Ola S1 Pro vs Ather 450 X vs TVS iQube S vs Bajaj Chetak I Electric scooter comparo I Autocar India

Summary

In this comprehensive electric scooter comparison test, four top e-scooters from established Indian two-wheeler manufacturers and startups are put to the test across Mumbai. The Ola S1 Pro and Ather 450x lead in performance, with the Ola boasting the highest top speed and powerful acceleration. However, the Ather excels in heat management and consistent performance across modes. The TVS iQube and Bajaj Chetak focus on comfort and city commuting, with the iQube offering a balance of performance and range. Ergonomics vary, with the Chetak and iQube providing the most comfort. Range testing reveals the Ola S1 Pro's superiority, but with performance drops as the battery depletes. Handling is a highlight for the Ather 450x, while the Ola S1 Pro offers a smooth ride. All scooters come with modern features like Bluetooth connectivity and mobile apps, but the Ather stands out with its glitch-free performance. Despite the high price, the Ather justifies it with its engineering, making it a top choice for a sporty, tech-savvy scooter, while the TVS iQube emerges as the most well-rounded option for its balance of comfort, performance, and affordability.

Takeaways

• 🛵 **Performance Leaders**: The Ola S1 Pro and Aether 450x excel in performance, with the Ola S1 Pro being the quickest to reach 60 kph and 80 kph.
• 🏆 **Top Speed**: The Ola S1 Pro has the highest top speed at 99.8 kph, making it unbeatable for city and highway use.
• 🔥 **Acceleration**: The Aether 450x has the most natural accelerator response and maintains consistent performance across all modes.
• 🚫 **Power Cut Issue**: The Ola S1 Pro and Cheetah cut power when brakes are touched, which could be dangerous in traffic or while taking a u-turn.
• 🔋 **Battery Range**: The Ola S1 Pro, with the largest battery, offers the best range, but its performance drops significantly as the battery level gets low.
• 🛍️ **Storage Space**: The Ola S1 Pro provides the largest boot space, which is a significant advantage for practicality.
• 💺 **Comfort**: The Cheetah and iQube offer the most comfortable riding positions, making them ideal for city commuting.
• 🔌 **Fast Charging**: The Aether and Ola are the only scooters that support fast charging, but Ola's network is still in the setup phase.
• 🛣️ **Ride Quality**: The iQube offers a good balance between ride and handling, while the Aether's suspension is stiff and not ideal for poor road conditions.
• 📱 **Technology Features**: All scooters come with Bluetooth connectivity and mobile app integration, but the Aether 450x and Ola S1 Pro have the most advanced features.
• 🏁 **Value for Money**: The iQube emerges as the most well-rounded scooter, offering a good balance of performance, comfort, and affordability.

Q & A

What is the main purpose of the video?

The video compares four of the best electric scooters currently available in the market to help users decide which one suits their needs best.

Why is the newly launched Vita V1 not included in the comparison?

The Vita V1 is not part of the comparison because it will only be available starting from December 2022.

Which electric scooter is noted as having the best top speed in the comparison?

The Ola S1 Pro is noted for having the best top speed in the comparison, reaching a v-box verified 99.8 kilometers per hour.

Which scooter offers the best acceleration from 0 to 30 kph?

The Ather 450x is the quickest scooter from 0 to 30 kph, beating the Ola S1 Pro in this specific range.

What is the key drawback of the Ola S1 Pro’s Eco mode?

The Eco mode on the Ola S1 Pro restricts acceleration to a pace that can be borderline dangerous in fast-moving city traffic and makes it difficult to climb steep gradients.

Which scooter is identified as the most comfortable for riders taller than 5 feet 10 inches?

The TVS iQube and Bajaj Chetak are identified as more comfortable options, especially for taller riders, due to their better ergonomics and seating positions.

How does the Ather 450x’s heat management system compare to other scooters?

The Ather 450x has excellent heat management, allowing the scooter to remain in its high-performance warp mode even when the battery is below 20%, unlike the Ola S1 Pro which drops its performance sooner.

Which scooter has the largest boot space, and how does it benefit the rider?

The Ola S1 Pro has the largest boot space among the scooters, making it convenient for carrying larger items like groceries or an office bag along with the scooter’s charger.

What is the major concern with the Ola S1 Pro based on customer feedback?

Despite its features, the Ola S1 Pro has a poor reputation among customers due to a variety of issues, including registration problems, minor electronic glitches, and even major vehicular problems.

Which scooter is identified as the best choice for a balance of practicality, comfort, and affordability?

The TVS iQube S is identified as the best well-rounded scooter, offering a good balance of range, performance, comfort, and affordability, making it the 'pick of the moment' in the video.