War of the Rohirrim Reviews CRUSH LOTR Girl Boss

Summary

The video script critiques modern adaptations of classic fantasy works like *The Lord of the Rings* and *War of the Rohirrim*, arguing that contemporary Western values distort the original essence of these stories. The focus is on the portrayal of female characters in traditionally male roles, which the speaker believes undermines the authenticity of the narrative. The critique extends to a broader cultural disconnect between the source material and modern reinterpretations, asserting that these changes prioritize progressive ideals over character depth and historical accuracy, resulting in shallow and inauthentic storytelling.

Takeaways

• 😀 The modern adaptation of *War of the Rohirrim* is critiqued for distorting the core values of Tolkien’s original work in favor of contemporary political and cultural ideologies.
• 😀 The film is accused of watering down the deeper moral themes of Tolkien’s world, replacing concepts like justice and sacrifice with modern identity politics.
• 😀 The character of Hera is highlighted as an example of how traditional roles are upended, with her elevated to an unnatural position of power that feels forced and out of place.
• 😀 There is a strong critique of how the male characters, like Wolf, are portrayed as shallow and irrational, which detracts from their depth and believability.
• 😀 The review suggests that the modern Western values imposed on the characters and narrative feel disconnected from the original, making the adaptation seem inauthentic.
• 😀 The visual aesthetics of the film are praised, but it’s argued that the plot and character development fall short of expectations, making the film feel hollow despite its visual appeal.
• 😀 The speaker laments the tendency of Hollywood to 'correct' historical narratives and classic stories by inserting contemporary moral lessons that often disrupt the original essence.
• 😀 A key criticism is that modern adaptations prioritize contemporary feminist ideals, often at the expense of respecting the traditional roles and dynamics seen in the original material.
• 😀 The film is accused of turning into a parody or satire of the original story by inserting modern social and political ideologies into a traditionally masculine narrative.
• 😀 Ultimately, the speaker believes that authentic storytelling lies in respecting historical roles and values, and that modern ideologies are distorting classic narratives into something unrecognizable.

Q & A

What is the main critique of 'War of the Rohirrim' in the transcript?

The main critique of 'War of the Rohirrim' is that it fails to authentically capture the values of Tolkien's work, particularly in how it portrays characters and themes. The critic argues that modern values, such as the empowerment of women and a shift from masculine roles, are forced into the narrative, undermining the authenticity and historical integrity of the story.

Why does the critique argue that the portrayal of female characters is problematic?

The critique suggests that the portrayal of female characters in 'War of the Rohirrim' feels forced and out of place. Female characters like Hera are portrayed as overly powerful, taking on traditionally male roles, which the critic believes makes the story less believable. The argument is that women should not be placed in male roles for the sake of modern values, as it disrupts the authenticity of the narrative.

What does the reviewer say about the relationship between the characters of Wolf and Hera?

The reviewer points out that the relationship between Wolf and Hera is underdeveloped, with the characters not exploring their childhood connection for drama or pathos. The critic suggests that this lack of depth in their relationship detracts from the emotional weight of the story.

How does the critique address the representation of masculinity in the film?

The critique argues that the film misrepresents masculinity, particularly through the character of Wolf, who is portrayed as rash, violent, and ineffective. The critic contrasts this with Hera's leadership, which they view as too stoic and oppressive, leading to a skewed representation of gender roles and power dynamics.

What is the critique's view on the execution of Tolkien's values in 'War of the Rohirrim'?

The critique suggests that the film fails to execute Tolkien's values effectively, pointing out that the story lacks the complexity and depth found in Tolkien's work. The critic believes that the film's modern moral framework oversimplifies the themes of sacrifice, justice, and heroism that are central to Tolkien's original vision.

How does the critique compare 'War of the Rohirrim' to other Hollywood adaptations of franchises?

The critique compares 'War of the Rohirrim' to other Hollywood adaptations of franchises by suggesting that it is another example of a studio taking a beloved property, such as 'The Lord of the Rings,' and distorting it to fit modern sensibilities. The critic argues that Hollywood's approach often leads to a shallow and unoriginal product that fails to capture the essence of the original work.

What role does the critic believe modern politics and values play in the film?

The critic argues that modern politics and values, particularly the emphasis on gender equality and the empowerment of women, are imposed onto the story in a way that detracts from the narrative's authenticity. The film is seen as an attempt to correct perceived gender imbalances in Tolkien's work, but this approach is viewed as inauthentic and unconvincing.

What does the critique say about the film's visual presentation?

While the critique acknowledges that the film is visually stunning, it also notes that the story itself is underwhelming. The critic points out that the film's visuals are not enough to compensate for its lackluster storytelling, which they argue fails to live up to the legacy of 'The Lord of the Rings.'

How does the critique view the balance between male and female roles in Tolkien's work?

The critique argues that Tolkien's work naturally aligns with traditional gender roles, where men and women each have distinct, important roles. The reviewer believes that attempts to correct these roles in modern adaptations, such as 'War of the Rohirrim,' are misguided and lead to a story that feels out of place. The critique suggests that respecting the original roles would make the story more believable and authentic.

What does the critic believe is the fundamental flaw in the modern adaptation of Tolkien's work?

The critic believes the fundamental flaw in modern adaptations of Tolkien's work is the imposition of contemporary values onto the narrative. This shift from traditional values—such as self-sacrifice, justice, and authentic heroism—results in a story that feels shallow, forced, and disconnected from the original spirit of the material.