John 6:60-69 Commentary

Hearers of the Word
13 Aug 202124:50

Summary

TLDRThis presentation explores John 6:60-69, delving into the Bread of Life discourse and the pivotal question Jesus poses to his disciples about their faith. It examines the challenges of accepting Jesus' teachings, particularly his identity and the significance of the cross. The speaker discusses the historical and theological context, including the Johannine community's struggles with belief and schism. The summary emphasizes the importance of understanding Jesus' identity for faith and the Eucharist, encouraging reflection on personal faith journeys and the enduring relevance of these teachings.

Takeaways

  • 📜 The presentation concludes the series on John 6, focusing on the 'Bread of Life' discourse and the pivotal scene between Jesus and Peter.
  • 🔍 The session begins with an introduction, reading of the text, analysis of the chapter's structure, background exploration, commentary, and concludes with a prayer.
  • 🗣️ The Gospel of John 6:60-69 raises the question of commitment to the Christian faith, particularly in the face of challenging teachings.
  • 📖 The text is compared with Mark's Gospel, highlighting the similarities and differences in the portrayal of Peter's confession of faith.
  • 🏛️ The Johannine community experienced divisions, reflected in the Gospel's language about being 'put out of the synagogue' and internal schisms.
  • 💬 The term 'this teaching is difficult' (John 6:60) conveys the challenge and potential offense of Jesus' teachings, particularly regarding his identity and the necessity of the cross.
  • 🌟 The Gospel emphasizes Jesus' dual nature as both fully human and divine, using the 'I am' statements that echo divine names from the Old Testament.
  • ✝️ The central event of the Fourth Gospel is the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus, which is a recurring theme and a source of shock for the audience.
  • 🚶 The disciples' turning away from Jesus (John 6:66) signifies a real challenge within the Johannine community and a test of faith for believers.
  • 🙏 Peter's response to Jesus' question (John 6:68-69) is a declaration of loyalty and recognition of Jesus as the 'Holy One of God', underscoring the depth of faith within the community.
  • 📝 The presentation suggests that the Gospel of John is relevant to modern believers, offering insights into faith, discipleship, and the challenges of understanding Jesus' identity and mission.

Q & A

  • What is the central theme of the presentation on John chapter six?

    -The central theme of the presentation is the exploration of the 'Bread of Life' discourse in John 6:60-69, focusing on the identity of Jesus and the challenges of faith presented in his teachings.

  • What is the significance of the question 'Do you also wish to go away?' in the context of John 6:60-69?

    -The question 'Do you also wish to go away?' is significant as it directly addresses the disciples' and the audience's commitment to Jesus, challenging them to reflect on their faith and reasons for staying or leaving in light of difficult teachings.

  • How does the presentation relate the teachings in John 6 to the broader context of the Johannine community?

    -The presentation relates the teachings in John 6 to the Johannine community by discussing the historical context of the community's experiences with expulsion from the synagogue, internal divisions, and the challenge of accepting Jesus' identity and teachings.

  • What does the expression 'this teaching is difficult' (John 6:60) signify in the context of the presentation?

    -The expression 'this teaching is difficult' signifies the disciples' struggle to accept Jesus' teachings, particularly those concerning his identity and the necessity of his death and resurrection for salvation, which were challenging to their preconceived beliefs.

  • How does the presentation connect the identity of Jesus in the Fourth Gospel to the divine name 'I am'?

    -The presentation connects the identity of Jesus to the divine name 'I am' by highlighting instances where Jesus uses this name, such as in John 6:48 and 8:58, emphasizing his divinity and unique relationship with God.

  • What is the pastoral situation that the writer of John's Gospel addresses in relation to the Eucharist?

    -The pastoral situation addressed is the participation in the Eucharist without an adequate faith in Jesus or understanding of his death and resurrection, which makes the Eucharist difficult to comprehend for some members of the Johannine community.

  • How does the presentation discuss the significance of Peter's confession in John 6:68-69?

    -The presentation discusses Peter's confession as an affirmation of faith in Jesus as the 'Holy One of God' and the source of eternal life, reflecting on the personal journey of faith and the communal response to Jesus' teachings.

  • What is the role of the Spirit in understanding the teachings of Jesus according to the presentation?

    -According to the presentation, the Spirit plays a crucial role in giving life and understanding to the teachings of Jesus, as stated in John 6:63, emphasizing that the words of Jesus are 'spirit and life'.

  • How does the presentation use the comparison between John 6 and Mark 8 to highlight similarities in Peter's confession?

