Three Mile Island: Near-miss nuclear disaster | Past PA | Pennsylvania history

Summary

The video script recounts the harrowing events of March 28, 1979, at Three Mile Island Nuclear Generating Station, marking the most serious nuclear incident in U.S. commercial power history. The mishap, which led to a partial meltdown, exposed flaws in emergency response and reactor design, triggering significant regulatory changes and public skepticism towards nuclear energy. The aftermath influenced policy, halted new plant constructions, and underscored the critical need for oversight and transparency in nuclear operations.

Takeaways

• 🕒 The Three Mile Island incident occurred on March 28, 1979, at 4 AM, marking the most serious and publicized accident in the history of American commercial nuclear power.
• 🏭 The nuclear power industry transitioned from a government monopoly to private enterprise in the 1950s, with the Atomic Energy Act of 1954 allowing for both military and commercial nuclear production.
• 🛡️ The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) was established in 1975 to provide independent oversight of the nuclear industry, addressing previous criticisms of the Atomic Energy Commission.
• 🌐 The opening of two nuclear units at Three Mile Island in 1974 and 1978 was seen as a sign of progress and economic revitalization for the local community.
• 🚨 On the day of the incident, operators faced a flurry of alarms and warning lights, leading to a confusing and nerve-wracking situation that escalated into a general emergency.
• 🔧 Technical failures and a stuck open relief valve led to a loss of coolant, causing the reactor core to overheat and partially melt.
• 🌡️ The reactor core reached temperatures of 4300 degrees Fahrenheit, causing significant damage, although the reactor's design prevented a complete meltdown.
• 💨 Trace amounts of radioactive gas were released into the environment, raising concerns for the surrounding community and leading to evacuation recommendations for certain groups.
• 📡 Miscommunication and a lack of transparency from Metropolitan Edison fueled fear and distrust, impacting the response to the incident.
• 🎥 The release of the movie 'The China Syndrome' just two weeks prior to the incident heightened public fears about nuclear accidents and corporate cover-ups.
• 🛑 The incident led to sweeping changes in emergency response, reactor operator training, engineering, and regulatory oversight, significantly enhancing US reactor safety.
• 📉 The Three Mile Island disaster had a lasting impact on the nuclear industry, leading to the cancellation of numerous proposed plants and a reevaluation of nuclear energy's role in the United States.

Q & A

What was the significance of the Three Mile Island incident on March 28, 1979?

The Three Mile Island incident was the most serious and publicized accident in the history of American commercial nuclear power, leading to significant changes in nuclear safety regulations and public perception of nuclear energy.

What was the Atomic Energy Act of 1954 responsible for?

The Atomic Energy Act of 1954 empowered the Atomic Energy Commission to balance the production of nuclear arms for the military with safe and efficient commercial nuclear production, eventually leading to the transition of nuclear power from a government monopoly to private enterprise.

Why was the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) created in 1975?

The NRC was created to address criticisms that the Atomic Energy Commission was enabling the industry it was supposed to regulate, thus establishing an independent government agency to oversee nuclear safety in the United States.

How did the residents of Middletown perceive the Three Mile Island Nuclear Generating Station?

Most residents welcomed the plant as a sign of progress and a means of revitalizing the local economy, especially in light of the financial and energy challenges of the 1970s.

What was the initial response of the plant staff to the alarms and warning lights on March 28, 1979?

The plant staff was initially overwhelmed by the alarms and warning lights, leading to confusion and a series of incorrect actions that contributed to the severity of the incident.

What technical breakdown led to the escalation of the situation at Three Mile Island?

Technical breakdowns stalled feedwater pumps, preventing water from reaching the steam generators, which caused pressure to mount within the system and initiated a series of events leading to the core meltdown.

Why did operators shut off the supply of emergency cooling water to the reactor?

Operators shut off the emergency cooling water supply because they mistakenly believed that the water level in the pressurizer was rising, despite the falling pressure, which was an unprecedented scenario they were not trained for.

What was the temperature of the reactor core at the height of the incident?

