photographs they take are halal?

To ensure photographs are halal, one should be mindful of the context, avoid indecent or inappropriate content, and take care to protect the privacy of the subjects. In particular, photographs of women should be handled with caution to preserve modesty and respect for hijab.