    -The presentation compares John 6:60-69 with Mark 8:27-30 to highlight the similarities in Peter's confession of Jesus as the Messiah and the divine identity of Jesus, showing how John's Gospel adapts and nuances the Markan account.

  • What is the significance of the phrase 'flesh is useless' in the context of the presentation?

    -The phrase 'flesh is useless' signifies the limitations of human understanding and the need for spiritual discernment to grasp the teachings of Jesus, especially in relation to his identity and the salvific event of the cross.

  • What does the presentation suggest as a way to deepen understanding of the Fourth Gospel?

    -The presentation suggests reading Sean Freyne's book 'The Sign' published by Dominican Publications as a way to deepen understanding of the Fourth Gospel and its theological themes.

Outlines

00:00

📖 Introduction to John 6's Final Presentation

The presenter warmly welcomes the audience to the concluding session on John 6, focusing on the pivotal dialogue between Jesus and Peter. The session's structure includes an introduction, scripture reading, chapter overview, background analysis, commentary, conclusions, and a closing prayer. The key question from the gospel, 'Do you also wish to go away?', is highlighted as it resonates with the audience, prompting reflection on personal faith and commitment to Christianity. The summary of John 6:60-69 is provided, depicting the disciples' struggle with Jesus' teachings, particularly the metaphor of the Bread of Life and the deeper spiritual understanding required. The presenter also invites the audience to consider the chapter's context within the broader narrative of John's Gospel.

05:00

🔍 Exploring the Backgrounds of John 6

This section delves into the various backgrounds influencing the narrative of John 6. Five key areas are discussed: the expulsion from the synagogue, the schism within the community, the challenging core teaching, the identity of Jesus, and the significance of the cross. The text's references to being 'put out of the synagogue' indicate the historical separation between Judaism and Christianity. Internal divisions within the early Christian community, as mentioned in John 6:66 and 1 John 2, are examined. The difficulty of the teaching in John 6:60 is explored, with the term 'scleros' suggesting an almost impossible acceptance of Jesus' identity and teachings. The presenter also reflects on the high Christology presented in the Gospel of John, emphasizing Jesus' dual nature as both human and divine, and the implications of this for the community's understanding of Jesus.

10:01

🕊 The Identity of Jesus and the Centrality of the Cross

The paragraph emphasizes the significance of Jesus' identity and the central role of the cross in the Fourth Gospel. It discusses how the identity of Jesus is portrayed through various scenes in John 6, each highlighting a different aspect of who Jesus is. The paragraph also touches on the shocking nature of the crucifixion and its role in God's plan of salvation, as reflected in 1 Corinthians 1. The audience is guided through the metaphorical eating of Jesus' flesh and drinking of His blood, which signifies belief in His sacrificial death and resurrection. The literal misunderstanding of this metaphor by some disciples is noted, drawing a parallel to similar misunderstandings by Nicodemus and the woman at the well. The paragraph concludes by reinforcing the challenging nature of the cross for the audience, especially for those of Jewish background.

15:04

🗝 Jesus' Resurrection and the Disciples' Reactions

This section discusses the theme of Jesus' resurrection and the reactions of His disciples to His teachings. The 'ascending' of Jesus is highlighted as a double echo of Jacob's ladder and His own resurrection, with references to John 1:51 and 3:13. The tension is increased by questioning the disciples' acceptance of the cross and the resurrection. The paragraph also touches on the spiritual versus physical aspects of life, with Jesus emphasizing that it is the Spirit that gives life, and the flesh is of little use. The theme of betrayal is introduced, along with the idea that not all who are exposed to Jesus' teachings believe in Him, reflecting the mystery of grace and the varied responses to Jesus' identity and mission.

20:04

🛣️ The Journey of Faith and Peter's Confession

The paragraph focuses on the journey of faith and the response of Simon Peter to Jesus' question about whether the disciples also wish to go away. Peter's rhetorical question implies that there is no one else to turn to but Jesus, who holds the words of eternal life. The paragraph invites the audience to reflect on their own faith journey and experience with Jesus. Peter's confession that Jesus is the 'Holy One of God' is unique to the Gospel of John and is explored in the context of Old Testament usage and its implications in the Gospel. The paragraph concludes with a reflection on the consecration of Jesus, as discussed in John 10:35-36 and 17, and the importance of recognizing Jesus' unique role and identity.