The reactor core reached a temperature of 4300 degrees Fahrenheit during the height of the incident, causing significant damage to the core.

How did the release of the movie 'The China Syndrome' affect public perception of the Three Mile Island incident?

The release of 'The China Syndrome' just two weeks before the incident heightened public fears of nuclear accidents and corporate cover-ups, reinforcing concerns about environmental devastation and contributing to the panic that ensued.

What actions did Governor Richard Thornburgh take in response to the incident?

Governor Thornburgh recommended a limited evacuation for young children and pregnant women within a five-mile radius of the plant, and sought additional guidance and resources from President Jimmy Carter to alleviate public hysteria.

What were the long-term effects of the Three Mile Island incident on the nuclear industry in the United States?

The incident led to the cancellation of dozens of proposed nuclear plants nationwide, increased regulatory oversight by the NRC, and sparked a fierce debate over the role of nuclear energy in the United States.

Outlines

00:00

🚨 Three Mile Island Nuclear Incident: A Turning Point in Nuclear Power History

This paragraph details the early morning of March 28, 1979, when the Three Mile Island Nuclear Generating Station experienced a serious accident. The operators were alerted by alarms and warning lights, marking the beginning of the most publicized incident in U.S. commercial nuclear power history. The script outlines the historical context of nuclear power's transition from government monopoly to private enterprise, the creation of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) in 1975, and the opening of the Three Mile Island units. It highlights the challenges faced by the NRC and the confusion during the incident, which led to a partial meltdown of the reactor core. The safety measures prevented a catastrophic failure, but the event sparked debates on nuclear energy's pros and cons and had lasting impacts on nuclear regulation and public perception.

05:03

📣 Crisis Management and Public Response to the Three Mile Island Accident

The second paragraph describes the immediate aftermath of the Three Mile Island accident, including the spread of information, the reactions of Pennsylvania Governor Richard Thornburgh, and the miscommunication from Metropolitan Edison that fueled fear and distrust. It discusses the psychological impact of the disaster, the chaos in neighboring communities, the influence of popular culture like 'The China Syndrome', and the NRC's measurements of radiation levels. The NRC's recommendation for a limited evacuation and the subsequent exodus of over 140,000 residents is also covered. The paragraph concludes with the arrival of President Jimmy Carter, a former Naval nuclear engineer, whose presence aimed to reassure the public and demonstrate control over the situation.

10:03

🏭 Lessons Learned from Three Mile Island: Impact on Nuclear Policy and Public Perception

The final paragraph reflects on the broader implications of the Three Mile Island incident. It emphasizes the importance of oversight, transparency, scientific understanding, and communication, especially during times of uncertainty. The event is portrayed as a cautionary tale that influenced societal and policy changes, despite the lack of immediate disaster. The disaster's impact on the nuclear industry is highlighted, with the cancellation of numerous proposed plants and the eventual closure and decommissioning of Three Mile Island's unaffected Unit 1. The paragraph invites viewers to share their interests for future episodes, focusing on the history of the Commonwealth.

Keywords

💡Three Mile Island

Three Mile Island refers to the site of a nuclear power plant complex located on Three Mile Island in the Susquehanna River, near Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. The term is central to the theme of the video as it was the location of the most serious nuclear accident in U.S. commercial nuclear power history, which occurred on March 28, 1979. The video script describes the events of that day and the subsequent reactions and impacts on the nuclear industry and public perception.

💡Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC)

The NRC is an independent government agency responsible for nuclear oversight in the United States. It was created in 1975 to balance the production of nuclear arms with safe and efficient commercial nuclear energy production. The video script highlights the role of the NRC in the aftermath of the Three Mile Island accident, where it became the key regulatory body that recommended evacuations and tightened oversight to enhance reactor safety.

💡Nuclear Power

Nuclear power is a form of energy production that uses the heat generated from nuclear fission in a controlled environment to produce electricity. The video discusses the transition of nuclear power from a government monopoly to private enterprise in the 1950s and the subsequent debates on the pros and cons of nuclear energy, especially in the context of the Three Mile Island incident.

