Paano gumawa ng maayos na Critique Paper?

Summary

This video script offers a comprehensive guide on crafting a critique paper. It emphasizes the importance of a thorough understanding of the material, suggesting a 70/30 ratio of critical evaluation to summary. The speaker outlines the structure, from introduction and background to a summary and critical evaluation, addressing key elements such as literary devices, audience appropriateness, and theoretical frameworks. The guide also stresses the significance of writing mechanics, the stages of writing, and the necessity of a final review to ensure the critique paper is polished and impactful.

Takeaways

• 📚 The purpose of a critique paper is to evaluate material for readers to understand it thoroughly.
• 🔍 A critique paper requires thorough reading to write effectively, emphasizing the importance of preparation.
• 📝 The structure of a critique paper typically includes an introduction, body, and conclusion.
• 📐 The paper should have a balance between summary and critical evaluation, often suggested as 30% summary and 70% evaluation.
• 👀 The introduction should mention the title, author, and provide background information about the material.
• 📑 In the body, provide a brief summary of the material's major points, ensuring multiple readings to capture details.
• 🔎 The critical evaluation should assess content, characters, literary devices, and other elements present in the material.
• 🤔隐形问题' (Invisible Questions) to answer in a critique paper include the purpose of the material, its strengths and weaknesses, and its appropriateness for the intended audience.
• 🎨 Discuss the literary theory depicted in the material, such as feminism, post-modernism, formalism, or reader response.
• ⭐ Consider using seven literary standards by William J. Long to evaluate the material: artistry, intellectual value, suggestiveness, spiritual value, universality, permanence, and style.
• 📣 Support your critique with quotes from the material and connect it to other relevant works to demonstrate comprehensiveness.
• 📝 The conclusion should provide a brief but strong general assessment of the material, summarizing the overall insight.

Q & A

What is the main purpose of a critique paper?

The main purpose of a critique paper is to evaluate material in order to provide readers with a thorough understanding of it.

What are the basic parts of a critique paper?

A critique paper typically consists of three basic parts: Introduction and Background, Summary, and Critical Evaluation.

How should the summary and critical evaluation be balanced in a critique paper?

The summary should typically comprise 20-30% of the paper, while the critical evaluation should make up 70-80%.

What should be included in the introduction of a critique paper?

The introduction should mention the title, author, and date of the material, as well as provide some background information about it.

What is the purpose of the brief summary in the critique paper?

The brief summary serves to introduce the material to the reader, ensuring they understand the context before diving into the critical evaluation.

What invisible questions should be addressed in the critical evaluation section?

The critical evaluation should address questions like the purpose of the material, its strengths and weaknesses, its appropriateness for the intended audience, and the literary theory it depicts.

How can a writer support their evaluation in a critique paper?

A writer can support their evaluation by quoting relevant lines from the material and connecting the critique to other relevant materials.

What should be included in the conclusion of a critique paper?

The conclusion should provide a general assessment or overall insight into the material, summarizing the critique and offering a strong closing statement.

Why is it important to review the critique paper before submission?

Reviewing the critique paper is crucial to ensure the content, language, grammar, and mechanics are accurate, resulting in a polished final version rather than a draft.

What writing mechanics should be considered when writing a critique paper?

Writers should consider mechanics such as abbreviations, contractions, punctuation, capitalization, grammar, and overall clarity in their writing.

Outlines

00:00

📚 Introduction to Critique Paper Writing

The paragraph introduces the concept of a critique paper, emphasizing its purpose, which is to evaluate material for better reader understanding. It outlines the necessary preparation, stressing the importance of thorough reading to write effectively. The paragraph also briefly explains the structure of a critique paper, mentioning the introduction, summary, and critical evaluation sections, and suggests that a good critique should consist of around 70% evaluation and 30% summary.

05:03

✍️ Key Elements of a Critique Paper

This paragraph provides a detailed breakdown of the essential parts of a critique paper. It emphasizes the importance of mentioning the title, author, and background of the material in the introduction. The body should contain a brief summary and a comprehensive assessment of the material, including an analysis of its content, characters, and literary devices. The paragraph also introduces the concept of 'invisible questions' that a critique paper should answer, such as the material's purpose, strengths and weaknesses, and its appropriateness for the intended audience.

10:05

🔍 Criteria and Standards for Evaluation

The paragraph delves into the criteria for evaluating a critique paper, referencing the seven literary standards according to William J. Long: artistry, intellectual value, suggestiveness, spiritual value, universality, permanence, and style. It discusses the importance of assessing whether the input material meets these standards and whether it is suitable for its intended audience. The paragraph also emphasizes the need to support evaluations with specific examples from the material and to connect the critique with other relevant works, showcasing a comprehensive review.