🏔️ Conclusions on John 6 and Reflections on Faith

The final paragraph summarizes the insights gained from the study of John 6, emphasizing the Gospel's focus on Jesus' identity and His work on the cross and resurrection. The traditional sequence used by the evangelist is noted, along with the editorial amendments made to address the specific context of the Johannine community. The primary focus on Jesus' identity and the secondary focus on the Eucharist are highlighted, reflecting the pastoral situation of the community. The paragraph concludes with a prayer for guidance and faithfulness, and an acknowledgment of the relevance of John 6 to contemporary believers. The presenter expresses gratitude for the audience's engagement with the series and recommends further reading on the Fourth Gospel, specifically Sean Freyne's book 'The Sign'.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Bread of Life

The term 'Bread of Life' is a metaphor used in the script to describe Jesus Christ, as it is a central theme in John 6:60-69. It refers to Jesus' teaching where He claims to be the spiritual nourishment that gives eternal life. In the script, it is mentioned as 'the bread of life, exploring John 60 to 69,' which signifies the discussion on the spiritual sustenance provided by Jesus.

💡Disciples

Disciples in the script refer to the followers of Jesus. They are depicted as individuals who hear Jesus' teachings and react to them. The term is used in the context of those who initially followed Jesus but found His teachings difficult and, as a result, some turned away, as seen in the line 'many of his disciples turned back and no longer went about with him.'

💡Spirit and Life

'Spirit and Life' is a phrase used by Jesus in the script to emphasize the spiritual nourishment and eternal life that His words provide. It is a key concept in understanding the spiritual teachings of Jesus, as mentioned in 'the words that I have spoken to you are spirit and life.' This phrase is central to the script's exploration of the spiritual sustenance offered through faith in Jesus.

💡Faith

Faith in the script is the belief and trust in Jesus Christ, particularly in His teachings and identity. It is a recurring theme, with the script discussing the faith of Peter and the challenges faced by the disciples in maintaining their faith, as in 'we have come to believe and know that you are the holy one of God.'

💡Eternal Life

Eternal life is a concept in the script that represents the everlasting life granted by God through faith in Jesus Christ. It is a central promise of Jesus' teachings, as seen in 'you have the words of eternal life.' The script explores the concept in relation to accepting Jesus' identity and teachings.

💡Schism

Schism in the script refers to the division or split within the Christian community, which is a historical context for the Gospel of John. It is mentioned in relation to the community's experience of internal divisions, as indicated by 'the Joanna and community also experienced internal divisions or what would later be called schism in the Christian movement.'

💡Identity of Jesus

The identity of Jesus is a pivotal theme in the script, focusing on who Jesus is according to the Gospel of John. It is explored through various teachings and events, such as 'you are the holy one of God,' and is central to the disciples' faith and the community's understanding of Jesus' role.

💡Cross

The cross in the script symbolizes the crucifixion of Jesus Christ, which is a central event in Christian theology. It is related to the teachings about Jesus' sacrifice and the salvation offered through it, as discussed in the context of 'the central event of the fourth gospel is the lifting up of the son of God on the cross and into resurrection.'

💡Resurrection

Resurrection in the script refers to the rising of Jesus Christ from the dead, a fundamental belief in Christianity. It is connected to the themes of eternal life and Jesus' identity, as seen in 'the lifting up of the son of God on the cross and into resurrection.'

💡Eucharist

The Eucharist is a sacrament in Christianity, symbolized by the breaking of bread, which is discussed in the script in relation to Jesus' teachings. It represents the communal participation in the memory of Jesus' sacrifice, as hinted at in 'the secondary focus is on the Eucharist.'

💡Johannine Community

The Johannine Community refers to the community of believers associated with the Gospel of John. The script discusses the context in which this Gospel was written and its relevance to the community's experiences, as in 'the pastoral setting is participation in the Eucharist without an adequate faith, in Jesus or an understanding of what happened for us in his death and resurrection.'

Highlights

Introduction to the final presentation on John 6, exploring the 'Bread of Life' discourse and the pivotal scene between Jesus and Peter.

The presentation sequence includes a welcome, reading of the text, examination of the chapter's context, background discussions, commentary, conclusions, and a prayer.

Gospel of John 6:60-69 raises the question of disciples' commitment, resonating with those who have faced challenges in their faith journey.

Jesus' teaching in John 6 is described as 'difficult', reflecting the challenge of accepting his identity and the significance of the cross.

The Johannine community experienced divisions, with some disciples turning away due to the challenging teachings on Jesus' identity and the centrality of the cross.