💡Meltdown

A meltdown is a catastrophic failure in a nuclear reactor that can result in the reactor core overheating and melting. In the script, the term is used to describe the severe damage to the reactor core at Three Mile Island, where almost half of the core melted due to a series of technical breakdowns and operator errors.

💡Radiation

Radiation refers to the emission of energy as electromagnetic waves or as moving subatomic particles, especially high-energy particles or waves that can cause ionization. In the context of the video, radiation is a key concern as trace amounts of radioactive gas were released into the environment during the Three Mile Island incident, causing fear and prompting evacuation recommendations.

💡Emergency Response

Emergency response is the organized effort to deal with the immediate effects of an accident or disaster. The video script discusses the emergency response to the Three Mile Island incident, including the activation of civil defense sirens, the recommendation for evacuations, and the involvement of local and federal authorities.

💡Reactor Core

The reactor core is the central part of a nuclear reactor where nuclear fission occurs, producing heat to generate steam for electricity production. The script describes how the reactor core at Three Mile Island was partially exposed and overheated, leading to a meltdown.

💡Coolant

In a nuclear reactor, coolant is a fluid that circulates through the reactor core to transfer heat produced by nuclear fission to a heat exchanger. The video script explains how a stuck-open relief valve and a lack of coolant circulation led to the overheating and eventual meltdown of the reactor core at Three Mile Island.

💡Human Factors

Human factors refer to the characteristics and capabilities of people that affect their ability to perform tasks and operate systems safely and effectively. The video mentions that the Three Mile Island incident led to a reevaluation of human factors in reactor design and operation, emphasizing the need for better training and understanding of potential accident scenarios.

💡Decommissioning

Decommissioning is the process of safely dismantling a nuclear facility and disposing of its components, typically after it has reached the end of its operational life. The script notes that the unaffected Unit 1 at Three Mile Island is currently undergoing decommissioning, following its closure in 2019.

💡Public Perception

Public perception refers to the general view or opinion that the public has about a particular issue or event. The video discusses how the Three Mile Island incident significantly influenced public perception of nuclear power, leading to widespread fear and debate over its role in the United States.

Highlights

The Three Mile Island incident on March 28, 1979, was the most serious and publicized nuclear power accident in U.S. history.

Nuclear power transitioned from government monopoly to private enterprise in the 1950s, leading to the Atomic Energy Act of 1954.

The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) was created in 1975 to provide independent oversight of the nuclear industry.

Three Mile Island Nuclear Generating Station's two units were opened in 1974 and 1978, symbolizing progress and economic revitalization.

The NRC faced challenges in balancing its responsibilities, often being overwhelmed by its workload.

On the day of the incident, alarms and warning lights alerted operators to a serious issue at Unit 2 of Three Mile Island.

Technical breakdowns and a stuck open relief valve led to a loss of coolant and a rise in pressure within the reactor.

Operators mistakenly shut off emergency cooling water due to a misreading of water level and pressure indicators.

The reactor core was partially exposed, leading to a reaction with steam and the release of immense heat.

The core reached temperatures of 4300 degrees, causing a significant portion of the fuel to melt.

The reactor's design safety margin prevented a complete meltdown, but the incident caused irreparable damage.

Trace amounts of radioactive gas were released, raising concerns for the surrounding community and environment.

Miscommunication and lack of transparency from Metropolitan Edison fueled fear and distrust among the public.

The incident occurred shortly after the release of 'The China Syndrome,' a film that heightened public fears about nuclear accidents.

The NRC measured low radiation levels but recommended a limited evacuation for pregnant women and young children.

Over 140,000 residents left the area due to concerns over potential nuclear radiation contamination.

Governor Thornburgh sought additional guidance from President Jimmy Carter to manage the escalating situation.

The incident led to sweeping changes in emergency response, reactor operator training, and regulatory oversight.

The Three Mile Island disaster had a lasting impact on the nuclear industry and public perception of nuclear energy.

Unit 2 was never reopened, and the unaffected Unit 1 closed in 2019, currently undergoing decommissioning.

