Star Wars fans cannot grow up

Summary

This video commentary dives into the Star Wars series *Andor*, examining both the show and the polarized reactions from the fan community. The creator critiques influencers like Star Wars Theory, Star Wars Girl, Script Trooper, and Robot Head for inconsistent, often superficial arguments against the series, highlighting their elitism and hypocrisy. Through humor and sharp analysis, the video defends *Andor*'s mature themes, realistic depictions of oppression, and storytelling depth, emphasizing the importance of letting the Star Wars universe evolve. The host also reflects on their personal journey from initial skepticism to admiration, illustrating how art can transform perceptions when audiences embrace growth and change.

Takeaways

• 😀 The narrator critiques Star Wars Theory for being overly rigid and elitist about what counts as 'real' Star Wars, focusing on minor details like 'bricks and screws.'
• 😀 Star Wars Theory demonstrates a victim mentality online, remakes content, and uses AI-generated thumbnails poorly, drawing widespread criticism.
• 😀 Certain fans, like Star Wars Girl and Script Trooper, misinterpret Andor’s mature themes and focus on superficial or nostalgic complaints.
• 😀 Andor Season 2 is praised for presenting complex moral dilemmas and showing the real consequences of fascist oppression, such as the Gorman massacre.
• 😀 The show handles intense moments effectively without over-relying on spectacle, emphasizing tension and narrative focus over visual excess.
• 😀 The narrator highlights inconsistencies in fan criticism, such as contradictory arguments about the Empire’s actions and moral logic.
• 😀 Mature themes in Andor challenge the expectation that Star Wars must always be child-friendly, expanding the franchise’s narrative scope.
• 😀 Resistance to change among some fans limits the growth of the Star Wars IP and hinders appreciation for innovative storytelling.
• 😀 The narrator reflects on personal growth, noting that being open to art allows Andor to provide a transformative experience similar to the original trilogy.
• 😀 Internet culture, including social media reactions and YouTube drama, is a major focus, showing how fan behavior shapes public discourse around Star Wars.
• 😀 The script uses humor, sarcasm, and hyperbole to both entertain and critique, blending media analysis with commentary on online fandom.

Q & A

What is the main critique regarding the Empire's actions in 'Andor' related to the Gormans?

The critique revolves around the inconsistency of the Empire’s motivations. On one hand, the Empire doesn't need the Gormans' cooperation, and on the other, they go to great lengths to oppress them. This creates confusion as to why the Empire would waste resources on a planet with so few people when their resources are better used elsewhere.

How does the video creator feel about the Gorman Massacre in 'Andor'?

The creator sees the Gorman Massacre as one of the darkest and most harrowing moments in Star Wars. They praise the show for not showing the violence directly but instead focusing on the emotional and personal impact, which enhances the horror of the event.

Why does the creator believe it's unnecessary to show the Imperial mining crafts or Krennic in the episode about the Gorman Massacre?

The creator argues that it’s unnecessary to show these details because the focus of the episode is on the present moment—the destruction unfolding in real time. The Empire’s actions are already implied, and the horror is about what’s happening now, not the mechanics of how it happened.

What critique is made about 'Ahsoka' in the script?

The critique of 'Ahsoka' suggests that it falls into the trap of nostalgic references and self-cannibalization. It doesn’t allow Star Wars to evolve beyond its original formula and fails to mature with the audience.

What is the main argument against fans rejecting 'Andor' and its tone?

The main argument is that many fans are reluctant to accept Star Wars as a mature and evolving series. They want Star Wars to remain the same as it was in the past, which limits its growth and the way it connects with new generations of viewers.

How does the creator explain their initial disconnection from 'Andor'?

The creator initially dismissed 'Andor' because of their disillusionment with Star Wars after the release of 'Obi-Wan Kenobi.' It took months of recommendations and further reflection for them to appreciate the show’s depth and narrative quality.

Why is the Gorman Massacre considered significant in the larger Star Wars universe?

The Gorman Massacre is significant because it showcases the Empire’s ruthless pursuit of control and power, resulting in the mass murder of innocent lives. It represents the cost of the Empire's tyranny, making it one of the darkest and most impactful moments in Star Wars history.

How does 'Andor' differ from other Star Wars series like 'Mandalorian' and 'Ahsoka'?

'Andor' is praised for focusing on the deeper, more personal consequences of the Empire’s actions, unlike 'Mandalorian' and 'Ahsoka,' which often emphasize action and spectacle. 'Andor' is more political, mature, and character-driven, while the others are more focused on nostalgia and traditional heroism.

What does the creator mean by 'if you let art simply do what it wants to do' in relation to 'Andor'?

The creator is suggesting that when viewers allow a piece of art, like 'Andor,' to evolve naturally and not be confined to preconceived expectations, it can lead to a deeper and more meaningful experience. They credit 'Andor' with expanding their perspective on both Star Wars and the world at large.

What is the overall message the creator is conveying in the video?

The creator is arguing that Star Wars needs to mature and evolve with its audience. They advocate for letting the franchise grow beyond nostalgia and explore more mature, complex themes, as 'Andor' successfully does. They criticize those who resist change and want Star Wars to remain in its original form.