John 6:60-69 corresponds to Mark 8:27-30, highlighting the confession of Peter and the differences in how the Gospels present this event.

The Gospel of John follows a Markan sequence with adjustments, emphasizing the identity of Jesus and the eucharistic themes.

The expression 'to be put out of the synagogue' reflects the historical separation between Judaism and early Christianity.

The term 'scleros' in John 6:60 conveys the difficulty of the teachings, suggesting an adverse reaction due to their challenging nature.

Jesus' identity in the Fourth Gospel is portrayed as both human and divine, using the divine name 'I am' from the burning bush.

The central event of the Fourth Gospel is the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus, which was a shocking revelation for the early Christian community.

John 6 emphasizes the necessity of the Spirit for life, contrasting the limitations of the flesh and the life-giving power of Jesus' words.

Peter's response to Jesus' question in John 6:67-68 is a declaration of faith, affirming Jesus as the source of eternal life and the Holy One of God.

The Gospel of John addresses the pastoral situation of the Johannine community, focusing on the identity of Jesus and the proper understanding of the eucharist.

The presentation concludes with a prayer for guidance to remain faithful to Jesus Christ, whose words are spirit and life.

Recommendation of Sean Gohain's book 'The Sign' for further exploration of the Fourth Gospel's themes and its relevance to contemporary faith.

Transcripts

play00:02

a very warm welcome as always to all of

play00:04

you to the final presentation on john

play00:07

chapter six we come at last to the scene

play00:10

between

play00:11

jesus and peter with the great question

play00:14

so i look forward to being with you

play00:16

during this last presentation

play00:20

the bread of life

play00:23

exploring john 60 to 69 the conclusion

play00:33

for this final presentation on john 6

play00:37

we'll follow the following sequence

play00:40

first of all a welcome and introduction

play00:42

then we'll read the text itself

play00:45

look at the place in the chapter as a

play00:47

whole

play00:48

and then we'll spend a good deal of time

play00:50

on

play00:50

various backgrounds

play00:53

before coming finally to a commentary

play00:55

some conclusions and as always a prayer

play00:58

to conclude

play01:05

so a very warm welcome again to

play01:06

everybody

play01:08

our gospel today has a question which in

play01:11

a way jumps off the page do you also

play01:14

wish to go away

play01:17

that gospel will have a particular

play01:18

resonance for us today some have indeed

play01:22

gone away

play01:24

and this leaves those of us who have

play01:26

remained with the question why have i

play01:28

not also gone away what keeps me engaged

play01:32

in the christian project a good strong

play01:35

personal question

play01:42

and here is our gospel for today

play01:45

john 6 60-69

play01:50

when many of his disciples heard it they

play01:53

said this teaching is difficult who can

play01:55

accept it

play01:57

but jesus being aware that his disciples

play02:00

were complaining about it said to them

play02:03

does this offend you

play02:05

then what if you were to see the son of

play02:08

man ascending to where he was before

play02:11

it is the spirit that gives life the

play02:13

flesh is useless

play02:15

the words that i have spoken to you are

play02:18

spirit and life

play02:20

but among you there are some who do not

play02:23

believe

play02:24

for jesus knew from the first who were

play02:27

the ones that did not believe and who

play02:30

was the one that would betray him

play02:33

and he said for this reason i have told

play02:35

you that no one can come to me unless it

play02:38

is granted by the father

play02:41

because of this

play02:42

many of his disciples turned back and no

play02:46

longer went about with him

play02:48

so jesus asked the twelve

play02:51

do you also wish to go away

play02:55

simon peter answered him lord to whom

play02:57

can we go

play02:59

you have the words of eternal life

play03:02

we have come to believe and know that

play03:05

you are the holy one of god

play03:14

for the last time we take a quick look

play03:16

at john chapter 6 as a whole

play03:19

and as seen in all the previous

play03:20

presentations there are

play03:22

six moments and we're in the fifth the

play03:26

faith of peter versus 60 to 69 in fact

play03:30

the remaining verses could also be added

play03:32

as part of the scene

play03:35

you may like to pause the presentation

play03:38

here and glance once more at all of

play03:40

chapter 6.

