Apa Jadinya Kalo Indonesia Jadi Negara Komunis?

Summary

This video explores the potential outcomes if Indonesia were to adopt communism, drawing comparisons with other communist countries like China. It delves into the economic, social, and political changes that could occur, such as government control over resources and businesses, restricted individual freedoms, and a centralized economy. While some believe this system could eliminate social inequality, the video also highlights the challenges it might bring, including stunted innovation, limited personal freedom, and potential economic decline. The video concludes by questioning whether communism could truly make Indonesia more prosperous.

Takeaways

• 🤔 If Indonesia were to adopt communism, it could lead to significant economic and political changes, potentially destabilizing the country.
• 📜 Communism, as an ideology, aims to abolish social classes and distribute wealth equally, with all resources owned collectively by the state.
• 📉 A communist economy in Indonesia would mean centralized control of resources, which could hinder economic innovation and individual business growth.
• 🏢 Private ownership of businesses, land, and resources would no longer exist, as everything would be controlled by the government.
• 🧑‍🏫 In a communist system, private schools, hospitals, and businesses would be abolished, and everything would belong to the government.
• 🚫 Political freedom would be severely restricted, with only one political party allowed, reducing public debate and opposition.
• 🎭 Cultural freedom and creative expression might be heavily controlled by the government, limiting the diversity of Indonesia's rich cultural heritage.
• 💼 Individuals would not have the freedom to choose their careers or jobs, as the state would determine employment based on collective needs.
• 🎓 Education and entertainment would also be controlled, potentially limiting creativity and personal interests in both areas.
• 🇨🇳 Although China is a communist country, its economic success is due to opening up to free markets, which is not pure communism, making Indonesia’s prospects under communism uncertain.

Q & A

What is the main idea behind communism as mentioned in the script?

The main idea behind communism is to eliminate social classes and distribute wealth equally among the population. All resources and means of production are collectively owned by the society, and individuals work according to their abilities and receive compensation based on their needs.

How did the Partai Komunis Indonesia (PKI) perform in the 1960s elections?

In the 1960s, the Partai Komunis Indonesia (PKI) was at the peak of its success, receiving the most votes as the fourth-largest party in the elections. It was also one of the largest communist parties in the world, aside from the Soviet Union and China.

What was the impact of the G30S event on the PKI?

The G30S event marked a significant turning point for the PKI. Following the event, communism was banned in Indonesia, leading to a drastic change in the political landscape and the end of the PKI's influence in the country's politics.

What would be the economic implications if Indonesia were to adopt communism?

If Indonesia were to adopt communism, it would have a centralized economic system where all natural resources like oil, gas, and electricity would be managed by the government. This could potentially lead to the disappearance of private businesses, including coffee shops, restaurants, and convenience stores, as they would all become state-owned.

How would the social gap be affected under a communist system in Indonesia?

Under a communist system, there理论上 would be no social gap as wealth would be distributed equally among the population. However, the script suggests that such a system could actually hinder economic development and innovation, which might not necessarily lead to a more advanced society.

What are the potential political consequences of Indonesia becoming a communist country?

If Indonesia were to become a communist country, it might end up with a single-party system, leading to political stability due to the absence of differing opinions and political competition. However, this could also result in a lack of government criticism and potentially exacerbate corruption, as the government would hold absolute power.

How might international relations change if Indonesia adopted communism?

As a communist country, Indonesia might become closer to other communist nations such as China or Vietnam, forming strong alliances. However, the script also points out that there could be restrictions on cultural expression, which might impact the country's rich cultural diversity.

What are the possible effects on education and personal freedom under communism in Indonesia?

Under communism, education would be controlled by the state, potentially leading to standardized curriculums and a loss of creativity among students. Personal freedom would also be limited, as individuals would work not for personal gain but for the collective good, which could hinder personal aspirations and dreams.

How does the script suggest that the adoption of communism would impact the daily life of Indonesians?

The script suggests that the daily life of Indonesians would drastically change under communism, with everything from work, education, to entertainment being controlled by the state. This could lead to a lack of personal choice and a more uniform society.

What is the script's perspective on whether communism could make Indonesia more advanced?

The script expresses a pessimistic view on the idea that communism could make Indonesia more advanced. It argues that most communist countries are not more advanced than Indonesia in terms of GDP and that freedom and innovation are crucial for progress, which are limited under communism.

What alternative economic model does the script suggest might be more suitable for Indonesia's advancement?

The script implies that a mixed economy, where individuals have the freedom to control the means of production with government regulation, might be more suitable for Indonesia's advancement. This model allows for personal freedom and innovation, which are seen as key factors for economic growth and prosperity.