Polemik Baru Disertasi Bahlil, Jatam Ungkap Peran Peneliti UI

Summary

Bahlil Lahadalia, a doctoral candidate at Universitas Indonesia, completed his dissertation in a remarkably short period of 1 year and 8 months, earning a cum laude distinction. However, his research has sparked controversy after JATAM (Mining Advocacy Network) raised concerns that their name was used without consent as a source in his dissertation. JATAM alleges that they were misled during the interview process by a researcher posing as a UI demography researcher. UI has acknowledged the concerns, stating that the dissertation is subject to revisions following the public defense, and will address any objections raised.

Takeaways

• 😀 Bahlil Lahadalia completed his doctoral dissertation at Universitas Indonesia (UI) in 1 year and 8 months with the distinction of 'cum laude.'
• 😀 The dissertation has sparked controversy due to the involvement of the advocacy group JATAM, who claims their name was used without permission.
• 😀 JATAM objects to being cited as a primary informant in the dissertation, claiming they never consented to the use of their name or data.
• 😀 The individual who approached JATAM for an interview, Ismi Azha, presented himself as conducting independent research, not as part of Bahlil's dissertation.
• 😀 JATAM granted an interview to Ismi Azha under the impression it was for a different research project on the impact of nickel mining, not for Bahlil's dissertation.
• 😀 JATAM only discovered later that their organization's name and information had been used in Bahlil's dissertation without their explicit consent.
• 😀 JATAM has formally objected to the inclusion of their name in the dissertation and demanded that their information be removed.
• 😀 Universitas Indonesia (UI) responded by acknowledging the objection and stating that Bahlil's dissertation can be revised based on feedback, including JATAM's concerns.
• 😀 UI's spokesperson clarified that after Bahlil's public defense, the next step would be the revision phase, where the issues raised would be addressed.
• 😀 The controversy highlights important ethical concerns regarding informed consent in academic research and the use of data and names without proper authorization.
• 😀 JATAM's demand for the removal of their name from the dissertation underscores the importance of transparency and communication in research practices.

Q & A

What academic degree did Bahlil Lahadalia receive from the University of Indonesia?

Bahlil Lahadalia received a doctoral degree in Strategic and Global Studies from the University of Indonesia (UI).

How long did it take Bahlil Lahadalia to complete his doctoral program?

Bahlil completed his doctoral program in 1 year and 8 months.

What distinction did Bahlil Lahadalia receive upon completing his dissertation?

Bahlil received the 'cum laude' distinction upon completing his dissertation.

What is the controversy surrounding Bahlil Lahadalia's dissertation?

The controversy centers around the use of JATAM (Mining Advocacy Network) as an informant in Bahlil’s dissertation, as JATAM claims they never authorized their name to be used.

Why did JATAM object to Bahlil's dissertation?

JATAM objected because they were not informed that their name would be used in Bahlil's dissertation and claimed they only approved an interview with a researcher from the Institute of Demographic Studies at UI, not for the dissertation itself.

Who was the person that interviewed JATAM members for Bahlil's dissertation, and what did they initially claim?

The person who interviewed JATAM members was Ismi Azha, who initially claimed that the research was for her own project at the Institute of Demographic Studies at UI, not for Bahlil Lahadalia’s dissertation.

What did JATAM demand after discovering that their name was used in Bahlil's dissertation?

JATAM demanded that their name, along with all the information provided during the interview, be removed from Bahlil Lahadalia's dissertation.

How did the University of Indonesia (UI) respond to JATAM’s objections?

UI responded by stating that Bahlil Lahadalia’s dissertation was still subject to revisions after the open defense, and they would consider any valid objections raised, but did not confirm if they had officially communicated with Bahlil regarding JATAM’s concerns.

What role did the open defense play in the dissertation process for Bahlil Lahadalia?

The open defense is a stage where Bahlil Lahadalia presented his dissertation, after which revisions could be made based on feedback, including any objections raised by parties such as JATAM.

What was the timeline for Bahlil Lahadalia’s doctoral program?

Bahlil Lahadalia entered UI’s doctoral program on February 13, 2023, and completed it by October 16, 2024, which is a period of approximately 1 year and 8 months.