play03:47

to appreciate this last scene we need to

play03:51

go back to a slide which was in the very

play03:53

first presentation that is

play03:56

john's following of a markan sequence

play03:59

and we saw there that inspired by mark's

play04:02

double telling of the multiplication

play04:04

john's gospel shows the following

play04:06

sequence

play04:07

number one the multiplication for five

play04:10

thousand number two the walking and the

play04:12

sea number three request for a sign

play04:15

number four remarks on bread number five

play04:18

the faith of peter and number six a

play04:20

short one passion theme and betrayal

play04:23

and you'll notice there on number five

play04:25

that john 6

play04:27

6069 corresponds more or less to mark 8

play04:31

27-30 the confession of peter at

play04:35

caesarea philippi

play04:42

and here are the two texts directly

play04:44

compared

play04:46

we've already read john 6 so may read

play04:48

mark 8 27-29

play04:53

jesus went with his disciples to the

play04:54

villages of caesarea philippi and on the

play04:57

way he asked his disciples who do people

play05:00

say that i am

play05:02

and they answered him john the baptist

play05:04

and others elijah and still others one

play05:06

of the prophets

play05:08

but he asked them but who do you say

play05:10

that i am and peter answered him you are

play05:14

the messiah

play05:16

and there are many similarities i've

play05:18

underlined a few of those so asked 12

play05:22

peter answered and you are

play05:25

of course john's gospel changes the

play05:28

question and also changes the answer

play05:37

we now come to the various backgrounds

play05:40

and for this presentation i have

play05:42

selected five

play05:44

the expulsion from the synagogue the

play05:46

schism in the community the core

play05:49

teaching is difficult the identity of

play05:51

jesus and the place of the cross

play05:55

and we look briefly at each one of those

play06:04

the community for which this gospel was

play06:06

written experienced several critical

play06:09

moments

play06:10

and one of these critical moments is

play06:12

registered in the text with a unique

play06:14

expression to be put out of the

play06:16

synagogue as you can see from the text

play06:18

there this expression occurs in chapter

play06:21

9 chapter 12 and chapter 16.

play06:26

the main

play06:27

story is the story of a man born blind

play06:31

and this expression to be put out of the

play06:33

synagogue is not something which

play06:35

happened during the ministry of the

play06:36

historical jesus but reflects the much

play06:39

later painful parting of the ways

play06:42

between judaism and emerging

play06:45

christianity

play06:52

the joanna and community also

play06:54

experienced internal divisions or what

play06:57

would later be called schism in the

play06:59

christian movement

play07:01

the evidence for this is in our verse in

play07:03

john 6 66 they turned back and no longer

play07:06

went about with him but also in the

play07:08

first letter of john chapter 2 where we

play07:12

read

play07:13

children it is the last hour

play07:16

as you have heard

play07:18

that the antichrist is coming so now

play07:20

many antichrists have come

play07:22

from this we know that this it is the

play07:24

last hour

play07:26

they went out from us

play07:28

but they did not belong to us for if

play07:30

they had belonged to us they would have

play07:32

remained with us but by going out they

play07:35

made it plain that none of them belongs

play07:37

to us

play07:39

so some kind of

play07:41

breakdown our division did occur

play07:43

we can always ask what might have

play07:45

triggered this and in fact john chapter

play07:48

6 is a good clue with his teaching on

play07:50

the identity of jesus and the centrality

play07:53

of the cross

play08:00

the expression this teaching is

play08:02

difficult is found in john chapter 6

play08:04

verse 60.