📝 Writing Mechanics and Final Review

This paragraph focuses on the final steps of writing a critique paper. It stresses the importance of considering writing mechanics, including grammar, punctuation, and overall writing quality. The paragraph outlines the necessity of conducting a final review to ensure the paper is polished and free of errors. It also reminds writers to follow the stages of writing: pre-writing, writing, and post-writing. Finally, it encourages writers to aim for producing the best version of their work before submission.

Keywords

💡Critique Paper

A critique paper is a form of academic writing that involves the evaluation of a piece of work, such as a short story, movie, or research article. In the video, the critique paper is the central focus, with the purpose of teaching viewers how to write one effectively. It is defined as a tool to provide a thorough understanding of the material to the readers, involving both summary and critical evaluation.

💡Introduction and Background

In the context of the video, 'introduction and background' refers to the initial section of a critique paper where the material being critiqued is presented along with its context. The script emphasizes the importance of introducing the title, author, and when it was written, setting the stage for the critique that will follow.

💡Summary

A 'summary' in the script refers to a concise representation of the main points of the material being critiqued. The video mentions that the critique paper should contain a brief summary, which is essential for the reader to grasp the essence of the material before delving into the critical evaluation.

💡Critical Evaluation

This term is central to the video's theme, highlighting the need for a comprehensive assessment of the input material. The script specifies that the critique paper should consist of 70% critical evaluation, indicating the depth of analysis expected beyond just summarizing the content.

💡Invisible Questions

The term 'invisible questions' in the script refers to the underlying queries that a critique paper should address, such as the purpose of the material, its strengths and weaknesses, and its appropriateness for the intended audience. These questions guide the critical evaluation process.

💡Literary Theory

The script touches upon 'literary theory' as a concept that may be depicted or utilized in the material being critiqued. It suggests that a critique paper should discuss the literary theories present, such as feminism or post-modernism, and provide reasons for their inclusion.

💡Criteria

In the video, 'criteria' are the standards used to measure and evaluate the material. The script mentions seven literary standards by William J. Long, including artistry, intellectual value, and style, which serve as a benchmark for the critique.

💡Recommendation

The script discusses the importance of making a 'recommendation' in a critique paper, suggesting whether the material is suitable for a particular audience or category of readers. It also asks for justifications for the recommendation, tying it to the overall evaluation.

💡Writing Mechanics

The term 'writing mechanics' in the script encompasses the technical aspects of writing, such as grammar, punctuation, and capitalization. The video emphasizes the importance of these mechanics for the clarity and professionalism of the critique paper.

💡Stages of Writing

The script outlines the 'stages of writing' as pre-writing, writing, and post-writing. It stresses the importance of reviewing and editing during the post-writing stage to ensure the final paper is polished and free from errors.

💡Universality

In the context of the video, 'universality' refers to the ability of a critique paper to connect the material being critiqued with other relevant works or themes. This demonstrates the broader significance and comprehensiveness of the critique.

Highlights

A critique paper evaluates material to help readers understand it thoroughly.

Preparation for writing a critique paper involves thorough reading to write better.

The structure of a critique paper includes an introduction, summary, and critical evaluation.

A critique paper should contain 30% summary and 70% critical evaluation.

The purpose of a critique paper is to evaluate material for better reader understanding.

When writing a critique, introduce the material, mentioning the title and author.

Provide a brief summary of the material's major points after reading it several times.

Give a comprehensive assessment of the material, discussing content, characters, and literary devices.

Answer 'invisible questions' such as the purpose, strengths, weaknesses, and appropriateness of the material.

Discuss the literary theory depicted in the material, such as feminism or post-modernism.

Use criteria like the seven literary standards to measure the material's quality.

Decide if you would recommend the material to a specific audience and explain why.

Support your critique with quotes or lines from the material to connect your points.

Connect your paper to other relevant materials to show universality and comprehensiveness.

In the conclusion, provide a brief but strong general assessment of the material.

Consider writing mechanics such as grammar, punctuation, and capitalization.

Review and edit the paper thoroughly to ensure it's the final version, not a draft.

Encourage viewers to like, subscribe, and enable notifications for more educational content.

