Diseminasi Ilmiah Pelayanan Publik Melalui Penulisan Artikel - 29 November 2024

Summary

The transcript discusses key aspects of academic journal submission, focusing on the importance of adhering to the specific formatting and guidelines of each journal. It emphasizes the significance of title-content alignment, common mistakes in article writing, and the need for innovation in research. The session also covers ethical concerns regarding confidential data in studies, with guidance on how to share findings in a way that respects participant privacy. Additionally, it touches on the decision between publishing in bulletins or journals, considering factors like data confidentiality and the intended reach of the publication.

Takeaways

• 😀 Make sure your journal submission follows the journal's template and guidelines to avoid rejection.
• 😀 If the journal's template is not followed, the likelihood of rejection increases.
• 😀 One common mistake in writing articles is misalignment between the title and content. Ensure the title reflects the content accurately.
• 😀 When preparing an article, ensure all components of the journal's template are completed before submitting.
• 😀 Another mistake is the similarity between different articles. Ensure the content is original and avoids plagiarism (Turnitin check).
• 😀 Be mindful of plagiarism and ensure the submission is unique, even when the topic overlaps with other journals within the same institution.
• 😀 Articles should be structured properly, with the content reflecting the title and the research method clearly outlined.
• 😀 Data gathered from surveys or research (such as health data from Hajj participants) can be published, but individual identities must remain anonymous.
• 😀 Cumulative data (e.g., age range of Hajj participants) can be shared in publications, but confidentiality of personal information should be maintained.
• 😀 Depending on the desired level of access, publishing in a journal is preferable for broader dissemination compared to a bulletin.
• 😀 When reporting data, focus on trends and aggregates rather than specific personal data to adhere to ethical standards in research.

Q & A

Why is it important to follow the journal's template when submitting an article?

It is important to follow the journal's template because each journal has specific formatting and structural requirements. Failure to adhere to these guidelines increases the likelihood of the article being rejected.

What are some common mistakes made when writing scientific articles?

Common mistakes include not following the journal's template, having a mismatch between the article's title and content, and failing to ensure that the content matches the title and objectives of the study.

How can a journal's content be evaluated for publication?

Content is evaluated based on whether it follows the journal's template, includes all necessary components, aligns with the article's title, and presents new or innovative findings in the field.

What is Turnitin, and why is it important for submitting an article?

Turnitin is a plagiarism detection tool. It is important for ensuring that the submitted article does not contain excessive similarities with existing publications, which could lead to issues with academic integrity.

Can data from internal reports be published in a journal?

Yes, data from internal reports can be published if it does not reveal confidential information about individual participants or respondents. For instance, aggregate data such as age groups or health trends can be shared, but specific personal information must be anonymized.

What type of data can be published without violating ethical guidelines?

Data that is aggregated and does not include personal identifiers can be published. For example, trends in age distribution, gender, or health conditions in a population can be shared as long as individual identities are not disclosed.

What should be considered when deciding whether to publish in a bulletin or a journal?

The decision should depend on the desired reach. Journals generally offer broader access to the public and are ideal for academic dissemination, while bulletins may have a more limited audience.

What is the significance of publishing surveillance data in a journal?

Publishing surveillance data can help inform public health practices, contribute to academic research, and provide insights into trends or risks, such as health conditions prevalent among specific demographics like Hajj pilgrims.

How can surveillance data contribute to academic research?

Surveillance data can reveal patterns, such as the age distribution and health conditions of participants. Academics can then use this data to develop strategies or educational materials for public health improvement, such as preparing older individuals for specific health risks before a Hajj pilgrimage.

What ethical considerations must be taken into account when publishing research involving individuals?

Ethical considerations include ensuring that participants' identities are protected and not disclosing sensitive personal information. The data must be anonymized, and any confidential information should be handled according to privacy guidelines.