play08:06

when many of his disciples heard it they

play08:08

said this teaching logos is difficult

play08:12

scleros

play08:13

who can accept it and the word scleros

play08:16

has a range of meanings it can mean

play08:18

externally hard or rough in some way

play08:21

it can also mean

play08:22

causing an adverse reaction because of

play08:24

being hard or harsh or unpleasant

play08:28

it could also mean being difficult to

play08:30

the point of being impossible implying

play08:32

an adverse force that is unyielding

play08:35

and number four being unyielding in

play08:37

behavior or or attitude and the

play08:40

metaphorical use here seem to point us

play08:42

in the direction of

play08:44

interpretations three and four so it's a

play08:48

strong expression this is difficult to

play08:50

the point of being impossible to accept

play08:54

now we can always ask what teaching was

play08:56

that that caused such a reaction

play09:05

so in a very brief and inadequate way we

play09:08

can ask what is the identity of jesus in

play09:12

the fourth gospel and two things may be

play09:15

said

play09:15

first of all he comes across as a real

play09:18

human being who gets tired who has

play09:21

friends who can be angry and who suffers

play09:24

when his friend lazarus dies

play09:27

so very human

play09:28

at the same time the only begotten son

play09:31

the one who makes the father known the

play09:33

word made flesh

play09:35

and in this gospel jesus uses the divine

play09:38

name i am who i am from the burning bush

play09:41

and a few texts can illustrate this

play09:43

very early in the gospel in 1 18 we read

play09:47

no one has ever seen god it is god the

play09:49

only son who is close to the father's

play09:52

heart who has made him known

play09:54

and in our chapter 6 48 i am the bread

play09:58

of life using the divine name from the

play10:00

burning bush

play10:02

669 is worth repeating for the unique

play10:05

expression we have come to believe and

play10:07

know you are the holy one of god

play10:10

and towards the end of the gospel thomas

play10:12

makes a remarkable confession of faith

play10:14

my lord and my god

play10:17

so part of the problem for the some

play10:19

members of the community was the very

play10:22

high teaching about the identity of

play10:24

jesus and his place in god

play10:33

the significance of the identity of

play10:35

jesus for this chapter is also apparent

play10:38

from a slide i have used before

play10:40

each of the sections as we saw lands in

play10:43

on something about the identity of jesus

play10:46

for the multiplication of the loaves

play10:48

this is indeed the prophet a potential

play10:51

king

play10:52

for the walking and the sea it is i egoi

play10:54

me the name of god

play10:56

the request for a sign led to a

play10:59

definition of jesus to believe in him

play11:01

whom he has sent

play11:03

in the remarks on the bread we saw

play11:04

regularly i am the bread of life and

play11:07

here we have you are the holy one of god

play11:09

in section 5

play11:11

and finally in section 6 the centrality

play11:14

of jesus is clear because

play11:16

the very last sentence is the one who

play11:18

was going to betray him

play11:21

so john 6 has in the foreground the

play11:24

identity of jesus who is he for the

play11:27

believing community a good question for

play11:30

us also today

play11:37

the central event of the fourth gospel

play11:41

is the lifting up of the son of god on

play11:43

the cross and into resurrection as

play11:46

already anticipated in john 3 16.