The event serves as a cautionary tale about the importance of oversight, transparency, and communication in times of uncertainty.

Transcripts

JARED FREDERICK: Four AM, Wednesday, March 28, 1979.

An array of ringing alarms and flashing warning lights

suddenly roused operators in a control room

at Three Mile Island Nuclear Generating Station

on the Susquehanna River.

Little could they have known, they

were on the brink of the most serious and publicized incident

in the history of American commercial nuclear power.

The flurry of ensuing actions, reports and debates

continue to shape our national discourse on the pros

and cons of nuclear energy.

[theme music]

By the 1950s, nuclear power had transitioned from a complete

government monopoly into a private enterprise.

In 1954, the Atomic Energy ACT empowered the atomic energy

commission to balance the ongoing production

of nuclear arms for the military with safe and efficient

commercial production.

Over time, however, the commission

was criticized for enabling the industry

it was intended to regulate.

That dynamic led to the creation of the nuclear regulatory

commission in 1975.

This independent government agency

was to become the final arbiter of nuclear oversight

in the United States.

The emergence of the NRC coincided

with the opening of two nuclear units

at Three Mile Island Nuclear Generating

Station in 1974 and 1978.

Operated by metropolitan Edison and located near Middletown,

only miles away from the State capital,

the plant was welcomed by most residents as a sign of progress

and a means of revitalizing the local economy.

After all, the financial and energy woes of the 1970s further

highlighted the need for America to invest in nuclear power.

Amidst these developments, the staff

of the fledgling nuclear regulatory commission

was often overwhelmed by its responsibilities.

One NRC director claimed, we had more work than we could handle.

While experts within the organization

believed that harmful nuclear incidents were the least likely

of all possible disasters to occur,

many also acknowledged that the pathways

to potential nuclear accidents had yet

to be thoroughly examined.

This issue became quite apparent on March 28, 1979.

[dramatic music]

In the pre-dawn hours at Three Mile Island,

nerve wracking uncertainty gripped plant staff

as alarms for Unit 2 began to sound.

[beeping]

One operator remembered that the control room console lit up

like a Christmas tree and an avalanche of data and warnings

created an atmosphere of confusion.

At one point, a radiation in the control room alert

blared, compelling staff to wear emergency respirators.

A general emergency was sounded.

Technical breakdowns had stalled feedwater pumps

from transporting water to steam generators.

Pressure within the system soon mounted.

Employees responded by opening a relief valve,

yet that valve, unknowingly, remained open

after it was meant to close and operators

were unaware of an ongoing loss of coolant.

Then something truly strange happened.

The water level in the pressurizer

was rising, although the pressure itself

was still falling.

This was a scenario staff had not been trained for.

Water level and pressure were supposed

to rise or fall together.

As such, the operators shut off the supply of emergency cooling

water to the reactor.

The lack of water circulation coupled

with the stuck open valve, meant the coolant level continued

to fall as it boiled away.

This eventually exposed the reactor core.

All the while, very hot fuel rods of the partially exposed

core reacted with steam.

That process gave off immense heat.

Enough to melt the fuel.

At the height of the incident, the core reached 4300 degrees.

When all was said and done, the reactor

endured irreparable damage.

Almost half of the core melted inside the reactor.

Fortunately, the considerable safety margin

in the reactor's design kept the core from melting through.

Not until emergency water was injected into the system later

in the day did the coolant pumps finally restart.

But concern did not end there.

Trace amounts of radioactive gas were

released into the environment as steam

from the melted fuel escaped through the open pressure valve.

And that issue soon became a chief concern

of the surrounding community.

Early on the morning of the 28th,

a radio traffic reporter picked up chatter about fire

and emergency crews being mobilized on Three Mile Island.

Word of the mounting situation was spreading around

the Harrisburg area by 09:00 AM.

Pennsylvania Governor, Richard Thornburgh remembered the moment

with cold realization.

The minute I heard that there had

been an accident at a nuclear facility,

he said, I knew we were in another dimension.