Transcripts

[Music]

hi

welcome back to my channel in this

lesson video pagosa

is the critique paper okay so you

critique paper

paper is to evaluate the material in

order for the readers to

immediately and thoroughly understand it

surely but definitely

malinois okay so secretive paper

certainly there is a preparation that's

what i'm

telling you and that is why you really

have to read

thoroughly in order for you to write

better okay

critique paper

so for example in your outline roman

numeral one

illagayna tendonium introduction and

background kailangan in the introduce

small

new input material tapos unknown

background non

roman numeral numerals

brief summary of the input materials

okay

short story and brief summary new story

and so nasa roman numerals

one introduction and background two

summary

three critical evaluation so

basic three parts okay introduction and

background

summary and critical evaluation that

means in the critique paper

meron summary atmeron kang evaluation

for example 30 percent summary

seventy percent critical evaluation

okay so parallel alcohol seventy percent

in critical evaluation

or your critique or young thorough

examination of the input

70 critical evaluation

30 percent summary not 100 percent

summary

okay so num 3070 or 70 30 lankuba

puederinkas in 80 20 80

critique or critical evaluation 20

percent summary

but then of course hindi talagana

mentioned

short story or movies or

published research articles another

question

of course because expect mona hindi pasa

in that manner when you provide the

summary you are introducing the material

to your reader

remember the goal of a critique paper or

the purpose

of a critique paper is to evaluate it in

order to provide

a better understanding to its reader

okay

let's now talk about the critique paper

per se

of course do not forget the basic part

so we have the introduction the body

and the conclusion in writing the

critique paper

do observe the following so one

introduce the input material okay

mention the title

the author when was it written that's

number one

number two give a background about

that material okay

characters john

okay in the body part so tip number

three

of course provide a brief summary

okay major points definitely is

in order for you to provide a brief

summary certainly

you have read several times

the material okay hindi is says

it should be more than three because

while you read it or as you read it

the more details you discover number

four

sonasa by the natal give a comprehensive

assessment of the input materials

invisible questions you're talking about

the content you're talking about the

characters

or the literary devices present in it

completion and literature

of course research articles

for example your input material is a

literary piece

let's say it's a short story so of

course you have to

talk about the different literary

devices present there and the elements

of course

so cinema characters and onset

a while ago i have mentioned it's like

invisible questions

so what are these invisible questions

that you're answering in your critique

paper one

what is the purpose of that material

of that story or of that research

article

is it to inform to persuade or to

entertain

okay natokoi

another invisible question that you have

to point out in your critique paper is

that

what are the strengths and weaknesses of

the input material

okay so you should be able to point them

out another

is it appropriate to its intended

audience

okay material intended audience

okay bye young language use okay

bahamian sankase

so that's what we call semantic noise is

it objective

or subjective in its approach

okay also mention what literary theory

does the peace depict does it depict

feminism

does it depict post-modernism formalism

reader response and others so you have

to talk about the literary theory

if you say it utilizes for example or it

depicts mimetic approach

then try to provide reasons connections

why mimetic okay another question that

could be the basis of your details

in the body is based on the set criteria

or universal criteria

what rating will you give first let's

talk about the criteria

for example you will be considering the

seven literary standards as the criteria

seven literary standards according to

william j

long so what are this we have artistry

intellectual value suggestiveness

spiritual

value universality permanence and style

so you can measure by the muso

input material bas is a standard

satellite standard

published research article another

question

will you recommend the piece so

yum critique paper

for this reader for this age or for this

kind of reader category of reader

and why okay so

mental health is it a material for

bibliotherapy

bucket recommended

why are you going to recommend it to

this particular type

of freedoms or audience number five

support what you're right okay so most

am critique paper

support the han musha hao puma so by

lifting some lines or quotes from the

input material

two try to connect your paper

to other relevant materials

other relevant materials

input materials so when you do that you

are showing universality

you are showing comprehensiveness of

your review

remember critique paper torso critical

evaluation

other similar types or relevant material

okay number six this is for the

conclusion part so the positive is the

intro to positive

is a conclusion give

your general assessment or your overall

insight

for that input material okay make it

brief

and make it great so brief and great

because it's closing part already so it

has to deal with

your general assessment and it has to be

strong

okay so we are done with the parts now

do not forget since this is

writing always consider the writing

mechanics

shampre of course

abbreviations yuma contractions

punctuation capitalization your grammar

so important and more writing mechanics

and do consider them because

imperium

number eight have a final review of the

paper

okay of course consider reviewing the

content

your language used of course your

grammar

and the mechanics

writing that is why do not forget the

stages of writing we have pre-writing

writing and post writing in the post

writing part we really have to check and

we have to edit so

that whatever we're going to submit with

our professor

instructor or teacher it's really the

final paper

and not the draft okay there we have it

of course kappa gaga and output papasta

output

make it the better or the best version

of your original output thank you so

much

don't forget to click like subscribe and

tap the notification bell for more

lesson uploads practical tips and

anything educational have fun learning

[Music]