play11:50

this teaching that god revealed himself

play11:53

and made himself known and offered

play11:55

salvation through the brutal event of

play11:58

crucifixion was always shocking

play12:01

it was shocking already for the pauline

play12:03

communities we read in 1 corinthians 1

play12:06

as follows

play12:08

for sins in the wisdom of god the world

play12:10

did not know god through wisdom god

play12:12

decided for the foolishness of our

play12:15

proclamation to save those who believe

play12:18

for jews demand signs and greeks desire

play12:21

wisdom but we proclaim christ crucified

play12:24

a stumbling block to jews and

play12:26

foolishness to gentiles but to those who

play12:28

are the called both jews and greeks

play12:31

christ the power of god and the wisdom

play12:34

of god

play12:35

for god's foolishness is wiser than

play12:38

human wisdom and god's weakness is

play12:40

stronger than human strength

play12:44

something of the challenge of believing

play12:45

on the cross is in our

play12:48

chapter 6 verses 52 to 57 where we read

play12:52

as follows

play12:53

then the jews disputed them on

play12:55

themselves how can this man give us his

play12:57

flesh to eat

play12:59

so jesus said to them very truly i tell

play13:01

you unless you eat the flesh of the son

play13:03

of man and drink his blood you have no

play13:05

life in you

play13:07

those who eat my flesh and drink my

play13:08

blood have eternal life and i will raise

play13:11

them up on the last day

play13:13

for my flesh is true food and my blood

play13:16

is true drink

play13:19

those who eat my flesh and drink my

play13:21

blood abide in me and i in them just as

play13:24

the living father sent me and i live

play13:27

because of the father so whoever eats me

play13:30

will live because of me

play13:33

and we saw in a previous commentary on

play13:35

verse 52 that the literal understanding

play13:39

resembles the literal understanding of

play13:40

nicodemus and the literal understanding

play13:43

of the woman at the well in other words

play13:44

it is a mistaken line of

play13:46

interpretation if we ask ourselves when

play13:49

in this gospel does jesus give his flesh

play13:52

and his blood the answer is on the cross

play13:55

because there is no lord's supper in the

play13:57

fourth gospel

play13:59

and that context to eat his flesh means

play14:01

first of all to believe in the salvation

play14:04

coming through the death and

play14:05

resurrection of jesus and then at a much

play14:08

secondary level to consume the sacrament

play14:12

this remained a kind of shock for the

play14:15

audience especially for those of jewish

play14:17

background always

play14:24

so with that great deal of background in

play14:27

mind we can turn to our commentary

play14:30

john 6 60

play14:33

when many of his disciples heard it they

play14:36

said this teaching is difficult who can

play14:39

accept it

play14:40

and be

play14:41

it is not only the jews who react

play14:44

negatively but his disciples that is

play14:47

members of the joannaand community

play14:50

and the teaching as we saw is to do with

play14:52

the identity of jesus and the place of

play14:55

the cross

play15:03

verses 61-62

play15:06

but jesus

play15:08

being aware that his disciples were

play15:10

complaining about it said to them

play15:12

does this offend you

play15:14

then what if you were to see the son of

play15:16

man ascending to where he was before

play15:20

and this ascending is a double echo of a

play15:22

previous theme of jacob's ladder in the

play15:24

fourth gospel and also jesus own

play15:27

resurrection we can see that in a couple

play15:30

of quotations

play15:32

in john 1 51

play15:34

very truly i tell you you will see

play15:36

heaven opened and the angels of god

play15:38

ascending and descending upon the son of

play15:40

man a clear echo of jacob's dream and

play15:43

jacob's ladder

play15:45

that's also echoed in 3 13 no one has

play15:49

ascended into heaven except the one who

play15:50

descended from heaven the son of man the

play15:54

reference the resurrection then is clear

play15:56

at the end of the gospel when jesus is

play15:58

talking to mary magdalene

play16:00

do not hold on to me because i have not

play16:02

yet ascended to the father but go to my

play16:05

brothers and say to them i am ascending

play16:07

to my father and your father to my god

play16:09

and your god

play16:11

and the effect of this reference is to

play16:14

increase the tension because does this

play16:17

offend you means does the teaching of

play16:19

the cross offend you what about the

play16:21

teaching of the resurrection all the

play16:24

more so

play16:30

john 6

play16:32

63 to 64.