Miscommunication and perhaps a lack

of transparency on the part of Metropolitan Edison

fueled a sense of fear and distrust.

Reporters, local politicians and those within the Governor's

office felt they were not receiving

full and accurate assessments from company spokesmen.

When inspectors from the NRC arrived on site,

they witnessed an eerie scene of employees scurrying

about in radiation suits.

The spectacle instilled the sensation

that something dreadfully troubling had occurred.

The unfolding disaster was perhaps as much psychological

as it was technological.

Pandemonium ensued in neighboring communities.

Communication and information alike were muddled.

Harrisburg's civil defense sirens

were triggered despite the fact there was no immediate threat.

Worries were heightened by popular culture of the time

as well.

Just two weeks before the incident, the suspense movie,

The China Syndrome had been released.

Depicting a fictional nuclear accident and a cover

up at a California plant, the movie

popularized the phrase implausibly

suggesting that a meltdown could burn through the Earth

all the way to China.

The film reinforced suddenly pertinent fears

of corporate corruption and environmental devastation.

The NRC noted to the New York Times on March 29

that low radiation levels had been measured up to one mile

from the plant and that traces had been found in the air

up to 16 miles away.

The amount in the immediate area was

described as above normal for the plant site,

but below what was considered dangerous to health.

Even so, the commission recommended

to governor Thornburgh that a limited evacuation

for specific segments of the local community was advisable.

Thornburgh thereafter recommended

that young children and pregnant women within a five mile

radius of the plant relocate.

Loudspeaker trucks announced the message

in the streets of Middletown, Goldsboro and elsewhere,

but a far larger demographic heeded the call.

Over 140,000 residents left the area that week.

Additional dread existed over the possibility

of nuclear radiation running off into the Susquehanna River

and thereby flowing into the Chesapeake Bay.

Exhausted by his haggling with the power company,

an increasingly agitated Governor Thornburgh

pleaded with president Jimmy Carter for additional guidance

and resources to alleviate the hysteria.

By that Saturday, additional fears

arose when scientists hypothesized

that a pocket of hydrogen at the top of the reactor vessel

might mix with too much oxygen and explode.

Such an explosion never occurred due to the overall lack

of oxygen in the system, but some experts argued over

the likelihood of such an eventuality up to the very

moment of president Carter's arrival on April 1st.

Carter, himself a former Naval nuclear engineer,

realized the gravity of the situation

and knew his presence might demonstrate to the public

that all was under control.

Public fear of immediate peril soon eased

and residents gradually returned to their homes.

According to the NRC, this was the most serious accident

in US commercial nuclear power plant operating history.

Although its small radioactive releases

had no detectable health effects on plant workers or the public,

its aftermath brought about sweeping changes involving

emergency response planning, reactor operator training,

human factors and engineering, radiation protection

and many other areas.

It also caused the NRC to tighten and heighten

its regulatory oversight.

All of these changes significantly

enhanced US reactor safety, but the incident

wreaked considerable havoc for the once heralded

nuclear industry.

Three Mile Island sparked fierce debate

over the role of nuclear energy in the United States.

On the steps of the Pennsylvania State house and elsewhere,

citizens loudly voiced their concerns.

The disaster coupled with already faltering

economic outlooks for new nuclear power plants

canceled the construction of dozens of proposed plants

nationwide.

Unit 2 on Three Mile Island never reopened and $1 billion

were spent on cleaning the damage.

The plant's Unit 1, which was unaffected

directly by the happenings in 1979, closed in 2019,

and is currently undergoing an extended decommissioning

process.

Whether you are for or against nuclear power,

the Three Mile Island incident remains a cautionary tale

of the importance of oversight, transparency,

scientific understanding and communication,

especially in extreme moments of uncertainty.

The event, likewise, demonstrates

that even if genuine disaster does not reach its fullest

capacity, the specter of disaster

is often enough to influence society and policy

in long standing ways.

Thanks for joining us on this episode of Passe Pas.

In the comment section below, tell us

what people, places, or products you'd like to see

featured in future episodes as we explore the Commonwealth's

history.

.

[theme music]