play16:35

it is the spirit that gives life the

play16:37

flesh is useless

play16:39

the words that i have spoken to you are

play16:41

spirit and life

play16:43

but among you there are some who do not

play16:45

believe for jesus knew from the first

play16:48

who were the ones that did not believe

play16:51

and who was the one that would betray

play16:52

him

play16:53

in effect

play16:55

these are passion themes

play16:57

which is very consistent with the topic

play17:00

of jesus death and resurrection

play17:03

and the sentence the spirit that gives

play17:04

light the flesh is useless echoes

play17:06

something in mark 14 38

play17:10

keep awake and pray that you may not

play17:12

come into the time of trial the spirit

play17:14

is indeed willing but the flesh is

play17:16

weak and the passion theme continues in

play17:20

the reference to betrayal which is

play17:22

frequent in john's gospel and in john 6

play17:25

71 judas son of simon iscariot is

play17:28

actually named

play17:30

as we saw many times the verb to believe

play17:33

is vast in this gospel occurring no

play17:35

fewer than 98 times

play17:44

john 6 65 and he said

play17:48

for this reason i have told you that no

play17:51

one can come to me unless it is granted

play17:54

by the father

play17:55

and this reflects the mystery of grace

play17:59

all have the same hunger the heart all

play18:01

see the evidence of jesus but not all

play18:03

believe

play18:05

something similar was reflected earlier

play18:07

in john 6 44

play18:09

no one can come to me unless drawn by

play18:13

the father who sent me

play18:21

john 6 66

play18:23

because of this many of his disciples

play18:26

turned back and no longer went about

play18:29

with him

play18:31

it's worth noting that it is not the

play18:32

jews at this point who walk away but the

play18:35

disciples that really means members of

play18:37

the later joanna in community

play18:41

in the

play18:42

historical jesus the story of rich young

play18:45

man does show us a story of a person who

play18:47

did walk away but on account of the

play18:50

challenge of discipleship not on account

play18:52

of the identity of

play18:54

jesus and i put in there again that

play18:56

quotation from

play18:58

1 john 2 18 to 19 a little unkind it

play19:02

says that those who went out from us

play19:05

would not have gone out for us if they

play19:06

had really belonged in the first place a

play19:08

bit harsh i suppose in today's context

play19:16

and so we come to the great question in

play19:20

verse 67

play19:22

so jesus asked the twelve

play19:24

do you also wish to go away

play19:28

and as i've noted before john's gospel

play19:30

is peppered with really good questions

play19:34

and as at caesarea philippi this

play19:36

question seems to jump off the page and

play19:39

address

play19:40

us in our own time do you also wish to

play19:43

go away

play19:45

and it's good to give time to reflecting

play19:47

on what answer would i give now at this

play19:51

point in my life

play19:58

when we come to the last two verses 68

play20:01

and 69

play20:03

simon peter answered him lord to whom

play20:06

can we go you have the words of eternal

play20:09

life

play20:10

we have come to believe and know that

play20:13

you are the holy one of god

play20:17

and peter's first reaction is a

play20:20

rhetorical question to whom can we go

play20:23

implying no one else

play20:25

and then you have

play20:27

experience the experience of jesus his

play20:30

words the gift of eternal life you also

play20:34

have been there a journey of faith we

play20:37

have come to believe and we know

play20:40

and these

play20:42

reactions from peter invite us to

play20:43

reflect on our own experience and our

play20:46

own journey of faith

play20:49

in the center then is an affirmation

play20:51

unique in the fourth gospel jesus is the

play20:54

holy one of god

play20:56

now this expression is used in the old

play20:58

testament meaning men consecrate to god

play21:00

in some way for instance samson in the

play21:03

book of judges or aeron in psalm 106

play21:07

but in john's gospel it seems to imply

play21:10

more and i put there a quotation from

play21:13

john 10

play21:14

35-36 which might capture it if those to

play21:18

whom the word of god came were called

play21:20

gods and the scripture cannot be

play21:22

annulled how can you say that the one

play21:24

whom the father has made holy and sent

play21:27

into the world is blaspheming because i

play21:29

said i am god's son

play21:32

and there's a longer reflection on the

play21:35

consecration of jesus so to speak in

play21:38

john 17 which would be worth meditating

play21:41

on its own merits

play21:48

having experienced together john chapter

play21:51

6 and having mulled over it in the

play21:53

various sessions

play21:55

some conclusions can be indicated

play21:59

the great journey of john 6 lands firmly

play22:03

on the identity of jesus and his work

play22:06

the cross really but not excluding the

play22:08

resurrection

play22:10

the writer made use of a traditional

play22:12

sequence as also preserved in mark which

play22:14

we saw several times with significant

play22:17

adjustments

play22:19

and the evangelist makes clear editorial

play22:21

emendations so the text will speak to

play22:24

the context of the joannen community of

play22:26

faith at the time of writing using their

play22:30

typical language of faith

play22:33

and as i emphasized more than once the

play22:36

primary focus of john 6 is on the

play22:38

identity of jesus in each scene

play22:42

and the secondary focus is on the

play22:44

eucharist this reflects the pastoral

play22:47

situation into which the evangelist is

play22:49

writing

play22:50

the pastoral setting is participation in

play22:53

the eucharist without an adequate faith

play22:55

in jesus or an understanding of what

play22:58

happened for us in his death and

play23:00

resurrection

play23:02

this pastoral situation is not unknown

play23:04

today of course and makes participation

play23:07

in the eucharist difficult to understand

play23:10

the writer continues his reflections on

play23:13

the eucharist in john 13 at the washing

play23:16

of the feet

play23:23

a prayer in every age o god you give

play23:26

your people freedom to walk in faith or

play23:29

turn away

play23:31

grant us grace to remain faithful to

play23:33

your holy one whose words are spirit and

play23:37

life

play23:38

jesus christ our lord who lives and

play23:40

reigns with you in the unity of the holy

play23:42

spirit god forever and ever amen

play23:52

so thank you very much everybody for

play23:54

your patience and staying with this

play23:56

program of six modules on john chapter

play24:00

six i hope you found it worthwhile

play24:02

it was a challenge for me to put all

play24:04

this stuff together and try to make it a

play24:06

bit relevant for us today i do believe

play24:09

the chapter speaks to a pastoral

play24:11

situation which is very like our own and

play24:15

so it can help us today as we try to

play24:17

make decisions for our future as

play24:20

individual believers and as members of

play24:22

the faith community

play24:24

i also hope that this presentation on

play24:27

john 6 would have intrigued you about

play24:29

the fourth gospel which is such a

play24:31

marvelous text and it's wonderful that

play24:33

it survived and that we still have it

play24:36

today to reflect upon

play24:39

if you were to read any book on this

play24:41

then i would certainly recommend sean

play24:43

gohan's book the sign published by

play24:46

dominican publications thanks very much

play24:48

everybody

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

相关标签
John 6Faith JourneyJesus IdentityBread of LifeSpiritual TeachingChristianity InsightsEucharist ReflectionDiscipleship ChallengeScripture AnalysisPeter's ConfessionBelief Exploration
您是否需要英文摘要?